Goal Driven Discovery of Distributional Differences via Language Descriptions
NeurIPS, 2023

Exploring large corpora can generate useful discoveries but is time-consuming for humans.    We formulate a new task, D5, that automatically discovers differences between two large corpora in a goal-driven way.     The task input is a problem comprising a user-specified research goal (“*comparing the side effects of drug A and drug*”) and a corpus pair (two large collections of patients' self-reported reactions after taking each drug).     The output is a goal-related description (discovery) of how these corpora differ (patients taking drug A “*mention feelings of paranoia*” more often).    We build a D5 system, and to quantitatively evaluate its performance, we 1) build a diagnostic benchmark, SynD5, to test whether it can recover known differences between two synthetic corpora, and 2) contribute a meta-dataset, OpenD5, aggregating 675 open-ended problems ranging across business, social sciences, humanities, machine learning, and health.    With both synthetic and real datasets, we confirm that language models can leverage the user-specified goals to propose more relevant candidate discoveries, and they sometimes produce discoveries previously unknown to the authors, including demographic differences in discussion topics, political stances in speech, insights in commercial reviews, and error patterns in NLP models.    Finally, we discuss the limitations of the current D5 system, which discovers correlation rather than causation and has the potential to reinforce societal biases when misused; therefore, practitioners should treat the outputs of our system with caution.

Included in review: Yes
Modality: Language
Contribution type: Methodological