EXTRACTION PROCESS USING SUPERCRITICAL FLUID

Abstract: A process for separation of components of a mixture comprising more than one organic substance or of a mixture comprising at least one organic substance and water by extraction using a supercritical fluid as an extractant. During the extraction an extraction aid having a higher affinity with an unextractable component of the mixture than with an extractable component of the mixture is present. Also disclosed is an apparatus for carrying out this process.

Description: The present invention relates to a process for the separation of a mixture comprising one or more than one organic substance and water, using a supercritical fluid. A separation process using a supercritical fluid is used in various industries, and this technique has aroused interest from the point of view of saving energy and resources. Compared with the usual extraction process and distillation, this technique has the following advantages: improved extraction efficiency because of higher selectivity of a supercritical fluid, lower energy costs because the change of phase for separation and recovery of an extract and extractant become unnecessary, treatment of a heat-susceptible substance without degradation due to a relatively low working temperature, and easy elimination of residual solvent in product, and so on. Therefore much research is underway in a wide range of industrial fields, including the food processing and pharmaceutical industries. Typical applications of this technique are the extraction and separation of hydrocarbons, the elimination of caffeine from coffee, the extraction of a hop extract in beer production, the extraction of natural flavors, the elimination of nicotine from tobacco, and the isolation of alcohol from an aqueous alcohol solution. As described above, although the supercritical fluid extraction process has many advantages, the separation ability thereof is limited in cases wherein components to be separated have similar boiling points, or wherein components to be separated form an azeotropic mixture. For example, Japanese Unexamined Patent Publication 59-141528 discloses a process for the concentration of an ethanol aqueous solution under a three-phase condition of gas / light liquid / heavy liquid. Murakami et al., in "Separation of Ethanol Aqueous Solution by Supercritical Gas" (18th Annual Meeting, The Society of Chemical Engineering, Japan AS 109, 1984), reported the use of a separation process using a supercritical fluid. Nevertheless, the supercritical fluid extraction process cannot increase the ethanol concentration to a rate higher than 90% by weight, and this concentration limit is lower than that obtained by distillation, which can increase the ethanol concentration to a rate of up to 95.6% by weight. The present invention provides a process for extracting an organic substance from a mixture with water, by extraction using a supercritical fluid as an extractant, characterised by the presence, during the extraction, of an extraction aid which has a higher affinity with the water than with the organic substance. In a preferred aspect, the invention provides an extraction process wherein for the separation of components of a mixture comprising ethanol and water, carbon dioxide is used as a supercritical fluid, an extraction aid having high affinity to water is used in an amount of at least 40% by weight in relation to a total weight of the supercritical fluid and the mixture to be separated, and an ethanol aqueous solution having an ethanol concentration higher than that of the azeotropic mixture, or substantially absolute ethanol, is obtained. Other preferred features are identified in the sub-claims. The invention may be carried out in an apparatus for the separation of a mixture comprising an extractor to which the mixture to be separated, an extractant in a supercritical state, and an extraction aid are fed, and from which an extract fraction consisting of mainly the extractant and an extractable component of the mixture to be separated, and a residual fraction consisting of mainly the extraction aid and an unextractable component of the mixture to be separated, are discharged; an extractant-recovering device which separates the extract fraction into the extractant and a separated crude product fraction or end product consisting of mainly the extractable component; and an extraction aid-recovering device which separates the residual fraction into the extraction aid and the unextractable component; and an optional refining device to refine the separated crude product fraction to obtain a refined product. Another suitable type of apparatus comprises a first extractor to which a mixture to be separated, and an extractant in a supercritical state, are fed, and from which a first extract fraction consisting of mainly the extractant and an extractable component of the mixture to be separated, and a first residual fraction consisting of substantially an unextractable component of the mixture to be separated, are discharged; a second extractor to which the first