Garnet as a host is unbelievable kind, he really wants to make you feel at home. I would say, the best host I ever met. He is open and ready to help if needed.
We visited NY during late October. In general the place is amazing, it is always calm and quiet.
The room is charm, warm (without asking for it, he provide us with a heater), and spacious enough to accommodate a couple with baggage. Moreover, the bed is super clean and comfortable (what one need after an entire day of activities in NYC).
The restroom is outside the room, and although it is shared with other guest(s), all the time it was tidy.
The location is awesome, with subway stations near by. If one is planning to visit low Manhattan and Brooklyn areas this is the spot. If one is planning to visit midtown and upper Manhattan, this is a great place to stay but be conscious about the time used to travel.