Marina and Ellie are without doubt really good hosts. I stayed in their apartment from mid-January until the end of May. I really enjoy staying there especially when winter was over since it’s close from the beach and it is really pretty during spring with all the cherry blossoms. The apartment is situated in a really nice and safe neighbourhood of Staten Island. Everything is close: groceries, washer/dryer, parks, public transportation... I only have good comments about my stay and would recommended the apartment. However, the commuting is something to have in mind if you’re planning a long stay like me. I spend three hours everyday commuting to mid-town. But it’s still the most affordable option if you don’t wanna share a tiny apartment in Manhattan and it was quite nice to take the ferry everyday.