Great place! Beds are comfortable with nice pillow options. Elliot was super responsive and helpful anytime I had any questions or concerns. We needed an HDMI cable and he personally dropped one off at the house the same day. The neighborhood seemed nice and safe, even after midnight. It was a nice touch that he had soap, shampoo, and conditioner dispensers in the shower. AC works great too! I would DEFINITELY stay here again and recommend it to others.
My ONLY complaint is a location issue. I couldn't walk directly to the subway, but had to walk about 10 minutes to get on a bus to the subway. It's not the end of the world, and the bus takes the same Metro Card the subway does, so it wasn't hard (You can buy a 7-day unlimited Metro Card for $33). It was just an extra step, and added about 20 minutes to the trip into the city. Probably in total, it takes about 45 minutes to 1 hour to get into the heart of Manhattan. 10 minute walk to bus stop, 5-10 minute wait for bus, 15 minute ride to subway, 5 minute wait for subway, 30 minute subway ride to the city.
Other than that little extra time/effort because of the location, the airbnb itself is great and Elliot is the man!