The majority of things about Cathy's place were positive - the apartment was clean, the bed was comfy, and it was well equipped. It was a 5 minute walk to the subway on the A line, which made it very easy to go into the city and also to JFK airport.
Unfortunately, noise travels very easily from upstairs, where Cathy lives. Each morning we could hear young children running around and shouting. On two of the nights there were local parties (one of which was in Cathy's house) which kept us awake due to the noise. It's a shame because it's obviously not a problem for people to have a party, but unfortunately due to the lack of noise insulation, it meant we had very little sleep on two of the nights.
All in all, it's well situated and very comfortable, but I'd advise against it for light sleepers.