My family and I stayed in Tom's basement apartment for a weekend for my sister's birthday. We enjoyed the location, as it was easy to find food/coffee within the neighborhood and close to Subway stations.
The only unpleasant thing about Tom's place is that it can get really cold in the apartment. There's a heater between both beds, but it only warms that section of the apartment. So, bring cozy items that you can wear when you're inside.
However, Tom was super cool and easy to communicate with. I would recommend this place for a quick weekend in New York.