extract fraction and an extraction aid are fed, and from which a second extract fraction consisting of mainly the extractant and an extractable component of the mixture to be separated, are discharged, and a second residual fraction consisting of mainly the extraction aid and an unextractable component of the mixture to be separated, are discharged; an extractant-recovering device which separates the second extract fraction into the extractant and a separated crude product fraction or end product consisting of mainly the extractable component; and an extraction aid-recovering device which separates the second residual fraction into the extraction aid and the unextractable component; and a optional refining device which refines the separated crude product fraction to obtain a refined product. Figures 1 to 3 represent flow charts of apparatus for carrying out embodiments of the present invention. The process of the present invention is preferably used to separate a mixture having components with similar boiling points or a mixture having components that form an azeotropic mixture. The mixtures having components with similar boiling points are, for example, methanol / water, acetic acid / water, and acetone / water. Mixtures whose components form an azeotropic mixture are, for example, ethanol / water, propanol / water, isopropanol / water, allyl alcohol / water, 2,3-dichloro-1-propanol / water, 2-methoxyethanol / water, 1-butanol / water, 2-butanol / water, tert-butanol / water, furfuryl alcohol / water, 1-pentanol / water, 2-pentanol / water, 4-methyl-1-butanol / water, 1,4-dioxane / water, ethyl ether / water, ethyl propyl ether / water, methyl ethyl ketone / water, tetrahydrofuran / water, ethylenediamine / water, methyl acrylate / water, methyl acetate / water, ethyl acetate / water, pyridine / water, methyl methacrylate / water, and formic acid / water. Typical extractants used in a form of a supercritical fluid are, for example, inorganic substances such as carbon dioxide, ammonia and nitrous oxide, and organic substances, for example, lower paraffinic hydrocarbons such as methane, ethane, propane, butane, pentane and hexane, and lower olefinic hydrocarbons such as ethylene and propylene. Moreover, other inorganic substances such as sulfur dioxide, hydrogen halide, and other organic substance such as alcohols, dimethyl butane, benzene, trichlorofluoromethane, ethers may be used. The above-mentioned extractant is used in an amount of 0.5 to 50, preferably 2 to 15, times by weight in relation to an amount of an extractable component or a total amount of extractable components, if more than one extractable component is present, in a mixture to be separated. The extraction aid used in the present process is any substance which has a higher affinity with an unextractable component of the mixture to be separated than with an extractable component of the mixture, and can improve the selection ability of the extractant in supercritical state. The selection of the extraction aid depends on the components of a mixture to be separated. In the case wherein a mixture comprising water and one or several organic substances should be separated, the extraction aid is selected from polyhydric alcohols, sugars, sugaralcohols, and the like. The extraction aids preferably include ethylene glycol, propylene glycol, diethylene glycol, butanediol, hexylene glycol, polyethylene glycol (mean molecular weight n = 200 to 7000), polypropylene glycol (mean molecular weight n = 400 to 7000), glycerol, and derivatives thereof, such as ethylene glycol monomethyl ether, ethylene glycol monoethyl ether, ethylene glycol monobutyl ether, diethylene glycol monomethyl ether, diethylene glycol monoethyl ether, diethylene glycol monobutyl ether and the like, and carbohydrates such as glucose, fructose, galactose, xylose, mannose, sucrose, lactose, maltose, xylobiose, starches, sorbitol, mannitol and the like. An amount of an extraction aid used depends on the composition of a mixture to be separated, kind of extractant, kind of extraction aid, and the like, and is preferably at least 40% by weight, more preferably 60 to 80% by weight, in relation to a total weight of the extraction aid and the mixture to be separated. Next, the present invention is described in detail with reference to the drawings, wherein an ethanol aqueous solution is used as an example of a starting mixture to be separated. Figure 1 represents a preferable system for carrying out the process. In the Figure, a central region of the extractor 2 comprises a starting mixture feeding site 11 for feeding a starting ethanol / water mixture 31; a lower region thereof comprises an extractant feeding site 15 for feeding an extractant such as carbon dioxide at a supercritical state, and a residual fraction discharging site 17 for discharging a residual fraction consisting of mainly water and an extraction aid such as ethylene glycol; and at an upper region thereof comprises an extraction aid feeding site 16 for feeding an extraction aid 34, and an extract fraction discharging site 18 for discharging