Some people have left critical reviews, but they are undeserved by and large.
The basement apartment is a large space that is clean and has very comfortable furniture. All the basics you'd expect are there (like a mini fridge, microwave, coffee pot, etc.) along with shampoo/conditioner bottles, towels, and even little wrapped chocolates.
The only thing to note is that the location isn't marked super clearly from the road; you'll be watching for a beige mail box at the end of the driveway. That aside, this is a great place to stay (and the town has lots of great places to eat -- Wagon Wheel has good pizza). 5/5