Overall, a great choice.
Pros:
- AC unit kept the room cool even in a brutal heat wave (worth 5 stars alone in NYC 😂)
- Room had everything we needed... coffee, a corkscrew, cups, water bottles, etc., even some hair gel for a nice night out
- Bedroom is a shoe free zone (a pro in my book)
- Great neighborhood, close to a few bars and restaurants
- Good communication with host
- Affordable
Cons:
- 10 minute walk from closest subway station
- The stairs leading down to the bedroom are narrow and steep with no rail (typical for a basement but still tricky with luggage)
- The front door catches on the tile, minor annoyance