Overall, this place is really great for the price if you don't have that many people with you! Admittedly, the inside was a lot creepier than I expected (it's in the basement of a house so not a lot of sunlight comes in, and the figurines lying around don't help), but my friends and I really enjoyed our stay and found it comfortable once we got over the initial shock.
Jeaneth -- who ended up being the main communicator -- was very responsive! Whenever I messaged her, I got replies very fast.
The place is very close to the nearest station and a main road in Queens, which was very nice when we were checking in and checking out. My only grief was that it took a while to get to and from Manhattan, but that's not the AirBnb's fault and more my own for knowing nothing about NY geography and transport. Still, it's very easy to travel from there! Getting to JFK was a breeze.
We were never missing amenities we needed and the ones we had were great, like the fridge, coffee maker, and microwave. Those were really helpful because I had been sick during my stay and needed to heat food/water up quite often.
Overall, a very nice place and totally worth it for the price. I'll come here again if I travel to NYC in the future. :-)