PROCESS FOR DETERMINING THE ACTIVITY OF A PALLADIUM-TIN CATALYST

Abstract: The effectiveness of a palladium-tin catalyst for subsequent plating thereon is determined by employing cyclic voltametry.

Description: The present invention is concerned with determining the activity of a palladium-tin colloidal catalyst and is especially concerned with determining the activity of such for subsequent electroless plating of a metal such as copper or nickel thereon. In the fabrication of printed circuit cards and boards, a dielectric sheet material is employed as a substrate. A conductive circuit pattern is provided on one or both of the major surfaces of the substrate. A conductive pattern can be formed on the surface of a substrate using a variety of known techniques. These known techniques include the subtractive technique where a layer of copper is etched to form the desired circuit pattern, the EDB (electroless direct bond) technique where copper is electrolessly plated directly on the surface of the substrate in the desired pattern, and the peel-apart technique where the desired circuit plated up from a thin layer of peel-apart copper. In any of these techniques, connections between layers are made by means of plated through-holes. In plating such holes, copper must be plated directly on the dielectric substrate (on the walls of the holes). Moreover, if one employs the EDB technique, one must plate directly onto the surface of the substrate. Since the dielectric substrate is non-conductive, in order to plate on the substrate (either on the walls or the holes, or on the surface of the substrate), the substrate must be seeded or catalyzed prior to the deposition of the metal onto the substrate. Among the more widely employed procedures for catalyzing a substrate is the use of a stannous chloride sensitizing solution and a palladium chloride activator to form a layer of metallic palladium particles. For instance, one method for catalyzing a dielectric substrate is exemplified by U.S. Patent 3,011,920 which includes sensitizing the substrate by first treating it with a solution of a colloidal metal, accelerating the treatment with a selective solvent to remove protective colloids from the sensitized dielectric substrate, and then electrolessly depositing a metal coating on the sensitized substrate; for example, with copper from a solution of a copper salt and a reducing agent. The use of palladium-tin colloidal catalysts has been satisfactory for electroless or electroplating thin layers of conductive metals on a non-conductive dielectric substrate for many prior art applications. However, as the demands for more complex circuitry increases and the requirements of quality of the plated metal likewise increase, the demands upon the quality of the catalyst have also increased. For instance, one recurring problem has been the existence of voids and through-holes and/or poor adhesion or coverage of the dielectric substrate. The quality and ability of the catalyst to coat the substrate has a significant effect on the resulting quality of the plated metal. Accordingly, it is important to be able to distinguish between active end non-active palladium-tin catalysts. Furthermore, it would be desirable to be able to do so in a consistent and reliable manner. In J. Electrochem. Soc., Electrochemical Science and Technology, Feb. 1983, Vol. 130, No. 2, pp. 311-317, J. Horkans "A Cyclic Voltammetric Study of Pd-Sn Colloidal Catalysts for Electroless Deposition" (D2) a one-step or two-step cyclic voltammetric method is described that allows the evaluation of catalysts for electroless deposition. However, the described cyclic voltammetric method alone is not satisfactory for the purpose of monitoring differences between good, acceptable seeder and seeder which is slightly below that suitable for producing a reliable product. The Horkans article does not suggest the particular combination of testing procedures employed in accordance with the present invention. IBM J. Res. Develop. Vol. 28, No. 6, Nov. 1984, pp. 690-696, Horkans et al., "Initiation of electroless Cu plating on nonmetallic surfaces" (D1) mentions under Analytic techniques the application of electrochemical methods for characterization of Pd-Sn colloids which have been described in the above given previous publication (D2). This publication also does not suggest the particular combination of testing procedures employed in accordance with the present invention. The process of the present invention provides for distinguishing between active and non-active palladium-tin catalysts. The process of the present invention makes it possible to consistently and reliably characterize the activity of the palladium-tin catalyst. In particular, the process of the present invention for determining the activity of a palladium-tin colloidal catalyst for the subsequent plating thereon includes determining the cyclic voltammetric Sn-Pd colloid peak of a dried sample of said catalyst, and comparing said cyclic voltammetric Sn-Pd colloid peak to the cyclic voltammetric Sn-Pd colloid peak of a reference Sn-Pd colloid catalyst;determining the optical density of a coating of a sample of said catalyst on a glass substrate and comparing it to reference optical density; determining the time for electrolessly plating a metal onto a glass substrate catalyzed with a sample of the catalyst and comparing the time to reference time; and determining the thickness of the coating on glass and comparing it to a reference. Figure 1 is a schematic diagram of apparatus suitable for carrying out the voltammetric procedure employed in the process of the present invention. The present invention is concerned with determining the activity of a palladium-tin catalyst for subsequent plating thereon and