Fantastic value, great hosts, and excellent location.
Family of four (two boys, 12 & 14) stayed between Christmas and New Year. The rooms were much more than we expected as far as privacy and space - one boy slept in the 2nd bedroom, the other (by choice) on the couch in the living room. Location is quiet (for NYC). Able to park on the street a few feet from the house at no cost.
We walked to the ferry terminal each morning and spend the day exploring Manhattan. Then walked back in the evening. Ferry ride is a NYC attraction in itself - with great views of the statue of liberty and lower Manhattan.
Full kitchen was stocked with basic food and drinks. Able to make our own breakfast each morning (a huge money saver). Full cable and wi-fi allowed us to unwind, watch the bowl games, and catch up after long days in the city.
Ondine and Jason are great hosts. They really went out of the way to make sure we were comfortable and knew about the city's latest attractions. We ate at a few local restaurant's based on our host's recommendations. All were excellent.
This is our new favorite lodging when visiting NYC.