I live in Columbus and had my parents in town from CA to visit for a week. Being walking distance to Kroger (grocery store), coffee shops, and restaurants was awesome. We also loved the bike trail nearby and had good weather so were able to enjoy the porch and backyard.
The house was about a 5/10 for cleanliness. Surfaces weren't wiped off and the previous guest left muddy dog paw prints on the couch that also wasn't cleaned off. Floors (except for upstairs bathroom) were also very dusty and had dog hair all over them. The basement bedroom isn't ideal for a night's sleep as it's next to the HVAC system (loud) and just doesn't feel cozy. I can't imagine a scenario in which I would choose to sleep in the bed in the basement... Finally, the internet/wifi kept going in and out, even after restarting the router and modem multiple times.
Hosts were very nice and responsive despite issues above!