Pros: Spotless, homey, comfortable, great location, lots of character, responsive host (at all hours, which unfortunately we had to learn - see below), abundance of amenities
Cons: Lack of privacy and inability to feel completely at home due to the fact that there are guests staying above you. Based on the photos and description we were shocked to learn a week prior to our arrival that we were in an up-down duplex. Because it is an older house and not technically an apartment, the sound proofing is poor. We were awoken our first night at 1am by the guests above us returning home. Brigitte was highly responsive to this and we appreciate it, but it was extremely disappointing.
Overall, I gave 5 stars because the pros outweigh the cons and the price is very reasonable given this arrangement. Just please be aware that it may not be the private cottage feel you may be expecting :-)