This was my first Airbnb stay, and I have enjoyed every bit of it. The host was extremely informative before our stay (e.g., giving detailed directions, recommendations of local places). The place is just as described. The room was very cozy, with lots of character. Everything was functional and clean. It was listed that pets are not allowed, which is a plus since my travel-mate is allergic.
Given this is my first Airbnb stay, I can't compare it with others. However, I'd say this is probably the most ideal way to introduce me to Airbnb. Compare to a hotel, there is a lot more personal touch :)

I was very satisfied with my stay, and will highly recommend this particular host (who has several Airbnb listings) to my friends.