Barry was very responsive and helpful upfront the visit. If you are visiting New York there is indeed no need to stay in Manhatten as the metro connection from Barry's place to NY city is quite convenient.
I must admit that this appartement / rooftop had the best view on a city I have ever enjoyed during an airbnb stay! Better than any hotel!
The room & ensuite bathroom were very spacious for a NY flat and Barry's flat mates very friendly although it is unlikely you will meet them after a long day of sightseeing.
The location is safe and the description of the appartement matches with reality.
If you have a chance to stay here, go for it!