Pluses:
1. Mitsy is a really friendly cat. Great for cat people. Really likes to be petted.
2. Location is right next to two subway stations each about 10 mins walk.
3. Great communication and extremely responsive, as she stays right in the next bedroom.
Cons:
1. Description was not updated to say that toiletries will not be provided. I did not mind as she gave me a soap, but this might be an issue for people with longer term stays
2. Subway noise as other reviewers have noted. As a new yorker myself, I have never stayed close to the subway and after this will never stay close to the line :). Again was not a big issue for me and I used the earbuds provided.
Everything else was as described. I did not interact with the host much as she was pretty busy. Also I am not sure if the bedroom door can be locked from the inside as the cat got in once in the morning lol. Again, I liked the cat, so I did not mind.