We chose Tanya's place because we needed three bedrooms, which is understandably hard to find in NYC. Although it's a little further uptown than we ideally wanted, the subway situation is super convenient with an express A/D stop right around the corner and the 1 a few blocks away. Everything was clean and comfortable, and Tanya was a great host. She always responded to messages immediately. A tip for workout enthusiasts: the NY Sports Club on 145th is two blocks away and you can get a free 5-day guest pass if you sign up online!