Jeremiah's place is nice, but lacks a polished finish. Lack of basics like more than one towel, shampoo, etc made it very difficult to simply stop in for a weekend.
The host did not give an introduction message like most hosts we've had, which is a minor thing but nice when visiting a new area.
There was a smoke detector that constantly went off unless we got a stool and held the mute button every few hours. Extremely annoying.
Finally, there was a brutal lingering smell. We kept the AC on fan mode 24/7 simply to help with the smell, along with buying a can of air freshener.
This would be an amazing AirBnB, but it lacks polish or any indication a lot of effort was put in to making this a great place. With a few tweaks it would be 5/5.