I gave 4/5 stars solely based on the situation of the house and not based on Aaron's hospitality or cleanliness. The walls to the other units in the house are very very thin, and a conversation in another unit sounds like they are in the room with you. So if youre spending most of your time out of the apartment, or don't mind having loud neighbors, you shouldn't have a problem.
Otherwise it was very clean and Aaron very accommodating to our needs, great walking distance to lots of good restaurants and breweries.