Joseph's apartment location was fantastic...2 blocks from Columbus Circle which gave access to most subway lines, Central Park, Lincoln Center, and a Whole Foods market. Joseph is a personable, thoughtful and kind man. The bed and bedding were sufficient for my neice and I, but if a couple stays here be prepared for 2 single mattresses. The building is a walk up, so it's 2 flights to his 3rd floor apartment. The bathroom is shared with Joseph. During our stay he also was out of town so we the place to ourselves. Had he been there during our stay the walk to bathroom requires walking through his sleeping area and frankly that would have been quite awkward. The apt is maybe 500sq ft at most. The neighborhood felt safe and has good little shops and cafes for a coffee and treats. The price was right considering the location! A big negative for me was the lack of cleanliness, and to me that is important. My neice felt the same way. Beyond mere dust, the place needs a really good cleaning top to bottom. I feel it's important to be honest on these reviews, as other people, myself included, rely on the experiences of others as a guide of where to stay when looking into visiting an area. We had a great time nonetheless, but because of the lack of cleanliness would probably look to stay elsewhere on another trip to NYC.. though I'm guessing to stay in Manhattan would probably cost a good bit more.