9/10. Minor inconvenience after a long travel day showing to late to no toilet paper upon arrival, and sheets were on an air mattress so I had to move them to the real mattress in the loft bed. Easily solved with a cvs right down the street and the host covered the cost without me even asking. Check in was as advertised and host was friendly, responsive, and accommodating. The apartment window does not face a street, which makes for rare quiet evenings in NYC with no car noises etc. Host is looking into a radiator that had a loud squeal sound a few of the nights, however. Great location a few minutes walk to subway lines on the west or to a walk in the park along the east river to the east. Would stay here again!