Jeffrey's was the first place where I stayed with a shared bathroom. Though initially I definitely was apprehensive of the arrangements and how it would work out, tbh Jeffrey made me feel right at home and there was complete and total privacy. the bathroom situation too worked out really well and it was well stocked with toiletries as well as all necessary amenities.
The cats are also normally quite, and they don't intrude into your space and so the stay was very peaceful.
Last but not the least, Jeffrey even went out of his way and kindly let me stay for almost a half day extra at his house, since my flight was delayed by almost 10 hours!
The surrounding area is also very safe and beautiful with Prospect Park, one of the best parks of Brooklyn/NYC, right across the street. It's also very convenient for public transport.
All in all, I really loved staying at his place and would definitely recommend it for anyone who is looking for a quiet, tranquil, home-like place to stay in.