Elma was great. We booked last minute having realised the hotel we'd originally booked was pants! First time we'd used air bnb. It was easy to book, Elma's was in a lovely location, lots of tasty places to eat out, easy to get into Manhattan either on the subway or a brisk walk to Brooklyn bridge. Room was homely and clean, as was bathroom. Only downside is that we got over charged on the taxi from JFK, worth looking into beforehand. Taxi was $70 there (should have been $40ish) same return journey on subway $7.