This place was okay, but watch out – the price AirBnB charges is only a fraction of what they'll charge you. They have a whole section hidden in the "house policies" section with extra taxes & fees, including a mandatory "resort" fee which gets you "free WiFi" and access to the elevator? Apparently this is a thing a lot of hotels are doing lately, but it's shady.
The place was okay – room literally a foot or so bigger than the bed, mostly clean with a few little inconsistencies that as a frequent traveler I can deal with, but someone looking for a nice place might not. A miniscule spot on the otherwise clean sheets, wallpaper in the bathroom beginning to peel in an otherwise clean, bright white bathroom. Not a big deal depending on your expectations.
The staff was very friendly, and it was still a short walk to Penn Station. If it weren't for the shady extra fees I'd stay again.