Theresa's place was very clean and spacious. We were 4 and we had more than enough room. The beds/furniture in general were very comfortable and of good quality. The kitchen was great, and it was very convenient to have a dishwasher, washing machine, and dryer in the apartment. Although the apartment is far from central/downtown New York, we did not experience any issues with commuting since it is quite close to several express lines.
However, we had issues with the wifi, air conditioning, and getting in touch with Theresa. These were quite essential for us since we were only in New York for four days, and wanted to have a seamless stay. We did not expect these issues since the apartment is quite pricey given that it's quite far from central NY.
Wifi: We were counting on the wifi to plan our itinerary for each day; however the wifi did not work for more than half our stay there. Although we notified Theresa on our first day, she did not live onsite and it didn't seem like she lived nearby. As a result, it was tough to get a quick resolution because we would message/call in the evening when we were back at the Airbnb but she would only respond in the morning when we had left for the day. This greatly inconvenienced us, and even delayed us on our third day since I had to spend time on the phone troubleshooting with the cable company.
Air conditioning: The air conditioning was also an issue since the AC units in the house (1 in each room) were very old, very noisy, and not very effective. If you are a light sleeper you will probably have a problem since the fan in each AC unit is very noisy. Also, the AC units were not effective at cooling, which was quite uncomfortable especially since we we were visiting in the summer and it does get quite muggy in the city.
The bottom line: Although we liked the apartment and found it very clean/spacious, for the price we paid we were very unhappy that we encountered these issues with her stay.