Staying at Jonathan's and Nicole's place was everything that I look for in an Airbnb. It was safe, clean and comfortable. Location to Manhattan was also just a train ride away and the nearest station was only a 3 minute walk from their place. The area of the Airbnb also has a number of place to grab supplies, coffee and food. Getting around Brooklyn was also just 2-4 rides away so Park Slope, Cobble hill and Brooklyn Heights were just so accessible - especially with all the cafes, restaurants and sites.
Checking in was a piece of cake add instructions to get in the house were clear and precise.
Aside from that, Jonathan and Nicole were very friendly people and I had enjoyed a few conversations with them. Nicole is an amazing baker and the baked goods are top-notch. She baked cookies, muffins and a chocolate peanut butter monster cookie while I was there. I enjoyed them tremendously. The house is really homey and the vibes were positive all throughout. It felt familiar - like staying with family. And if you dreamed about experiencing a pre-war New York town house, then this is the place for you.
I would most certainly stay at their Airbnb listing again when I return to NYC. :)