RADIO FREQUENCY INTERFERENCE RADIATION SUPPRESSING IGNITION SYSTEM

Abstract: For an ignition system including an an ignition coil (40), a distributor (10) and spark plugs (70), several measures are taken to suppress radio frequency interference radiation therefrom. The distributor (10) has a rotor segment (24) with its output tip surface (24a) formed of of conductive and dielectric materials (26, 28) separately disposed from each other. Each of the spark plugs (70) includes a monolithic resistor (80) connected between its input terminal (82) and its center electrode (74). The spark plugs are connected to the distributor through respective first cables (60) each including a carbon impregnated conductive wire (92) covered with an insulating sheath (94). The ignition coil (40) is connected to the distributor (10) through a second cable (50) including a carbon impregnated conductive wire covered with an in­ sulating sheath. The second cable carbon impregnated conductive wire has a resistance of 12 kΩ or more.

Description: DESCRIPTION This invention relates to a radio frequency interference radiation suppressing ignition system for use with motor vehicle internal combustion engines. Motor vehicle radio frequency interference radiation, which is caused by the breakdown of the arc gap between the distributor rotor output segment tip surface and each of the circumferentially disposed distributor output terminals and by the breakdown of the arc gap of each spark plug, creates disturbances in television units, radio units, and other broadcasting units. In order to avoid such disturbances, standards have been established in Japan and foreign countries to regulate or control motor vehicle radio frequency interference radiation. Such motor vehicle radio frequency interference radiation would also cause troubles in motor vehicle electronic controlled systems including an electronic controlled fuel injection system, electronic controlled antiskid system, electronic controlled automatic transmission system, etc. to endanger safe vehicle traffic. Various measures have been taken to effect the suppression of radio frequency interference radiation from ignition systems. These measures include: 1. A distributor having a rotor output segment formed of insulating and dielectric materials to provide a rotor output tip surface including the conductive and dielectric materials separately disposed from each other; 2. Spark plugs each having a monolithic resistor connected between its input terminal and its center electrode; and 3. Resistive-cord cables connected between the distributor and the respective spark plugs and between the distributor and an ignition coil. However, the measures have been found to be insufficient to fully meet the radio frequency interference radiation control standards particularly in the frequency range of about 20 MRz to 100 MHz. Accordingly, the need has been recognized for a new measure which can suppress radio frequency interference radiation to a sufficient extent particularly in the frequency range of about 20 MHz to 100 MHz to compensate for the aforementioned drawbacks inherent in conventional ignition systems. Therefore, the present invention provides a radio frequency interference radiation suppressing ignition system which can suppress radio frequency interference radiation to a sufficient extent over the entire frequency range. There is provided in accordance with the present invention an ignition system for use with motor vehicle internal combustion engines. The system comprises a distributor including a rotor segment supported on a rotor adapted to be rotated about its axis within a distributor cap having an input terminal electrically connected to the rotor segment and a plurality of output terminals circumferentially disposed about the rotor axis of rotation. The rotor segment has an output tip surface formed of conductive and dielectric materials separately disposed from each other. The system also comprises a plurality of spark plugs each having an input terminal, a center electrode, and a monolithic resistor electrically connected between the spark plug input terminal and the spark plug center electrode. The spark plugs input terminals are connected to the distributor output terminals through respective first cables each including a carbon impregnated conductive wire covered with an insulating sheath. The distributor input termnal is connected to an ignition coil through a second cable including a highvoltage-carrying resistive wire covered with an insulating sheath. The second cable high-voltage-carrying resistive wire has a resistance of 12 kQ or more. Preferably, the second cable carbon impregnated conductive wire has a length of 70 cm or more. The details as well as other