Recently stayed at Nathan's with eight other guys for a friend's bachelor party. Everything was wonderful, particularly for what we needed for the weekend. House was nicely stocked with towels / other amenities, is very new looking with nice finishes / decorations to go along with it, and very open / spacious.
Only minor issue - which i understand isn't really within their control - is that while sitting in the backyard patio area (which is a nice extra feature as well), the odors from the construction port-a-potty next door were quite noticeable, otherwise had a great overall experience and would definitely recommend to others (could have comfortably fit a handful more people i think as well if needed).