Absolutely loved staying here for our summer in New York. It was such a gorgeous location - so close to the park with lovely restaurants and coffee shops near. It had brilliant amenities - iron, tv, great kitchen and the washer & dryer was a life saver. It was so clean and also Melissa & Eric were always so prompt to respond any time we messaged them for anything.
The only drawback was we could hear the family above us quite a lot, footsteps, running, crying, baby screaming etc. (mostly early in the mornings) but we had read it mentioned by a lot of previous reviews so we already knew what we were agreeing to when we booked, no fault to Melissa or Eric. So if you're a light sleeper maybe just bring ear plugs?