I've rated this highly overall due to some high points and hosts who are keen to learn and do better. I feel that it could be great stay with a family or small group with improvements, especially in warmer weather when you can use the outside and the BBQ.
The TL; DR version is that I arrived to a dark and very cold house (56F) and through overall found the home to be nice, the kitchen is dark/randomly semi-renovated, and there were quality issues--host has stressed that these issues have since been dealt with.
Pluses: having a driveway to park in, good beds and bedding, cozy living room, good TV, fine Wifi, some restaurants and grocery stores within short driving distance but car is required).