As per description, it is a basic room but location makes up for everything else. I booked the room for my stay in NYC as I wanted to be as close to Carnegie Hall as possible for a concert that I took part in on 25 Nov. It was a 5min walk to Carnegie Hall.
Some of the reviews commented on the appearance of the room. We found the room clean and neat with everything that we needed. I think some people found the furniture "old and used" but everything is clean.
Sharing the bathroom was not an issue as the owner was not home most of the time. We didn't even need to use the kitchen as dishwashing liquid was provided in the bathroom and we could rinse out our coffee mugs there.
The owner was also very accommodating in arranging at the last minute for early access to the apartment as we arrived an hour earlier than I had anticipated. He was also very thoughtful and provided us with an additional heater for the room when NYC experienced the coldest Thanksgiving Day in the last 100 years!
I would definitely stay there again if I ever get a chance to visit NYC again.