Vinny was an amazing host! He checked on us constantly, and always replied to my messages. He sent detailed check in instructions that were so helpful. when i reached out about the other guests being not so clean, he sent someone out to clean the apartment! the apartment was exactly as described and in a great location. it is a 4th floor walk up, which wasn’t an issue for us. there were restaurants and shops all around the apartment and the train was a couple blocks away. anywhere in Manhattan was about a 20-30 min train ride, so it was super convenient. this was an amazing and inexpensive stay for our last minute trip to NYC! thank you again vinny!!