We stayed at Jeanie and Taylor's place for four nights. They are a very nice young couple who have put a lot of effort and expense into renovating this basement space into a quite livable rental. I truly wish I could give them a five star review, as the room potentially deserves that rating, but in good conscience do so.
The devil is in the details, however, and this visit did not quite make the grade. We are long time Airbnb hosts ourselves, and are familiar with what is needed to make guests content by removing any problem areas. The apartment was clean and quite comfortable, but there were no towels provided until the Hosts got back and we could ask for them. Other small things made our stay less than perfect, and showed a lack of quality control, such as none of the pens on the desk worked, no bar soap, soap dish, glass, or bathmat provided in the bathroom, the bathroom door did not close properly, and there was almost no space to place toiletries other than the toilet lid, other people's clothing lying on the couch, only one dresser drawer was usable as the others were full of stuff, etc., etc.
We have written the Hosts privately with suggestions that we feel would make a difference for future guests.