First and foremost: Simon is an excellent host. Problems (and there were very few!) were sorted within 24 hours - most times sooner. He is pleasant and thoughtful, and he really makes you feel welcome. He is a very useful resource on the city and is always happy to offer suggestions on where to eat / what to do.
I was in the apartment for 2 months so I feel I got a really good idea of the place. The apartment, while a studio, has the feeling of a much bigger space. Because the bed is situated in its own alcove, you don’t get the feeling that you are watching TV in the bedroom - none of that “hotel” feeling here!
All of the furniture, especially the bed, is comfortable and new. The kitchen has been newly renovated and, while small, can accommodate most cooks. The bathroom is a good size and the water pressure (especially in the shower) is top-notch. All in all, this is a very comfortable place to stay.
The area can’t be beat. Within minutes you are at Lincoln Center or Times Square. There are restaurants aplenty in the area, as well as several grocery stores. The apartment is a block or two away from most major subway lines.
The only setback for me was noise: one of the elderly neighbours is a bit hard of hearing so you can, on most nights, hear her TV in the bedroom. This isn’t Simon’s fault, of course, but I felt I had to mention it. I didn’t lose a night’s sleep because of it but a light sleeper might.
I would probably stay here again if I were in New York for an extended period of time. It felt like being at home, and what more can one ask for?