We have just spent a fantastic 3 nights at Leslie and John's place. The room is extremely clean and comfortable with everything you need for a few days away. The location is amazing!! 5 mins walk to the subway and 15 mins walk to central park.
I would highly recommend for a few days exploring NYC. You can get anywhere you need to be very easily whilst also being in a beautiful and quiet suburb.
Also thanks for the tip about Cafe Luxembourg just up the road! We had an amazing breakfast and dinner there.