We (myself, my wife and our 1 year old) stayed at john's for five weeks while our house was being rennovated. John was a great host, met us for check-in and responded quickly if we had any questions. The space was perfectly adequate and met all our needs. The location and view are fantastic. I think the space could be improved by upgrading she of the kitchen utensils and appliances. Overall though I think most people would be very happy. The one issue and thing that would stop us rebooking at least in the near future was the fact that the family lives directly above and there must not be any sound proofing between the two areas as we could hear every step or every scrape of furniture. I truly don't think this would bother most people and it wasn't late into the night but did always seem to coincide with our 1 year olds nap or bedtime, waking him up. This resulted in a few sleepless nights for us. Again this would only be an issue for people with very young children but maybe something to consider for those that do