We had a wonderful stay in this palatial (by NYC standards!) and one-of-a-kind apartment above the Soho Playhouse. Everything was as described and was well cared for and comfortable. Indoor/outdoor decor has changed a little since the pictured photos, but the changes are not functional. We didn't make much use of the roof terrace ourselves, but that's definitely a fun little addition too.
As noted in other reviews, the location can't be beat with easy access to restaurants, cafes, stores, and entertainment, as well as convenient access to the subway system if you want to explore the rest of the city. Our favorite restaurant in the neighborhood was Pepe Rosso, which a friend introduced us to. It's a family-owned restaurant with an unassuming character, outdoor dining option, and fabulous Italian food - tell Lorenzo friends of "Bob Saidenberg, The Sheriff of Good Times" sent you.
The building has some really interesting history which makes the stay there even more special - check out the photos outside the apartment and ask Britt! By the way, communication with Britt was excellent, check-in/out was smooth, and we especially appreciated Britt accommodating us to check out a little late and leave our bags in the foyer.
Just a couple heads up items: the kitchen is really quite minimal - we suggested the addition of a microwave to allow heating of takeout food at least. Also, there is no elevator to the apartment. My 88-year-old mother managed the several flights of stairs during our 4-day stay, but I could imagine that being an accessibility challenge for someone.
If you are looking for a unique and real NYC experience, I highly recommend booking this place. And be sure to check out a show or two downstairs while you're there!