I rented the Blue Marlin house for a weekend in May, 2016.
Although the house was nicely furnished and overall in good shape, we had a few issues that I believe could have been easily taken care off prior to our arrival. The hot water and outdoor grill did not work due to a gas problem. None of the TV's in the house worked for our entire stay. The pool was dirty when we arrived. Someone came to clean it but the chemicals only cleared up the water after a day and half when was almost time to leave. The gas problem was resolved eventually but we had no hot water until the last day of our stay.
The house had one inconvenience that the only way to get outside to the patio/pool area was through one of the bedrooms, no direct access to the pool from living room.
The overall cleanliness of the house was unsatisfactory as well.

Besides these issues, both our host Lauren and the owner were very nice and welcoming and apologized for the problems.
The house was in a quiet neighborhood and the patio area was very relaxing. Beach was only 10 minutes away. There was also a marina where you could book a diving or snorkeling trip, which we did and was very nice.