We would definitely recommend Julian's cottage! It was exactly right for our needs. We appreciated the homey touches (the rugs! the plants! the record player!) and the comfortable bed. Plus, Julian was very responsive and easy to communicate with. It's true that it's quite close to the train tracks, which wasn't a problem for us, but it might be something to consider if you're a light sleeper. However, Julian provides a white-noise machine and earplugs, and my boyfriend (who is a light sleeper) used these and slept fine. We were impressed that, although the cottage is relatively small, it comes with some very nice amenities, like a patio with patio furniture. We would come back!