Pros: Beautiful home, great location, comfortable beds, Pierce was quick to respond.
Cons: the house was supplied with the absolute bare minimum--there was one set of silverware but no dishes, coffee mugs, cups, etc. No paper towels and barely any coffee left in the small can that was supplied. We were definitely unimpressed given how much we were paying for the stay. No extra blankets or bedding in the house. Found numerous mostly-dead tree roaches in the living room upon our arrival and throughout our stay. The hottub was inflatable and dirty (the bottom of it was covered in dirt and leaves), so we didn't end up using.
Overall, the house was nice and we had a good time. But it seems like the owner could easily stock the house with basic necessities and make this a 5-star listing.