We stayed at Gilbert’s place while visiting NYC. The location is amazing and the flat had a great typical New York vibe. Our room was clean and well equipped too.
The communication was smooth too and Gilbert was accommodating, allowing us to check-in earlier than planned.
The only suggestion would be regarding cleanliness in the commonly shared areas - these spaces could have been a bit more tidy.
Overall, we enjoyed the stay a lot and would recommend it to others!