I rated it as 5 stars in good faith because John was very responsive and open to a refund. I think with some TLC this could be a great pick. Overall the place is as it appears, great location, cute setup, everything is decently sized. Unfortunately many of these things are superficial. The furniture is old and damaged, there is dust and grime on the vents and door-jams, there was no door-sweep and there does seem to be a minor pest problem. The AC unit in the main room works but the bedroom does not. I am sensitive to smoke smells and they enter through the vents and cracks in the door, it was overwhelming to me but maybe not to others. I think with some deep cleaning and repairs this could be a great spot.