I saw reviews on google that were complaining about free hands noise and space saying the streets were loud and that the lobby was cute but besides that the character doesn’t continue in the rooms and the hallways were dark. So foolish. Everywhere in New York the streets are loud. We slept with the window open and ya occasionally I’d wake up but it was nothing that would prevent you from sleeping. The area was pretty quiet at night so I’d say it would be. More quiet option than other districts. The hallways are dark but it adds to the historic feel so I think it gave it character. The gym was nice and the rooftop bar was cool. Loved that the subway was right there making everything so easy. Would stay again