PROS: Beautiful views, outdoor rooftop area amazing, well stocked with cooking items and even some oil and spices, etc. Plenty of coffee, tea, dishwasher and laundry soap, shampoo, etc. kitchen with nice appliances, master bedroom/bath roomy and well appointed. Beds comfortable. Walking distance to many sites, groceries, restaurants. Felt safe in neighborhood. Deserves 5 stars based on all the pros.
CONS: Here’s where we felt it fell short of “over the top amazing” - Lowest level guest bedrooms very basic with only bed and one nightstand and one table lamp each, no closets for renters use, although there were racks for the clothes, but no hangers (found some later, but not in the room we were in). Ceiling fans would help as air units only in top 2 levels and for sound - the walls are seriously paper thin. We had 3 couples and the bottom level has a shared bathroom for the 2 bedrooms, which we knew going in, as we knew about the many stairs (the kind where you are out of breath climbing up), but with the shared bathroom, a small table w chair to get ready and not hog the bathroom would be ideal in each of the 2 bedrooms. Living room furniture not very comfortable and one small chair and small couch not enough for 6 adults. Property is probably better suited for 2 adults who stay in the master and their children downstairs. No TVs in any bedrooms which is not a deal breaker, but to watch the news would be nice.