This apartment was nice but did not really appeal to my taste. Of course, it's just my opinion, and other people may have different opinions. Here are the pros and cons of this apartment:

Pros-
-Decoration was taseful and well-chosen.
-The bed was comfortable and my family slept very well.
-The internet was pretty fast.
-And Edwin (we didn't get to meet Charlie) was beyond nice and made us feel very welcome, and when we didn't have enough towels in the bathroom he gladly gave us some more. Thank you, Edwin!

Cons-
-We didn't really notice this in the picture but the apartment is very small, and we felt a little cramped. So if you have a bigger family and need more room this is not the apartment for you.
-The building is old, and you could hear everything from outside. There were some people who lived above us, and they put on some music, and you could hear it and it was rather loud.
-In the kitchen sink, and the bathroom sink, when you turn on the water, the water is constantly changing from very hot to cold, and again and again... But there was no problem with the shower, thank goodness.
-And the apartment is somewhat dusty. We had to wear slippers that we brought from home the whole time.

Other than that, it was a nice place. We had a good stay in New York City. Thank you, Edwin!

-Jack from Chicago.