The Sheffield House is the quintessential Block Island B&B. From the vintage furniture to the lace curtains in the windows of our room, it was perfect. The location is fantastic as it is up on a hill so you'll get a wonderful breeze but it is also a short 5-minute walk from the town center and not much farther to the beach (depending on what part of the beach you are going to).
I know the shared bathroom can make people a little nervous, but we never had a problem waiting for the bathroom and there is also an outdoor shower. I also think at least one other room has an en-suite bathroom, so there are more than enough bathrooms in my opinion.
We are so happy to have found this place and can't wait to visit again!