We love cats and when we found there was a Catlandia in Brooklyn we decided at once to stay there during our trip to NYC! And the 4 cats are simply adorable, even when they wake you up at 4am! :)))
The room is nice, big, the bed is comfortable and there's much room for everything.
The check-in was fine, we didn't meet the hosts when we arrived but we were in touch by phone and everything was easy (apart that we forgot the keys out of the door, SORRY again!). We met Daniella and Eli the following morning before they left, so we had the whole flat for the 2 of us for the rest of our stay: no privacy problems, just us and the cats! :)
The position of the house is perfect just in front of the subway station. It only takes some time (30/40 mins) to get to Manhattan, but that's acceptable.
Unfortunately, I'm very sorry to write it, we found the apartment, out of our room, quite messy and dirty and also breakfast should have been included, but there were just some teabags. Reading other very positive reviews I think maybe we were just a bit unlucky, I'm sure Daniella and Eli will improve it.
Overall our stay at Catlandia was fine, expecially for the cats! :)