My family and I have just come back from a trip to New York staying at Jenny's Place and we loved every moment. The place was clean, well equipped (thank you coffee machine, photography corner for the kids, well stocked bathroom and toiletries and more).
The location was great, few minutes from the supermarket and easy walking distance to the station, loads more shops, restaurants and loads of food trucks. Ps try the chicken and shawarma wrap (shawarfel sandwich I think it is called) from the falafel truck by the station near the Krispy Kreme donut shop.
Also Jenny's Mum having learnt that I was after a cooking lesson, kindly came and spent one morning with me teaching me to cook amazing Mexican dishes. She would have spent another morning with me but I did not have time. And when she realised how much we liked Mexican, she adapted our breakfast that she brought every morning to include Mexican food - we were very happy. I need to go back to get a Puerto Rican food lesson next time.
Seriously choose this place. It is awesome