The apartment was just as described and we couldn't have been happier. It is in a great location for exploring the city (with a subway stop close by) and yet so much quieter than I expected. Everything was clean, orderly, and comfortable. I was also very surprised but pleased by the water pressure in the bath (a pet peeve of mine) -- tons of hot water for a strong shower after being out and about in the city all day!
Sara is an excellent host. Communication was always timely, even when we had an issue with our flight and had to contact her after hours. She also provided lots of wonderful recommendations for the neighborhood. Guest expectations were clearly expressed with no surprises. This was our first trip to New York and we would definitely rent from Sara again.