I will definitely come back to this house the next time I'm in NY! I have stayed in this room (better: house) for 10 days with a friend.
The room is spacious considering that you can use the entire floor, and even the living room on the first floor.
There is plenty of room in the fridge(s) for your groceries and the possibility to cook your own meal in the kitchen.
The house is close to the subway so you will get anywhere you want in NYC within the hour.
John and T. are very warm and welcoming people that will make the extra effort to make your stay comfortable!