Most importantly, I am a light sleeper, and the trip was very restful. There is beautiful light in the larger bedroom during the day. The hosts were communicative and helpful, right down to the small details (two sets of keys, a succint info sheet including neighborhood recommendations, great coffee). I've stayed in many nyc Airbnbs, and this is hands down the best and the one I will choose for future trips. The key handoff is in person, and there is no kitchen (but plenty of plates, mugs, glasses, napkins, and cutlery as well as a microwave and minifridge with small freezer), which some travelers may not prefer (not issues for us).