Overall, my girlfriend and I had a great stay. The area was safe, and right next to central park. It is just 2 streets down from the blue line, and the red line is a bit further, about 3 avenues down, so convenient to get to the subway. It was actually quiet at night, which is surprising given it is the city. A lot of food options near the Broadway area, with my personal favorite being Miss Saigon.
The host will usually answer any questions or concerns promptly and succinctly. The super intendant, Jack was extremely helpful as well.
During our stay, the bedroom did not have a windows AC like the picture, and the washer looking thing in the kitchen photo does not exist. Friendly suggestion to the host to please update the pictures so future guests may make an informed decision. I would have given a 5 star review had these pictures been accurate.
A useful tip to future guests: bring smaller suitcases instead of larger ones as the stairway up is a bit narrow.