Dear travelers, My rating is written of the experience as a single mom traveling with a toddler (2 ½ years old)... I know I have different needs and than other travelers. And yes, I searched extra for an a family-friendly apartment.
I have to say it was my first bad experience on airbnb. where to start?
It was over an hour ride from La Guardia and I spent 70$. When I came to the apartment, I realized there where about 15 steps to the apartment - no elevator. Imagine a single person with a stroller, luggage and a toddler....spot the problems and struggle every day. I couldn't leave the stroller in the hallway because the main door (entrance) was 24/7 open. I don't know why.
Coming into the apartment, first I thought ok, nice size but then I saw all the dirt. It was gross. I am not so pedantic but I think when you rent out your home there should be a basic cleanness - especially when you know someone comes with a kid. Everyone knows kids are playing on the ground. Although the sheets seemed like they were already used and didn't smell fresh.
The furniture was broken. I am happy my toddler didn't hurt himself.
The kitchen didn't had enough dishes, not even a pan or spices - not even a bottle of water (I think that's a minimum when you host someone) As a host, you know which a long flight your guest had and would be happy just to have a sip. (I don't trust the tab water in NYC).
One day the security in the kitchen kicked out. Sandy needed 3 days to fix it. I wasn't't able to do the laundry or to use the microwave.
The subway station is a 10 min walk, which was ok for me. I have been a few times to NYC so that although the train ride didn't bother me much (Q-train has all the important stops). And I liked it that I was close to Coney Island (5 stops). If it is your first time you should choose a nearer location to Manhattan.
I felt safe in the neighborhood and had a great time with the neighbors and people living there. The neighborhood is jewish and you should be tolerant and respect their religion.
Grocery shopping and restaurants are nearby.
I think the location would fit to a family with older kids or only adults.