Carlos' stay was just as described and pictured on the listing. Carlos provided a lot of necessities that a traveler would expect at a hotel (toothpaste, shampoo, body wash, etc.). Carlos also makes sure you're acquainted, gives you a tour, and answers any questions you might have of the area.
You'll probably expect some noise at night from the city but the housemates are very quiet and calm. The temperature control of the shower was tricky and felt like it had a mind of its own and the pillow sheets looked looked a bit worn and discolored (but clean)
Other than that, I would recommend Carlos' place. Close enough to the subway and really close to the bus stop that takes you to and from LGA airport