My husband I just spent 3 nights at Gary's apartment. It was wonderful! Had everything we needed and more. Much more spacious than we anticipated and clean and comfy! The photos don't do it justice. It's in a great location - convenient to wonderful restaurants, shopping, markets, wine stores, dry cleaners, subway lines, etc. Noise on 7th Avenue didn't bother us at all. Gary was available whenever we had any questions, although we had no problems or concerns. We love NYC and have always stayed at hotels. Now that we have experienced apartment life, we hope Gary's apartment is available during our next visit. I would not hesitate to recommend this great apartment!