My stay at Marcello's place was great. It is a perfect location for seeing plays and exploring Manhattan. It was as I expected with a walk up (lots of exercise) and a small studio apartment. The wifi was excellent and there was lots of hot water. Being on the 4th floor meant that it was quiet and there wasn't much street noise. The only snafu was when I arrived I couldn't get a hold of Marcello. I wasn't aware he was out of town and had arranged for his friend to let me in. I had emailed Marcello the day before arrival and the day of but didn't get a response. On arrival I contacted Airbnb and asked for their help. It finally worked out but I was worried that I'd have to get find a hotel at the last minute. Thus the 4 star rating instead of 5. His friend, Enzo, was very helpful.