We've given 5 star reviews for location in other places we've stayed (and we still think they deserve it ) but Catalina's place is on another scale- the view from the balcony is movie quality stuff. The place was clean - simple, but tastefully decorated (which we think a beach house should be) and had most things we would expect from an Airbnb.
Unfortunately - the cala was a lot busier (even in pandemic 2020) than we'd seen it on our last trip to Mallorca (4 years ago) - but I guess we should have expected that the secret would slowly make it out eventually.