We had a wonderful stay at Carroll Gardens. The appartment was beautiful and very comfortable. The subway was literally just 2 minutes down the road and there were plenty of places to hang out. It is a lovely and relaxed neighbourhood. It was just perfect! Ewa and Paul were great hosts who get that balance right between being available but not intrusive. We would recommend this place highly to anybody visiting New York! One tip - if you are staying for a week, get an unlimited metrocard for the subway. This allows unlimited travel around New York for $30.