My husband and I LOVED staying at John's place. He was incredibly accommodating, such a gracious host. We were even invited to join the dinner party he was hosting when we arrived. We had other plans, unfortunately, but that was a nice touch, something you wouldn't get at a hotel.

The apartment is just gorgeous. Very clean, inviting, cozy. You cannot beat the location, either. The neighborhood is top-notch. Easily accessible to other neighborhoods, not that you would need to leave the West Village. The food, the shops, it's all there. I was constantly saying to my husband, "I feel like we're walking around on a movie set."

We cannot recommend booking John's place if you have the chance. We felt like we got a very authentic New York experience, one we couldn't have had in a hotel, coming and going to a gorgeous West Village apartment. We certainly couldn't have stayed in a West Village hotel, not given the prices. Would have had to book at less desirable location.

Some people might hesitate to do Airbnb, perhaps for apartments that you have to share. We never felt crowded or as though it was an awkward arrangement. John was very easy to share with. And, if you price compare on Airbnb for this location, you will find John is incredibly reasonable.

We would love to come back!