Our stay was during winter during the pandemic, so we had semi-unusual wants for this trip.
The listing was clean, well designed, and in a tucked away location.
Our main issues were in two issues 1) unusable fireplace and 2) temperature regulation in listing.
For 1), we asked the host upon check-in how to operate the fireplace. At that point, they told us the fireplace was unusable due to "city ordinance". We expressed our disappointment/confusion, since the listing advertised a fireplace (we limited our search by it) and the host had not been upfront with that lack. I consider a fireplace a major amenity, like a pool or a jacuzzi, that I'm willing to pay a premium on a listing for. The host had a very unprofessional attitude about the issue, saying things like "it's only 60 today" (the low was in fact 37) and "you didn't ask specifically about this before". The core of the issue was that they weren't upfront about a lack of a major advertised amentiy that we paid extra for. We ended up getting a partial refund through Airbnb customer service.
For 2), we had a terrible time regulating the temperature in the listing. There was a nest available, but the upstairs and downstairs reacted very differently. The downstairs was a few degrees below the setting and the upstairs a few higher. This led to us having a hard time sleeping the first night before we figured out we needed to set it lower that desired. Also, we discovered the second night that the fireplace (mentioned above we were told not to use), had the floo left open, probably contributing to the temperature issues.
Overall, it was a nice listing. But, with the fireplace lack, temperature issues, and host attitude, we honestly wished we had just done a staycation at home.