Overall this was a great place to stay in terms of location. The house felt very clean, and was very close to the Long Island Rail Road train which makes it very easy to travel through New York. Amy was very responsive leading up to the trip and gave us fantastic tips and directions to get to her apartment.
A couple things that I think are good to know: you (as the guest) cannot control the heat. We visited in December/January and the entire house is heated and controlled by the owner at 68F. It felt colder to us than that, and we had to ask for more blankets to stay warm. If you are a person that likes a warm apartment, this might not work out for you.
We also had to email the hosts for toilet paper for the apartment, which we never got a response on and ended up needing to buy toilet paper ourselves. Renee (the co-host) lives above the unit and we were able to get a hold of her when we needed more blankets, but we didn't cross paths again in the evening when we needed toilet paper.
Overall the apartment is a great location and was very clean and comfortable to stay in.