First off, the layout of the house was great for us with a 2 year old. Having everything on one level was very convenient. The area was remote (but close enough to Annandale or Buffalo if you needed anything), and mostly quiet with the exception of the neighbor driving his go-cart around for 2-3 hours every night.
When we arrived the grass in the yard was very long due to some recent rain, but after a message to the property manger he had someone there cutting it within an hour, which was greatly appreciated so we could use it the next day. However, neither the dock or the boat were in the water yet, and with all the geese frequenting the yard, the water and shoreline were borderline unusable for us. I'd make sure to ask before you book if you were planning on using either. Other than that, the outdoor amenities were great and well furnished with a nicely stocked shed, and lots of seating.
The house itself was mostly clean. The counters in the kitchen did need a wipe down, lots of dead bugs in the windowsills, and the sheets on the beds had to be washed due to all the dog hair discovered, but other than that it was fine. I think it was mentioned previously, but the cooking pots, pans, and utensils were quite dated.
Overall, we had a good stay for a reasonable price.