an extract fraction 33 consisting of mainly extracted ethanol extractant and a small amount of an extraction aid, ethylene glycol. A starting material ethanol aqueous solution, for example, a 10% ethanol aqueous solution 31, is fed via the starting mixture feeding site 11 into the extractor 2. An extractant carbon dioxide 35 is compressed by a compressor 7 to a pressure of, for example, 100 atm., and brought to a supercritical state by cooling to, for example, 40°C, with a heat exchanger 8, and fed via the extractant feeding site 15 into the extractor 2. On the other hand, an extraction aid 34 is fed via the extraction aid feeding site 16 into the extractor 2. As a result of the extraction in the extractor 2, the residual fraction 32, consisting of separated water derived from the starting ethanol solution and a major portion of the extraction aid, is discharged via the residual fraction discharging site 17. On the other hand, an extract fraction 33, consisting of the extractant still in a supercritical state, ethanol concentrated to a concentration higher than an azeotropic concentration, for example, 98%, and a small amount of the extraction aid ethylene glycol, is discharged via the extract fraction discharging site 18. The extraction aid recovering device 4 is, for example, a distillation column, and has a residual fraction feeding site 19 for feeding the residual fraction 32, a water discharging site 20 for discharging water (or vapor) 36, and an extraction aid discharging site 21 for discharging an extraction aid 37. In the extraction aid recovering device 4, the residual fraction 32 consisting of a major portion of water derived from the starting ethanol aqueous solution and a major portion of the extraction aid (for example, more than 99% of fed extraction aid) is distilled and separated into water 36 and the extraction aid 37. The extraction aid 37 is then combined with a small amount of an extraction aid 38 recovered by the refining device, described hereinafter in detail, and the combined extraction aid 34 is recycled via a pump 9 into the extractor 2. The extraction aid may be either in a supercritical state or a subcritical state. If the extraction aid is in a subcritical state, the extraction aid is preferably adjusted to a temperature higher than a temperature 0.9 times a critical temperature, and to a pressure higher than a pressure 0.5 times a critical pressure, by a heat exchanger 12 and the pump 9. The extractant recovering device 5 may be a conventional device used for the separation of extracted ethanol from an extractant by destroying or shifting a supercritical condition, and comprises an extract fraction feeding site 22 for feeding the extract fraction 33, an extractant discharging site 23 for discharging a recovered extractant 35, and a separated crude fraction discharging site 24 for discharging separated crude ethanol 39. For example, by decreasing a pressure or increasing a temperature of the extract fraction 33, which has been in a supercritical state, the extract fraction 33 is separated into an extractant 35 and a crude ethanol product 39 which is sufficiently concentrated and, occasionally, contains a small amount of an extraction aid. A decreasing pressure is preferable for the separation. The recovered extractant 35 is adjusted to a predetermined supercritical state by the compressor 7 and the heat exchanger 8, and then recycled into the extractor 2. Note, if necessary, any loss of the extractant during the recycling is supplemented by a fresh extractant 50. The refining device 6 is, for example, a distillation column, and comprises a separated crude product feeding site 25, an extraction aid discharging site 26, and an end product discharging site 27. In the refining device, the crude product 39 consisting of a small amount of the extraction aid and highly concentrated ethanol, for example, an ethanol product having a concentration of more than 98% in relation to a total of water and ethanol, which concentration is higher than an azeotropic concentration of a mixture consisting of ethanol and water, is separated into an ethanol product 40 having a concentration of more than 98% and a small amount of the extraction aid 38. The extraction aid 38 is combined with the extraction aid 37 recovered from the extraction aid recovering device 4, and the combined extraction aid 34 is recycled into the extractor 2, as described above. Note, in the above-mentioned embodiment, a minor portion of the ethylene glycol is removed by an extract, when an extraction aid which is not removed by an extract, for example, starch, glucose, sucrose or the like, is used, since the extraction aid is not incorporated into the extract fraction 33, and therefore, into the crude product 39, the refining device 6 may not be necessary. Moreover, in the above-mentioned embodiment, for the extraction aid recovering device 4 and the refining device 6 distillation columns are used, these devices are not limited to a distillation column; and any means having the above-mentioned separation function, for example, reverse