I had a pleasant stay at Joe's apartment. He's easy to talk to and replies immediately so check in/check-out process was very easy. The location of his apartment is very central. Good restaurants and subway station are nearby. The apartment is small(I expected it to be small) there's no elevator so buckle up to walk up to the 5th (or 6th) floor. If you don't mind any of these things then this is the place to stay in the heart of New York on a budget. Oh and the rooftop is a bonus. Feels great to be up there :)