My husband and I stayed in Shahar's lovely Upper West Side apartment recently and the place entirely met our expectations. It was exceedingly quiet and the bed was extremely comfortable. We particularly appreciated the air conditioning as we were there during a heat wave but the apartment remained refreshingly cool. The shower is excellent! It was reassuring to have a doorman, too. The location is excellent: a ten minute walk to Central Park and a two minute walk to the subway. During our entire stay, Shahar remained in contact via text, and quickly answered any questions we had. We would definitely stay there again!