My review is a little more mixed (and maybe balanced) than other reviews.

The good: The studio is well located: on a quiet street and nearby various subway lines which will get you to Midtown in 10-15 minutes. It's fairly sizeable. The host, Chris, was available, helpful, and easily contactable. Checkin was smooth.

The less than good: Although the studio is well positioned there were several noise disturbances. It's near a boiler which kicks in at any time, and I was woken up several times by a homeless guy rumaging through the bins which are outside the apartment's windows. But overall it's still quiet for Manhattan.

Because it's a basement studio it is quite dark. Several reviewers have commented favourably on the furniture and decor. But this is a matter of taste. I found the apartment cluttered - skins, masks, religious paraphernalia, all over the place. If you prefer minimal this apartment might not be to your liking. The bathroom has become somewhat grubby and could do with a thorough clean - and indeed makeover.

Despite my misgivings I had a satisfactory stay.