Pros: Great spot, conveniently located, very well maintained, very responsive host, as pictured (except not as much natural light as I thought), very clean, private and overall a great experience.
Cons: Very loud kids upstairs, though only in the evening and in the morning, presumably before work/school. Otherwise it was very quiet. Lots of garbage bags outside the door and main window but seemingly unavoidable in NY.
Would strongly recommend but suggest bringing ear plugs.