First, let me start by saying that the Renters Club is an incredible management operation. Upon arriving at the house (that had been used very well the previous weekend of Austin City Limits) they were quick to fix any problem we had with the cleanliness and readiness of the property. Most Airbnb homes that I have rented do not have this sort of management team and I would tell anybody renting the home that you are in good hands.
Second, this home has been rented a lot, you can tell. After paying $6000 for a weekend rental it is fair to expect a little bit nicer and well-kept space that should be better maintained. Also, it should be known that someone (maybe matinence person) lives on-site in the home, in a sperate wing. This was mentioned to us beforehand, and I must have missed the fact that they were actually in a wing of the house where you could here a TV and talking through walls until about 230 AM at night - a little unsettling to say the least. Because of that, it really loses the private factor. It also sits on a highway, and you can hear freeway noise throught the day and into the night. In a competitive rental market and high rate home I would have expected the above things to be a little more clear.
Third, the things I really liked about the home was the crazy amount of space for people to enjoy and relax, amazing kitchen with ample space, incredible views, wonderful pool setting, and a great management team to work with.