Let me start by saying we really loved the location - a short walk to Broadway, although there was some construction going on when we were there - which could be heard weekdays in one of the bedrooms (the one without the en suite). And the apartment was cute with comfy beds. But overall, I think the listing was a bit overpriced for the experience as it had quite a few quirks.
The first was that there was no window (noted on the listing) which made the entire experience very casino-like.
The second is that the only bathroom has no soundproofing - it was off of one of the bedrooms with a roller door that did not shut, so you will hear everything from everywhere in the apartment. (especially those In the room with en suite). The apartment is very small so really no way to avoid that unless they change the door and add soundproofing.
The third was that it was not possible to control the temperature for more than 3 hours. Even if you hit "hold" on the temperature you wanted, it would revert to a timed program after three hours, which was way too hot. The host wasn't able to fix it while we were there. And on a nit-picky note, the apartment was missing some of the regular conveniences that I think you should expect in an airbnb. There was a Kuerig coffee machine, but no pods, so we had to go out and find pods during our vacation. Also, there was only 1 roll of toilet paper so we also had to go out and buy it when it ran out. Attention to these little things would have made for a better experience. Also, there was no luggage storage, although the host did suggest some brunch places that would store it. (We ended up eating/storing at Woolworth's downstairs)