osmosis, pervaporation, and like, can be used. The second embodiment of the present process is shown in Fig. 2. In this figure, the same numbers as those in Fig. 1 are used for parts corresponding to those in Fig. 1. This embodiment is the same as the above-mentioned first embodiment except that a starting mixture, for example, a 10% ethanol aqueous solution, is subjected to extraction and separation without an extraction aid in the first extractor 1, and subsequently, extraction using an extraction aid is carried out in the second extractor 2. The first extractor 1 has an upper region comprising a starting mixture feeding site 11 and a first extract fraction discharging site 13, and a lower region comprising an extractant feeding site 15. In this embodiment, for example, a 10% ethanol aqueous solution 31, is fed via the starting mixture feeding site 11 into the first extractor 1, wherein the ethanol aqueous solution is separated into a first residual fraction 41, and a first extract fraction 42 consisting of an extractant carbon dioxide and a concentrated ethanol product having a concentration of about 90% in relation to a total amount of water and ethanol. The second extractor 2 has a lower region comprising a first extract fraction feeding site 14. In the second extractor 2, the first extract fraction 42 is separated into a second residual fraction 32 and a second extract fraction 33. In the second embodiment, the extraction aid recovering device 4, the extractant recovering device 5, and the refining device 6 function in the same manner as described for the first embodiment. In this embodiment, since a major portion of the water in the starting mixture has been eliminated in the first extractor, an amount of water in the first extract fraction 42 and, therefore, in the second residual fraction, is very small. Therefore, an amount of water eliminated in the extraction aid recovering device 4 is very small, resulting in a decreased amount of extraction aid used, and therefore, in a remarkable saving in construction and operation costs for the extraction aid recovering device 4. Figure 3 represents a third embodiment of apparatus for carrying out the invention. In this embodiment, the first extractor 1 and the second extractor 2 in Fig. 2 are integrated as the extractor 3, as shown in Fig. 3. the lower half (1) of the extractor 3 corresponds to the first extractor 1 in Fig. 2, and the upper half (2) of the extractor 3 corresponds to the second extractor 2 in Fig. 2. The extractor 3 has an upper region comprising an extract fraction discharging site 18 and an extraction aid feeding site 16, a central region comprising a starting mixture feeding site 11 and a second residual fraction discharging site 17, and a lower region comprising a first residual fraction discharging site 10 and an extractant feeding site 15. A starting mixture, for example, a 10% ethanol aqueous solution 31, is fed via the starting mixture feeding site 11 to the extractor 3, and an extractant, for example, carbon dioxide in a supercritical state, is fed via the extractant feeding site 15 into the extractor 3; and a first residual fraction 41 consisting of water derived from the starting mixture is discharged, and an extractant still in a supercritical state and concentrated ethanol having a concentration of about 90% in relation to a total amount of water and ethanol, move from the lower part (1) of the extractor 3 to the upper part (2) of the extractor 3. An extraction aid, which has been fed via the extraction aid feeding site 16 into the extractor 3, is recovered in a receiver 45, except that a minor portion of the extraction aid is transferred to a extract fraction 33. The extraction aid recovered in the receiver 45 is removed, via a second residual fraction discharging site 17, as a second residual fraction 32. The extractant recovering device 5 and the refining device 6 function in the same manner as described for the first embodiment. In this embodiment, since the apparatus can be compactly constructed, the construction and operation costs are further reduced. In the third embodiment, the second residual fraction 32 consisting of a large amount of extraction aid and a small amount of water is separated by a reverse osmosis or pervaporation device 70 instead of a distillation column 4. Although a continuous separation process is used in the above-mentioned embodiments, a batch-wise process also can be used. In the batch-wise process, first a starting mixture and an extraction aid are fed into an extractor at a predetermined ratio, and then an extractant in a supercritical state is introduced into the extractor to obtain an extract fraction. Although in the above-mentioned embodiment the process of the present invention is illustrated in detail for a mixture of water and ethanol, similarly, a mixture of water and another lower alcohol such as methanol, propanol, butanol or the like, or a mixture of water and a lower alkanoic acid such as acetic acid, propionic acid or the like, can be separated to produce a concentrated lower alcohol or lower alkanoic