We went to NYC for my wife's birthday. This was our first experience using Airbnb.
PRO:
-The hosts are fantastic. TJ and Andy were great to talk to and very knowledgable. Two very trustworthy individuals and we felt like we made new friends. A class act.
-The apartment is one of many in an older building. The lobby is simple and is manned by security personnel, so it feels safe.
-The location is a stone's throw from Central Park and there are restaurants and museums within walking distance and perhaps a quick bus trip.
-There is a wonderful bar/restaurant next door. OMG - Fantastic food; pricey but worth it.
CONS:
-There is lots of noise outside. The song says it is "The city that never sleeps" - it is true. Bring ear plugs -- those work great!
-If you have a car, be prepared to walk a little. We were lucky to have a parking spot right outside the lobby doors. Parking is free -- yes, free -- on the street. However, on Tuesday's from 930-1100 the street is cleaned so you need to move your vehicle.
Conclusion:
It was our first Airbnb experience and it was so cool. We got to see so many sights, the 9-11 Memorial; the Statue of Liberty; Ellis Isle; and Museums. None of it would have been possible if we were worrying about our stuff in our room. The reality is that the hosts made the trip worthwhile --- And we would do it again --- In a New York minute.