We stayed at the Pilgrim's Roost with Pam for one night, and it was incredible! You should not hesitate to book, she redefines hospitality. You'll find a clean and tasteful private space, with amenities like bottled water, cheese, and snacks. It was incredibly clean. The fireplace was warm and glowing for us right away.
We've stayed a lot of AirBNBs, and I can attest that this one is about the experience Pam provides -- she is an incredible and thoughtful person, who wanted us to have a great stay. At the same time, we were able to have a private and restful time. The room and amenities are super -- the bed is one of the most comfortable I've slept on.
Our only regret is not staying longer. At the time we booked, this place did not have any reviews. If you're hesitating because of that, don't - it was a fantastic experience and you won't regret it.