So, I suppose I'll start this out with listing all the things I encountered during our stay.
They do not put it very clearly that there are lots of stairs to go up. They are also very small and narrow stairs at that. Sometimes even four floors of it (though we got lucky on this front, others did not.)
In our room, specifically, our bed was touching the radiator, which came on whenever it pleased and we had no way of controlling it or the heat it put out (it got VERY HOT when it was on), the curtains also touched this radiator. There was barely half a foot on either side of the bed to get into it, and a pipe that would get extremely hot right next to one of the small bed side tables. Making this table unusable while the radiator and pipe were hot, as anything on the table was at risk of sliding into this hot pipe. There's an opening in the headboard where pillows fall down, to land next to the very hot radiator.
There's also outlets near this radiator incase you wish to melt some electronics.
Could not see the TV from our bed, as it was mounted against one of the side walls and between two tall pieces of furniture (which were not built properly and the drawer of the wardrobe prevented you from opening it fully).
The only mirrors was the one in the bathroom and a giant one put at head-height for decoration only that was near the bed. Almost konked my head on it a few times.
The wifi is very slow and for the first two days, and other small spots between our stay, it didn't even work.
Our window was extremely drafty, which proved an extra problem when trying to move the fire-daring curtains off of the hell-blazing radiator. It was also lined with tape in some way of attempting to keep the cold out.
There is no staff outside of cleaning staff around, expect to be on your own with anything you need unless you want to try and email someone.
This also allowed a bunch of women to run up and down the stairs, screaming and laughing, and banging on everyone's doors, for at least an hour or two. During their supposed "quiet hours".
Beware the comments about it being near a club. We may have lucked out and were on the opposite side, but many have complained about the noise.
The door locks for the room have no back-lighting so you have to press a button in order to see the buttons you are pressing, which makes it very difficult.
On our last day, the pipes were rattling loudly and we heard a huge family of mice in our walls! Never saw them or knew they were there otherwise.
Don't trust the tap water.
Some pros? The shower was amazing. Water pressure was perfect and it could get as hot as the radiator in the other room. Beautiful floors that have non-slip grooves on them and glass rolling doors. None of it is disability friendly though, but it was a beautiful shower nonetheless.
There was a ceiling fan, which was a blessing, especially when the radiator came on, even if it didn't get rid of all the heat.
There was another heater too, which confuses one if the radiator was not in our control, but we could control this one for when the radiator was not on, which helped if the ceiling fan dissipated too much heat or the window sucked it all out.
Mini-fridge worked well, as long as you didn't have anything frozen as the freezer part was mostly ice. Coffee pot also worked, though we did not use their coffee and instead picked up some good coffee and filters and made our own.
It does have a great location! It was easy to get food delivered and easy to find our way around New York from that area. It was worth the price for the shower and the location, though we did book almost a year in advance and got the rooms even cheaper than their listings now (about $80 a night) but next time I'll know to indulge a bit more cost into the hotel.
All in all, it was a very New York experience.