Casa Caimari was a perfect start to our holiday. Maria is a fantastic host, who knows the island extremely well and gave us excellent advice about what to see and where to eat. The breakfast at Marias was also outstanding, especially when compared to some of the smaller hotels on the island. Local produce, freshly made!
The room was very nicely decorated and clean, with clear instructions about how to use all ammenities. The only small negative was that the beds were quite hard - but that's a matter of taste - and that there's no real door to the bathroom. It's probably not a problem for most traveling couples, but could be a little awkward for some friends sharing the space. ;)
All-in-all we would both recommend making Marias Casa Caimari your first stop and taking good notes about her advice about Mallorca.