We had a great stay at Nick's place. The apartment is extremely clean and well presented. We enjoyed exploring the neighbourhood and the cafes and restaurants on Tompkins Avenue. Nick was easy to communicate with and gave very clear instructions for check-in and local tips. We had some problems with the key and Nick was very helpful and quick to respond.
We were in NY for a work trip, and it took us quite a long time to travel into Times Square each morning. Also the noise from the flat above is quite loud - you can hear them moving around and talking.
Otherwise a great apartment in a cool neighbourhood.