This was our second time staying at the cottage and really enjoyed having this small private place to ourselves after 5 days in busy Manhattan. The first night here it rained steadily all night and we loved going to sleep to the sound of rain on the roof. The small space and simple decoration gives this place a great vibe. This is a perfect space for 1-2 people just to be in Brooklyn.
The closest subway stop is around 15 minutes away (this isn't a big deal unless it's raining/snowing sideways due to wind). If your entry into the city is from Grand Central, this is very easy to get to with one subway ride and a little bit of walking!
The neighborhood is quiet and there are great restaurants nearby. I highly suggest walking up to Greenlight Bookstore then taking your newest book over to Annex to read with your beverage of choice. We didn't get a chance to hang out in the park this visit but it's very close.
Sarah & Allon are easy to communicate with and give you your space, which is impressive considering this cottage is pretty much in their back yard.