We really enjoyed staying in this appartment. It was just big enough for our family (4 persons, kids aged 9 and 11). It was clean and contained everything that you need. Claudia and Doug were very friendly and the fact that they live downstairs made communication easy (though they always responded to e-mails and texts very quickly too). We appreciated the area. Very conveniently located close to the subway. We can't think of anything negative and would definitely consider staying there again if we ever go back to N.Y.