Shelley's place is great! She was very welcoming and even left me a little welcome note on her chalkboard! She respects your privacy and responds extremely quick. Her place is only a short 10 min walk to the train station and there is a deli on every block to fulfill all your late night munchies. The rooftop was definitely the cherry on top! Very quiet and peaceful. Just a heads up there is a curtain in place of a door, but that did not really bother me and my boyfriend!