I lived in the Murray Hill Bedroom with 3 other girls. Given that there was only 1 bedroom, it was a bit of squeeze, but the pictures were accurate.
There were definitely many issues that we did not foresee and that were never resolved. One, wifi only worked for half the apartment and this was never fixed, despite multiple complaints and communications. There was no talk of a refund of price for this either. Second, the stove was broken and our host ended up only giving us a lighter to fix the problem. Also, the host was incredibly rude and cursed my roommates when they asked that these things be fixed. Third, mail couldn't be sent to the apartment. I actually had lost several packages before I realized this. However, I did send some to the host's apartment and he brought them over, which was nice of him. Fourth, the shower was clogged and the water kept switching from incredibly hot to incredibly cold.
All in all, it was a very uncomfortable stay given the number of people living and the oldness/issues with the apartment. It was incredibly hard to communicate with the host, and we had to swallow many of the issues we faced. Given how many experiences I've had with Airbnb, this by far the most unpleasant one. For the price, it was semi-expected especially for an old building. The only positive from all this was that it was in a great location.