My husband and I stayed at Judy's place 4 nights. It was a great place to stay and Judy was very responsibe and generous. Few specific things to note...
It's about an hour outside Manhattan by subway. The station is very close and easily accessible. We mainly commuted this way and it's doable, just some time there and back.
It's clean and quaint! We spent most of our days in the city and were basically only at Airbnb for sleeping. I wouldn't necessarily recommend this if you are hoping to spend a lot of time there, just because of the size. There wasn't a bunch of room for luggage or things like that but the size was expected for NYC. It was perfect for what we wanted from our trip!
Judy was excellent to communicate with and very helpful. My husband needed some extra face towels and needed more neck support with pillows so she went out of her way to get us extra pillows and towels and was very responsive in the process. She also has a hallway full of sanitation supplies if needed.
We really enjoyed our stay and would stay again if we found ourselves back in the area!