We booked this place for an out of town guest and had a very pleasant experience. Jerry and his wife are a great team and easy to reach at any time. It's hard to think of a better location on the UES, on the same block as Whole Foods, and a couple of blocks from the 456 train express stop, the Q train, and Fairway. The place itself was small but cozy and comfortable, clean and with everything we needed for the stay.
The only negative about the place itself is that it's a fourth-floor walkup, and the stairs are very steep. But this didn't present a large problem for us. More of a nuisance was the fact that both washers in the laundry were malfunctioning (ate the money but didn't wash the clothes), and this required multiple tiring trips up and down the stairs, and fruitless calls to the laundry service line. Our guest eventually made arrangements to wash the clothes elsewhere. Of course it should be noted that the hosts do not maintain the laundry room. Also, the hosts made two visits to show the apartment during our two-week stay, but they did provide advance notice of the visits.
Overall, we liked the place and would rent again!