Karilyn's place has been great for us! We were staying here with 2 people and we had plenty of space, a nice kitchen and everything was clean and tidy. There was some snacks at the ready as well for us after a long trip which was a delight!
Location is amazing for seeing and exploring New York with a (free) train to the ferry right next to the place. (No sound coming from the trains that we heard from inside the house).
All in all a great stay! Definitely recommended!