Positives: plenty. First, Mike's responses were helpful ahead of our arrival (we had no problems so need to contact him when we were there). The listing was a very accurate description of the accommodation. Mike couldn't be there in person to check us in or out but he arranged this with Chilli Blue next door and this worked very smoothly and they were able to look after our bags for the day after we had checked out, which was helpful. The location, which was a key criterion for us, is excellent, very close to a station and just a short walk to the Botanical Gardens and beyond. And Millie's next door is a lovely little cafe.
I would have liked a slightly bigger shower with a perspex surround rather than a curtain, but this is a small gripe and no one else in my family was bothered. Also there is only one fan, above the main bed and effective, but the living area could get hot. The main disappointment was noise at (some) nights from nearby backpackers, which we had not anticipated. This was an irritant but not sustained enough to prevent us from sleeping.