We loved staying at Susan's apartment! The apartment is only 2 blocks from the subway and then only 2-3 stations from the city so really convenient. Check in was a breeze and Susan was always available and helpful if we had any questions.
The apartment is large (for NY standard) and was very quiet and very clean and had every available thing you could need while on holiday. The area is like a little village with a number of cafes and restaurants within easy walking distance.
We absolutely loved it at Susan's place and would not hesitate to recommend to anyone!