Carla was very kind, flexible and responsive. The listing described the location accurately. If you are looking for something close to midtown, to walk to a Broadway show or Times Square then the place is great. I did not realize before booking that I would be charged a per person fee, which added $68. The place was not extremely clean which is what we expected based on the description and the instructions before arrival. The building hallways are not very clean but the host cannot control that, so it is understandable. We appreciated that there was a Brita pitcher with water in the fridge and that towels were provided. Although we did not need it, it is awesome to have a washer and dryer in the unit! A few other things to note- there is no TV in the apartment and also, if you are a light sleeper, the neighbors are loud and the walls are thin, but that could happen anywhere! Just bring headphones. Thanks for having us, Carla! We would return again!