features and advantages of this invention are set forth below and are shown in the accompanying drawings, in which: Fig. 1 is a sectional view showing an ignition system made in accordance with the teachings of the present invention; Fig. 2 is a graph plotting relative radio frequency interference radiation intensity in decibels against distributor discharge voltage in kilovolts to indicate the correlation therebetween; Fig. 3 is a comparative graph of a family of curves representing radio frequency interference radiation intensity versus frequency, each curve being for a different set of radio frequency interference radiation suppressing measures; Figs. 4A and 4B are comparative graphs plotting radio frequency interference radiation intensity with respect to given points of frequency; ; Fig. 5 is a comparative graph of a family of curves representing radio frequency interference radiation suppressing effect versus frequency, each curve being for a different resistive-cord cable length; and Figs. 6A and 6B are comparative graphs plotting radio frequency interference radiation intensity with respect to given points of frequency. Referring now to Fig. 1, the ignition distributor 10 comprises a distributor rotor 20 which is rotated by a driving shaft 12, usually gear coupled to the cam shaft of the associated internal combustion engine, within a distributor cap 30 having a center input terminal 32 and a plurality of output terminals 38 circumferentially disposed about the axis of rotation of the rotor 20. The center input terminal 32 is connected through a lead 50 to the secondary winding of the associated ignition coil 40. The output terminals 38 are connected through respective spark plug leads 60 to the engine spark plugs, one of which is shown at 70. The ignition distributor rotor 20 comprises a body member 22 of an electrical insulating material adapted to engage and be rotated about an axis of rotation by the driving shaft 12. The body member 22 supports a rotor output segment 24 on which a center electrode 34 is urged in contact therewith and electrically connected to the center terminal 32 by a spring 36. The rotor output segment 24 extends in a direction toward and terminates radially inwardly from the circumferentially disposed distributor output terminals 38. The rotor dutput segment 24 has an output tip surface 24a which successively faces the distributor output terminals 38 across a distributor gap while the rotor output segment 24 is rotated with the body member 22 to distribute power to the respective spark plugs. Referring to Fig. 2, radio frequency interference radiation intensity in decibels is plotted on the ordinate axis of the graph and distributor discharge voltage in kilovolts is plotted on the abscissa with the distributor gap being set at 1.75 mm. As will be observed from this diagram, the radio frequency interference radiation intensity is highly correlative to the distributor discharge voltage and is varied substantially in a linear relationship to the distributor discharge voltage. In order to suppress radio frequency interference radiation, various attempts have been made to reduce the distributor discharge voltage. It is the conventional practice to form the rotor output segment 24 out of a conductive material and a dielectric material to provide a rotor output tip surface 24a including the conductive and dielectric materials separately disposed from each other. For example, the rotor output segment 24 may be formed of a conductive segment of a conductive material such for example as stainless steel or brass and a dielectric segment placed on at least either of the upper and lower surfaces of the conductive segment. From the standpoints of high noise suppression effect, good design flexibility, high arc resistance, high heat resistance, etc., it is most preferable to form the dielectric segment out of silicone glass, that is, glass fiber impregnated or coated with silicone resin such as silicone vanish. Returning to Fig. 1, the rotor output segment 24 is shown as formed of a conductive segment 26 placed on a dielectric segment 28. A rotor output segment formed of a conductive segment of a 0.6 mm thickness stainless steel plate and a dielectric segment of a 0.5 mm thickness silicone glass plate is tested for radio frequency interference radiation suppressing effect. The test results indicate that the distributor discharge voltage is 4 to 5 kilovolts and an about 15 decibel reduction appears in radio frequency interference radiation intensity as compared to a rotor output segment formed of only a 0.6 mm brass plate. The engine spark plug 70 comprises a conductive external housing 72 formed with a threaded portion which is threadably engaged with an internally threaded