We had a nice stay at Meredith's place.
The apartment was fine for the time we spent in it, not so much because we were mostly out visiting New York City! It was large enough for a group of 5 people (2 couples and one single) and very comfy. If you like zen atmosphere you will feel good in this place. Everything was as described, no bad surprise.
Our host was flexible with the check-in and check-out times, which allowed us to leave our luggage in the apartment instead of carrying it in New York before and after the check-in and out times.
Thus, I would definitely recommend this place if you plan to visit New York. Moreover its location is quite central in Manhattan and close to the subway by feet, which saves precious time when visiting!