We needed a last minute place after a dear friend had taken ill who we normally stay with. This place fitted the bill brilliantly. Its in a great location if you prefer downtown manhatten (which we do, having spent all our years staying in Greenwich Village). The studio is a good size for New York. Loved the shower and roll top bath. Cute details of kitsch decor and a really comfy bed! Its a little dark being slightly below street level, but we were there during a really sunny heatwave so it was welcome, as was the air conditioning.
Our check in process was a little messy, only because what we'd arranged wasn't what happened. Evelyn does send really detailed notes prior to your stay, and tends to reply quickly to enquiries.
It can be a little noisy late night, but that's to be expected in New York and it didn't bother us.
A nice touch is that the owner has a restaurant a couple of blocks away which you can go to for breakfast where you get a token for $5 off whatever you order.
Its a good price compared to other places of comparable size and location