We rented this unit for a few days during President's week, so we had to pay an increased rental price as a result. At $300+ a night we had higher expectations and expected the unit was going to be more as described.
Positives: Geoff was great with his communication. We always got impressively quick responses about any questions we had. Things that did earn stars were number of towels, well stocked kitchen, space, and proximity to entertainment. We liked that most things we wanted to do or see where either a short bike ride or drive away. The fire place, fire table, and hot tub were also nice treats. The games/puzzles were nice to have, as were the items for beach. We liked the option of having the bicycles. They are just a bit older and some could use some maintenance.
Negatives: The house appeared more well kept in photos. The house looks like it has been through a few house parties and as a result needs some TLC -- plates on plugs, paint, some cleaning, new or better cleaned bedding. The yard needs some landscaping work/clean up of weeks, maintenance of pavers.
Overall, we wouldn't stay at the place again at the rate we paid. But, we would stay at a regular rate if we knew some TLC had been shown to some of the items we mentioned here and to the owner.