We had a very nice stay at Hershey’s place. It was convenient, clean and comfortable. Communication was easy and fast, and Hershey was very accommodating. The couple of drawbacks we encountered had nothing to do with the apartment itself. You do hear - and feel - the train running underground. A very NY experience! Also typical of NY apartments, the apartments are close together, and the walls (and ceilings) are a little thin, so you hear any commotion/voices/heavy footsteps/etc, of which there was some. Nothing crazy, just occasionally bothersome.
Again, the place was lovely and well appointed, and Hershey was a great host.