We loved our stay at Judy's place. It was everything we were looking for and more on our visit to NYC. The flat is spacious and bright. My fiance and I were really able to stretch out and relax. We really felt at home on our short stay, having our tea in the mornings and even making dinner one night when we were too pooped to go out. We were surprised how quiet it was, as well; Judy's husband mentioned that they had super insulating windows. The neighborhood is lovely, as well, with numerous neat independant shops and cafes within walking distance. Close to subways, too, which made it convenient to get to and from the city.
We would definitely want to stay here again next time we visit.