Amedeo's place was as expected. I booked this place for my parents (in their mid 60s) while they were visiting. They told me that the place was very comfortable and clean. While I knew the walk up would be hard, we still booked since bnbs are scarce in the area. In hindsight, I would think twice about booking this place for my parents again. To be fair, Amedeo warned me ahead of time. I think a combination of exploring Manhattan, the extreme heat and not being used to a pedestrian city, it was difficult for my parents to go up and down multiple times.
They also told me that you can hear street noise from the apt, but that is to be expected as it is on a busy street. Other than that, no issues or complaints.