You will get in Sheila's place mostly what is described:
location and neighborhood are great, access to subway is close as well as many places to wine and dine in the area.
We have not met Sheila face to face and the access to the apartment is by using lockbox where the keys are left in.
Wine and cookies were expecting us on the counter and those were a nice touch. Also the place was clean with fresh linen and towels.
Few things though should be improved in order to make the stay really excellent:
sofa is not comfortable to sit on, not just for sleeping, and the shower head has seen better times and better be replaced.
Also note that if you are with a baby and you plan to have him/her sleep in the crib - it is an old pack n' play and the mattress is too worn out and is not suitable for babies back.
We thought it will be suitable, but once arrived we understood we have to have our 3 months old baby sleeping with us in our bed if we don't want to damage his back.
Also mind you that Sheila has refused to allow us to store our luggage in the apartment's exterior hallway (outside of the apartment) for couple of hours before heading to the airport, so mind that if you have few hours delay between checkout and your flight departure.