A charming and cozy spot to call home for a few days, or even longer. The location may seem a bit off the beaten track, but that's all the more reason to stay here; it's a gorgeous part of town that not too many visitors to New York ever see, and staying in a huge, rambling old home is a novelty in the city. (If apartment living freaks you out a little bit, this is the place for you!) You also have access to both Prospect Park--one of NY's jewels--and Green-wood Cemetery, which itself is worth a morning's wander. And the local subway line gets you into Manhattan with plenty of time to spare.
Check-in and out couldn't be easier. The room is very spacious and comfortable (especially the bed!), with a walk-in closet, and the bathroom is the fanciest I've ever enjoyed in an Airbnb. The other room on the floor was occupied by different people during my five-day stay, but sharing was never an issue; in fact, I never laid eyes on any of my fellow travelers. I did meet Laura in front of the house on my way out one morning, and we gabbed away like old friends.
I certainly hope to stay at Laura's again; in fact, I'm considering bringing the family and taking the whole floor.