This is a nice studio in a great location. Matthew is an extremely attentive and helpful host. He even did some shopping for us before we arrived! And had the food waiting in the kitchen when we arrived. I would definitely give him 5 stars for anyone coming from far away, or unfamiliar with NY city.
My only reservation is that it wasn't really a great place for little kids. Even though it's listed as "kid friendly", and as containing kids' books and toys, in reality there are tons of fragile momentos on every surface, kitchen tools within easy reach, and basically no toys or books. I would only recommend staying here with older kids -- maybe 9 years old and older.