We had a great stay, we property was extremely quiet!
The apartment was in the top floor so getting bags up was a bit of work, but would only be an issue for less mobile guests.
The 2nd bedroom is off the main bedroom which may be a privacy issue for some. The bed in the living area was very uncomfortable so our ten year old slept on the sofa and was perfectly comfortable there.
Easy access into Manhattan and wonderful dining options within walking distance (we really enjoyed Lobo Mexican which is a 5 min walk)
Vicki was a wonderful host and we would definitely stay here again!