pros: Very responsive host, early check in, close to Penn Station, lots to do in the immediate area, beds are reasonably comfy, check in is easy as cake
cons: it's over a bar. now it's just a wine bar, so it's not as bad as a lot of bars would be, but there is noise and the bar uses the entry way for their back entrance (for garbage and such). so
Also when it's cold the radiator isn't enough, but if you use the space heater you'll be fine.