I really enjoyed staying with Kaitlyn and I can only recommend booking her place. The appartment is really nice (and very good value for money, I believe). My bedroom was cozy and the bed very comfortable (as it was very, very hot in NYC during my stay, I really appreciated the AC as well). At first, the area seemed a bit rougher than expected, but I always felt safe even when walking home by myself in the middle of the night.
As Kaitlyn had to go away for a week, I had the appartment to myself which was great, as I had already stayed with friends for quite some time. Communication with Kaitlyn was super easy and all the instructions were to the point. Overlall, Kaitlyn was a very nice and very helpful host.