Wonderful experience from start to finish. Excellent communication before we got there and during our stay. Having Art and Ed was like having my own private NYC travel guide! So many excellent suggestions for sights to see, places to eat, and even helped us map our subway stops. They had guest cards for a few of the museums we visited and saved us a ton there too. They are such thoughtful hosts - cell phone chargers, lots of snacks, breakfast, even let me do some laundry. We loved our stay with Art and Ed and would happily stay again. Such a memorable stay.