We were 3 to spend 5 nights at Kaitlin's. We really enjoyed our time in NY and her place is close to everything you need (subway, bars, shops..). Our major issue was that we didn't understand how small the place was going to be for 3 people and we didn't sleep very well (2 in a one size bed and one on the couch). But Kaitlin and her husband were nice and welcoming and they make everything to make you feel comfortable !