We stayed there for 8 days in october 2017
Pros - location is excellent, close to restaurants, subways.
Size is reasonable for a New York apt, it is a true 2 bedroom.
Cons - the pictures are very accurate. It is an older, dimly lit space without any recent renovations.
The owner did not leave us any hand soap, dish soap, dish detergent, cleaning supplies, shampoo or soap. There was half a roll of toilet paper and half a roll of paper towels. We ran out of garbage bags mid week. When I asked about these things he said that we needed to buy them ourselves.
I asked for an 2d set of keys for when we went to different places. He said he would get back to me about it but i had to keep reminding him and finally after nearly 5 days he got me another key.
The windows don't have window guards and the window sills are low. You have to be careful if you have young kids.
The air conditioner was not functioning. The owner was responsive in arranging for a service man to come the next day.
The toilet ran for 30 seconds every couple minutes the whole time we were there.