If we could base this air bnb rate on communication and location alone, it would've easily gotten a 5! John was great at informing us he had a volunteer event that am, so we couldn't get into the house until a little after 2. Plus, this place is within 10 minutes of anything you could want to visit in Columbus! Also, note there are no discharge instructions so that made leaving easier.
With that being said, it's important to know the reasons why we will not return and only gave it a 2. I've stayed in many air bnb's before and this was by far the dirtiest, which was made evident by a cheese it on top of a decoration that was nearly brown in color, no hand soap for guests and build up of dog hair on the floor, couch & room corners. We were willing to sweep, but there was no broom to be found. As a pet friendly air bnb, it's important to note that there was dog hair imbedded in the bathroom towels and the couch had so much on it that we had to put a blanket on top just to sit down. From my experiences with dog friendly air bnb's, there's typically not a trace of an animal having been inside before arrival because the cleanliness is well above average.
I am typically an understanding person if I can clean up or fix the frustration myself, but this time I couldn't and it's unfortunate. If you don't mind your socks covered in hair & lack of cleanliness, you might be okay here.