I really recommend Shelby's room, we had a very good experience. Communication with Shelby was excellent, and although we never met her, retrieving the keys from the lock box was easy. The apartment is on the 2nd floor and the staircase is quite narrow, so keep that in mind if you have very large suitcases, it's definitely doable, but it will be a little workout. The room itself is bright (morning sun, so bring some masks if you want to sleep late), comfortable and large enough to fit 2 cabin-size suitcases and still be able to navigate around the double bed. I read about people complaining about the noise, yes, you can hear traffic, but it was not an issue at all for us. The bedroom and the bathroom were spotless upon arrival. The room is not fully enclosed, there is a small hole in the wall around the heater (it was one room that got split into two) that communicates with the bedroom of Shelby's roommate, and the rooms share a window, a heater, and you can see the light and hear the noise from the other room. It was a little weird to hear the roommate watch videos in his bed early in the morning, but that's really the only very small negative. Overall a great value considering how spacious and clean the room is.