Positives:
There is no flat better located than this one; the subway is right there, and you can walk to all sorts of great places like Central Park.
The rooftop dining space is beautiful and is definitely unique.
New York apartments are tiny, so it's more like booking a hotel room than an apartment but that's absolutely fine.
The shower is also really good.
On the negatives:
Hilary was 45min late to drop the keys off - this was deeply annoying, particularly as she didn't let us know and didn't respond to our calls or texts asking where she was or even apologise when she got there. Also it was raining heavily.
The corridor carpet needs a wash (bedroom has wooden floors)
Big one is there's no air-con and the fan won't cool you so be aware you'll get super hot if it's hot or humid.