We stayed for a short weekend. This place is very hip and trendy. The room was clean and cozy. We didn’t get a chance to go on the rooftop so I cannot give that a fair rating. No issues with noise. Like others said - there was a bit of a wait for the elevators but it’s was a weekend in manhattan, what do you expect?
Only real con was that they did not have water or ice or even a vending machine. After their concession stand closes, you’re on your own.