Elaine's house is adorable and in a safe, lovely neighborhood in a trendy area of Columbus. She did a fantastic job of communicating promptly and also offered a wealth of suggestions on things to do/see/eat. Check-in with the lockbox works seamlessly.
However, there were cleanliness issues with the bathroom that would make me very hesitant to book with her again- especially since another very recent reviewer mentioned cleanliness issues as well. I booked with her anyway figuring that having been called out on it once there wouldn't be any further problems. I was mistaken. If cleanliness could be addressed once and for all, this would be an A+ stay. However as it is, I don't know that I would book again.