John's place was perfect for our quick NY getaway. I will say take note of the mention of the thin walls, it is a very honest statement. It didn't bother us too much but it was slightly difficult falling asleep. The linen could have been a tad bit cleaner as well, but it made do. All in all, we had plenty of space for the four of us and we had a great time. I would stay here again as the location was perfect!