Pros: The house is spacious and comfortable - it has a separate dining and living room apart from the bedroom. It has all the amenities that you may need. The location is also excellent - right in the middle of Hell's Kitchen and close to several bars/restaurants and other areas such as Times Square, Broadway, Central Park.
Cons: We had two main issues during our stay - (1) there was a mouse problem in the house which the owner informed us of only during check-in. He told us we should not leave any food outside - and we made sure to keep any food in the fridge and left nothing outside. Yet the mouse entered our bags and suitcases, chewed on things like the cigars we bought and spread it inside the suitcase. We could see and hear the mouse all the time. It was generally stressful and unhygienic to live with a mouse in the Airbnb. I think the owner should inform guests of this issue before they make the payment. (2) There is a noise issue - the house is right above two bars and since it is on the second floor, you can hear people loudly talking and screaming till 4 am. We couldn't sleep without earplugs.
But overall, we enjoyed our stay.