I would stay there again in a heartbeat.
The hammock, games (croquet, PS3), A/C upstairs, huge deck, and distance to the beach were the surprise positives.
The beds downstairs weren't great. One of the kids slept on a trundle downstairs, which was in the way a bit. It came with 2 doubles, 2 bunk beds, 1 single, and 2 trundles. The double bed downstairs was home-made and rickety, and not too comfy.
It is a very welcoming property, and we had a great vacation. Thank you Xanthe!