We had a great time. Easy access and walking distance to all the subway lines and the Metro North station. Great restaurants nearby.
The apartment is up 2 rather steep flights of stairs, so not for people who have a hard time with walking or with heavy luggage! But we loved it. It's on a busy street with lots of lively activity from the restaurants at night - but the bedrooms are in the back, and the noise barely carried. The hot water takes a while to heat up, so you need to be patient, but once it's hot, it's REALLY hot!
We really appreciated having all that space to hang out in - so rare for a NY apartment. Perfect for our week-long reunion with old friends!