First of all, S is by far the kindest, most helpful and responsive host I have ever encountered. He had great recommendations for restaurants near the apartment and elsewhere in the City. The apartment has amazing views of Manhattan - no need to go the the Empire State Building to get a view from up high - this apartment has it. (and you can see the Empire State Building from the living room window). The beds were comfortable - this is a big thing for me. Really great King bed in the master - and my daughters said theirs were comfortable as well. It's a spacious apartment, by NY standards, and is very comfortable. Great location in the City - 30 minute walk to MOMA, 20-25 minute walk to Broadway shows, about 20 minutes to Chelsea Market/the Highline. And also easy subway access. We had a great week.