We recently stayed at John's on Dangar Island and overall had a pleasant experience. The ferry from Brooklyn was easy to use. You will need to bring most of your own food as there are no shops on the island, but there is a cafe located right at the ferry wharf which has very good coffee and food as well as some groceries if you're running out. The walk from the ferry to the house is quite steep and can be strenuous in the heat, but it is manageable. The house had a rustic charm to it, which added to the secluded, peaceful feeling of being on an island. The host provided linen and towels, as well as some kitchen essentials such as flour, oil, salt, coffee, and tea. We appreciated this as it made the stay more convenient. The quiet atmosphere was lovely, with the only noise coming from the birds outside. One thing to note is that the swimming around the island is not the best. Overall, I would recommend this Airbnb to anyone looking for a quiet, secluded getaway.