Brookes place has a great location and believe in summer time using the rooftop terrace will lift the overall experience. For a February stay the place was rather cold. It didn't help that the heaters kept turning off during the night with the "change the filter" indicator blinking. After consulting Brooke, the full dishwasher and dust balls on the floor was taken care off. The heater never really got to work. But luckily the weather changed towards the end of our stay.
Overall, great place - could work for a single person during summer. But its priced in the higher end of the scale for New York. Next time coming alone to NY I would book it. But not for 2 or 3 persons. And not during winter.