The main drawback for me was the bed. It was too soft and the pillows too thin. I woke up each morning with a neck ache. I was also surprised there was no drawer or drawers for socks, underwear, t-shirts and sweaters. The closet had ample room and hangers for shirts, pants, and jackets. Most Airbnb's that I have stayed in were empty of personal items and Shelley's apartment was overflowing with personal stuff.
The kitchen and bath were well stocked and when the toaster smoked, Shelley replaced it the next day. I wish it had been warmer to take advantage of the terrace, a real bonus in New York City!