Sheila's place was great, it was super cute and the perfect fit for the two of us. We fell in love with the neighbourhood and really appreciated having a corner store nearby. East Wind snack shop and the The Sicilian were excellent restaurants within walking distance.
The only issue at Sheila's was the upstairs neighbors. While I can appreciate that noise from above is a normal part of apartment living, the stomping and banging from these people was excessive. It went on for hours a day from 5am until after midnight and sounded like they were about to come through the floor, I don't know if they were wearing wooden shoes or what but it was way past a volume that was acceptable. Other reviews speak to this but if I'd realized how bad it was I would have booked elsewhere, we were so happy to get home so we could get some sleep.
Sheila has little control over this issue, but it's definitely worth considering before booking.