Me and my friend decided to stay at Yeva & Igor because of the price and it was not too far from Broadway. We did not have any issues with the house. It was very clean and we found everything we needed. The only problem we had was in the neighborhood. Every time we went out of the house, drivers would honk to us. There is a market right next to the airbnb which we went couple times. The last time we had moral harassment from the workers. We felt secure in the house, but not outside it.
If you are a guy traveling alone, or a couple I would say it will be fine. But for two girls on their own was a little embarrassing.