The Good:
Location was amazing - West Village is bustling with activity, super scenic, has lots of greenery, and has a great variety of restaurants, cafes, markets, bars, and shops. It's also very close to various subways stations, and fairly central to Manhattan.
The Neutral:
Room is cozy and as advertised. It's in a walkup on the second floor. Building is a bit older, but fine for what it is. Walls are somewhat thin, but noise wasn't too much of an issue.
The Bad:
The bathroom was extremely unclean. I was greeted by a dead roach next to the trashcan when I first entered. There was also mildew on the shower floors and curtains, with a bit of visible black mold as well. There were no clean towels either, all of it reeked of mildew, so I was forced to dry off using paper towels.