What to say about Melanie's place? I stayed there for 2 months, but I wish I could stay for 1 year at least! I had had some Airbnb experiences before, but it was always the whole place. It was the first time that I booked a place to share with someone that I had never met before, and I couldn't have made a better choice!
If you want a "real New York experience" just book her place. It is a safe area, with everything you need around: laundry, supermarket, pharmacy, restaurants and 1 block from subway station (it is very easy to go anywhere in NYC from there).
When I say "New York experience", I am not talking just about the area or the place (which is very clean, organized and cozy). You will also have the best host. Melanie is always ready to support you on anything you need. Also, she respects your privacy and she is very friendly.
Just be aware that you also should respect her place and privacy too (all of us need those things, right?!)
Have a lovely stay!