I've stayed at several AirBnBs in Columbus, and I think so far this is my favorite. There were three of us staying, but it never felt cramped or crowded. The big parking spaces in the back were much appreciated!
The neighborhood could be tricky to navigate, but the hosts provided clear, concise, turn-by-turn directions so we never felt lost or confused. The check-in and check-out processes were emailed well ahead of time, so there was never any concern about getting in or getting out or how this particular AirBnB would work.
Lastly, the bedrooms were clean and nice and the mattresses were BY FAR the most comfortable I've ever slept on in an AirBnB. Would absolutely not hesitate to stay there again!