We stayed for 8 days at Katherine's place. The location is really good as you have 2 subway lines 6 minutes away (walking distance). There are plenty of nice and sort of cheap (for NY) restaurants in the neighborhood. The room itself is very spacious and you have everything you need (mini closet, hairdryer, desk in case you need to work). Katherine is an amazing host, very caring and the communication was smooth.
The cats are lovely (big plus for cat lovers). I would definitely stay again here if I head to NY for a second time.