We've had a very pleasant stay at Geralds apartment. It is more than big enough for a two person city trip and features everything you need. The house was pretty quiet, located at 5th Ave, with Central Park directly across the street. Metrostations are a few blocks away. The apartment itself was comfortable and clean. Even though we didn't meet in person, communication with Gerald was easy and friendly and he replied quickly to all questions.
All in all we had a great time at Geralds apartment and would sure book it again for our next visit in NYC.