I visited NY for a wedding and Tony's apartment was perfect for the occasion and in just the right spot. Tony was very friendly, helpful, and always available in case I needed anything, but my stay went so smoothly that I never did. The place was very clean and comfortable.
The only star I subtracted was for location because the view from the flat is of the train tracks and there's a little noise. To be fair though, the noise was not loud enough to interrupt my sleep and I was told that even the nicest hotels in the area will have some subway vibrations. One of the windows also had a tree between the apartment and the trains and the sound of the wind and sight of the leaves help a lot.
All things considered, the price for the apartment was reasonable, the stay great, and I was happy that I booked with Tony.