You really can't beat the location of this place. 3 of us were in town for a night to check out some Village clubs and did it right by finding this place. It's such a beautiful apartment and Neil & Katie allow their guests to feel right at home in a laissez faire style. We grabbed a pizza and beverages and enjoyed the rooftop access which has great views - you can even see the Hudson. I guess I can see how some reviewers might not see this as a luxury apartment, but if you know anything about NYC living as I do from being there for some years you know that it's not spread out. It's a great value if traveling with friends and is directly across the street from Fat Cat which is always a ball.