As for everything else, context matters for Airbnb reviews too. When I stayed at an Airbnb in New Orleans, I paid a smaller daily amount for a whole house to myself that included a lavish kitchen, a dining table and a bathroom replete with a bathtub. This house in NYC, on the other hand, came with none of those luxuries while being shared by multiple guests, so I was a bit shocked at the outset (this being my very first trip to the city).
However, since context matters and we're talking of NYC, I would rate this as a pretty good place to stay for a short duration. Carlos wasn't available at the time, so a friend of his - who was very courteous - helped me enter the house and answered my queries.
I do hope that the rather complicated door locking mechanism is replaced by a keypad, which is increasingly the norm in Airbnb listings now (and there's a long history behind it for those who care to find out).