Liquid crystal display unit and method for displaying an image with such unit

Abstract: A liquid crystal display unit (100) is described in which a first panel of pixel elements is used to control red and green portions of a displayed image using an additive technique while a second panel, having pixels aligned with the first panel pixels, controls the blue portion of the image through subtractive techniques. The resulting display system can provide enhanced brightness, resolution and color characteristics. The display system makes use of the fact that the eye is less sensitive to blue radiation for several visual parameters. As a result of the decreased sensitivity, the second (blue) panel can operate with less stringent requirements.

Description: BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 1. Field of the Invention The present invention relates to a liquid crystal color display unit and to a method for displaying an image with such unit. 2. Description of the Related Art Liquid crystal mosaic display technology is being developed as a possible successor to color cathode ray tubes (CRTs) in many display applications, including those applications in the avionics field. This technology offers important advantages such as higher reliability along with reduced power, size and weight. But in the current state of development of the liquid crystal technology, capability of this technology for the rendering of an image falls short of the image capability achievable using CRT technology. This invention addresses three specific problem areas still remaining in liquid crystal mosaic displays: color definition; image resolution; and display brightness. In terms of color definition, the liquid crystal mosaic display color rendition suffers from effects similar to those observed on a misaligned CRT display tube. The primary hues, the red, green and blue colors, do not blend properly. A white line, for example, appears to have multicolored fringes, symptomatic of deficient color synthesis. Part of the problem can be attributed to the symbol generator which controls the formation of graphics on the flat panel. However, part of the problem can also be attributed to the display itself, a contribution addressed by this invention. In terms of image resolution, graphic symbols and lines appear excessively jagged or discontinuous on color mosaic displays, especially when compared with lines drawn on calligraphic color CRT systems. Again part of the image resolution problem can be attributed to the symbol generator while the display panel itself also provides a contribution. A major part of the contribution from the display panel is the result of the presence of blue pixels as part of the display pixel mosaic. Referring now to Fig. 1A, the low degree of spatial sensitivity that the human visual system has for blue light as compared to the other primary colors is illustrated. The eye's peak response to blue light occurs at about one half the frequency of peak response for the red radiation and half again the frequency for green radiation. This result indicates that blue radiation contributes only a minor amount to image shape and spatial detail. As a result, blue pixels on the display surface of the panel tend to degrade the overall resolution capability of color mosaic displays, a feature addressed by the present invention. With respect to display brightness, the origin of the problem can be attributed to both the pixel arrangement of the panel and the current backlight technology used in liquid crystal displays. The backlight technology includes the lamp and the electronics controlling the backlight lamp. The chief figure of merit for achieving a given level of brightness is how much power is needed to achieve that brightness level. Research is being aggressively pursued to make backlight technology more efficient. The present invention, however, addresses the brightness problem from a different perspective. Once again, the pixel arrangement on the surface of the flat panel display can account for a considerable portion of the problem. Blue pixels contribute little to the total perceived luminance of the panel display. The photopic response of the eye accounts for this phenomenon. Figure 1B illustrates that red and green radiation provide a larger contribution to perceived brightness than blue radiation. Blue radiation can typically provide only about a ten percent contribution to the overall brightness of the panel. Referring next to Figure 2, the effect of having blue pixels occupying space in the pixel arrangement is shown. Wherever a blue pixel is present, the effect on the pattern of pixels is to occlude the perceivable luminance passing through the display surface. No appreciable contribution to luminance capability is available at the sites of the blue pixels. As a result, these blue pixel regions of Figure 2 can be considered as black regions. These regions occupy thirty percent of useful area in a typical Red/Green/Blue (RGB) pixel mosaic arrangement. In order to compete successfully with the cathode ray tube technology in a multiplicity of applications, the liquid crystal mosaic displays must evolve to the point where they efficiently achieve enough brightness to prevent bright sunshine from washing