I chose this apartment primarily because of it's proximity to a popular subway line, but it offered so much more that I didn't expect to like as much as I did!
The room was bright and airy, with big windows I could open to let the cool breezes through.
The small kitchenette was just the right size to prepare small things, although I have no doubt a better cook would be able to whip up a lovely meal even with the smaller appliances.
I've stayed at more than 40 Airbnb locations and the bed always seems to be the biggest factor that can make/break a visit. I'm happy to report that Marylyn's apartment features a lovely bed with just the right mix of firmness so there is no sag and soft, fluffy pillow top to make you want to linger past your alarm.
The shared bathroom was also a concern, but I never once saw the person I was sharing it with, even though I know someone was staying in the other room. It should be noted that only two apartments shared this bath, which made it easy to negotiate another group's schedule.
The only real issue I had was with the Internet connection. It was slow, almost non-existent, at some points of the day, which made my two hours of computer work each day take about three. Since I work while I travel, this was especially annoying, but Marylyn was kind enough to make a few phone calls and the service improved slightly during my trip.
Otherwise, this was the perfect location. The small local groceries were nice for last-minute items, the subway station (A,C trains) was super-easy to access quickly, and the second floor location meant it felt safe and still open.