We stayed at Dr. Jay's place for Memorial Day Weekend 2017. As many of the reviews mention, the home was well beyond our expectations - a true Airbnb gem. The week leading up to our stay Dr. Jay made sure to communicate all of the important details of the house. Despite the fact that the home (mansion) is quite lavishly furnished and decorated, we never felt overburdened by Dr. Jay's rules or expectations. Dr. Jay expects that you will treat the home as your own, and if you abide by the clearly laid out guidelines and clean up after yourself, you will have an amazing time.
Our favorite part of the house was the backyard, of course. The lawn down by the lake was sizable enough for wiffle ball, and the patio on top of the boat shelter was an awesome place to relax. The pool and hot tub were beautiful and well taken care of - as we arrived there was a landscaping service skimming the pool. It was very evident that Dr. Jay takes excellent care of the property for his guests.
Additionally, all of the rooms and beds were comfortable and in great condition - everything, everywhere was well kept and cleanly.
We went down to 6th street both nights of our stay, and the commute was nothing to worry about.
If you're on the fence about booking Dr. Jay's property for your group - just do it. Everything went as smoothly as it could have. We all hope we'll be back soon.