This was a five star stay, for me. The five stars are based on value and Charles' pleasantness and great communication.
Accommodation: Spacious, clean, and the AC works great. There are basic amenities (cutlery, glasses, pots, pans, and plates) in the kitchen. In addition, there is a full sized stove and fridge.
Bedrooms: Basic and comfortable, windows and a good AC.
Communication: Charles is friendly and great at responding to any messages. I felt that he was reliable and trustworthy. I appreciate that from a host.
Location: I am a native New Yorker. I do not require a stay in an upscale neighborhood, but a non-New Yorker is free, ofc, to read about the Rockaways in general. It can be urban and gritty in places. That said, I had a night without incident and the apartment was quiet.
What's Around: There is a very large Stop and Shop around the corner. The beach is very close, maybe a ten minute walk. It is a nice section of the beach, lots of surfers.