Nikhil was an excellent host - very accommodating. The apartment great and bigger than expected. [This was a pleasant surprise but perhaps Airbnb could make it a requirement that all listings include a rough floor plan to scale as well as the photographs. That would eliminate surprises - pleasant or otherwise.]
The district was perfect - all the good things about NYC were close at hand - and none of the not so good.
I would totally recommend Nikhil's apartment to anyone. If forced to find even the smallest regret I would say the lack of free-to-air or cable TV was a disappointment. When we holiday in a new place watching the local TV gives a real insight into culture and vibe of a city and we missed out on that. But in every other respect the apartment was brilliant.