tl;dr: Clean, tidy, great host, 5 min walk to A train, shared bath
Had an excellent experience at Sarah's.
Considering it was the most affordable option available at the time I was looking, I feel like I completely hit the jackpot.
The place was super tidy and clean and Sarah was awesome, being great about communication and fun to talk to as well. There really is a peace of mind you get when you feel like the place you're staying at is well-maintained. As a solo, imo low-maintenance traveler, I don't think I could have asked for much more and there was no issue sharing the 1 bath during my stay. If I wanted hotel amenities I could have paid twice or triple the price and got way less value imo.
The 5 min walk to the A train made it super easy to get into Manhattan and downtown Brooklyn/Williamsburg and nearby bus stops made it easy to get to and from Bushwick. I personally felt completely safe walking around even at 3 in the morning and enjoyed the Caribbean charm of Fulton St.
While there is kitchen access, I didn't end up using it, although super appreciated when Sarah shared some of her cooking with me. Being able to use a washer/dryer while I was there was also a lifesaver!
Thanks again Sarah!