I took my parents to NYC and chose Judy's place to stay. It was pure perfection. The area is super nice. On Atlantic Avenue you'll find nice restaurants and a corner store that sells all necessary food items (bread, baguette, cheese, etc). So especially after a busy day in Manhattan, Brooklyn is just a good place to calm down and relax.
The apartment itself is as described. The bed was super comfortable and the kitchen sufficiently equipped (however we only had breakfast there).
You do not need to bring any shampoo, hair dryer, etc. It's all there.

This being said, I would come back at any time!

Thanks, Judy!