Ann's place is ideally located for anyone who wants to enjoy the West Village and its nearby neighborhoods. Subway stops to the rest of the city are practically a stones throw away.
She is a conscientious host, and her place is large by NYC standards. She is also very communicative and clear in her instruction. However, there are a few things to keep in mind.
- It's the West Village. If you're sensitive to noise, you should stay in a different part of the city. It's exactly what we were looking for as many of our favorite NYC restaurants are in the area, but it might be a consideration for you.
- Stairs. Ann's place is five stories. Get used to walking up and down, a lot.
- Cats. You have to take care of them. They're friendly, but like all pets, occasionally demanding when you wish they weren't. If you like cats, great. If you don't, maybe pick somewhere else. If you're indifferent, just remember you'll need to factor in their care when you're planning your days.
- Building Age. The building has to be more than 100 years old, so there are a number of idiosyncrasies, little leaks, and rules for proper care.
We had a minor plumbing issue with the shower while we were there. To Ann's credit, she helped us take care of it immediately. The plumber showed up within a few minutes and addressed the problem, which did not recur. But, again, you should be aware that this will not be like staying at a Hilton.
We had a great time in NYC, and you simply can't beat her location, which positively contributed to that. Ann is incredibly responsive and as long as you have the right expectations, you'll have a great time too.