I loved Judy's house, neighborhood, and Judy herself. It was great to discover a beautiful new neighborhood and restaurants and parks that we would not otherwise have known about, and great to get to know Judy as well. Much, much better for me than an impersonal hotel in a business sector. I (and my dog!) loved her double back yard with the gardens she tends so diligently, and I loved sitting with my husband on her back deck and hearing the wind in the trees. We also enjoyed discovering the Cedar Lake area, which was a hop away from her house. We'll be back on a future visit to the Twin Cities, and I told my mom and friends they should consider Judy's place if they travel up that direction. If you have a dog family member, she or he is also welcome and Judy will even have the water bowl ready when you arrive.
If you want luxury, being in the middle of the tourist sector, want the hotel experience, or you prioritize private bathrooms or whatnot, then choose that option - expect a personal and homey and positive experience if you choose to stay with Judy.