I want to start with the fact that this was my first Airbnb stay so I may have expectations out of alignment.
Nathan was a great host; his communication was clear and his responses were speedy and everything was as I had expected from him. He made it all very very easy.
The location is in a brilliant; 4 minutes walk to Manly; 6 minutes to the wharf and out of the way enough that rowdy party goers don't bother you. The added benefit of parking onsite - sensational.
The apartment itself is cosy; beds are comfy with lots of pillows and extra doonas. Nathan has loads and loads of storage space available to you can completely unpack which is always nice.
The only downside I found was that I was cold. Sydney didn't turn on the magnificent weather I was hoping for and the apartment has no heating (except a fan heater in the bathroom) so at night it was particularly chilly. I know that he's planning on rectifying that soon. There were a few bits and bobs in the fridge that I think should have been removed and I would have loved a hairdryer.
But apart from that it was just great for my needs. Location was great, parking availability was terrific and great comms from Nathan. And the most important question I think is "would I stay there again?" The answer to that is Yes!