Macia's Fisherman's Cottage was incredible, far beyond our expectations. Macia was incredibly communicative and helpful; he scheduled a meetup spot once we arrived in Santanyi from the airport, and guided us to the harbor so we wouldn't have trouble finding the spot. He also offered to call me a taxi for my departure date, which was so helpful and thoughtful.
I would absolute recommend staying in his cottage. Aside from not having internet, which I almost preferred to fully enjoy the experience, the cottage was walking distances from the adorable town around Cala Figueroa, with breathtaking views, wonderful food, and a minimal mix of tourists and locals enjoying the quiet life that is Santanyi.