We enjoyed our stay in the East Village. This location was convenient as the metro is nearby, and there are many fantastic food places around (Katz, Supper). This place was very affordable for a stay in Manhattan. The room was cosy and very warm, which was great for our Winter stay! There was also an AC unit in the room in case it got too warm. Note that this is an old building with no elevator so all luggage has to be carried up 3 flights of stairs - pack appropriately for this!
Jennifer was not in town when we visited but her roommate Geoffrey was friendly and welcoming and mostly hung out in his room.
The only issues we encountered with this place were with the bathroom - the door could not be fully closed and locked, and the hot water from the shower was irregular and would turn cold intermittently. Guests should also be warned about the hot metal pipe in the bathroom that is not fully insulated - it is VERY hot and burns if accidentally touched.
Aside from that, this apartment was cosy, warm and an excellent place for our first trip to New York. Highly recommended!