My wife and I just completed a 4-night Thanksgiving weekend (2014) stay at this very nice apartment, hosted by Ana. Overall review: Excellent! The apartment is perfectly located, close to Columbus Circle and Central Park, to Times Square, to many very nice local restaurants and services in Hell's Kitchen, and is in a safe neighborhood. Communications with host Ana were clear, easy and comprehensive; we had no need to bother her during our visit because all necessary information had been provided prior to our arrival. Even though this was our first Airbnb reservation, and we probably made several "first-time" mistakes, the host's communications treated us with kindness and respect. Upon arrival, the building entrance was secure, and the apartment was clean in every room. We were joined by our 27-year old son and his girl friend, who said the pull-out couch was "pretty good" to sleep on, though pull-outs are rarely perfect. The bedroom was private and comfortable. The listing information and pictures were accurate. Full windows in the living room and the bedroom really brightened the stay. One real benefit (for us at least) was the art that is indicated in a photo in the listing -- the pieces provided great discussion points for cocktails before heading out for dinner. In summary, the location of this apartment is a real plus, the host was very effective, and we would absolutely stay here again. A great experience!