We had a wonderful stay in Danica's home.
The location was perfect for us as we not intend to be in Manhattan after the long day of walk.
however we came back one night by the subway at 11:30 pm and had no trouble.
Just be aware that at the week-end there are less metro in work and that it can take a bit longer to go in Manhattan;
Danica's was very welcome and kind to us and allowed us to let our luggages for 2 hours more than the checkout hours.
Thanks a lot, it was a wonderful stay for me and my sons.
We'll sure be glad to comme back... if we can :-)