We stayed in both homes during this trip, and they were both perfect! Awesome location (close to all the things we wanted to do — UT game, Rainey st, bats viewing and check out restaurants), and the homes were clean and modern.
We had plenty of space for 6 of us (4 stayed in the big home, and 2 in the little home). Parking was super easy, and ubers were only $10 or so to most places we wanted to get to. These would be at the top of my list if I visit again!