All-in-all we thought this place was great. The train station (Utica) is less than a 5min walk (about two blocks) and can get you to Times Square in 30-45min -- I do suggest looking into the subway map a bit prior to heading up if you're inexperienced as it can be a bit overwhelming, especially while busy.

As bullets:

THE GOOD (nearly everything, but will note the main points):
- Great Host
- Very Reasonable price
- Apartment was more spacious than anticipated with nice decor (futon acting as second bed was also more comfortable than anticipated)
- Solid WiFi included
- Very close to subway stop (A Train is express to Manhattan)
- Parking on the street is available, though traffic is hell.
- Quiet and clean neighborhood... We didn't encounter and issues at all
- Ample dishes, bedding, and towels for all guests.
- Great pizza place right around the corner and very fast delivery (Daddy Green's)
- Quick train ride to 4th and Smith area on the C train to an area with excellent options for dining.

THE LESS THAN GREAT:
- Water pressure was really bad and sinks were very slow to drain. I'm unsure if this is simply standard in NYC area, but I was surprised. It was less of an issue with me than my sister, whom mentioned that she was barely able to get the shampoo rinsed out of her hair.
- There were no window coverings in the living room (though please note that Kristian let me know that he was going to have this addressed the night we departed). This really wasn't an issue for me or the others that stayed with me, but I could see that some folks would have a concern there.
- Taxis are not easy to come by in the least, even when trying to schedule via phone... Though if you're efficient with the train, it's a bit of a moot point.
- Lack of grocers in the neighborhood... Or at least ones with much of a selection.

The experience was great, Kristian was extremely welcoming and helpful through iMessage (and offered to talk via cell or in person if needed) throughout our trip. I highly recommend this place and absolutely plan on staying there again if still available on my next visit to the NYC area.