I was coming to Columbus for a conference that was downtown. I'd asked about the location/distance, etc. to make sure I was close enough to the Sheraton. It is a 30 min walk. A bit far with suitcases.
The loft is also on the third floor....lots of narrow stairs and LOTS of low ceilings to make the stairs and tiny TINY bathroom and kitchen work. I hit my head a bunch.
Kitchen was pretty well stocked....no burners, but a toaster over and micro. Furniture is mostly funk/rummage sale. Not a new bed. The closets were all full. And the garbage can under the sink had not been emptied.
I needed to set up my computer and work, and the electrical outlet situation is very "old house" as is the in-the-window air conditioner.

That said, the hosts are very laid back, and out of the way. IF you want to interact, don't stay here, but I liked it. Also, the neighborhood is VERY charming, in an up-and-coming kind of way. Cute, old houses full of charm, many still needing lots of TLC.
There is also a vibrant restaurant scene (4 places) just a few blocks away...nice hang outs, and pretty good food in a neighborhood, with NO downtown feel.
With all that, I'd say it was on the Plus side of OK, not great, and a bit too expensive for what it was.
On the plus side,