I booked Shelby's place after carefully reading reviews, so was prepared to share a one room studio with two other women and knew I would be sleeping on what some guests described as a cot. With that in mind, I had a great stay. Lillian and Shelby are very welcoming and pleasant company. Lillian's place is great if you need a place to sleep on the Upper West Side. Just be prepared that there is obviously no privacy (other than when you use the bathroom of course) and you are truly sharing a room that serves as the hosts' bedroom, living room and office. If you are looking for an authentic New York City experience this is it - Lillian has made the most of a small space and Lillian and Shelby are great examples of two single hard working ladies who just love NYC and don't want to live anywhere else.