John and Catherine are very warm and gracious hosts. I was welcomed with muffins and given great tips on places to see and eat in New York. The room with a private bath was spacious and had all the comforts of a home, including a kitchenette with all the essential appliances and stocked with breakfast needs; and a small dining table. Having a private entrance was very convenient and the subway was just around the corner, which made it an easy commute to downtown. The only downside was some noise during the night from next door. Overall a great stay!