Gary's place is a cozy place, great stay and private- which is tricky to find in this price range. No sharing of the bathroom :)
Plenty of extras like glasses, coffee cups, fridge, etc- however needs a better place to clean/dry them rather than the bathroom sink down the hall. -- Very minor suggestion compared to how smooth it was staying at Gary's place.
Polite, quiet, safe, close by subway and grub- Perfect for a calm, non-touristy stay in the Big Apple.
Thanks!