We really enjoyed our stay at Sheena's. The place was flawless and she was a pretty good host to us, answered all our questions, was so kind all the time and gave us some pretty good recommendations, she even shared Thanksgiving dinner with us... The room is not too big yet cozy and there's a private bathroom for the visitor (which also was very clean).
The location is great (4 minute walk to the nearest subway station), not far from Manhattan and it is pretty easy to get anywhere in the island. The neighborhood is calm, many groceries stores and restaurants nearby.
Definitely we'd stay here again. Great interior design by the way. :)