We mostly enjoyed our stay at Michelle's.
The pros being the location (easy access to subway), very spacious size room and comfortable bed. Nice to have the fridge in the room too. The room felt private with the lock. Good communication with Michelle.
The cons would be the front door. A nightmare to get in, and were it not for 2 other guests leaving as we arrived, we wouldn't have gotten in that first night. There is a trick to opening it, it isn't just an old door that "sticks". It was also hard to get out unless you held the latch in a specific way. The WiFi in our room was very unstable and only worked after resetting the router every time.
Felt more like a hotel with the shared bathrooms, not so much an "at-home", "Brooklyn brownstone" experience unfortunately.
We also weren't allowed to leave our suitcases at the house on our last day after checking out. Which is a new experience for me in an Airbnb. Since you're usually staying in someone's house, not a converted hostel, I've never had an issue leaving bags for a few hours before. All in all there wasn't anything particularly bad about the stay, just a few points that I'd have liked to know before.