We had mixed feelings about Scott's place.
The good:
Scott was great. He worked with us to let us drop off our bags in the morning before we checked in, and he was very responsive with questions and issues during our stay.
The location was awesome - a close walk to all the Soho shopping and restaurants but tucked away on less busy street. Easy access to several subway lines, groceries, etc.
The place really was big, especially in comparison to other places I've seen in the city.
The roof deck was fabulous - we were up there every night we had good weather.
The less good:
The kitchen was really fancy with nice appliances but was missing some basics like a coffee pot, can opener, and microwave.
The bathroom off the master suite doesn't have a door or wall separating it from the bedroom.
This place felt more lived-in than other Airbnbs we have stayed in. There was food in the fridge and freezer, toiletries in the showers, clothes in the closets - I thought this was a little unusual.
The location is really close to the tunnel entrance so the traffic got really loud at busy times, lots of honking. Thankfully this was not happening at night.
In general the place was also more worn than in looked in the pictures, and could have used some general upkeep. The roof was leaking while we were there, the doorknob to one of the bathrooms was falling off, etc.
All in all, if you're looking for a big place to crash in Soho, this is your place, but I didn't think it was worth the price tag.