We had five people and my 10 month old baby in this space- and I have to say: it worked. This is a small apartment (normal in NYC standards), but very clean and comfortable. The hostess, Nicole, was excellent. She was very available and communicative.
There was an issue with the hot water heater the day we before were set to arrive. She told us right away and gave us options. She offered to refund our money and help us find another place or if we were willing to risk it- she would give us a 50% refund.
We were in town for a wedding, very close to the location of this air bnb so finding a new place further away would have been a MUCH bigger problem than no hot water- so we took the 50 % refund and roughed it out.
Overall we were pleased with this location, the excellent host, the cleanliness and the comfort.