GOOD
This apartment is well located close to Times Square etc
Laundromat, great Amish market very close as are lots of bars, restaurants etc
BAD
Extremely noisey in front bedroom, as apartment is on 9th Ave
Key pickup / drop off a good 15 minute walk, so with suitcases this is really difficult, in fact the biggest negative
Old lumpy beds, old pillows and threadbare linen made sleeping awful- need replacing
TV did not work
Only seating for meals for 2 people, and lounge only seats 3, so bad if you are eating in for 4 people!
Not much space for food preparation
Communication with questions etc just prior and during stay was never responded to by owner at all
Basically like a lot of AirBnB now, this is a commercial sublet with no guest focus and so not a good option- and overpriced for what you are getting