My husband and I came for a 40th birthday weekend and were not disappointed! Evan & Maria's place is exactly as it appears... cute, well furnished, nicely decorated, clean, and full of thoughtful touches. We found shampoo, a bottle of wine, clean dishes, hand soap, extra blankets, sightseeing brochures, an iron, a hair dryer... the list goes on and on! Key pickup was simple and they always answered our questions quickly through AirBnB. The location is above a restaurant but it is a quiet street and we never heard any noise from below (in fact, we smelled delicious garlic dishes being prepared on more than one night). Their place is within easy walking distance of a couple subway stations, we even walked to Times Square one night (about 15 min walk). Strolling the East River after dark felt safe and quiet, Midtown East is SUCH a nice neighborhood! Evan and Maria's place was a fantastic spot to come home to each night, recharge for a bit, and then hit the town again.
Not only did my husband I love their place, we recommended it to our friends and are planning a return trip. We can't give it higher praise than that! P.S. We highly recommend La Vera Pizza on the corner as well as the burgers at PJ Clarke's a few blocks away!