We spent a wonderful time in NYC. Thanks again Natalie and Thomas for your hospitality! The place was as described - conveniently located and close to the subway which will take you directly to Manhattan. The neighborhood was nice, but a little too loud sometimes (music coming from the local shops and cars passing by the apartment). We recommend these hosts if you want to have a pleasant stay in NYC and don't want to spend fortune on accommodation.
All the best from Poland! :)