Our stay with Rob and his rommates was perfectly fine - the flat was compared to other NY offers very spacious and has a great rooftop located in lower east side.
Rob was easy-going and super helpful regarding all our enquiries and questions, the boys living in the flat are very nice and welcoming - super fast communication.
Even though there are other people living in the flat, we often enjoyed the luxery to have to whole apartment to ourselves.
We had a great time in New York and can only recommend it!