This apartment is a great location in the city if you are looking for close to time square and the shows without being right in the loudest part of the city. I loved that the apartment is in the rear which means there was little street noise and only some hallway noise compared to most hotels that are a constant parade of noise and poor insulation. The double bed was good, the futon though could use a mattress pad. You could double up the comforters like I did to help. It's not the worst futon I've slept on though. I didn't feel like Elaine sleeping on the Seinfeld's futon in Fl. Then again I'm very small so take this in consideration. We mostly spent the day out and came back in the middle of the day for breaks. The train/mta/subway was close a 5 min walk up or down either way and very walkable from PABT. There are a ton of variety of food places in the area to explore. We chose the place because it was close to our favorite ramen places (ippudo and hide chan) and a good 20 min walk to Highline/Chelsea market for one of the days. Amy's bread is close by too for great breakfast breads before you head out to the park or ect. There is also a Target close by to buy anything you may have forgotten. In my case Chapstick and face moisturizer for super windy days. The apartment was clean and tidy I'd prefer unscented products, but at least it was clean. The windows provided a good cross breeze when it was warm (65 felt like 70) in April. Msg ahead to clarify your heating/ac needs imo. The apt door lock just needed to be pulled out a tiny bit then turned held and opened fine. Hallways and one flight of stairs can be tight if you're big or bringing a lot of luggage. We only ran into someone once on the way out while throwing our garbage. Though from 9-1 sounded like they were renovating the place upstairs. Most people are awake or out at these times though. Shower and water pressure heat ect was awesome, I even took a tiny bath. Turn the shower to 4 o'clock for very warm, 3 for hot. Communication at first made me nervous, but as reviews came it it was alright. Neighborhood is fine, it is just far enough from the main hussle and bussle to not feel like you're getting swept down stream once you step out and not too quiet that you feel like little Bruce Wayne around the corner. Just enough tourist traffic.
TL;DR Great amount of space for the price. If you're looking for a bnb vs hotel this is it. Comfortable enough, great additional amenities and space to rest in-between adventures. Location and price are spot on. Wish there was a more comfy chair than the futon and a mattress pad on futon could help. But by the time you get back from your day out you'll probably sleep like a rock anyways. Otherwise 5 out of 5.