Painter is a host really trying to provide a great experience.
The location is perfect, quiet neighborhood with good cafés and restaurant within short walking distance. Very convenient, quick public transportation over to the center of Manhattan.
For us the main negative part was probably the temperature of the apartment. This is probably not an issue for 10 months of the year. We knew about this before hand, but still it proofed to be negative for the experience. I like to use the kitchen when I am traveling like this, in this place I ended not using the kitchen much.
Lastly, being an electrical engineer by education, working in the safety department of a large factory there were some issues that did not make me comfortable.