This is one of my favorite AirBnB's that I've ever stayed at. The apartment is in a beautifully cared-for, architecturally detailed old house with tons of natural light, so you just want to curl up in the chair in the little window nook and hang out in such a pleasant space. But then you would miss out on the neighborhood, which is equally lovely even without the park and delicious coffee house a few blocks away that put it over the top.
Mitch and Donna weren't in town when I stayed there, but that didn't stop them from being communicative and available to take care of requests. However, my requests were almost non-existent because they have already thought of pretty much everything one could want and then some. There are screens to put in the windows if you want to open them, a comfortable bed that is both firm and cozy at the same time with super soft sheets and extra blankets, interesting books to peruse, all kinds of goodies in the kitchen area, a bath tub as well as a shower, and a comfortable sofa bed in the front room. They really seem to have covered every need ahead of time, down to including the wifi information in their welcome email in case you need to access it before you get in the apartment (a thoughtful touch for those of us who still exist in the world without data plans).
The area is quiet--I'm a light sleeper and nothing woke me up. And the apartment is immaculately clean without feeling sterile. To the contrary, I felt like I stepped back in time to a classy luxury suite.
The price is definitely on the upper end of what I feel comfortable paying for an AirBnB, but between the apartment itself, the friendliness of Mitch and Donna, and the location, I found it well worth it. My only regret there is that I won't be able to go back quite as often as I would otherwise like!