Let me start by saying we'd stay at the loft on Third Ave North again.
Location was perfect for us for as Broadway was our main destination. The loft was clean and stylish. The beds were comfortable and the towels fluffy. Two bathrooms for four women was a wise decision and the washer / dryer was a great extra.
A few things that caught us by surprise:
We drove to Nashville, figuring we'd mostly leave the car parked while there. The cost of parking reminded me of Chicago. :( The parking lot right next to the loft building was $38 for 24 hours, so keep that in mind if you're planning to drive.
The coffeemaker in the loft was a single-cup Keurig which was incompatible with the bag of ground coffee we brought along. A heads up regarding that would have helped us to bring the right supplies. (I did try to view the pictures on the website prior to our arrival but couldn't make the details of the coffeemaker so I assumed it was a regular machine)
One of the bathroom tubs has a VERY slow drain (the plunger left in that bathroom helped to speed things up a bit)
Again, we'd recommend Amanda's loft: we'll be better prepared next time and wanted other future guests to be too. ☺