acid. According to the present process, a mixture whose components have a similar boiling point, and therefore, are difficult to be separated by usual distillation, can be effectively separated. Moreover, a mixture of water and an organic substance which can form an azeotropic mixture with water, can be efficiently separated to produce a highly concentrated organic product over an azeotropic concentration. Examples The present invention will now be further illustrated by, but is by no means limited to, the following examples. Example 1. About 2000 g of total weight of a mixture consisting of ethanol, water and ethylene glycol, having a ratio that differs run by run, was charged in a 3 liter - extractor, and carbon dioxide in a supercritical state was then introduced to the extractor to separate ethanol. More specifically, ethylene glycol, as an extraction aid, was charged into the extractor in an amount of 10, 50, or 80% by weight in relation to a total weight of the ethylene glycol and an ethanol aqueous solution. A balance amount of the ethanol aqueous solution having an ethanol concentration of about 20, 30, 60, 70, 80, or 90% by weight in relation to a total weight of ethanol and water, was also charged into the extractor. A batch-wise extraction was then carried out by a flow-through method, wherein carbon dioxide in a supercritical state was passed through the extractor at a pressure of l03.5 kg/cm² (10.1 N/mm²) (gauge pressure) and a temperature of 40°C, and at a flow rate of l.5 to 3 kg/hour. A pressure of the fluid which has passed through the extractor, which was still in a supercritical state, was reduced to 30 kg/cm² (2.9 N/mm²) (gauge pressure) to separate carbon dioxide from other components which substantially consist of ethanol and water and is designated as "extract" in the Examples. An ethanol concentration of the extract was determined by gas chromatography. The results are shown in Table l. In this table, the phrase "ethanol concentration of original liquid" denotes the percentage by weight of ethanol in relation to a total weight of ethanol, ethylene glycol and water before the supercritical carbon dioxide is passed through the extractor, and "Solubility of ethanol + water" denotes a total amount of ethanol and water dissolved in l00 g of carbon dioxide in the fluid which has passed through the extractor. The term "Selectivity" denotes a value obtained by dividing a percentage by weight of ethanol in relation to a weight of water in the extract by a percentage by weight of ethanol in relation to a weight of water in the original ethanol aqueous solution. Next, for comparison, the same experiment as described above was repeated except that the extraction aid ethylene glycol was not added. The results are shown in Table 2. As can be seen from a comparison of Table l and 2, when the extraction aid ethylene glycol was not used, the maximum ethanol concentration was about 90%. On the other hand, when ethylene glycol was added by an amount of 50% by weight, an ethanol concentration much higher than the azeotropic concentration was obtained. Example 2. Example l was repeated except that diethylene glycol was used as an extraction aid. The results are shown in Table 3. Example 3. Example l was repeated except that polyethylene glycol (mean molecular weight 200) was used as an extraction aid. The results are shown in Table 4. Example 4. Example l was repeated except that glucose was used as an extraction aid. The results are shown in Table 5. Example 5. Example l was repeated except that glycerol was used as an extraction aid. The results are shown in Table 6. Example 6. A l0% by weight ethanol aqueous solution was continuously extracted by an apparatus as shown in Fig. 2. That is, the solution was continuously fed to a top of the first extraction column (packed column; packing diameter 3 to 4 mm, Dixon Packing; column diameter 2.5 cm, packed height 2 m); on the other hand, a carbon dioxide extractant in a supercritical state at a temperature of 40°C and a pressure of l03.4 kg/cm² (10.1 N/mm²) (gauge pressure) was introduced to a bottom of the extraction column at a flow rate of 5200 g/hour. From the top of the extraction column, a first extract fraction containing 8l% by weight of ethanol was obtained at a flow rate of 68.5 g/hour. The first extract fraction was continuously sent to a bottom of the second extraction column (packed column; packing diameter 3 ∿ 4 mm, Dixon Packing; column diameter 2.5 cm, packed height l m), and to a top of the second extraction column, ethylene glycol as an extraction aid was fed at a flow rate of 300 g/hour. From the top of the second extraction column, 98% by weight of ethanol product was obtained at a rate of 55 g/hour. In the second extraction column, the operation temperature was 40°C, and the operation pressure was l03.4 kg/cm² (10.1 N/mm²) (gauge pressure). Example 7. A ten percent by weight ethanol aqueous solution was continuously extracted using an apparatus as shown in Fig. 2. That is, the solution was fed to a central site of the first extraction column (packed