Great place to stay as a couple. Jorian left a note on the door welcoming us that my wife adored. It was close enough to the beach that we decided to walk there (about 20ish min), and was even closer to good food places. The area around the apartment was interesting and full of history, and it felt safe walking out at night.
One thing to note for those who are both light sleepers and late risers, I recommend some ear plugs. The garage door does make noise as some other reviewers have pointed out. If you are a heavy sleeper or an early riser, this won’t be as big a deal for you. Just come prepared knowing that (this is a carriage house after all!).
That said, can definitely recommend this place for a nice Santa Cruz vacation.