The host was great with responses and very personable. She even stayed up to receive us when our arrival was later than expected. She gave great neighborhood recommendations and the apartment is within walking/subway rides of many NYC destinations.
There is a strong smell of smoke in the hallway. We are not smokers, and we have allergies, so this bothered us. We kept the bedroom and living area doors closed to keep the smoke in the hallway.
The foam mattress in the master bedroom was uncomfortable, but doable, for a three-night stay.
The price point is a bit high per night for this type of apartment.
I noted the previous response about the toilet paper, but we understood this issue based on our understanding of septic systems. It was fine for a three-day weekend stay.