This suited our need which was just a place to lay our heads. We definitely paid the extra money for the experience as the arcade is the first indoor mall from the 1800s. Very small and cozy, the description is spot on. Was a little chilly when we got there (58 degrees) and took a while to warm up. The water temp was perfect. Close to downtown and walkable … if it wasn’t so cold out we would have taken advantage of that. It is inconvenient to get the keys at another location but also no issues obtaining them. Would stay here again for a quick trip and the experience.