We survived Hurricane Henri at Shel's house and loved our entire week on island!
The house has good bones and weathered the storm perfectly. Great house in a great location! Shel is an excellent host...communication was very easy with her. She responded right away to any questions we had (mostly leading up to our stay in terms of what we needed to bring) and was very helpful while we were on island.
The house is incredibly well-stocked for a rental...particularly in the kitchen. You can tell this is a home and not just a rental for Shel and family. Kitchen had everything you could possibly think of to cook meals at home (which we did several times). Plenty of extra bedding, pillows, etc. Lots of books and toys/games for kids. Even several beach chairs and umbrellas. Honestly, it's one of the best-stocked homes we've ever rented.
Location is fantastic...we easily biked to town and beach. Shel notes that her house is directly across the street from Club Soda, which tends to have an active night life. She is not wrong, the place was bumping several nights we were there, BUT it never bothered us, or our young children. If we chose to sit on our front porch we could hear the music when people entered/exited, but from inside the house we never heard a peep. The majority of the activity and noise is at the back of the club, where they have outdoor space, but none of that can be heard from the street. It truly was never an issue for us at Shel's.
Overall, everything in the listing matches with reality. Of note is the house does not have central air, but individual AC units in each bedroom that kept the rooms very cool. We were very happy with our stay and hope to be back again soon!