Evelyn's place is lovely-- you cannot beat the location of having all the restaurants, shops and easy transit of West Village at your doorstep. The space was exactly as advertised and had everything I needed to be comfortable during my stay. Evelyn was easy to communicate with and check-in was a breeze.
The only downside to her space for me is I am a light sleeper and there is quite a bit of noise from the outside being on the ground floor in a busy area, and also noise carrying through the inside the house (its a beautiful old house, but this means you can hear a lot inside too). This disrupted my sleep in the mornings and evenings but a heavier sleeper should not have a problem.
All and all a great value in a great neighborhood. Recommended.