This room in Shelly's place is one of those "only in New York" type of listings. A lovely loft bedroom with a door that opens right out onto the roof. Great Brooklyn skyline view. Private entrance and bathroom were extremely helpful. Shelley was a very kind and welcoming host. You do get to hear a lot of what goes on in the common room downstairs, but everyone was quiet and wrapped up by bedtime and the noise was never above a reasonable volume. Would totally stay again.