We had a good stay in this apartment. It was very clean and the beds were comfortable. The host was very easy to communicate with and friendly and helpful.
It's a bit of a hike to Manhattan by subway or Uber (half an hour, at least) but we wanted two bedrooms and these are hard to find, at least when I was searching. We needed to go out for the whole day when we left (no going back and forth), but we saved a lot of money over taking two hotel rooms in the more touristy areas and were able to have a living room and little kitchen, which were nice for breakfasts and playing cards together.
The cable package was disappointing for members of our group who wanted to watch a football game, but otherwise we felt this apartment was a good choice.