You can't ask for a better location right between Soho and the Lower East Side, walking distance to all the wonderful restaurants not only in the area but also Chinatown, and convenient to The Cooper Union. If you don't mind climbing a ladder, the rooftop is magical. We spent two evenings up there, sipping wine and enjoying the breeze. The beds were comfortable and the bathroom was well stocked with amenities. There was even chilled beer in the fridge.
This is an older eclectic place so don't expect perfectly straight floors or the polished perfection of a hotel. This is a home with character and we thoroughly enjoyed staying in real New York. As there was no air conditioning, I probably wouldn't risk booking during the summer again (weather in New York can get quite hot) but at any other time of the year, I wouldn't want to stay anywhere else. Loved it and our host, Fatima. She is delightful, witty and warm.