I had an outstanding stay.
The appartment is great. it is very quiet for NYC and located in a super safe neighbourhood (and NYC is a very safe city anyway).
Theodora was an amazing host - very friendly and helpful. She replied very quickly to emails.
The location is unbeatable. Amazing variety of restaurants and bars within a 10 min walk. 10 Min Metro-ride to all the big Tourist-attractions in the city. 2 metro-stops to the bars and clubs at Meatpacking district, if you are into that.
I would (and probably will) stay at this appartment again.