especially for electroless plating thereon. Typical palladium-tin colloidal catalysts subjected to the process of the present invention contain about 1.2 to about 2.5 grams/liter of a palladium salt which is preferably PdCl₂, about 80 to about 150 grams/liter of a stannous salt which is preferably SnCl₂ 2H₂ O, and about 100 to about 150 milliliters per liter of an acid which is preferably HCl. When HCl is provided in the form of a 37% HCl solution in the catalyst, about 290 to about 360 milliliters of the HCl solution is typically employed. In accordance with the present invention, in order to characterize the palladium-tin catalyst as being active or non-active, a sample of the catalyst is subjected to a plurality of testing procedures, preferably to the four testing procedures mentioned in claim 1. One of the essential procedures employed in accordance with the present invention involves a cyclic voltammetry method. By employing a cyclic voltammetric procedure, the Sn-Pd colloid peak of the sample is determined. The cyclic voltammetric procedure includes providing a cathode, a reference electrode, and an anode in a suitable container. The cathode employed is a copper surface covered with the sample to be tested. The preferred copper surface is a one ounce copper foil which corresponds to a layer thickness of 36 µm. A typical size for testing is about 4.45 cm by 4,45 cm square. Prior to coating or covering the copper foil with the sample to be tested, the copper substrate can be immersed in concentrated HCl (about 37% HCl) for about 0.75 to about 1.25 minutes, typical of which is about 1 minute, followed by washing with deionized water in order to prepare the copper substrate for contact with the sample to be tested. Next, the copper foil is immersed in the sample for about 4.75 to about 5.25 minutes, typically about 5 minutes. The foil is then removed from the sample to be tested, washed with deionized water, air-dried under high pressure, and finally, oven-dried for about 14 to about 16 minutes, typically about 15 minutes at about 60°C to about 70°C and typically about 65°C. The seeded copper foil is placed in the test cell, along with a reference electrode and cathode of copper foil. Suitable reference electrodes include saturated calomel electrodes and silver/silver chloride. The anode surface is generally platinum or palladium. The anode surface area is usually about equal to the surface area of the cathode to about twice the surface area of the cathode. The electrolyte employed in the test is a 0.1N perchloric acid aqueous solution (HClO₄). About 120 milliliters of such is employed in a container of about 200 cc. The solution is purged with nitrogen for about 4.75 minutes to about 5.25 minutes, typically about 5 minutes in order to remove any oxygen from the solution. An electric current is passed between the cathode and the anode. The current density is usually in the range of about 0.04 to about 0.21 milliamperes/cm² of the cathode surface area (one side) and preferably about 0.07 to about 0.21 milliamperes/cm² of the cathode surface area (one side). The voltage difference between the cathode and the reference electrode is varied in the direction to thereby remove or oxidize the materials of the cathode and then reversed to recoat or reduce the materials of the cathode. The voltage is usually varied between about _0.56 volts versus a saturated calomel electrode for a platinum anode and increased at a rate of about 10 to about 100 and preferably about 20 to about 30 and most typically about 26 millivolts per second, up to about +0,04 volts and is then reversed back to a voltage of about _0.56 volts. Generally about 1 1/2 complete cycles are employed per test. During this time, the electrodes are maintained in a stationary position. The voltage versus the current are recorded and plotted. The Pd-Sn colloid peak for this set-up is at about _0.28 volts. The peak of the Pd-Sn colloid is compared to the Sn-Pd colloid peak of a reference seeder known to be active. If the peak is not at least equal to that of the reference catalyst or seeder, then the catalyst is rejected. Reference to Figure 1 illustrates apparatus suitable for carrying out the cyclic voltammetric procedure employed in the process of the present invention. In particular, there is shown a container designated by 1 containing the electrodes and electrolyte. The electrolyte is conveyed to the testing apparatus via conduit 3 and exits the testing apparatus via conduit 2. Nitrogen is injected into the bath via conduit 4 and exits via conduit 5. Immersed in the electrolyte is the reference electrode 6, the seeded cathode 7, and the metal anode (counter-electrode) 8. The anode 8 is electrically connected to ammeter 9 and to the negative pole of a control led current-potential source (not shown) via ohmic connection 10. Reference electrode 6 is electrically connected to a potential recording device 11 via ohmic connection 12. The cathode 7 is electrically connected to the positive pole of a controlled current-potential source (not shown) via ohmic connectors 13 and 15. The cathode 7 is electrically connected to the potential recording device 11 via connectors 13 and 14. Potential recording device 11 records the voltage difference between the reference electrode 6 and the cathode or working electrode 7. Moreover, in accordance with preferred aspects of the present invention, to further assure activity of the palladium-tin catalyst, additional tests are carried out. In particular, another test performed to characterize the catalyst composition in accordance with the present invention is to measure the optical density of a coating of the seeder on glass substrate and comparing it to that measured for reference seeder composition. The procedure includes