This was the best possible first experience with Air BnB. We hardly saw Shelley, but she made sure we were doing well and was only a text away. The place is very clean and comfortable, although a little chilly at night; but that's because it was spring and rainy. Bed was comfortable. The kitchen had everything we needed when we cooked dinner one night. Bathroom is clean. Loved the quirky decor. We're glad we ended up staying in Brooklyn even though the commute to Manhattan is around 35 minutes by train. Neighborhood was safe and drug and grocery stores are walkable distances. Would love to stay with her again in the future.