Comfy Cottage met many of the expectations set by the other reviews. Quiet neighborhood, well stocked fridge and snack station, pillows/towels, stores/food/entertainment nearby. The positive ratings are all well earned.
However, the promised driveway parking was almost never available and neighborhood parking was not ideal. Also, some of the accommodations are very small. The bed and sofa are uncomfortable for two people to share and I cannot overstate how tiny the shower is. It was impossible not to brush up on the walls and curtains while showering, which was a bit unnerving. There was also a very strong smell of mildew in the bathroom. There was no mold or mildew visible, everything was very clean. But it was noticeable.
However, the room met all of our needs and was a comfortable enough space. We couldn't reach the host on check in day but we did see her as we checked out. She was very nice. Despite some of the drawbacks, I would recommend this space for anyone who needs a nice quiet and clean space to stay in the Bronx. There is not much availability for hotels/AirBnbs in the Bronx, so I appreciated having this safe and quiet space and not over-crowding my relative's house.