I'd give it more than five out of five if I could. This is the best deal in airbnb in NY by a country mile.
I had a whole place to myself with separate kitchen, bedroom and living area. The bed was extremely confortable, wifi was flawless and there was a working area where I could easily work.
It's completely peaceful and quiet so it's a very restful place, the kitchen overlooks an extension of Greenwood Cemetery so it's very green too.
It's right next to the subway which is only two stops away from Manhattan! and also next to Industry City which has plenty of places to eat and do shopping.
But best of all it was Anthony and Jessica who were extremely nice, accommodating and have instantaneous response time. Any issues (if you can find them) they will address immediately.
Thanks to Anthony and Jessica they've been a life saver, I will definitely stay again!