We had a group of 13 stay for 4 nights in September 2018 and had a blast! This house is perfect for a bachelor party or reunion as it is newly remodeled, clean, and has a lost of common space on the second level and the rooftop. Short UBER ride to broadway or Vanderbilt.
The immediate area isn't great, but seems to be under rebuild with several apartments like this right around. I probably wouldn't recommend this area for a bachelorette party, but we didn't experience any issues. The house was a little low on a few supplies like trash bags and toilet paper but the host was very responsive and even had someone drop off a couple trash bags to us. The host responded very quickly to any of our questions (and we asked a bunch) and was helpful throughout the stay.
Overall, I would definitely recommend this to a larger group looking for a clean, comfortable space with a rooftop for hanging and easy access to Broadway.