The place and the surrounding was high above all our expectations. We spent 5 nights in Trey's home but spending some weeks would have been better :)
The flat itself is very cute, equipped with everything you need, the room is spacious enough and the hosts are friendly and helpful. We didn't meet much but they were always available in need and helped in everything they could.
And the rooftop... it is just AMAZING! You can see the floodlit Manhattan at night and and having breakfast when the sun comes up over NY is priceless. I miss it already!
The neighbourhood is safe, diverse, colorful with many nice pubs and with lots of deli. Public transport is easy and quick on the weekdays and easy but a bit slower during the weekends ( a metro reconstruction just started on the M line during our stay but we could still use the J line which is also in a comfortable walk from the flat). You can reach the closest edge of Manhattan in 20 minutes.
There are many local buses as well so travelling in Brooklyn (Williamsburg, DUMBO, Prospect Park etc.) was more than easy, too. And I could continue why Trey's place was the best choice. It was for sure :)