Pros:
-Communication with the host was easy and he was very responsive.
-The space was pretty clean.
-The location was good; quiet but close to the highway.
-We were able to find street parking close to the AirBnB every night, even if we arrived late.
Cons:
-As soon as we arrived to the apartment we were "greeted" with signs in EVERY room. They warned us not to pee on the floor, wipe the toilet seat, and follow all rules. Noncompliance would result in being reported to AirBnB and the NY Police Department. I have no problem with an AirBnB establishing rules but it is unusual to have multiple and somewhat threatening signs posted in every room of the house.
-One of the people in our group is 6 ft tall and the space was very uncomfortable for him. He would hit his head if he walked into the 1/2 bathroom. In the full bathroom the angle of the wall also made it difficult for him to use the mirror. In the large bedroom there was also the potential of him hitting his head when he sat up in bed.
-The dishwasher was broken but the host had not left a dish drainer, towels, etc. to clean dishes. He did provide towels after we asked for them.
-Kitchen stove is missing a few knobs and one of the cabinets doesn't close.