Perfect for a weekend trip of catching broadway shows and late night comedy in Chelsea / Greenwich Village with my wife. I'm so glad we stayed in East Village and not the Time's Square area. Loads of good food options.
It has everything you need to have a home base in the East Village. From here you can get anywhere else in the city fairly easily, lots within walking distance.
It was very clean, which is always my main concern in air bnb stays. Only things you should consider is that the bed is firm, but a lot of people like that. I would also bring earplugs. This apartment isn't any louder than anything else in East Village, but if you're not used to street noise, you'll probably want earplugs. If you plan on sleeping past sunrise and you're sensitive to daylight, bring an eye mask. The curtains don't block the morning sun.
We would absolutely stay here again. Jack was one of our favorite hosts of all time and took extremely good care of us.