We definitely enjoyed our stay at Judith's apartment. It looks as good or even better than the pictures, it feels like home and there is a lot of space. The bathroom was also very nice and pristine clean and so was the kitchen.
We had plenty of towels and bedding available and we didn't miss anything we could have needed, it is well equipped.
The area is calm and we felt safe; the trip to downtown Manhattan is 30-40 minutes door to door (depending where you go, obviously) and a cab during the night is quite reasonable if you're too tired to take the train at night.
Last but not least, Judith was lovely and very efficient whenever we needed anything.
As a whole, you get the feeling of a home away from home.