I had a great experience at Carol's place. Much better than expected. This was my first time doing the room and shared bathroom thing, but I felt extremely comfortable in her home. The house has good energy and is very clean. My room was small, but I loved it. The neighborhood seems pretty safe, but I did rent a car so didn't have much experience walking around, but it was central to just about anywhere I needed to go, that's why I specifically booked in the Bronx. I would definitely stay here again next time I visit NY. As long as you have simple common courtesy, you will enjoy your stay at Carol's house.