Amanda's house is very comfortable, so you really feel at home. The beds are amazing and there's a lot of space, 3 floors, for a family to spread out in. The house itself is very cool architecturally speaking and Amanda has decorated it beautifully. You have everything you need, including a nice porch and backyard (with fire pit) to relax in. I wish we had more time just to hang out at the house.
The location is great. You're around the corner from the F/G trains so it's 10-15 min. from lower Manhattan. You can walk into Park Slope (with tons of restaurants, shops, and bars) in 10 min. There are 2 restaurants (French and Italian), a bar, wine shop, and cafe around the corner near the train. We ate at the French one and I'd definitely go back. There are 2 delis, a pizzeria, supermarket, pharmacy, and ice cream shop all 1-3 blocks away.
You are 1/2 block from Prospect Park and a great playground. In the park you've got a Zoo, Carousel, boat rental, ice skating in winter, and Celebrate Brooklyn (free outdoor concerts) in summer.
The street is quiet and green. It's a great base for exploring Manhattan or going to the beaches at Coney Island. You can drive down or take the F train to the end of the line. There's also Luna Park (and amusement park) there.
We had a fantastic time and would definitely stay there again. Amanda was a great hostess. We did self check-in but she was very attentive and responded quickly to questions via email.