Pros:
Great hosts who were very responsive and took care of any issues quickly. This apartment has plenty of room. It has good access to public transit with multiple train stations within a few blocks and a bus stop right outside the building. There are 3 decent groceries within about 3 blocks and a wide range of restaurants and eateries for many budgets and many tastes within 15 min walk. You are pretty far north but its only about 30 min from leaving the apartment to times square via public transit.
Cons:
Some people may find the sometimes boisterous guys hanging outside the stoop a bit intimidating, though I have always found them to be respectful. You are on the 4th floor and there is no elevator so be prepared to do some steps, though I got used to this pretty quickly!