We enjoyed our stay at Bedhaus. It was a nice and very comfortable place. Unfortunately we did not get to our hosts but Brady was very responsive to our messages. At first we were a little concerned about the area due to some reviews, however I must say that we felt safe. There are a lot of cafés and bars nearby and it's easy to get to Manhattan and many other places in New York.
Sometimes we felt a little anonymous because there were quite a lot of people staying at Bedhaus and it was more like a hostel/guesthouse. It was different from what we've experienced on airbnb so far. I don't know if it would have been different if the hosts were there.