out displayed information. Additionally, they must also exhibit higher resolution and improved color mixture attributes for higher quality imagery to be displayed. Achieving these goals has proven difficult in the past. A wide range of techniques have been implemented in flat panel display technology to alleviate the problems described above. Listed below is a description of the principal approaches for solving color definition, image resolution and display brightness problems in the liquid crystal mosaic displays. Generally, color image synthesis in liquid crystal mosaic displays use either additive or subtractive techniques, see for instance European patent application 89 105 846.3. Additive techniques use spatial proximity, temporal superposition or spatial superposition techniques to mix primary hues into different colors. Additive spatial proximity methods are the most common approach used in liquid crystal flat panel technology. Figure 3 illustrates the basic technique of spatial proximity. Small dots (pixels) of primary colors, typically red, green and blue, are evenly dispersed across the surface of the flat panel display. If the dots (pixels) are small enough and close enough, then the eye fuses or integrates the contribution of each color dot together with its neighbors. The additive method can achieve enhanced resolution by making the pixels smaller and more densely packed. Additionally, the differently colored pixels can be arranged into different patterns, in hopes of striking a better fit with the characteristics of the human visual system. Full color imagery is therefore perceived. Excellent resolution can result because each pixel is capable of full color control and full luminance control. Additive spatial proximity, the method generally preferred throughout the industry, suffers three serious drawbacks, outlined above in the problem discussion. Color definition is faulty in the case of computer generated imagery (unless signal processing methods are used) resulting in color fringing and rainbows effects. As the pixels are made smaller, color integration is improved but light output is worsened because a greater percentage of the primary display area gets consumed by address lines and interconnecting conductors. In addition, blue contributes very little to perceived brightness yet consumes typically one quarter to one third the active display area as indicated previously. Blue also detracts from resolution capability, limiting edge definition and image sharpness. The three principal problems with this approach then are: 1) poor color integration and 2) wasted luminance and 3) wasted resolution. In additive temporal superposition methods, the primary hues are rapidly sequenced before the eye. Figure 4 shows one possible sequence. First, the red portion of the image is flashed on the flat panel display, then the green portion of the image is flashed on the flat panel display and, a short time later, the blue portion of the image is flashed on the flat panel display. Successful color synthesis using this temporal additive technique depends on the limited temporal frequency response of human vision. If the sequencing occurs rapidly enough, the eye cannot discern the separate primary hues, but, instead, perceives their overall integrated image. Temporal superposition suffers from smearing effects, jitter and image instability as the observer shifts his viewing position rapidly or vibration induces similar motion. In addition, todays liquid crystal materials exhibit such slow optical response times, rapid temporal sequencing using them is virtually impossible. In additive spatial superposition methods, separate images, each comprised of only one primary hue, are optically fused into one full color image. Typically three images, corresponding to red, green and blue hues, are used. These separate images are formed from three separate image sources. The output images of these three sources are then fused by optics into one full color image to be viewed by the observer (cf. Figure 5). Excellent resolution is typical of this approach because each pixel is capable of full color and full luminance control. Brightness can also be high since three image forming sources are operated in parallel. Additive spatial superposition techniques suffer from complexity problems and performance difficulties. These systems also tend to be prohibitively large for many applications, especially those of the aerospace market. Cost generally rises due to the fact that three separate imaging devices are needed. Then additional hardware must be used to combine the three images. Frequently, this hardware must be extremely precise and rigid to maintain color purity. In subtractive display apparatus, as illustrated in Fig. 6 and e.g. known from Optical Engineering 23 (1984), No. 3, pages 247-252, white (broad band) radiation is passed through successive layers of complimentary color filters, each layer being electrically controlled for absorbing a well-defined region of the spectrum. By modulating the voltage applied to each layer, different portions of the white light spectrum can be occluded or, in the alternative, be allowed to pass through unimpeded. This spectral control, the ability to withdraw selectively different