We had a fantastic stay at Puerta Catedral. It’s in the perfect location, just one block from the Cathedral itself, steps from the best healthy breakfast restaurants, and easily accessible to all other tourist sights. It was also very clean, had powerful AC (which was necessary in the brutal afternoon heat), and the hosts were communicative and helpful. The roof was the perfect place to decompress with a drink after a siesta, looking over at the Cathedral and the sunset.