Edward's place was exactly as advertised. The room was spacious and clean, the bed was comfortable and the bathroom was clean with a good shower. For a Manhattan 2 bedroom apartment, it's a very decent size. Edward had warned us it may be noisy at night, but we were there on a Monday night so it was actually pretty quiet. Edward and his room mate were polite and helpful, and allowed us to leave our bags in the morning before we checked in, which was much appreciated. Only two minor inconveniences if anything - it's a a six floor hike up the stairs so you'll get pretty fit, and the bathroom was at the far end of the apartment compared to the bedroom. But very minor things!