This was our second time at Todd's place and our first time repeating an airbnb. His place is in a great location - near multiple subway lines and bus routes (near = 10 minutes or less), central park, and a ton of restaurants and bars. You're also close to quite a few museums.
Lie all NYC apartments, its not big, but it does have a nice kitchen, roomy bathroom, and enough space to keep your things. It's a first floor apartment, which is excellent, but it also means your closer to the street, which might create a bit more noise than if you were a few floors up. That said, it isn't a particularly loud neighborhood and ear plugs will drown it all out. Wall mounted A/C keeps the place cool.
Last time we stayed at Todd's, I had a couple of minor complaints, but actually only remember 1. I had mentioned the towels felt really flimsy - like drying with thin sandpaper. However, it wasn't a big deal at the time and it looks like he got new towels because that wasn't an issue this time.
We really enjoy staying at Todd's place. It's reasonably priced, in a great location, and he is a very accommodating and gracious host. We wouldn't hesitate to stay here again if the opportunity arises.