We rented Jimmy's place for a bachelor party of 14. The place accommodated all of us and is an amazing location for restaurants, bars, and groceries. The Uber to Broadway is a 7 min drive, UberXLs were around $14. Also, the airport isn't far either.
The place itself is 5 stars for sure. Porch with rocking chairs, fenced in backyard, nice kitchen, and plenty of space for large groups.
I definitely recommend it. Five Points is a great area.