We very much enjoyed our trip to NYC and Shelley & Malachi's accommodation was perfect for our requirements. They were both very welcoming and couldn't have been more helpful. The room benefits of having a large en-suit bathroom with a superb shower. Other people have mentioned that there is no door to the room so they felt there was a lack of privacy. The room is located up it's own stair case with a 90 degree bend so there is no visibility into the room from anywhere in the apartment. There is a screen that can be pulled across the entrance if necessary but we felt that the space was completely private. The whole accommodation was very clean and well maintained. There is good access to the metro stations, with 2 options being within 10 minutes walk away. Central Manhattan is about 30 minutes direct away. Both Shelley & Malachi were very helpful and arranged for us to drop our bags off early and collect them after checkout.