I booked Shirley's room because it was close to the US Open and it did not disappoint. Walking to the grounds was simple and quick. The kitchen was always clean and I was able to use the fridge to store some food and drinks. The washroom is cleaned daily. The air conditioner in the room was a godsend and trust me, you'll appreciate it after a long day out! You are also very near downtown Flushing, which has amazing food of the asian variety. So many places to eat that I barely scratched the list!
The house is close to LaGuardia airport so you have to be okay with the sounds of planes. The house is rented out to quite a few people when I was there so there will be times when the washroom isn't free and even though there's signage asking guests to remove hair from the drain after a shower, that was not always done. The soap for the sink was used by some guests for showers and there were assorted body hairs on the soap.
The walls are pretty thin so you will hear guests in other rooms if there are arguments. I did bring earplugs so noise was not an issue when I was sleeping.
For the price of the room, there are more pros than cons. I'd definitely stay here again!