Overall - just ok. Here's why:
1. Cleanliness - sub par. Owner refunded cleaning fee. House wasn't clean and would benefit from a deep cleaning and a new maid service.
2. Accuracy - it isn't what the listing says, it is what it does not say. Be prepared to bring your own towels (1/person provided for 6 days), wash cloths (none provided), hand towels (none provided) Kitchen towels (none provided). Plumbing - great water pressure upstairs / non existent in downstairs bath. Outdoor furniture has no cushions as shown and is far more used than photo shows. Patio not as shown - furniture has no cushions, no table and 1 chair vs 4. Lighting (except kitchen and bathrooms) is a real issue - missing lightbulbs, broken lamps. Bring a flashlight.
3. Check-in - maid was still "cleaning" after 4pm check-in.
4. Communication - Good. Michelle addressed all the issues I had in a prompt and friendly manner.
5. Location - close to everything we wanted to do ... however the noise from car alarms and neighbors, and unfortunately a few incidents that made it feel unsafe
6. Value - if all of the above were improved upon this would certainly live up to the value.
The home is great for a large group, and if you don't mind the items mentioned above, I would say rent it.