For my first Airbnb experience, Shelby and Julian were the perfect hosts! They were friendly and extremely helpful. The apartment was cozy, clean, and great for a short stay in NY. I appreciated the welcome information they provided which listed how to navigate the train system, local restaurants/bars, WiFi info, and anything else important to know. The apartment is located in a quiet neighborhood and the train ride into the city was simple and only about 15min. We only took the train during our stay, which is great for people on a budget! They allowed full access to the apartment and really made us feel as though we lived there! Overall great experience!