Mustafa's place is quaint, eclectic, in a great location, and very well kept. Though he originally told me that I would have to wait to check in at 3pm, when I arrived he was able to accommodate me much sooner. He made sure I had everything I needed, stocked the fridge with some groceries, and told me how to get around. I did see the biggest cockroach I've ever seen in my life in the apartment, but I only saw one. My only real issue was a miscommunication surrounding my checkout. I was asked when I thought I'd be checking out and gave my guesstimate of "probably around 7am" (checkout is at 11am) When the event I was in town for had a schedule change that effected my checkout time I told Mustafa immediately that I would be checking out at 9am instead. Still two hours before checkout. Well apparently Mustafa had told his next guest they could check in early but did not relay that information to me or convey that he needed a definite checkout time and so I had no idea he needed me out by 7am, I just thought he needed to know when to pick up the keys. His response to my telling him about the change in checkout time was rude and very unprofessional. It still makes me upset thinking about it. Because of that Wanderlust would not be my first choice next time I'm in NYC. Otherwise, great stay.