My cousin and I stayed at Mel & Luis' place for a girls trip to NYC, and we had a great time! The place was spacious, clean, and felt safe, which were all important to us. Mel & Luis allowed us to leave our bags there when we arrived, giving us extra time to explore. They were both really friendly and willing to help.
The only downside of this place is that it took a little while to get into Manhattan. From the apartment to Washington Square Park was about 45 minutes by subway. We made use of the time with planning our days which made up for it.
I would recommend this apartment for a second trip to the city or if you are specifically interested in what Brooklyn has to offer!
P.S. Cup of Brooklyn is a nearby coffee shop that has AMAZING cold brew!