Jennifer's place is a perfect location for your NYC experience. We were there for concert at Madison Square Garden which is within easy walking distance. It was close to everything we needed for our quick weekend tour of NYC. Jennifer was very nice host and provided complimentary coffee at her espresso bar and stored our luggage for us while we explored before our check-in.
A few cons which can be expected of an affordable apartment in NYC, but one I was not expecting was to be hit with a strong smell of cigarette smoke when I opened the door. There is a no smoking sign in the building, but obviously not adhered to. I put some essential oils on cotton balls in the window unit vents, and by the time we returned from our tour that evening, it was tolerable. If you are sensitive to cigarette smoke, I wouldn't recommend. It is very small and I would not recommend for more than two people. Not a good place to just hang out, but sufficient to rest and refresh. It is up four flights of narrow stairs, so I advise bringing minimal luggage as space is quite tight in the apartment for storage. Not the cleanest Airbnb I've experienced, but not bad.