Our stay at David and Jenn's cabin was amazing and I already want to go back. It's smartly and tastefully furnished and the property is incredibly picturesque (well manicured landscape, windmill, outdoor party lights, fire pit, view of the Newport bridge).
They were excellent hosts – great communication, friendly, and very accommodating. They even left us s'more ingredients! As a bonus you can watch them work in the glass blowing studio or even take a lesson to do it on your own.
Would highly recommend if you're looking for a quiet, peaceful, rustic experience.