Pros: the rental team was very communicative and prompt in responding with status, even if situations were not immediately resolved. The house is spacious and can easily fit 12 people. The neighborhood is beautiful to walk around in, and convenient to downtown. The main area of the house (sitting area, kitchen, dining room) are all really lovely and well done.
Cons: we had a lot of issues from cleanliness to the heater to issues with checkout. However, the hosting team certainly did do their best to address things in a timely manner, and AirBnB was able to step in and help us resolve in the end. One of the two bathrooms is located inside a smaller room with a queen bed, so that's something to consider if you're staying with a larger group.
The only other thing I would note is that the basement, though spacious, definitely feels like a basement and doesn't get any light. I found this surprising, given the photos. All in all, I think if the house is correctly cleaned and prepped before guests arrive (I'm assuming we had extraordinary circumstances), it's definitely worth the value with a large group.