Depends what your wants/needs are for your trip to NYC...
Pros
- Excellent location right by Columbus Circle and steps from Central Park
- 3 queen size beds if you need that arrangement (although 1 bedroom didn't have a window)
- All the needed comforts of home (washer, dryer, coffee maker, kitchen, TV, etc.)
- Very good communication with Allen throughout visit
Cons
- Very small for 6 people despite 3 bedrooms (hard to comfortably sit in family room), one small bathroom
- Cold showers in the morning - had to run water for 10+ mins to get warm water
- Issues with TV buffering several times as it was trying to connect with internet (uses Sling internet TV)
- Tried to bake a pizza one evening and bottom oven would not warm up enough... finally got the top oven to heat up enough
Again - Depends what's important to you based on your time in NYC