I stayed at Rosalia's apartment with my wife and our 1-year daughter for four days.
The apartment is very beautiful,cozy, and clean. It had absolutely everything that we needed, including a secure parking spot which is rare in NYC.
We were with a baby, and coming back around 8pm, we felt safe walking back from the metro, but maybe we would be less comfortable if came back much later at night.
The apartment is a few minutes walk from metro, which is great.
Overall,we had a great stay and would come back and strongly recommend it.