Honestly I want to keep this a secret so my friends and I are the only ones that know about this gem, but then I don't think that would be fair for Hershey's business haha.
If you're going to stay in Brooklyn, even if you're going to stay in other areas of NYC, don't bother: just stay at Hershey's. It's newly renovated, Hershey is extremely professional and an incredible host! The extra touches make me feel like this was an Airbnb PLUS. And because of the size, it doesn't feel like you're in NYC. My friend and I were entertaining the idea of how much it would cost to buy because we wanted it all to ourselves. You won't be disappointed, I guarantee it.