My husband and I stayed at Eyal and Brendan's apartment for a week in June 2017 and couldn't fault it.
Eyal and Brendan were out of town the weekend that we arrived but they made sure we had everything we needed to check in smoothly and settle in for a comfortable stay. We had been travelling for a week before we arrived so were looking for some home comforts and we weren't disappointed. The apartment is beautifully renovated, spacious and meticulously clean, with lots of fresh towels and a very comfortable bed! Access to the laundry is made very easy too and the guys provide everything you need which is extremely handy if you're there for more than a few days or as part of a longer trip.
As some of the other reviews mention, you do get a bit of noise from the street, but that is to be expected when you have windows overlooking the street and you're only one floor up.
Location is great, only a few blocks from the subway under Madison Square Garden and close to the Highline which is a lovely walk above the streets down to 10th street; and plenty of restaurants around as its close to Hell's Kitchen.
Overall, we had a fantastic stay and would definitely recommend to our friends.