We picked Hilltop Happiness based on the great reviews and it lived up to all of them! It is an amazing, comfortable place to stay with plenty of room to relax inside and out on the deck and patio. We really appreciated the air conditioning and the cold waters in the fridge as we were there during a heat wave! It was a welcome escape from the heat after beaching it all day. We brought our bikes and the place is really in the center of the island so you can get to all the best spots. We even rode to dinner. The ride back is up hill but at least we could cool down in the AC! It really was fun to watch the planes come and go from the airport and even with that it was such a quiet place to retreat to after a day in town or on the beach. So quiet! Of course being that close to the airport means you HAVE to have at least have one breakfast at Bethany's Diner located at the airport. The room was very well appointed - coffee and tea for the morning or after dinner - snacks for your excursions and fridge for a cold water, beer, or rosé at the end of the day on the deck. So comfortable and Rich was easily reached if we ever had a question or needed anything. One of the best things is the included taxi pickup when you get off the ferry. While we did not take advantage of it we did use it to take our bags to the house so we did not have to ride with them on our bikes! It was so convenient! We will definitely be back - there is a reason this place is so booked up! It is worth it!