We chose this place for our brief get-away because of the overwhelming positive reviews, and its relative privacy/quietness away from the cacophony of a busy tourist town. Everything turned out to be just as described and commended. The one star off is for one disadvantage of its location - the dining scene in Jamestown is a bit of a disappointment. Restaurants are scant, and most are closed before Thursday, which leaves only a couple options, and it can take a while to get a table. It was stifling hot during our stay, so we would come back in the afternoon for a swim to cool down; by dinner time we didn't feel like driving all the way across the bridge again. We quickly learned to have our best meal at lunch time in Newport, but if you care more about a nice dinner, or your itinerary doesn't allow much time for a good lunch, then don't expect much from Jamestown :-).