We only briefly met Nan and Martin but found them to be very nice and more than willing to be accommodating. It is obvious that they have worked very hard to turn their space into a very positive experience for their guests. The microwave, toaster and mini fridge along with the water and coffee are a plus. It is a very quiet, peaceful setting. The bed (even though we are accustomed to a king) was quite comfy. I liked the window AC - it generated some constant sleep noise as well as kept it nice and cool for good sleeping. The covered parking was also nice. The shower and towels were great. The wifi was great. The soap, shampoo, etc. were also great.
And now the other side - we were a little turned off be the age of the space and still had the "we're relegated to the basement" feeling. I am very sensitive to smells and while there really wasn't a musty basement smell, the fireplace odor was a bit uncomfortable. I also think I smelled a little bit of cat odor. There seemed to be a small amount of loose particulate matter on the floor - I'm not sure if the floor is swept or vacuumed but it appears that some stuff is being missed. If it were me, I would also repair the storm/screen door. That's a first impression thing. Considering all factors, including price/value, I probably would not stay here again. It would, however, be a better value for 3-5 people. I have communicated my concerns directly to Nan and she is very willing to correct and improve the issues that I noted, so consideration should be given for the space to be improved.