Melissa's Airbnb is simply amazing. We were travelling with a group of 3 and the apartment was very spacious, clean and light. Melissa provided us with a very helpful booklet that contained info on the house, but also with nice tips for places to go. The apartment is almost next to the subway (3 mins walking distance), and very thoughtful decorated.
During our stay, we often said to ourselves: "This place is way better than most hotels". If we ever find ourselves in New York again, we would definitely like to stay in Melissa's and Cary's apartment again!