For future guests: even though there is (at the time of writing) a nice photo of a fully stocked kitchen, you are not allowed to cook there. I didn't realize that when I booked. It is in the description, but pretty buried (or wasn't obvious to me). Also, no meat allowed in the apartment.
The subway/train is above ground and runs right next to the apartment, all night. I live in a city with loud trains, but I barely slept while visiting, even with a white noise machine on my phone and ear plugs.
The fridge was full of food, including spoiled milk and some old smelly things.
There is also only one key, which was an issue for me and my wife. This is advertised as a 3 bedroom, so beware if you travel in large numbers.
Hannah was nice and helpful. Maybe it's just because right now other places are cheap in NYC, but the price was not worth the stay.