Overall for the price, the place was great and hosts were responsive! Super close to the train station (10 - 15 min walk) which was great to get to the city and back. The place was really clean, with the exception of the dishes. We had to wash the mugs and water heater before using them. Otherwise the rest of the place was clean and the rooms were comfortable and had everything you needed including heaters for the winter time. Wouldn’t hesitate coming back here if I ever find myself in NY again.