It's a small apartment, overall clean, tidy and simple; I think good value. It has all that it say it has. I also want to add that even though they don't show it in the pictures they have a small closet.
The check- in was super easy, they just left an envelope with my name on the front desk. On check-out I gave the key back to the front desk.
It's in a great location: walking I could get to Penn Station, Times Square, the NY library, empire state, Rockefeller, to name some attractions. Also there's a subway station nearby, and a few rental bikes racks. You also don't have to walk too far to find food or drinks.
The only reasons I don't rate it 4 stars: one could be fixed but the other may not be fixable but you should know in order to see if you accommodate to it: I think the mattress and pillows need to be changed. The mattress is sagging on one side and the pillows are just not comfortable. I wouldn't say I loved the sleep I got.
The other issue is that even though I was surprised to not hear the traffic (it's on the 7th floor), on the 4 nights I was there, there were always people yelling (also not helping with my sleep). It seemed it came from others inside the building. Lastly, a guy offered drugs right outside the building door. I saw this dude twice.
Overall, it's good value and greatly located.