Allan's apartment is great. The pictures don't do it justice. Love that the bedrooms are on opposite sides of the apartment, offers privacy from your fellow travelers (especially if they snore!). The back bedroom is really quiet as it overlooks a courtyard. I didn't hear any neighbors either - no foot traffic or TV noise.
The location is fantastic, such an easy walk to Times Square. If your main purpose for your trip is to go to Broadway shows, this apartment is ideal. Just far enough away from the TS crowds and craziness. But really easy to get to the theaters.
There is a small convenience store a few doors down to stock up on sundries, and plenty of restaurant choices right outside the door.