It is a good location for NYC- easy commute. The house is generally clean but especially the furniture, fixtures, fabrics etc are very old. The furniture seems to be put together from different sources one by one - not matching each other .
If you think that your plane may have a delay think twice to book this one - as check in time is 6 to 10 pm and the host is not very flexible. It may turnout very stressful for you to think that you may be left out or have to pay an extra fee. The host is not very communicative but he will respond if you need something.
All in all- if you want to have a low cost stay in NY and don't care about some details you may opt for this one.