I traveled with 3 friends for pleasure. We stayed for 5 days, 4 nights. There were so many great things about this location. There were a few not so good things about it too.
Pros- good price, the host were responsive every time i messaged them, they returned my message. It was cold and the host not only had the heat adjusted they left a electric heater in the event that it wasn't warm enough (super sweet). Excellent location as it is in walking distance of many tourists spots (Empire State building, Macy's, etc.) and the metro is not far, very cute studio apartment, there are a few restaurants and eateries close to location (don't hesitate to explore the area). There are cheap gift shops close by.
Cons
The bathroom is small. Im not sure if the noise we heard all day/night was coming from the furnace or construction workers in the building but it was noisy the entire trip. There is wind coming through the window. Old building.
Overall, i would work w/ this host & location again.