I enjoyed staying in Jeff and Anna's lovely space! I didn't get to meet them, but the care they put into thinking through the many little things someone might want or need were very obvious! It is a welcoming space filled with beautiful and delightful details - high quality towels and linens, comfortable stylish furniture, a great washer/dryer, a big screen TV with Fios, stove/microwave/toaster oven/fridge (all clean and high quality), some cooking ingredients (olive oil, salt, canned tomatoes), high quality coffee. I found the bus and the SIR very convenient at any hour of the day or night. Nice restaurants nearby. Relatively close to beach, Alice Austin house. Snug Cove and Great Kill accessible on public transportation.
I would happily return or recommend to anyone.
One note about biking. I tried biking around in Staten Island with mixed results. Decent bike lanes to get to South Beach, but not to go all the way to Great Kill Park (which was by far by favorite place). For that, I would recommend taking the bike (for free) on the SIR to Bay Terrace station and then a short bit down Buffalo to the entrance of the park.