This suited us perfectly. Two comfortable bedrooms in a light-filled apartment that had everything we needed and was walking distance from every place we wanted to be. We walked to music at the City Winery on 11th, walked to a Broadway show (a mile, but very walkable), walked to and from Penn Station where we arrived and departed NYC from, found plenty of nearby food options and were a block from the subway when we needed to travel a longer distance. I haven't stayed in this neighborhood (West Chelsea) before, but would definitely go back. Unlike the many airbnbs that are solely rental properties, this is someone's home and full of their stuff, so you should go in knowing that -- but the vibe at David's place is so friendly that even that ends up being a plus. Highly recommended!