Nelima's place is exactly as described in pictures - super cozy, comfy bed, good shower, and clean (the house smells really good), and very close to the subway which is very handy (station is around 2 min from the house and it will take you around 30 minutes into Manhattan).There are also many shops and restaurants nearby, so very good for a longer stay.
The room is on the first floor and you will need to climb a flight of stairs so be prepared if youre bringing heavy luggage.
The street can get a bit noisy at times - bring some earplugs should you be a light sleeper.
I would recommend Nelimas place.