Guest A: A quiet bungalow tucked into a side street off of 4th Ave, the apartment was spacious, bright and overall comfortable. The caretaker was very helpful, and was able to produce a clothes steamer for us. There were a couple odd things about it. First, the main bedroom was a loft off the kitchen, which was a nice room. The other two rooms were side rooms off the living room and the kitchen. The one off the living room had a curtain for a door. The other one ended up being in the hallway to the bathroom. If you're traveling for business with your co-workers, this might not be the best arrangement. However, if you're a bunch of friends traveling together, it's probably not such a big deal. The other issue was that there was no coffee maker. It was apparently broken. Of all the appliances, that's the one you probably need to have an alternate for in that case.
Guest B: Quaint neighborhood a very convenient walk to the subway and coffee shops; apartment smaller than it looks in photos; single bathroom that is only entered through another bedroom slightly inconvenient for three people; generally a nice setup with nice amenities (except coffee maker was broken); clean and well decorated; one of the ‘bedrooms’ was not necessarily a bedroom, rather a small space off of the living room with a curtain, though the bed was comfortable. I generally enjoyed it - it was cute and very New York City-ish.