The room I stayed in at Paula's was spacious with a very comfortable bed (I slept better than I usually do at home) and a/c, which I greatly appreciated with the temperatures in the high 80s during the day and the 70s at night. Paula was an accommodating host, and allowed me check in early (so I could go to the theatre without having to drag my luggage along). The apartment was in a great location, too, with lots of restaurant options, 4-5 blocks to the subway, and within easy walking distance to the theatre district and Central Park.
Things to be aware of: Paula has several guest rooms that share a bathroom and a kitchen, but some guests must exit into the stairwell of the building to access the hallway with the bathroom and the kitchen, which is where my room was located. As a result, it means the outer door to the stairwell is generally left unlocked so that guests from other parts of the apartment can access the kitchen and bathroom. Fortunately, my guest room had a lock on the door, but it made me a little uncomfortable knowing that anyone in the building could hypothetically access the hallway. Secondly, guests staying in the other parts of the apartment did not seem to realize that there were other guest rooms next to the kitchen and bathroom, as some of them were pretty loud at night. Thankfully, once they became aware of other guests, they quieted down.