I would highly recommend staying here. The apartment is very pretty and comfortable. You have a private garden and a fun shower. I grew up on a crosstown street, so the neighborhood seemed quiet for Manhattan. However, the apartment is right between two subway stops and it's a quick ride to Columbus Circle.
Whenever I had a question, either Tom or Sarah replied quickly. Tom also provides suggestions for neighborhood spots. He also provided guidebooks and pamphlets. There are lots of restaurants nearby and many stay open late, which is really nice if you want to do more things before eating. I would certainly stay at Tom and Sarah's place again.