Pros: Great hospitality and communication. He responds right away and is flexible with your stay. Plenty of closet space and the room is spacious. The location is not bad especially since it's right next to Yankee Stadium and plenty of restaurants.
Cons: There were some roaches during my first night. As soon as I told the host, he took care of it right away and I never saw any after that. Ceiling and walls are a bit sketchy, but I rarely looked at them. Could use a coffee maker. There is some noise from neighbors outside, but that is out of the host's control.
Overall: It's 5 stars based on it's value. Host is great and you'll sleep just fine at night.