We stayed at Tony's place for an extended weekend trip to New York. The space was all that we needed - essentially a clean, relatively quiet hotel room. The available sim card was an amazing value add for us since we are from Canada and it allowed us to avoid roaming charges. Street parking was free (just watch for the street cleaning signs). Tony was always responsive and helpful. His check in instructions were clear and included helpful pictures.
Most of our planned activities were in Midtown, so the room was about a half hour away by transit. This worked well for us most of the time, although, sometimes it would have been nice if the room was closer so we could more easily go back to it in the middle of the day. Ultimately, we found the distance between the room and our activities to be a minor inconvenience, especially when considering what a room closer to/in Midtown costs!
Overall, very happy with our stay and would stay here again.