My experience in Erin's house was very pleasant. She was atencious and more than this, gave me the chance to have a early check in. She always tried to reach me asking if I needed something more.
Even with the other room occupied by her room mate, I had total privacy and I almost didn't see him there.
The location is perfect for a couple who like to go out tonight in a very safe neighborhood. However, for people who suffers of light sleep, I recommend to use ear plugs on weekends.
I felt that was the best place to stay in Manhatan because it's in the middle of everything.
The bed is very comfortable and the bathroom was clean.
I would stay again in Erin's appartment.