We stayed at Susan's place from 21 Nov to 27 Nov 2010 and the apartment was even better than we had expected.

It was very clean and had a very homely/cozy feeling to it. It was getting cold so we did not make much use of the rooftop deck but everything else was wonderful. The location was great and within walking distance to many amenities, e.g. restaurants, movie theaters, shopping and subway (Metro).

This is definitely the place to stay when traveling to NYC. Thanks you.