We loved Catherine's place. I generally don't like to stay in basement apartments but this doesn't feel like a basement with the beautiful view. Very cute place. The baked goods and desserts were a special treat and we appreciated her flexibility in letting us drop our bags early so we didn't have to take them on our college tour. The only downside is that the floors make a lot of noise with every footstep (and one of the beds also creaked every time you moved). If you're a light sleeper, might be an issue, but other than that, a great place!