Our time at Shantis appartment was awesome!!! Everything is exactly like it seems to be on the photos. At that place you directly have the feeling of home and of being welcome!
Before our trip we were uncertain concerning the neighborhood, but we didn't feel insecure at all. Even coming home late the night is not a problem. Shanti and her sister Dai were very pleasant, helpful and easy to contact.
So all in all I can't find any ngative words - it's just a perfect place to stay during your NYC-trip!