The apartment had some good points and some not so good points. First, the good stuff. Devon was nice and helpful when I needed her to be. The location of the apartment was perfect for my needs. Its on the UWS and close to all public transport and Central Park. The room was large and I was able to keep many things there and still have space to walk around. The not so good points include the fact that there are three flights of pretty steep stairs; one from the street to the main floor, one set down to the apartment main door and another down to the basement room Devon rents. It was OK for me but it should be explained carefully. Its difficult moving luggage in and out of there. The basement room has no windows or proper ventilation and gets very stuffy even in Spring weather. The hosts should think about putting a fan to circulate the air a bit. My biggest complaint about the stay was the fact that the room was pretty dirty. The bed sheets were clean but the floors needed scrubbing. The bathroom was full of someone else's bathroom trash when I moved in and the bathroom was littered with empty plastic bottles of hand soap and lotion, seriously empty bottles. The bathroom rug was pretty filthy. Devon doesn't seem to put much care or energy into being a airbnb host and one gets the feeling that on has slipped into the role of a college roomate, with nasty stuff in the frig and no one who cares to keep the place even slightly cleaned or organized. Its an OK way to live if you're not collecting a nice daily fee as a hostess. I didn't see anyone there most of the time so it was difficult to ask for things like a bar of soap or toilet paper. I just bought my own and it was fine. I did not however feel like I wanted to clean the place up, even though I was seriously tempted to do so. The room could be a nice little rental space if there was just more care put into making it sanitary and a bit more pleasant for guests. They just need to care more. Their own upstairs space was equally unpleasant. You just need to care more when you're collecting money from others for use of the space.