First of all: the room on the picture is not exactly the one we stayed in, but that‘s completely okay since the room is very similar (just a tick smaller).
The perks first: We actually really enjoyed our stay. The daily room service was great and the room was perfectly clean with a lot of fresh towels and enough supplies (toilet paper and so on). The communication was also great, responses from the host were immediate. The bathroom is really nice and the room felt like a hotel. The location is top! And even though it is a very crowded area in NY, there was no noise at all in the apartments!
Now unfortunately what made our stay not perfect:
The bed. And what bugged us most about it, is that people have already mentioned that in all ther previous reviews (I thought they maybe were exaggerating, trust me, they were not!) so the host is obviously aware. But the bed is TERRIBLE. It is too tiny for too people, very short and INCREDIBLY LOUD. Whenever you move even just a cm it squeaks. The mattress was just uncomfortable and felt like it was about 200 years old - and when you pay that amount of money for a room, I expect a decent bed, since the thing you will do most in NY in your room is sleeping.
The shower: Also previously mentioned. It leaks like crazy.
And last: Perfectly fresh and eatable stuff with our room number written on it, was just thrown out into the trash, which was unacceptable for us.
All in all, our stay was very nice if you don‘t considerate those things. :-)