I loved my stay at Caitlin's place and highly recommend booking here for your trip to NYC. It's in the perfect location in the UWS - located so close the subway and easy to get to all parts of the city.
The place looks just like the photos and the bed is so comfortable like many of the other reviews mention. Caitlin's place has so many charming touches that make her place even more incredible.
It was so fun talking and getting to know Caitlin - so many good conversations and things to talk about. She is very friendly, so easy to talk to and will make you feel right at home. She has amazing recommendations and I loved the coffee in the mornings.
Also, Clooney is the friendly cat around.