column; packing diameter 3 to 4 mm, Dixon Packing; column diameter 2.5 cm, packed height 4 m); on the other hand a carbon dioxide extractant in a supercritical state at a temperature of 60°C and a pressure of 200 kg/cm² (19.6 N/mm²) (gauge pressure) was fed at a flow rate of 4800 g/hour to the bottom of the column. From the top of the extraction column, a first extract fraction containing 47.l% by weight of ethanol was obtained with an ethanol recovery rate of about 99% in relation to an amount of original ethanol, at a flow rate of 63.l g/hour. Next, the first extract fraction was sent to a bottom of the second extraction column (packed column; packing diameter 3 ∿ 4 mm, Dixon Packing; column diameter 2.5 cm, packed height 2 m) which was controlled to maintain a temperature of 40°C and a pressure of l00 kg/cm² (9.8 N/mm²) (gauge pressure); and a glycerol extraction aid was fed to the top of the second extraction column at a flow rate of l00 g/hour. From the top of the column, an absolute ethanol product having a concentration of 99.9% by weight of ethanol was obtained at a rate of 28 g/hour. In this case, a portion of the ethanol product was recycled to the top of the second extraction column as reflux. Example 8. An acetic acid aqueous solution consisting of 8l.8 g of acetic acid and 690 g of water was charged into a 3 ℓ - volume extractor, and l530 g of ethylene glycol as an extraction aid was added to the extractor. Carbon dioxide in a supercritical state at a temperature of 40°C and a pressure of l00 kg/cm² (9.8 N/mm²) (gauge pressure) was fed to the extractor at a rate of l kg/hour for two hours while maintaining a temperature of 40°C and a pressure of l00 kg/cm² (9.8 N/mm²) (gauge pressure) in the extractor, to carry out supercritical extraction. By shifting a supercritical condition of a fluid which has passed through the extractor, by reducing the pressure, carbon dioxide was separated from other components which constitute an extract fraction. As a result, the extract fraction was 24.l g of an acetic acid aqueous solution having an acetic acid concentration of 86% by weight.

Claims: A process for extracting an organic substance from a mixture with water, by extraction using a supercritical fluid as an extractant, characterised by the presence, during the extraction, of an extraction aid which has a higher affinity with the water than with the organic substance. A process according to claim 1, wherein the difference of boiling points between the water and organic substance is so small that the components cannot be satisfactorily separated without the extraction aid. A process according to claim 1, wherein the mixture comprises water and an organic substance which can form an azeotropic mixture with water. A process according to claim 1, claim 2 or claim 3 wherein the extractant used in a form of supercritical fluid is an inorganic compound selected from carbon dioxide, ammonia and nitrous oxide. A process according to claim 1, claim 2 or claim 3 wherein the extractant used in a form of supercritical fluid is a lower hydrocarbon selected from paraffinic hydrocarbon and olefinic hydrocarbon. A process according to any preceding claim wherein a substance having a high boiling point and a high affinity to water is used as an extraction aid for the separation of the mixture. A process according to claim 6, wherein the extraction aid is a polyhydric alcohol selected from polyethylene glycol, polypropylene glycol and glycerol. A process according to claim 6, wherein the extraction aid is a carbohydrate selected from glucose, sucrose and starch. A process according to claim 6, wherein the extraction aid is a sugaralcohol. A process according to any preceding claim wherein the extraction aid is used in an amount of at least 40% by weight in relation to a total weight of the extraction aid and the mixture to be separated. A process according to claim 10, wherein the extraction aid is used in an amount of 60 to 80% by weight in relation to a total weight of the extraction aid and the mixture to be separated. A process according to claim 1, wherein a working temperature is at least a multiple of 0.9 in relation to a critical temperature of the extraction aid. A process according to claim 1, wherein a working pressure is at least a multiple of 0.5 in relation to a critical pressure of the extraction aid. A process according to claim 1, wherein for the separation of components of a mixture comprising ethanol and water, carbon dioxide is used as a supercritical fluid, an extraction aid having high affinity to water is used in an amount of at least 40% by weight in relation to a total weight of the supercritical fluid and the mixture to be separated, and an ethanol aqueous solution having an ethanol concentration higher than that of the azeotropic mixture, or substantially absolute ethanol, is obtained.

Inventors: HIRATA, MITSUHO, ISHIKAWA, TAKESHI, SHIRAISHI, HIROSHI
Applicants: SUNTORY LIMITED
Application year: 1987
Main classification: B01D11
IPC codes: C07B31, C07C53, C07C27, C07C29, C07C67, C07C51, C07B63, C07C31, B01D11