We stayed at John's for almost six months during our home renovation. We needed a furnished house with ample space to work-from-home during COVID and a fenced yard for a dog. That's a needle in a haystack in Nashville, so we were grateful for John's house.
Pros: The house is on a main road, but it's in a very central location - close to Publix, Target, hospitals, good takeout - everything you need to live comfortably in Nashville. The backyard is fully fenced and dog-friendly. I've found that just because a listing allows dogs, doesn't mean it's dog-friendly. There are no gaps in the fence, poisonous plants or other things that can cause trouble. The house has ample space for a small family. John is super responsive - we were having issues with the WiFi and he replaced the WiFi and switched carriers while we were there. Future guests should feel confident in the WiFi quality.
Cons: The house is an old craftsman and can use a little TLC. The listing photos were probably taken a few years ago and the house could use some restoration and new furnishings. While we were there, we had issues with the tub finish chipping, a leak and a broken washing machine. For the latter two, John was very prompt to respond and get things remediated. We're old house lovers, and it's just the reality of living in an old house.
All-in-all, not a luxury experience, but exactly what we needed to get through our renovation.