portions of the spectrum, can be used to synthesize full color imagery. Resolution can be excellent with this approach because full color control is available at the site of each pixel. Subtractive methods suffer from an expected higher cost, parallax effects and complex methods for color control. At least three and possibly four separate liquid crystal panels are needed to make a subtractive superpositional liquid crystal display. Currently, this additional complexity is viewed as too costly. In addition, parallax can be troublesome using this technique. As the viewing angle is changed with respect to the display, each layer of pixels in the panel is viewed from a slightly different position. Pixels on different layers of the display will be observed to move with respect to each other. Lines can vary substantially in perceived thickness, due to head motion alone. Effects such as these, which are functions of viewing angle, are unacceptable for many (e.g., aerospace) applications. Finally, color control has proven to be particularly troublesome to date. Experiments indicate that, unless better dyes, backlighting or even a fourth layer can be developed, colors cannot be tracked over a broad range of ambient lighting conditions. The difficulty lies in the complex interrelationships between hue and luminance. One interferes with the other in a non-linear manner which currently has proven very difficult to predict. It is, therefore, the object of the present invention to provide a liquid crystal color display unit and a method of displaying a color image on such a display unit that provides increased display brightness, increased image resolution and better color reproduction. This object is achieved by the features of claim 1. Further advantageous embodiments of said unit may be taken from the dependent claims. Independent claim 7 is directed to a method for solving the indicated object. SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION The aforementioned and other features are accomplished, according to the present invention, by providing a liquid crystal display system in which a first panel has liquid crystal pixel elements that control the transmission of red and green image components and a second panel, aligned with the first panel for which liquid crystal pixel elements control the transmission blue image components therethrough. The first panel controls the red and green color components by additive spatial proximity techniques. The second panel controls the blue image component by subtractive techniques. Because of the reduced sensitivity of the eye to blue color components, the pixel array of the second panel can have diminished resolution and can have a diminished refresh rate compared to the first panel. These and other features of the invention will be understood upon reading of the following description along with the drawings. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS Figure 1A illustrates the eye's lower spatial frequency for blue as compared to other primary colors. Figure 1B illustrates the reduced sensitivity to blue radiation as compared to radiation of the other primary colors. Figure 2 illustrates the regions (blue pixels) that do not contribute to the mosaic display luminance. Figure 3 illustrates how the eye integrates neighboring pixels to provide a full color spectrum from primary hues. Figure 4A and Figure 4B illustrate temporal integration of a sequence of primary color images to provide a complete image. Figure 5 is a block diagram illustrating the development of an image using spatial superposition of image portions. Figure 6 illustrates a controllable filter for creating a color image by removing selected portion of broad band optical transmission passing therethrough. Figure 7 is a schematic diagram of a first panel of an additive/subtractive display panel of the present invention. Figure 8A illustrates the passband characteristics of a magenta filter; Figure 8B shows the passband characteristics of a cyan filter; and 8C illustrates the passband characteristics of dichroic filter for transmitting blue light. Figure 9 is a schematic diagram of a second panel of the additive/subtractive display of the present invention. Figure 10 is a cross-sectional view of the additive/subtractive display system according to the present invention. Figure 11 is a table illustrating the colors available with the additive/subtractive display panel of Fig. 10. Figure 12 is a CIE diagram illustrating the colors that can be achieved using the additive subtractive display system of the present invention. DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT 1. Detailed Description of the Figures Referring now to Fig. 7, a first panel 1 of the additive/subtractive display is shown. The liquid crystal display has an MxN matrix of pixels, each pixel being addressed by one of M column conductors and one of N row conductors. The M column conductors are selected by x-axis column bus drive unit 2 in response to groups of address signals, Wx, and the N row conductors are selected by y-row bus drive unit 3 in response to groups of address signals, Wy. The intersection of activated column conductors and an activated row conductor activates the associated pixels along the row. Either active