We stayed 4 days in Rosalies apartment. Rosalie is a super likeable host. When we checked-in she showed and explained us everything we need to know about the apartment and also gave us some New York "insider tips". Thank you Rosalie for being that courteous.
We definitely enjoyed our stay and recommend the apartment for a stay in New York. The location (20 minutes walk to Central Park) is awesome to experience New York and casual New York atmosphere.
But some smaller deficits future visitors should know about, led to my 4-star-review. The Glases of the windows are pretty thin, so that you can hear the noise from the traffic at the streets and it has a bit of wind draft. Also so bathroom is quiete small, so that you can just rotate inside the room.
But all in all the apartment absolutely fits for a short New York trip.