I have used Airbnb for many years now, and I can say Gaetano's place is one of the best so far! The apartment is conveniently located and despite the fact that is in Hell's Kitchen (very noisy area), the room is very quite!!
I really enjoyed my stay as Gaetano and Suzanne are very easy going people and they offer great hospitality! You feel at home as soon as you arrive.
The rooms is spacious and well equipped! I couldn't ask for more. Looking forward to go back soon!
Also, the place is clean and has a cozy feeling :) very warm even if when it's -5 outside!