We had a great stay at Nadine's. The house is exactly as pictured. Feels a bit old (squeaky floors and the shower pressure is not great) but it's clean and well maintained. It's spacious and fully equipped (particularly the kitchen, which we made good use of). The neighborhood is quiet but has several stores and restaurants (and a couple of cute coffee shops!).
The subway lines nearby (A/C and J/Z) make it very easy to get to places, although it does take some time. About 10-15 minutes to the station and 15-40 minutes to Manhattan, depending on where you're going. But you are getting 3 times the size of a Manhattan hotel, for 1/3 the price.
Overall, I would recommend this place!