opening (not shown) formed in the engine block of the associated engine so that a portion of the spark plug 70 extends within the cylinder of the engine. The components of the spark plug 70 within the cylinder include a center electrode 74 and a counter electrode 76 integral with the external housing threaded portion. The center electrode 74 is separated physically and electrically from the external housing 72 by an internal insulator 78. The internal insulator supports, at its upper section, an input terminal 82, which terminal is connected through the spark plug lead 60 to the distributor output terminal 38. A resistor 80 extends through the internal insulator 78 to electrically connect the input terminal 82 to the center electode 74. The resistor 80 is in the form of a monolithic resistor having a resistance per unit length of 3 kQ to 15 kfl having no effect on engine performance, and a length (Q) of 8 mm or more and, more preferably, 12 mm to 15 mm. The whole length (L) of the spark plug 70 is normally 60 mm to 70 mm. The spark plug 70 having such a monolithic resistor 80 is effective to suppress radio frequency interference radiation. The reason for this radio frequency interference radiation suppressing effect is traceable to the fact that the monolithic resistor 80 and the electrostatic capacity between the monolithic resistor 80 and the external housing 72 constitute an RC filter to attenuate noise field components. An actual monolithic resistor includes an electrostatic capacity parallel to the resistance, the shunt electrostatic capacity increasing with decreasing monolithic resistor length. If the length of the monolithic resistor is less than 8 mm, the shunt electrostatic capacity becomes so great as to degrade the radio frequency interference radiation suppressing effect. A remarkable radio frequency interference radiation suppressing effect can be obtained with the monolithic resistor having a length of 12 mm to 15 mm. The high-voltage-carrying lead 50 connected between the ignition coil 40 and the distributor input terminal 32 and the high-voltage-carrying leads 60 connected between the distributor output terminals 38 and the respective spark plug input terminals 82 are taken in the form of a high-voltage-carrying resistive cable which may be made by covering a carbon impregnated conductive wire 92 with an insulating sheath 94 and covering with a woven sleeve 96. The woven sleeve 96 is normally formed of an insulating material. The carbon impregnated conductive wire 92 has a resistance per unit length of 8 kQ/m to 20 kn/m. Fig, 3 contains curve Ao representing radio frequency interference radiation intensity versus frequency required by radio frequency interference radiation control standards, and a family of curves Al, A2, A3 and A4 each plotting radio frequancy interference radiation intensity against frequency from test results obtained while actually running a bonnet type passenger car equipped with a 1500 cc engine associated with an ignition system wherein a different set of radio frequency interference radiation suppressing measures is taken. The radio frequency interference radiation suppressing measures include: Measure (1) forming the rotor output segment 24 out of a dielectric segment 28 of a 0.5 mm thickness silicone glass plate and a conductive segment 26 of a 0.6 mm thickness brass plate placed on the dielectric segment 28; Measure (2) connecting the spark plug center electrode 74 to the spark plug input terminal 82 through a monolithic resistor 80 having a resistance value of 5 kQ and a length (Z) of 12 mm; and Measure (3) taking each of the high-voltagecarrying leads 50 and 60 in the form of a resistive-cord cable having a carbon impregnated wire conductor of 15 kQ/m covered with an insulator sheath covered with an insulator woven sleeve. Curve Al relates to an ignition system wherein Measures (1) and (2) are taken but Measure (3) is not taken with the high-voltage-carrying leads 50 and 60 being taken in the form of normal non-resistive cables. Curve A2 relates to another ignition system wherein Measures (2) and (3) are taken but Measure (1) is not taken with the rotor output segment 24 being formed of a conductive segment 26 of a 0.6 mm thickness brass plate only. Curve A3 relates to still another ignition system wherein Measures (1) and (3) are taken but Measure (2) is not taken with the spark !lug center electrode 74 being connected directly to the spark plug input terminal 82 employing no monolithic resistor 80. Curve A4 relates to another ignition system wherein Measures (1), (2) and (3) are taken. In Fig. 3, 1 pV/m is represented as zero decibels. As can be seen by a study of Fig. 3, with each of the ignition systems wherein either of Measures (1), (2) and (3) is