We had a great stay at Nicole's place, me and 3 other friends. The place is perfect for 4 people and the bed and couch were both comfortable. The place is very close to the subway, approximately 3 short blocks away. At the first, the neighborhood feels a bit strange (compared to other neighborhoods in nyc) but we felt safe in the end.
The apartment has cleans towels and sheets, which was perfect for us.
The only cons I would mention is that the place is booked every single day, so if you need a more flexible check in/out time, be aware of that. Nicole let us leave our bags before check in time. Additionally, sometimes you can hear the noise from the upper floors in the house, but nothing too loud, just steps.
I would definitely recommend Nicole's place, thanks for all support :)