If you choose a place in NYC at this price, you need to know what you sign up for. Don't expect an incredibly clean room - mine smelled of smoke when I arrived, and the smell was difficult to remove. The room can be locked though, which I found reassuring. The rest of the apartment is shared with other people, so expect those parts to be not super clean neither.
The apartment can conveniently be reached by different subway lines, and Central Park is just a few minutes walk away, as well as Delis, bakeries etc. Bill was really flexible with check in times, which was great!
So to summarize, probably good for the price, but I wouldn't come back due to the cleanliness issues.