This was my first stay in an Airbnb, so my reference is limited.
PROS:
Off-street parking (could probably fit 2 cars).
Comfortable spot with relaxing feel.
Near airport and a lot of fun places.
Free Netflix + comfortable couch to watch or sleep on.
Not a lot of uptight rules.
Clear, simple instructions for finding house and getting inside.
There are heaters to counter any issues with main thermostat.
Host seemed pretty cool and prepared to aid in any issues. They would be the reason for me to return.
CONS:
Heat/AC thermostat was extremely annoying, particularly walking in the first night after a long day of traveling in the cold. Difficult to use, and turns off and resets very often. Best to tell host to set temperature and just don't touch it again.
Fenced-in parking spot can be difficult to get in and out of with the other cars parked on the street (including in front of your house).
Shower didn't get past warm after the first night. Faucet water was always freezing.