My wife and I very much enjoyed our stay. Cindy and Craig were very personable, gracious, and responsive hosts, and the setting is lovely. The overall rating (4 stars) reflects the objective quality of the accommodations; this is a very small cottage with limited kitchen facilities, and we can't honestly give a 5-star rating to such a modest space. However, the listing accurately represents the property, we were comfortable there, and we would be happy to stay again if we should be seeking lodging in the area.