If you are a heavy sleeper who doesn't care about aesthetics, we do recommend this place, because it is indeed very conveniently located. But unfortunately, we were quite disappointed and uncomfortable while staying here, and were glad to leave.
Parking was tricky--be warned that there is no elevator to the third floor and you may have to walk a block or two if you have heavy things to carry up. As other reviewers mentioned, the place felt like a grimy college apartment (weird, strong smell!), and the WiFi did not work even though it was advertised. We were constantly cold--the several space heaters did not do enough, so we wore jackets the whole time (it was 40-50 degrees outside). Most importantly to us, it was NOT quiet for sleeping despite being advertised as such. Because the bedroom windows are so old and single paned, it sounded as if they were open, so we were frequently awakened by people opening and closing doors, talking, etc. throughout the night--there are many apartment buildings nearby. There is also bright light out the bedroom windows, only partially dimmed by the blinds. The views out the main windows were dominated by nearby college housing/apartments, which largely block the city view. (We closed some of the blinds to avoid looking at a shirtless guy atop his girlfriend in their bed.) We were relieved when our stay was over.
We didn't meet Sheldon in person, and he sounds like a very nice guy from other reviewers. He was communicative and helpful via text, although it was a bit disconcerting to be reminded several times of the no smoking rule--we are nonsmokers. But I think he has very different standards from us in terms of what makes a "charming" apartment. This would have been an awesome place to live in our early twenties, but for those who like staying warm, true charm, and quiet sleep, it's not a good place.