First thing: you probably don't think this is possible from the pictures, but the place was honestly even nicer in person than I expected. Absolutely gorgeous, an amazing way to spend my Birthday.
Sue was accommodating on multiple levels, the place was well cared for, I'm fairly certain every necessary toiletry and ammenity was present (I'm a bit of an over-packer so it would've been difficult for me to notice). Everything was just the tops!
One small word of warning: this place is distinctly more of a summer rental. There were a few things moved or missing (a fire pit/logs that were pictured, plastic cups to adhere to the no glass in the pool area rule) and the big thing to note is that only the spa was heated; meaning that the pool itself is too cold to use in the off-season. Nowhere in Sue's advertisement was I mislead about any of this, I just made my own assumptions. This was still a 5-star experience, I just wanted to put this for anyone like myself who may have let their brain run a little wild.