The apartment is very spacious and clean. It is way bigger than the pictures show. The building the apartment is in even has a roof terrace.
The location is perfect. Lots of bars and restaurants in the neighbourhood and Central Park is in walking distance.
The street the apartment is located on is a bit noisey in the evening because the street leads to queensboro bridge.
Gordon is overall a really nice guy and even organised for a maid to clean our apartment every two weeks.
The reason I'm giving only three stars is that he entered our apartment on several occasions (five times that we know of!) without giving us prior notice. It is the law in tha state of New York that the landlord has to give at least 24 hours prior notice before entering the apartment. And even if it weren't the law - come on its common courtesy to let your guest know you're showing they're apartment to strangers....
Overall the apartment is a good place to stay when you're in New York.