This was our first AirBnB experience and it was fantastic. Five of us stayed in the Dreamers Suite (2 beds and a cot) during some wonderful July weather. We really enjoyed meeting the other guests in the house from Germany, Vienna, South Africa, and Kazakhstan.
The option to stay on Staten Island was excellent. Since the ferry is free and you get a great view of the Statue of Liberty, we felt as if it was part of our New York adventure. We chose to park at the St. George ferry terminal since it made sense for the 5 of us ($8 if you are lucky enough to find a spot, or $13 a few blocks away at a parking lot), not to mention it was easier for my parents in their 70s.
We couldn't get over the value of choosing to stay here. Although we never met Alissa, she responded promptly to a request for supplies via her cleaner. Thanks Alissa for such a memorable experience.