This place is HUGE for NYC. You get a living room, a large bed, and a huge, well-equipped kitchen. There is even a full-sized tub in the bathroom! The appliances are all new and easy to use. Jonathan was super helpful and was flexible with check in. We didn't have the pleasure of meeting the hosts, but the apartment was very private and quiet.
Pros: LOTS of space. It feels like an actual home. Bathtub is great for soaking tired feet if you've been exploring all day. Large kitchen with a full sized fridge and all the pots and pans etc. you need for cooking. Very close to the C train. Plenty of tasty restaurants within a 10-15 minute walk. Flexible and easy check in and check out.
(Very few) Cons: BE CAREFUL of the gate, it is very easy to have your hand caught. You cannot access the garden out back. The neighborhood is a little rough at night, but it seems to be improving.