Our party of 3 adults stayed for 6 nights - Gabriella's place was exactly as described with a very comfortable living room for hanging out.
The galley kitchen is small and not set up for major cooking, but that was fine with us. The beds were comfy and everything worked as expected. The front bedroom on 2nd Ave is more noisy but the white noise machine helped a lot - the back bedroom was dark and quiet.
Also the stairs are a bit narrow so anyone with mobility issues might have a challenge. The location itself is not the most scenic BUT the proximity to the subway (many lines!) and walking distance to great neighborhoods (8 min walk to Dominique Ansel Bakery!) more than made up for that.
Overall, highly recommend!