In may 2015 we stayed with 4 people in John's apartment, and it was a great time. John was very cordial, and told us the 'places to be' in the local area, and gave us good tips for our stay. The apartment was exactly as in the ad was. It was old, and not huge, but big enough for us.The apartment had a fine atmosphere. Ideal with 2 bedrooms. The only downside were the hard beds. East Village is an ideal neighborhood to stay in New York.