I've given Jeff's apartment 5 stars out of 5 because it suited us perfectly, but I'm sure he would agree that it wouldn't be ideal for absolutely everyone.
First the bits that are 5 star in anyone's book...
You won't find a better location - the apartment is right in the heart of Manhattan
Nor will you find a better host - Jeff is very friendly; he made tea, answered all of our questions patiently, and was happy to offer (or research) suggestions and alternatives to make sure that we got the most from our stay. He is also happy to blend into the background.
The apartment is very clean, free WiFi is provided, as is use of cupboard space, fridge and cooker.
There are a couple of things that wouldn't suit every visitor...
This is one of the deals where the host stays in the same apartment as the guest. You get your own private bedroom, and share bathroom and living room with the host. As I mentioned earlier, Jeff becomes as visible or invisible as you want him to be - but I know that some people demand a completely private deal.
The bed is comfortable and large, but the bedroom isn't huge. Bear in mind that you're in a prime location within the West Village, where space costs money!
In summary, we booked with high expectations and we got what we expected. We would certainly go back to 235 West 4th St, Apt 2F. Thanks again Jeff.