Neil & Katie's place was great, within short walking distance of shops, restaurants, and theaters. The 1 train is steps away, and W 4th station a short walk off. This is the first NYC apartment we've stayed in, so can't really compare to others. The beds were comfortable, WiFi worked well. Katie was very easy to communicate with, answered our many questions immediately. A/C had not been set up in the bedrooms yet for spring, but our hosts immediately responded and had someone come within hours and fix it so we were cool by bedtime. It was great to be able to go up on the roof and see the city view! We were there on weeknights, and did need earplugs to sleep with the music audible from the club behind. We knew beforehand this might be the case and were prepared. Overall this was a great apartment to be able to see all that we wanted for a 2-day stay!