The place is fine for a short stay: good location and good value. The hosts were very good with communication. The general feel is more like a hostel than a traditional Airbnb where you stay in a home.
On the negative side, our room didn't have a window except for a skylight that let in light as soon as the sun came up, and cold drafts could be felt. The bathroom is shared among four rooms, and gets quite cold in the winter. If you're sensitive to noises, the sounds from the rest of the guests can be heard pretty clearly from the room, as well as the bell from the nearby school and, more softly, planes from nearby LaGuardia.
All in all, if none of these things bother you too much, it is good value for NYC.