Seth and Paulo's place its a very good choice if you are on a budget - NY is a very expensive city and here you'll get a cozy room where you can use the kitchen (and save some money if you have time to cook or make your own breakfast). You get what you pay, so in overall we were happy with our choice - not very expensive, with all that you need. (even with a shared bathroom)
You'll get a warm room, with a real bed (not a sofa or something), a good wireless signal and two very helpful hostess. Seth and Paulo always answer our questions since the first moment. In new year's eve they give us a bottle of champagne to celebrate and it shows their hospitality. The room and bathroom were clean.
The only unpleasant thing was the tricky lockers from the house and apartment doors.