Katie's listing was perfect for our stay in NYC. The apartment is well allocated. And everything was as described and as the previous visitors stated in their reviews. (the apartment has very little natural light, but hey - it's Manhattan and we were there not to hang out in the apartment but outside, and the heat pipes make really really strange noise, especially arund 5 am!! One from our group of 4 really couldn't sleep beacause of that- so concider to take some ear plugs if you're sensitiv sleeper. For the rest of us it was not as annoying, eventhough it sounds more like there is someone hidden in the basemant and tries to get attention. Creepy thoughs).
But Katie is very kind and responsive. The shower was great and clean, the kitchen well equipped, wifi worked great for all of us.
In general: I totally recommend and would stay again!