We enjoyed our stay at Caroline very much. The place is sparkly clean and exactly as shown in the picture. The bathroom is quite large and very nicely decorated. We could see trees from our windows, it was like a home away from home. The neighborhood was beautiful (with a lot of trees) and we felt safe even coming back to our place late at night. There are lof restaurants nearby not to mention a subway station. Caroline was very welcoming and helpful. The self-check-in with a PIN was a breeze.
Our overall experience was way better than the last time when we stayed at a hotel in Manhattan. If you want to experience real New York, stay in a house in New York. I would highly recommend Caroline's place.