We stayed in PH1 and it was clean and comfortable. Although smaller than it appeared in the pictures, it had all of the stated amenities. The location is amazing - we walked to the train station, a Broadway show, Central Park, Times Square and more. The one downside that was not covered in the listing description is the noise. We could hear our neighbors (next to and below us) including when they talked at normal volume and could hear their footsteps even. This made for a restless night of sleep because we could hear other guests opening and closing doors, their conversations, and bursts from the extremely loud water and heating pipes into the early AM hours - our sound machine was no match for the racket.