We stayed at Eric's place on Van Buren St for two weeks, and absolutely loved it. We're a young couple who wanted to explore NYC together, and only one us had visited the city before. Prior to arrival Eric was really proactive in sending us all the useful info we might need - it came in really handy. Also, checking that the booking is a good match for you seems a reassuringly high priority for him. He and Justin were charming hosts, with great attention to detail. For instance, when it snowed, Justin made sure the sidewalk out front was shovelled clear.
The apartment itself is beautiful - Eric and Justin have a great eye for furnishings and lighting. Stocking the fridge with basics on arrival was really appreciated after a long journey. The bed is comfortable, the bathroom is clean and well organised, and the kitchen has everything two people might need.
The neighbourhood isn't the most upmarket, but it's far from the worst area in Brooklyn - the brownstones are attractive and well maintained, and we always felt safe, even at night. The walk to the subway is reasonable, and the local stores and takeouts were great.
We both felt extremely welcome here and would come again.