The reviews on this listing are all 5-star. The reviews on Paul's other properties are also good (because I checked before I rented). So I just don't know what happened for us. The location is fantastic. Otherwise the stay was disappointing. The house was simply not clean. And that is just not ok considering we are in the midst of a pandemic. Paul will likely say that we didn't reach out while we were there to complain about the cleanliness. And he will be right, we didn't. Based on my interactions with him beforehand, it just didn't seem worth it. I did write to him privately when we checked out a day early and I received "Thanks for letting us know." I didn't expect anything other than an apology, and after spending a significant amount of money to stay there, I didn't even receive that. So I am sorry to have to write this, but I don't think it is fair for others to go through the same disappointing experience.