I cannot say enough good things about Gordon's place! This is my second time staying with him and I'll definitely be staying here again. First of all, the building's impeccably well maintained. The photos of the apartment are spot on: the rooms are spacious and cozy, sparkling clean with lovely, modern decor. And they're conveniently stocked with amenities like toilet paper, trash bags, towels, etc....I NEVER had any issues with heat/AC, noise, pests, safety -- which is rare for an NYC apartment. And Gordon and his team were always super prompt, professional, accommodating and just lovely to deal with all around.
Add to that, the location's unbeatable. Everything you need's a short walk away: the subway, bus lines, Whole Foods/Trader Joes, Duane Reade, Central Park, gyms, nail/wax/hair salons, and tons of fun bars and restaurants. Added plus: there's a laundromat next door that offers wash-and-fold and a very affordable pickup/delivery service (though Gordon's building also has a convenient laundry room in the basement).
All in all, Gordon's place is fantastic and I highly recommend it -- one of the best Airbnb stays I've had!