Location is very good if you want easy access to subway or Central park, it is in a quiet and safe neighborhood, with good restaurants and groceries around.
Joel gave us full information, very helpful, and almost everything in the description was real.
If he would have separate storage for guests towels and linens and personal belongings and if it would be cleaner (it was clean, but when you have a cat it is necessary to have a better cleaning) I would give him an 9, but now I can give him only a 7.8