We had a nice stay at Paul’s place. The room was comfortable, and the air con worked well (which we needed in NY heat!) - unfortunately the shared bathroom wasn’t very clean, however understand this is dependent on the other guests being courteous, which on the occasion we stayed unfortunately they were not. The location was a bit out of town, but close to the subway (but a bit further than we would have liked to travel each day- approx 25-30 mins to get downtown). Be aware that it is on the top floor (3 flights) with no lift. Overall, it was a quiet location, and comfortable stay, thank you Paul.