I stayed at Gary’s place for 3 weeks and had a great stay! The apt is spacious for 2 people and had almost everything we needed (towels, pots+pans, umbrellas, etc). It was quiet and mostly free of street noise. Having central park and many subway stations nearby was a plus. Gary was very responsive to messages and the check in process was easy despite my plans changing last minute.
The only issues we had were that 1) the walls are a bit thin so can hear neighbors if they are talking loudly 2) you cannot adjust the temperature in the apt so it was a bit too warm at times and 3) you need your own laundry detergent to do laundry in the shared laundry room.
Overall we had a great stay at the apt