We had a great time in Troy's place, it was our first experience in airbnb. If I had to point the greatest thing, it would be definetely the location. You'll be very near to times square and all Subway lines.
In the arrival Troy was very kind and helped us to carry our luggage upstairs (the apartment is in 5th floor and there's no elevator, but that was no problem at all).
The only negative point is that if you go in a period that is too hot, like we went, the air conditioner didn't handle and the room was a little hot and it was very noisy.
Above all, I would definitely recommend it for whoever is coming to ny!