not taken, the radio frequency interference radiation intensity is higher at many frequency points than that required by the radio frequency interference radiation control standards, while with the ignition system wherein all of Measures (1), (2) and (3) are taken, the radio frequency interference radiation intensity is lower over the entire frequency range than that required by the radio frequency interference radiation control standards. From a more detailed inspection of curves Ao and A4, however, it can be seen that while the ignition system wherein all of Measures (1), (2) and (3) are taken meets the radio frequency interference radiation control standards, the difference between the radio frequency interference radiation intensity represented by curve A4 and that represented by curve Ao is relatively small in the frequency range from about 20 MHz to 100 MHz. Fig. 4A contains curve Ao representing radio frequency interference radiation intensity versus frequency required by the radio frequency interference radiation control standards and curve B plotting radio frequency interference radiation intensity against frequency from test results obtained while actually running a cabover type truck equipped with a four-cycle, 2000 cc engine associated with an ignition system wherein all of Measures (1), (2) and (3) are taken. The test results indicate that the radio frequency interference radiation suppressing effect is low in the frequency range of about 20 KHz to about 100 KFIz and the radio frequency interference radiation intensity is higher at low frequency points than that required by the radio frequency interference radiation control standards. Fig. 4B contains curve Ao representing radio frequency interference radiation intensity versus frequency required by the radio frequency interference radiation control standards and curve C plotting radio frequency interference radiation intensity against frequency from test results obtained while actually running a two-box, bonnet type truck equipped with a four-cycle, 1500 cc engine associated with an ignition system wherein all of Measures (1), (2) and (3) are taken. The test results indicates that the radio frequency interference radiation suppressing effect is low in the frequency range of about 20 KHz to about 100 KHz and the radio frequency interference radiation intensity is higher at low frequency points than that required by the radio frequency interference radiation control standards. The reason why the radio frequency interference radiation suppression effect becomes low in the frequency range of abot 20 MHz to about 100 MHz as shown in Figs. 4A and 4B are not fully understood, but some general observations may be made in connection with automotive vehicle shape, engine height, and other factors. When spark discharge occurs in the distributor 10 between the rotor output segment 24 and an output terminal 38, current flows through the high-voltage-carrying cable 50 connected between the distributor center input terminal 32 and the ignition coil 40 and also through the high-voltage-carrying cable 60 connected between the distributor output terminal 38 and the engine spark plug 70. As a result, each of the high-voltage-carrying cables 50 and 60 serves as an antenna from which a noise field is radiated into space. The highvoltage-carrying cable 60 has a length of 60 cm or more and .has its one end connected to the spark plug center electrode 74 through the monolithic resistor 70 and hence to the ground through an air gap between the spark plug center and counter electrodes 74 and 76. This attenuates the current through the cable 60 and shortens the effective antenna length of the cable 60, reducing the intensity of the noise field radiated from the cable 60 to a considerable extent. On the other hand, since the highvoltage-carrying cable 50 has a length as short as 30 cm and has its one end connected to the ignition coil secondary winding and hence to the ignition coil primary winding lead, the extent to which the current through the cable 50 is attenuated is too small to prevent radiation of a high intensity of noise field from the cable 50 particularly in the frequency range of about 20 MHz to 100 MHz. Accordingly, the need has been recognized for a new measure which can suppress the intensity of noise field to a sufficient extent particularly in the frequency range of about 20 MHz to about 100 MHz to compensate for the aforementioned drawbacks inherent in ignition systems wherein Measures (1), (2) and (3) are taken. Each of the high-voltage-carrying cables 50 and 60 is taken in the form of a resistive-cord cable including a carbon impregnated conductive wire 92 covered with an insulating sheath 94 covered with a woven sleeve 96. Normally, the