I stayed at Jen's Place when I was in NYC with my girlfriend, and it was really nice place! Previous reviews worried me about bed size, but for us, bed was really comfortable and nice(and big enough). I really loved their puppy and cats. He was one of most adorable, friendly and cute puppy I have ever seen. Juan and Jen were friendly and gave us a lot of details about surroundings and tour sites.
I would go back to this place for sure!