pros:
• Location can't be beat. I'm a native New Yorker and know the City pretty well. Hell's Kitchen is hands down best location for centrality, shows, and getting away from tourists while being one. 9th Avenue is food heaven. The Highline is next door.
• Jennifer is very nice and good communicator
• Place is clean and everything works.
• Bedroom is quiet ('living room' and its couch is on street and very noisy
cons:
• I now know that 'cute' is New York airbnb parlance means "tiny". I can't imagine 3 people here
• It's a fourth floor walkup
In sum, if you want a basecamp and don't mind stairs, it's a very good value. If you are planning to hang around the pad, you might get claustropobia.