My friend and I stayed at Carley and Sebastian's place for 4 nights while we were in NYC doing some job searching. We found it to be perfect for our needs, a great price point and the hosts were friendly and super responsive. The apartment is adorable, cozy and exactly as pictured.
We absolutely loved Cafe Ghia, which was in close walking distance. The L is very close as well and didn't take long to get into the city. The corner shop had an amazing spicy chicken sandwich that was a nice late-night snack. :)
Overall, we'd highly recommend and would definitely stay there again if the chance comes up!