carbon impregnated conductive wire has a resistance value per unit length of 8 kQ/m to 20 kfl/m. The carbon impregnated conductive wire and the distributed electrostatic capacity between the carbon impregnated conductive wire and the engine ground constitute an RC low pass filter which is effective to attenuate the current flow through the carbon impregnated conductive wire, thereby effecting the suppression of radio frequency interference radiation. Fig. 5 contains curves D1, D2 and D3 each relating the radio frequency interference radiation suppression effect in decibels to the resistive-cord cable resistance in kilo-ohms for a different resistive-cord cable length. The term "resistive-cord cable resistance" as used throughout this invention is intended to mean "the resistance value of the carbon impregnated conductive wire itself." It will also be appreciated that the term n resistive-cord cable length" is intended to mean "the length of the carbon impregnated conductive wire between its one tip end and the other tip end thereof." Curve D1 relates to a lm resistive-cord cable.50, curve D2 relates to a 70 cm resistive-cord cable 50, and curve D3 relates to a 35 cm resistive-cord cable 50. From an inspection of the graph of Fig. 5, it can be seen that the resistive-cord cable 50 is required to have a resistance value of 12 kQ or more to suppress the radio frequency interference radiation to a sufficient extent and that it is preferable for the resistive-cord cable 50 to have a length of 70 cm or more. The characteristics of the RC low pass filter composed of the carbon impregnated conductive wire and the distributed electrostatic capacity is dependent upon the resistance and length of the resistive-cord cable 50. With the resistive-cord cable 50 having a resistance of 12 kQ or more, the RC low pass filter has its cut-off frequency lowered to increase the ability to cut off the transmission of frequencies ranging from about 20 MHz to 100 MHz. If the resistance of the resistive-cord cable 50 exceeds about 25 kQ, however, substantially no increase occurs in the ability to suppress radio frequency interference radiation and an excessive loss occurs in spark pulse energy to spoil engine performance. With the resistive-cord cable 50 having a length of 70 cm or more, the distributed electrostatic capacity increases to increase the ability to cut off the transmission of frequencies ranging from about 20 MHz to 100 MHz for the same resistive-cord cable resistance. If the length of the resistive-cord cable 50 exceeds about 120 cm, however, substantially no increase occurs in the ability to suppress radio frequency interference radiation and problems occur in wiring the resistive-cord cable 50. Fig. 6A contains curve Ao representing radio frequency interference radiation versus frequency required by the radio frequency interference radiation control standards, and curves B and E each plotting radio frequency interference radiation intensity against frequency from test results obtained while actually running a cabover type truck equipped with a four-cycle, 2000 cc engine associated with an ignition system. Curve B relates to an ignition system wherein all of Measures (1), (2) and (3) are taken with the resistive-cord cable 50 having a resistance of 5 kfl and a length of 34 cm. Curve E relates to an ignition system made in accordance with the teachings of the present invention wherein all of Measures (1), (2) and (3) are taken with the resistive-cord cable 50 having a resistance of 15 kQ and a length of 100 cm. It is apparent from the test results that the ignition system of the present invention can suppress radio frequency interference radiation in the frequency range of about 20 MHz to about 100 MHz to.an extent sufficient to meet the radio frequency interference radiation control standards. Fig. 6B contains curve Ao representing radio frequency interference radiation intensity versus frequency required by the radio frequency interference radiation control standards, and curves C and F each plotting radio frequency interference radiation intensity against frequency from test results obtained while actually running a two-box, bonnet type truck equipped with a fourcycle, 1500 cc engine associated with an ignition system. Curve C relates to an ignition system wherein all of Measures (1), (2) and (3) are taken with the resistive-cord cable 50 having a resistance of 5 kQ and a length of 34 cm. Curve F relates to an ignition system made in accordance with the teachings of the present invention wherein all of Measures (1), (2) and (3) are taken with the resistive-cord cable 50 having a resistance of 15 kQ and a length of 100 cm. It is apparent from the test results that the ignition system of the present invention