We stayed at Windrose House for a wedding at The Sullivan House. Walked from the ferry terminal with ease. (Ferry is 50-55 min. from Pt.Judith). We did not have a car, rented mopeds one afternoon. 2-3 hours was perfect to tour island.
House was very clean and perfect for our needs. Things to note...Bedroom #1 states it has a Queen AND 2 singles- they are 2 separate rooms. The Q room has its own bath and A/C, and there is a room w/ 2 S's with no attached bath & no A/C. This is actually a 5th bedroom. There is NO A/C in the kitchen and family room, but lots of windows with lots of breeze most of the time.
BIG PLUS...there was an outdoor shower out the back and we ALL LOVED using it. Sitting out front on the porch was the perfect spot to gather. Drinks on the porch/lawn at The Spring House had GREAT VIEWS. The Hotel Manisses was very charming. Ballards was fun...huge beach bar. Would definitely stay here agin.