I cannot recommend staying with Catherine enough! In terms of comfort, the loft room is cute, secluded and spacious (small living room included!) and the bed is very cozy with great pillows. My boyfriend and I slept like babies each night we were there.
On top of that, the location is very convenient and nearby many out-of-this-world coffee shops and restaurants. As a personal suggestion, head down to Lauretta-Jean's one morning for great coffee and any combination of pie you can dream up.
The biggest reason to stay with Catherine, though, is that she goes out of her way to make you comfortable and accomadated. She donate some of her own toothpaste to us in the middle of the night when we realized we were without it, and she even drove us to the airport when our ride bailed on us. Talk about kindness.
All in all, I can confidently say that you will absolutely enjoy your stay!