matrix methods or multiplexing methods can be used to activate the pixels, techniques known in the related art. In the active matrix approach, active devices such as thin film transistors or metal insulator metal diodes are used as switching or non-linear devices to control the storage of charge across each pixel. In multiplexing methods, no active device is present. The relationships of voltage signals on row bus lines with respect to voltages present on column bus lines controls charge storage across each pixel which in turn controls the state of the pixel (liquid crystal) optically active material. This method depends on the sharp electro-optical threshold of the liquid crystal material itself rather than on the threshold behavior of intervening electronic devices used in active matrices. Still referring to Fig. 7, the color pixel arrangement of the top layer of the additive subtractive display is illustrated. Pixels of one complimentary primary hue, (magenta filter) pixel 4, for example, are distributed in a checkerboard pattern with pixels of another complimentary primary hue (cyan filter) pixel 5. The checkerboard pattern is used by way of example and is not meant to be limiting. The optical passband characteristics of the magenta and cyan filters are shown in Fig. 8A and 8B. No blue primary hue pixels are present in the pixel pattern of the top surface. The use of only magenta and cyan filter pixels leads to the resolution and brightness advantages described earlier in the disclosure. Referring next to Fig. 9, the second panel 6 of the additive/subtractive display is shown. The matrix is shown with half the number (M/2 x N/2) of rows and columns used in the first panel 1. This degraded resoluticn is possible because of the lower spatial resolution capability human vision has for blue light modulation as compared to red and green light modulation. Except for this spatial resolution difference, the drive units and address waveforms used for second panel 6 can be identical to those used for the first panel 1. Another difference is possible, however. The refresh rate of images displayed on the second panel 6 can be lowered relative to the refresh rate of the first panel 1 because human vision is less sensitive to blue light in terms of temporal resolution as well as spatial resolution. When red/green images are displayed on a display device whose images decay with time, the red/green images need to be refreshed periodically at a typical frequency of 60Hz. This critical fusion frequency allows the eye to integrate the flashing images into a steady scene absent of flicker or image decay. Blue light images can be seen without flicker at much lower refresh frequencies, 10Hz for example. This phenomenon can be used to have the overall effect of lowering the drive requirements for the blue color portion of the system. Still referring to Fig. 9, the color pixel arrangement of the bottom layer 6 is shown. Each pixel 7 controls the passage of blue light through the display. Each pixel can block blue light from passing through or, alternatively, can be energized so blue light can pass through unimpeded. In order to accomplish this, a guest host dichroic liquid crystal material (Merck ZLI2010 for example) is used. The passband characteristics of this liquid crystal material are shown in Fig. 8c. The passband spectral characteristic is variable and is a function of applied voltage. If voltage of one value is applied, then the passband is 9 as shown by Fig. 8c. No blue light is allowed to be transmitted. Other spectral components (red and green), however, can pass through freely, giving this filter a yellow hue when placed before a broad band light source (white light). When, on the other hand, another appropriate voltage is applied, then all wavelengths, including blue, are allowed to pass freely through the dichroic material. The passband is shown by dotted line 8 plus solid line 9 in Fig. 8c. Therefore, if the second panel 6 is placed before a broad band (white) light source and all the pixels are activated with the appropriate voltage, then the light passed through the second panel 6 appears blue-white instead of yellow. To obtain white, one half the pixels in the lower layer are activated. This activation provides an improved balance of the blue contribution to the overall spectral output. The ability of the bottom layer 6 to modulate blue light on a pixel by pixel basis, yet pass other spectral components is used together with the first panel 1 to produce full color images. Referring next to Fig. 10, the cross section of a total additive/subtractive display unit 100 incorporating both the first panel 1 (of Fig. 7) and the second panel 6 (of Fig. 9) is shown. The additive/subtractive display unit 100 includes a glass plate 14 and a glass plate 13 which enclose a region 16 containing dichroic material combined with a liquid crystal material. The glass plate 13 and filter plate 15, which includes a mosaic of magenta and cyan filters, enclose a region 12 containing a liquid crystal. Pixel control devices 10 in region 16 and pixel control devices 11 in region 12 are also shown. These pixel control devices 10 and 11 can be active matrix control devices (thin film transistors or metal/insulator/metal diodes for