Pros: location, quirky, cozy, little yorkies!
Cons: found someones crunchy contacts left on the side table, someone who was in the room before us down the hall which felt odd, robes had a couple stains, notes and trash found from previous people, came home from a concert the first night to be confronted by homeowner about a door being left open which was not us (making us feel uncomfortable)
The location was great and the homeowner was very kind other than putting us in an awkward position! If there's another place you are choosing between, I'd opt for the peace of mind of no hassle.