Hi Folks!
You should very much consider this rental! I couldn't agree more with all the positive reviews. We were extremely comfortable in Paul & his wife's apartment. Everything was just lovely, clean and of an extra nice, quality comfort. I think I slept better than I do at home--lovely bedding! They have provided every possible kitchen, bedroom and bath detail you could want or need (excellent water pressure in shower too!), plus books & toys for kids (if needed), local travel books, and there is plenty of privacy. Felt like home, but even better! : ) Lots to do in vicinity and easy access to everywhere we needed to go.
FYI, there is a good amount of regular car traffic on the main road in front of the house (kind of a white noise of sorts), as it is right on Green Lake, and many folks bike & stroll around the lake (pretty views!) The house sits on a fairly steep hill, and there are about 8 steps up to an small path that then slopes toward the entry (all with very pretty landscaping). I have some knee problems so I notice these things more than most people (I wanted something to hold on to on that sloping path)--so, if you have physical limitations, you may be concerned. Lastly, Paul was very helpful when we had some arrival date glitches, and we appreciated his flexibility very much.
Just wish we could've stayed longer! Enjoy your travels!