We had a great stay and Nate is SO responsive! However, the house needs some attention..
PROS: very walkable (coffee shop, restaurants, bars), the house is adorable, and the pool is lovely. Great open living room space for hanging out, eating, and games. The AC and ceiling fans were great for the unexpectedly warm weather.
CONS: the space was quite dusty/dirty (we moved the couch slightly to make room for a game of charades and there was an inch of dust and hair), the backyard is full of weeds (stinging nettles as tall as my hips), the outside games are very weather worn, and the trash and recycling were overflowing from previous guests to the point where we just lined up bags next to the bins. We only had 10 people and found it to be a bit tight, especially with the bathroom access ONLY being through a bedroom. Don't let the early sleepers sleep in the bedrooms where the bathrooms are!
Overall it was a lovely spot but expensive for what it was!