We really enjoyed staying at Sarah's place -though we just met her husband Jason and not Sarah herself. He was very helpful, even let us borrow a ground blanket for use at Brooklyn Bridge park.
Location was good, grocery store and restaurants not far. We felt safe in the neighborhood, took a 2 mile walk to Brooklyn Bridge park in the afternoon. Subway stop not too far away which we used in addition to Uber.
Really nice outdoor patio which we enjoyed a few times in the beautiful fall weather. Internet worked well although we did not attempt to watch any videos to test speed.
Very quiet and peaceful. Located on third floor so be prepared for a couple flights of stairs but should not be a problem for most people.
Comfortable furniture - no problems sleeping.
Definitely beats staying in a hotel! Would definitely recommend.