We just had a 10 days stay at Jillian's apartment, I'm going to be honest about the pros and cons:
Pros:
-Clean
-New
-Spacious main room and bathroom
-Second floor
-Big supermarkets not far
-10 minute walk subway (for NY it's not bad)
-Jillian was in communication at all times, we arrived later than expected so she waited for us.
Cons:
-The kitchen is poorly equipped, the stove and the oven were not functioning, in exchange Jillian gave us a single hot plate but you'll understand that is very complicated to make a complete diner in a single hot plate. We chose this apartment on purpose cause we wanted to cook our food and finally it wasn't possible. Regarding the dinnerware set, there were a few things at our disposal: only two forks, one spoon (she gave us a second one), two water glasses, two plates to eat, one frying pan, etc.. When you stay for 10 days you'll need a little more otherwise you'll have to wash everytime after you eat.
-The WiFi is very bad and slow, I think it is shared with other apartments because the modem was not present. If you want WiFi connection you have to stay on the kitchen, otherwise if you go to the bedroom you'll have a poor connection (or nothing).
-amenities: only one toilet paper (again for a 10 days stay, we had to ask Jillian for a second one), we had the limit basics for the kitchen like coffee or tea, but normally for a long stay, hosts leave water bottles or something for the guests, this time we had nothing.
-The bed is too small for two people (although the mattress is very comfortable).
-The day of our departure We wanted to leave our bags until the evening but it was impossible, she wanted us to come and pick them at 1pm max.
I'll recommend this apartment for a short stay, but if you're planning to stay for a week or longer get sure you'll have everything you need.