This was our first air bnb experience and I suspect future trips may struggle to match it! The apartment is even lovelier than it looks in the photos. Four adults spent 15 days here (one sleeping on the sofa bed) and we were really comfortable. There were many thoughtful touches we really appreciated after a long flight - fresh coffee, tea, biscuits and dairy produce in the fridge. There were tasteful Christmas decorations and lights which were especially welcoming. Bob responded immediately to all of our requests. Access to Manhattan was easy and quick via the A train, a real bonus. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend Robin and Bob and their lovely home to others.