We had a wonderful stay at the Peaceful Puffin. The location is really perfect-- walking distance to everything downtown but also quick drives to the mansions, beaches, etc. We loved walking to the coffee shop down the street (Harvest) in the mornings and then to the nearby park (Morton) with a fantastic playground for our son. It seems like there aren't a ton of food delivery options (key for parents with kiddos with early bedtimes) so we really appreciated the other commenter's rec for Bar Cino (highly recommend!). All of the amenities (pack n play, beach toys, fully stocked kitchen, w/d, toys) made travel much easier for our family.