I really enjoyed my time at Jay's place in Middletown. The house was just renovated before I arrived so everything felt very new. I thought they made great selections and put together a really stylish and useful rental. The beds were really comfortable, everything was sparkling clean on arrival. Really enjoyed the back deck during the mornings and late afternoon/evening when the sun wasn't at full strength. Luckily there was terrific weather during my stay. It's about 1/2 mile walk to First Beach and a 1 mile walk to Surfer's End of Second Beach (some of which is on a busier road), but for me that was no problem. I also walked into Newport a few times with friends at night, which is a bit longer, but a very nice walk. There is great Uber service in Newport so it's very easy to get around without walking!