If ever staying on Staten Island, look no further than Magnolia House. The hosts, Danforth and Darwin, are two of the most charming, interesting, and downright nice people I've had the pleasure of meeting. As an added bonus, Darwin's firsthand knowledge of old Hollywood makes for conversation that is impossible to forget.
My girlfriend and I spent two nights to celebrate our anniversary with a staycation. The floor rented to us was decorated with a fascinating and eclectic collection of items from around the world - it truly feels like staying in a private museum. Danforth kindly prepared the fireplace for us so we could relax in the evenings next to a cozy roaring fire. Darwin cooked us an amazing breakfast each morning. Both hosts were amazingly attentive.
I cannot recommend this place enough. It's an experience you won't soon forget.