I stayed with Edward for 2 weeks which definitely gave me the time to get to know Edward, the location, and the space.
To start Edward is and amazing host. Very laid back, very active and often out doing something interesting, very friendly, and always willing to give great advice about the area. He made me feel welcome.
The location is unreal. It is right next to the beach. I spent a lot of evenings catching the sunset. The water is so clear! The town of freshwater feels local and a lot of cute shops and restaurants. Even a small grocery store around the corner. All accessable with walking through a peaceful and safe neighborhood. If you surf, this is an ideal spot because not only is freshwater a great surf spot, it is walking distance to Manly and Curl curl which are worth checking out, surfing or not.
The place is great. I am so happy I wasn't cramped in a little apartment. The house has a lot is space. There is the living/dining room but you also have back yard with a table and chair and a front yard + patio. So, if you'd like some alone time it is easy i.e. you are not in each other's hair! The room has it's own entry and you don't share a wall with Edward, the rooms are separated. The bathroom is only one but has a separate rooms for the shower and toilet, so not once did I ever need to wait.
The only con I can think of is if you stay you may fall love with the dog and miss her. She is a lovely girl that is super calm and quite.