example) or, alternatively, can represent the intersection points of the row/column electrodes of multiplexed display technology described above. The blue control devices 10 are shown with twice the spacing and, therefore, half the resolution of the red/green control devices 11. This reduced element spacing reflects the physical differences of human vision resolution for resolving colors described previously. Alternatively, the resolution of the second panel 6 can be identical to that of the first panel 1. This configuration has the effect of adding a higher degree of fault tolerance capability in addition to increased blue light resolution capability. Several blue panel control devices and their associated blue pixels can be activated simultaneously in this configuration to cover the same area as a lower resolution blue control pixel. Therefore, some measure of redundancy or immunity to local failure can be achieved. The blue panel control devices 10 provide control over each pixel, enabling the additive/subtractive display to control the passage of blue light over the area of each cell or pixel 7 of Fig. 9 in the matrix of the second panel 6. Each pixel can either permit white light or yellow light to pass through the second panel 6 to the first panel 1. The red/green control devices 11 control the passage of light through the top layer 1. The red/green control devices determine whether any light is free to pass through the red-blue (magenta) 4 and green-blue (cyan) 5 filters located on the color filter surface of the top panel 1. Consequently, this layer not only controls hue but, significantly, controls brightness. Each pixel can be controlled to render gray shades as well as hue. This capability builds on the advantageous methods for rendering gray shades established by additive technology and avoids the distinctly complex luminance/chrominance interrelationships manifest in subtractive technology, alone. Referring next to Fig. 11, the operating conditions of pixels in each panel needed to produce the display colors listed is shown. For example, if a black pixel 12 is desired, then the condition of the second panel 6 is inconsequential because any light passing through this panel will be blocked by the off condition of the magenta and cyan pixels in the first panel 1. lf a white region 13 is desired, then one half of the pixels of the second panel 6 must be in the pass "yellow plus blue" (white) state and the magenta 4 and cyan 5 pixels in first panel 1 must be fully ON. Although the panel in actuality produces only discrete magenta and cyan pixels in this state, the eye fuses them into white because of the close proximity of these hues. For this fusion to be successful, the pixels must be small enough and close enough to fall within the integration zone of the eye. In order to produce a red region 14, the second panel 6 must be placed in the yellow or minus blue state 9 shown in Fig. 8. The magenta pixels 4 in the first panel 1 must be ON and the cyan pixels 5 in the desired region must be placed in the OFF state. Referring next to Fig. 12, a CIE color chart illustrating the range of colors which can be produced by gray level control of all pixels. If the blue control pixels 7 of the second panel 6 are varied from the pass blue state 8 plus 9 (all wavelengths are passed yielding white) to the block blue state 9, then each magenta pixel 4 moves from the magenta state to red along line 15 and each cyan pixel 5 moves from cyan to green along line 16 shown in Fig. 12. If blue is blocked entirely by pixels on layer 6, and if the cyan pixels 5 are ON and the magenta pixels are varied along a continuum from OFF to ON, then colors along line segment 17 will be produced, ending in yellow when the resultant green and red pixels are finally integrated by the eye. Conversely, if blue is again blocked by the second panel 6, but, this time, the magenta pixels 4 are fully ON and the cyan pixels 5 are varied from OFF to ON, then colors along line segment 18 will be produced. Again the final color is yellow. When all pixels are allowed to vary from one extreme state to the other, all the colors within region 19 can be produced. In addition, by taking advantage of additive methods, luminance can be varied as well. Images can be shaded, shaped and contoured in much the same manner as is used with additive juxtaposition mechanisms. It is the red/green pixels of additive methods which provide the brightness and shape information. Similarly, it is the magenta/cyan pixels of the additive/subtractive display system which provide the same kind of information. 