The place stay would have easily been 5 stars but we had 3 issues while there. We wanted an early checkin and could not get a response from the host until I contact Air BNB. There were mice in our apartment that we had to get rid of. I’m not surprised with it being in NYC but it was a negative. Lastly the AC was a problem and we could never get it to work properly. We would turn on the cold air but it would constantly flip over to heat. Aside from those problems, we really enjoyed our stay!