First time in NYC and first time booking an AirB&B so not able to compare. But both went very well!! Eric was a great host. He was there to greet us when we arrived. He gave us a nice orientation and recommendations. The place had everything we needed and easy access to all of our destinations using the subway and Uber. He has a few repairs he is working on (damage from a leak and uncovered electrical outlets) but nothing that interfered with our stay. The kitchen had the basics. We didn’t cook much as we were on the go. He could add some kitchen towels for doing dishes and hot pads for lifting pans off the stove. We bought a roll of paper towels and made due. He may have provided those as he said to let him know if we needed anything, but we didn’t bother asking. Due to the time of year, the deck was a bit overgrown so we didn’t feel comfortable sitting out there. The furnishings were adequate and the newly remodeled bathroom was very nice and clean. I would stay here again or recommend to a friend! Thanks Eric