I stayed at Eddie's for five days while attending a conference at the Greater Columbus Convention Center--there is a good direct bus connection between there and Eddie's place--and found it to be an excellent experience. While there were some other guests staying there during my visit, I mostly felt like I had the place to myself. The house is in a student neighbourhood, so there was some noise late at night, particularly over the weekend, but nothing that kept me from sleeping. While the house is showing its age in places, and was a bit dusty in a few places, it was a fine simple place to stay, which was what I was looking for. The kitchen was well-equipped and the washer and dryer were quite useful. There are some nice nearby parks along the river that I enjoyed walking in and good grocery stores within easy walking distance.
Eddie was very prompt about replying to various small queries during my stay.