Anthony's place is great. I would for sure recommend staying there. Redhook is a really charming little area. A bit of a hike to the subway. We walked to the Carolle street station. It was about a 20 min walk.
The place looks exactly like the photos. Probably one of the best representations I've seen on Airbnb. It's really good value for the location and comfort of the accomodations. I would recommend.