I stayed for just 1 night as I had some meetings in the city and needed a quiet place to crash before heading home the next day.
Pros:
Nice and quiet, Lots of light, high ceilings, good location, close to subway, safe neighborhood. Alexandra was very communicative and so great that she lives in the building. That kind of personal touch is refreshing in NYC.
Cons:
The place has really good bones, but the details are lacking. It all felt like it was furnished by Goodwill. The furniture and decor is a bit tacky. The kitchen was not very well equipped, only 2 mismatched mugs, one glass, few dishes. I didn't need the kitchen much, but just wanted folks to be aware in case they were counting on cooking. The hot water in the shower took about 10 minutes to get warm enough to shower.
I'd say for NYC Airbnb standards it's a decent place. I think it could be a great place with a few little tweaks here and there.