2. Operation of the Preferred Embodiment The present invention differs from prior art by tailoring the panel in better accord with the human visual system. Specifically, the invention addresses the fact that human vision relies almost exclusively on non-blue light, the red colors and the green colors, for spatial and intensity information. Further, the invention takes into account the fact that the eye uses blue light energy almost exclusively for chromatic information alone. Because blue light contributes very little to spatial detail and brightness, the invention removes blue light control from the principal display surface and dedicates this surface to the brighter and more resolvable red and green pixels. To achieve a wide range of colors, blue light control is placed behind the principal imaging layer, using techniques developed recently for the subtractive superpositional approach. Together, these two image planes add and subtract light to synthesize higher resolution, higher brightness images with a broad range of colors. The invention combines the simplicity and superior luminance control of one approach (additive juxtaposition) with the resolution enhancement of the second approach (superpositional subtractive). By taking better advantage of the human visual system, the display system of the present invention produces up to one third more luminance and resolution capability than predominant methods without incurring the volume and complexity cost of the other methods. Blue pixel control, useful for color synthesis, but wasteful for brightness and image sharpness, is relegated to a secondary surface. This control leaves the primary display surface free to display the highly useful red and green pixels. These two display surfaces are sandwiched together into one compact flat panel display. Because imagery is not rapidly sequenced as a function of primary hue, the invention does not suffer from the temporal anomalies of temporal superposition approaches. Because it does not require recombination optics, it has a size advantage over spatial superposition methods. Finally, because it is primarily an additive display and uses only two imaging layers with blue on the secondary layer, it delivers more manageable luminance and color control, less complexity and parallax stability than the subtractive approach. The foregoing description is included to illustrate the operation of the preferred embodiment and is not meant to limit the scope of the invention. The scope of the invention is to be limited only by the following claims.

Claims: A liquid crystal color display unit to be used with a broad band light source, which display unit comprises a first liquid crystal panel (1) stacked on a second liquid crystal panel (6), wherein said first panel (1) controls the transmission of red and green light components therethrough and comprises a liquid crystal material (12) confined between two mutually parallel glass plates (13,15); combined color elements each of which comprises a mosaic of red/blue color filters and green/blue color filters (15), which combined color elements are located on the top of the outer glass plate (13); a first plurality of control elements (11) defining a) a first plurality of controllable pixel units (4) for controlling the transmission of the light through the red/blue color filter and b) a second plurality of controllable pixel units (5) for controlling the transmission of light through the green/blue color filter; wherein said second panel (6) controls the transmission of the blue light component of the broad band light source which illuminates the first panel through the second panel, said second panel comprising a dichroic material; a liquid crystal material (16) confined between two mutually parallel glass plates (13,14), a second plurality of control elements (10) defining a third plurality of controllable pixel units (7), each of which is aligned with one combined color element on the first panel; and whereby the second panel acts to controllably substract the blue component from illuminating light, so that the red/blue and green/blue color filters on the first panel are controllably illuminated with light with or without a blue component, thereby achieving a color display due to additive color mixing in the eye of the observer. Display unit according to claim 1, characterized in that image resolution is determined by said first panel (1) pixel units (4,5). Display unit according to claim 1, characterized in that brightness parameters of an image are controlled by said first panel (1) pixel units (4, 5). Display unit according to claim 3, characterized in that said pluralities of pixel units (4, 5, 7) are controlled using matrix addressing techniques. Display unit according to one of claims 1 to 4, characterized in that said second panel (6) pixel units (7) are at least as large as said first panel (1) pixel units (4, 5), a second panel pixel unit (7) transmitting radiation from said broad band light source to said plurality of pixel units of said first panel. Display unit according to claim 5, characterized in that colors of said image are obtained by combining radiation transmitted through a plurality of proximate first panel (1) pixel units (4,5). A method of displaying a color image on a liquid crystal display unit, characterized by the steps of: controllably blocking or transmitting blue image components in a first liquid crystal panel in response to white light applied thereto by a broadband light source; and using such filtered or non-filtered light to illuminate a mosaic of red/blue and green/blue filter elements on a second liquid crystal panel, so as to achieve the range of colors necessary for producing said color image on an observer's eye by additive color mixing.

Inventors: JOHNSON MICHAEL J, JOHNSON, MICHAEL J.
Applicants: HONEYWELL INC, HONEYWELL INC.
Application year: 1989
Main classification: G02F1
IPC codes: G02F1, G09F9