Kelly was a great host and very responsive. We stayed on a very cold night in February and she was courteous enough to check in about heat in the apartment and whether we were warm enough (we were!). Overall, the apartment was very cozy and met our needs. Value-wise, I think this is a pretty typical AirBnB situation for New York City. Personally, given the house was removed from the more bustling areas of Brooklyn, the lack of a kitchen, and the fairly average amenities, I might opt to pay the same price and stay at the Hilton next time.