Shelby was a fantastic host. She was very responsive and I texted her when we got on the train and she was waiting for us at the apartment when we arrived. The apartment was exactly what it looks like in the pictures. We are a family of 4 with 2 small children and the space was definitely enough for us. It's in a fantastic neighborhood -very close to some of the best restaurants and bars as well as the subway. The street noise could be loud at times (after all it's New York!) so bring some earplugs!