Overall, great place to stay!
The property is unassuming from the front but the inside is gorgeous and the back yard area is so relaxing and set up beautifully! We loved the pool and the picnic table with all the string lights for ambiance, as well as the HUGE TV in the living room (perfect for catching the games on Sunday). Plenty of beach towels were provided, as well as toilet paper and other general essentials. The fridge was pre-stocked with a very large selection of alcoholic and non-alcoholic drinks and condiments. We bought cheap fishing rods at Dick's nearby and caught several fish off the dock in the back yard.
Do yourself a favor and go the "The Egg & You" for breakfast and/or lunch (they close at 2p). It's very close to the house and everything on the menu was delicious (we went twice). Ask for Janet... I promise you'll enjoy yourselves.
The few negatives:
There's a firepit in the pictures, but it has since been removed and cannot be used.
Towels and hand towels were provided but not washcloths so be sure to bring your own.
There was a mount for an outdoor TV near the pool, but no TV. There was a TV on the patio, but it didn't work. Those 2 TVs would have been a HUGE upgrade to the outdoor space.