We stayed at Jerry's place from Nov 20-27. Here are the Pros and Cons.
CONS (Everyone seems to start with Pros, so I'll do it differently.)
1. The bedrooms are fine for 1 person, but get tight with 2+.
2. The floor in one of the bedrooms slants toward the door. So luggage will roll.
3. To get to our apt on the 3rd floor you must go up 2 long, steep, narrow staircases from the ground floor.
4. The hot water fluctuates between warm and hot during a shower.
5. Because of the way the apt was renovated, the kitchen and 2 of the bedrooms are elevated about 5 inches higher than the rest of the apt. So you need to watch where you walk.
PROS
1. The kitchen is adequate (but small).
2. Full-size frig.
3. There are plates, cups, flatware, pots, pans.
4. The TV offers an fine selection for viewing.
(Although I don't know why one comes to NYC to watch TV.)
5. The living room is large enough for everyone to gather and relax.
6. There are 3 subway lines reasonably close (G, 7 and E lines)
7. The digital door locks means no worrying about keys.
8. The neighborhood seemed safe, day and night.
9. Jerry was very responsive to issues.
10. There's a nearby Trader Joes to get groceries.
11. The Court Square Diner just around the corner from TJ's is open 24/7.
OVERALL
If you need a place with 4 bedrooms in a safe neighborhood with convenient subway access, this is a good choice.