Although I knew at the outset I was renting a basement apartment , I think I expected there to be more natural light in the unit than there was. If lots of windows are a factor for you, it might not be the best choice. The unit was clean and spacious. As the owner says, one can hear the habitual noises of the house upstairs - it’s not bad or overly loud, just day-to -day living in an older home. I was visiting someone living in Irvington so for me the location made the stay worthwhile. If Irvington is convenient for you, then this is a good rental choice.