We've given this five stars on every criterion. Marc's apartment is second to none for location and unusually spacious for this part of town. He even turned up at our door with a torch when we were caught in a traditional New York blackout. His advice was clear and easy to follow, and we loved that the amenities included the likes of a food processor and teapot in the kitchen. Proximity to several subway lines saw us venturing out to a few of the boroughs for the first time, adding another level to a great trip. We can't wait to come back and are recommending this to all our friends as a first choice when visiting New York.