I recently stayed at May and Sofias place this past weekend. Overall it was not bad but it was not great either. Since we had a large party we had access to the basement. The basement was really not ideal. It had a terrible smell from garbage that was down there and also a really bad musty smell. It was super dry and there was a humidifier but it made it really hot. I had two guests with me who have bad asthma and had to sleep elsewhere. Overall the top floor was fine, a little more spacious then I imagined so that was nice. Location was good, easy to get to and easy to check in. Its an easy drive into Manhattan took about 25 mins. Street parking was nearly impossible but to be expected. I could not find the garage that was supposed to be close by for $18 dollars a night but we parked 3 blocks away in a garage and it was fine. What we paid per person made it worth it because we were in New York. If you don't have access to the basement and don't mind being outside of the hustle and bustle of Manhattan its a good option.