Cons:
(1) key pick up/drop off is at a 7-eleven, 2.5 looong NYC blocks away from the actual unit location. If you are coming from a long trip and ready to hit the shower and have more than a carry on with you this is not convenient at all. Same on drop off - if you have luggage that you need to leave somewhere or at least do not want to carry all your luggage with you to the drop off this place is not for you
(2) the place is not as nice as it looks on the photos. The garden is long dried out with an AC box from the unit above dripping on your head as soon as you open the garden door. The place has literally half a window for the entire apartment. Bed and mattress look old and the building itself is old and the interior has not been updated/fixed up since the 70s.
The unit is VERY tiny (even for NYC) I would guess 270 sq ft
Pros: Holly was for the most part a responsive host. The place is quiet and in a good location but it's just an average location for Chelsea.
I gave this place 3 stars because I envisioned a charming, convenient flat and nothing was terribly wrong but it just did not live up to my expectations. (and picking up the keys blocks away is not fun)