The positives: the location and size of this apartment are great. We loved being located right next to the park, close to several subway stops, and in a wonderfully vibrant neighborhood with many great food options and bodegas. The size of the apartment was very comfortable for our family of 4, giving everyone enough space (not easy in NYC).
The downsides: cleanliness and amenities. The apartment wasn't all that clean when we arrived. We contacted the host about this, and he did offer to send the cleaners back in, but still this was a disappointment. While all the listed appliances were present (washer/dryer, AC window units, dishwasher, etc), other amenities were pretty sparse - only one roll of toilet paper, no soap in the shower, only 4 towels total (no washcloths or hand towels), minimal dishware, no dressers or shelves for putting your stuff on, etc - so be prepared to buy or bring these items, or just do without.