Emily's place was as expected, 3 bedrooms, and convenient in Columbus Circle. We chose it because we were traveling with kids and wanted immediate access to the park.
Pros - location, beds were comfy enough, and generally for a midtown Manhattan apartment we didn't feel cramped.
Cons- if you are visiting in the winter the heating is wacky as ever - the rooms get crazy hot if you keep doors closed and the radiators are the loudest I think I can ever remember.
Overall a decent stay for what we needed.