Michelle's place is great. It was very clean and I personally think the apartment looks nicer than the pictures. Michelle is a wonderful host and prepared a crib and other baby items for us. If you are traveling with a small child I can highly recommend staying here. Besides the crib, there was a changing station, a stroller, and toys for our son to play with.
There are many great restaurants in walking distance (Michelle leaves a little leaflet with some recommendations in the house) and the subway is a short walk away. You can easily get to Times Square and other places using the red line.
Fun fact: I have never stayed at a house that had that many lightswitches ;)