can suppress radio frequency interference radiation in the frequency range of about 20 MHz to about 100 MHz to an extent sufficient to meet the radio frequency interference radiation control standards. Various tests indicate that such radio frequency interference radiation suppressing effects as shown in Figs. 6A and 6B are obtained when the measure forming the high-voltage-carrying cable 50 out of a resistive-cord cable having a resistance of 12 kQ or more and/or a length of 70 cm or more is taken along with all of the Measures (1), (2) and (3) is not taken even though the high-voltage-carrying cable 50 is composed of a resistivecord cable having a resistance of 12 kQ or more and a length of 70 cm or more. There has been provided, in accordance with the present invention, an engine ignition system including an ignition coil, a distributor, and spark plugs for which several measures are taken to suppress radio frequency interference radiation therefrom. The distributor has a rotor output segment with its output tip surface formed of conductive and dielectric materials separately disposed from each other. Each of the spark plugs includes a monolithic resistor connected between its input terminal and its center electrode. The spark plugs are connected to the distributor through respective high-voltage-carrying cables each including a carbon impregnated conductive wire covered with an insulating sheath. The ignition coil is connected to the distributor through a high-voltagecarrying cable which includes a carbon impregnated conductive wire having a resistance of 12 kQ or more to suppress radio frequency interference radiation in the range of about 20 MHz to about 100 MHz. As a result, the ignition system of the present invention can suppress radio frequency interference radiation to an extent sufficient to fully meet the radio frequency interference radiation control standards over the entire frequency range. While the present invention has been des.cribed in conjunction with a specific embodiment thereof, it is evident that many alternatives, modifications and variations will be apparent to those skilled in the art. Accordingly, it is intended to embrace all alternatives, modifications and variations that fall within the broad scope of the appended claims.

Claims: CLAIMS 1. An ignition system for use with a motor vehicle internal combustion engine, comprising: - a distributor (10) including a rotor segment (24) sup ported on a rotor (20) adapted to be rotated about its axis within a distributor cap (30) having an input ter minal (32) electrically connected to said rotor segment (24) and a plurality of output terminals (38) circumfe rentially disposed about the rotor axis of rotation, said rotor segment (24) having an output tip surface (24a) formed of conductive and dielectric materials (26, 28) separately disposed from each other; - a plurality of spark plugs (70) each having an input ter minal (82), a center electrode (74), and a monolithic re sistor (80) electrically connected between said spark plug input terminal (82) and said spark plug center elec trode (74); ; - a plurality of first cables (60) electrically connecting said distributor output terminals (38) to said spark plug input terminals (82), respectively, each of said first cables being a resistive-cord cable; and - a second cable (50) electrically connecting an ignition coil (40) to said distributor input terminal (32), said second cable also being a resistive-cord cable, c h a r a c t e r i z e d in that each of said first cables (60) includes a carbon impregnated conductive wire (92) covered with an insulating sheath (94), and that said second table (50) includes a high-voltage-carrying resistive wire (92) covered with an insulating sheath (94), said second cable high-voltage-carrying resistive wire (92) having a resistance of 12 kRor more. 2. Ignition system as claimed in claim 1, c h a r a ct e r i z e d in that said second cable high-voltagecarrying resistive wire (92) has a resistance in the range from 12 kE to 25 kSt 3. Ignition system as claimed in claim 1 or 2, c h a r a c t e r i z e d in that said second cable high-voltage-carrying resistive wire (92) has a length of 70cm or more. 4. Ignition system as claimed in claim 3, c h a r a ct e r i z e d in that said second cable high-voltagecarrying resistive wire (92) has a length in the range from 70cm to 120cm. 5. Ignition system as claimed in any of the claims 1 to 4, c h a r a c t e r i z e d in that said second cable high-voltage-carrying resistive wire (92) is in the form of a carbon impregnated conductive wire.

Inventors: SONE, MASAZUMI
Applicants: NISSAN MOTOR CO., LTD.
Application year: 1983
Main classification: H04B15
IPC codes: F02P7, H01T13, H04B15, F02P15, F02P13