We had a group of 12 for a bachelor party weekend at Juan's property and had a great time. The outdoor areas on the property are great for activities and hanging out while swimming in the pool or grilling, and the big rec room is great for bringing the party indoors when it gets too hot or after the bugs come out in the evening. Juan was a great communicator and the check in/out process was a breeze.
All that said, there were a few things which may or may not be obvious from the listing that I would flag for future renters:
-The kitchen is functional, but doesn't offer a ton of prep space or a great array of tools. We managed just fine for our purposes, which was mostly grilling and some basic breakfast stuff, but anyone wanting to do a lot of cooking for a big group might struggle (for instance, there was only one sharp knife we could find anywhere). We also had to make a trip to swap out the propane tank for the gas grill when we arrived.
-The sleeping quarters are quite tight if you have a larger group. The couches that are pictured in the rec room are no longer there (they've added a pool table and moved the ping pong table inside) so there is no sofa bed, and many of the beds are fulls instead of queens, so not ideal for sharing between adults.
-The listing mentions that the owner maintains a private loft on the property. We were told his son stays there, and while for the most part it wasn't obtrusive, one of the bedrooms is in the lower level of that building and the members of our group who stayed in there complained of some loud early morning noise above them (furniture being moved around, or something like that).
-Not at all Juan's fault, but the water levels at the lake are super low and have been for some time. There's still dock access (we rented boats and had them delivered to us one day), but the water is nowhere near where it's pictured in the house photos. So if you want to swim in the lake, it's a little bit of a trek down to the dock and back up, not really something you can do and still be in shouting distance of the back yard or pool.
-We had some trouble getting Ubers/Lyfts to pick us up at the location. We always eventually got them, but you may want to plan extra time or book private car services for early morning airport runs or golf outings.
I would still recommend Juan's property as a fun, casual hangout spot. But it's not inexpensive, and these were a few areas where it wasn't a home run considering the cost. It's also clear they are making a lot of updates (many positive!), and so the listing just feels quite out of step with what the property actually looks like now.