employing glass slides such as those of about 2.54 cm by 7.62 cm, cleaning for about 0.75 to about 1.25 minutes, typically 1 minute in hot K-2 cleaner, followed by a hot deionized water rinse for about 1.75 to about 2.25 minutes, typically about 2 minutes. Next, the slide is coated immersed in a bath containing Reten, typically about 0.05 weight percent in 2% H₂SO₄ aqueous solution for about 0.75 to about 1.25 minutes, typically 1 minute. The coated slide is then rinsed in deionized water for about 0.75 to about 1.25 minutes, typically about 1 minute and coated with the seeder by immersion in the seeder composition for about 2.75 to about 1.25 minutes, typically about 3 minutes. The slide is then washed for about 1.75 to about 2.25 minutes, typically about 2 minutes in deionized water and dried for about 14 to about 16 minutes, typically about 15 minutes in an oven at about 60°C to about 70°C, typically about 65°C. The optical density can be measured using a densitometer such as a McBeth Densitometer. The light transmission values should be about 40% to about 72% with about 58% being preferred. The activity of the catalyst composition is further verified by determining the amount of time for plating onto the glass slides treated as above. Such glass slides containing the seeder composition are prepared for the plating by first cleaning, such as by contacting the slides in hydrochloric acid (e.g. 8% concentration) for about 4 to about 6 seconds, typically about 5 seconds to activate the catalyst, then in deionized water for about 4 to about 6 seconds, typically about 5 seconds. The slides are then placed in an electroless copper plating bath at a temperature of about 70-80°C, typically about 72°C ± 2°C for about 3 to about 5 minutes, typically about 4 minutes. The quality of the coating is then compared to that obtained in the same bath by using a reference seeded composition. The glass plating can also be determined by placing both the glass slides containing the seeder compositions of the sample to be tested, as well as a reference seeder composition in an electroless plating bath and removing the slides upon one of the slides being coated with the copper. Then the quality and thickness of the coatings are compared. Moreover, the activity of the seeder is verified by comparing the take time for the electroless plating to occur, as compared to the take time of a reference seeder. This can be determined by placing cards containing conductive lines referred to as resistance or Rho cards with sample and reference seeders compositions coated thereon in the same manner as the glass slides hereinabove were coated. The cards are attached to an ohmmeter which, in turn, is connected to a chart recorder. The cards are placed into an electroless plating bath which is at a bath temperature of about 70 to about 80°C, typically about 72°C ± 2°C. The take time is recorded on the chart and is calculated from the break point in the recorder tracing which indicates an electrical connection between the conductive lines on the card. This take time test provides for an understanding of the activity of the bath by providing a time versus copper deposition relationship.

Claims: 1. Method for determining the activity of a palladium-tin colloidal catalyst for subsequent plating thereon which comprises: determining the cyclic voltammetric Sn-Pd colloid peak of a dried sample of said catalyst, and comparing said cyclic voltammetric Sn-Pd colloid peak to the cyclic voltammetric Sn-Pd colloid peak of a reference Sn-Pd colloid catalyst; determining the optical density of a coating of a sample of said catalyst on a glass substrate and comparing it to reference optical density; determining the time for electrolessly plating a metal onto a glass substrate catalyzed with a sample of the catalyst and comparing the time to reference time; and determining the thickness of the coating on glass and comparing it to a reference. 2. Method of claim 1 wherein said cyclic voltammetric Sn-Pd colloid peak is determined by varying the voltage between about _0.56 V versus a saturated calomel electrode to about +0.04 V and then back to about _0.56 V. 3. Method of claim 2 wherein said Pd-Sn colloid peak is at about _0.28 V. 4. Method of claim 3 wherein the electrolyte used in determining said cyclic voltammetric Sn-Pd colloid peak is about a 0.1 N perchloric acid aqueous solution. 5. Method of claim 1 wherein the electrodes used in determining said Sn-Pd colloid peak are maintained in a stationary position during the determination of said colloid peak. 6. Method of claim 1 wherein said metal is copper. 7. Method of claim 1 which further includes determining the take time for electroless plating of a metal onto a resistance card and comparing it to a reference take time. 8. Method of claim 1 wherein said palladium-tin catalyst contains about 1.2 to about 2.5 g/l of a palladium salt and about 80 to about 150 g/l of a stannous salt. 9. Method of claim 8 wherein said palladium salt is PdCl₂ and said stannous salt is SnCl₂ × 2 H₂O. 10. Method of claim 1 wherein said cyclic voltammetric Sn-Pd colloid peak is determined by varying the voltage for about 1 1/2 complete cycles. 11. Method of claim 1 wherein said cycle voltammetric Sn-Pd colloid peak is determined by employing as cathode (7) a copper foil coated with the catalyst being tested, a reference electrode (6), and an anode (8). 12. Method of claim 11 wherein said copper foil is one ounce copper foil.

Inventors: AMELIO, WILLIAM JOSEPH, CZARNECKI, KENNETH RAYMOND, LEMON, GARY KEVIN, MARKOVICH, VOYA, SAMBUCETTI, CARLOS JUAN, ZARR, RICHARD STUART
Applicants: INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATION
Application year: 1987
Main classification: G01N27
IPC codes: H05K3, G01N27, C23C18