Overall my stay at Red Autumn was great. The location was ideal for my vacation being that it was close to family and friends. The check in process was simple and easy. Contacting the host was stress free. The apartment was exactly as pictured , no surprises. For cleanliness I give a 4 only because I found the floors to be a bit dusty but nothing a quick sweep and mop couldn’t fix. There is a dog that barks a lot on the first floor so that at times was a little bothersome but not too crazy. But I would definitely stay again on my next trip to NYC.