Easy to recommend, close to subways and in a lively neighbourhood.
The Hosts:
We had a few minor challenges, like a late arrival due to flights and a faulty key. In both cases the hosts were very accommodating, reachable and friendly. Which was very reassuring as guests. They are also good sources on things to see, places to eat etc.
The Apartment:
Everything as advertised, the bed was comfortable, it was quiet and safe at night. You will be sharing the small kitchen with an elderly resident - so we found it a little difficult to use the kitchen properly.
Location in NY:
If you don't know NYC, East Village can be a little unsafe after 11 pm, and we had some unpleasant encounters in the area - exercise common sense, and you'll be fine. It's a very lively and charming neighbourhood, with great restaurants, bars and helpful residents.
Would definitely recommend.