The Wayfaring Buckeye Hostel was very clean and very safe. I was traveling cross country alone and just needed a place to stay to sleep for a couple hours. I was a little concerned because I had never been in Columbus or stayed at a hostel before. However, I highly recommend the Wayfaring Hostel for anyone (short- or long-term stays). The pictures are accurate and the amenities are great, especially the free breakfast and bike rentals if you're going to be staying a bit longer (the area seems really bike friendly).
If you are noise/light sensitive, you might want to bring some ear plugs/eye mask because it is possible that people coming and going will bother you. However, if you're looking for an affordable place in a safe neighborhood, this is the spot for you. Hope to get another chance to stay here!