We had an absolutely glorious time at Blue Haven, which had something for everyone (3-year-old daughter, parents, and grandparents). Location is quiet and residential, but just 10 minutes walk from the beach. Newport is just a short drive away, along with a number of quality restaurant options in Middletown itself.
Huge credit to Sara and Lance, for keeping their house in such immaculate condition and thinking of every little thing! (For example: a box of toys for kids in the lower level...totally unexpected!). They care deeply about their guests and in keeping the place up to standard - which is certainly great for the next guest as well.
We highly recommend!