I have been a user of Airbnbs for over a decade and this is the first review where I can honestly say I would not recommend staying here. While the photos and the furnishings are accurate and beautiful, that is where the good parts of the experience end.
What surprised me most was that, when I asked the hosts why the bathroom and the common areas were not clean when I arrived, I was told that they are the responsibility of the three occupants of the space. That has never been my experience in a shared space and no one was cleaning the common space and it became disgusting. I also inquired about additional paper towels, toilet paper, soap, and cleaning supplies. I was told that these are also the responsibility of all three guests. What?!
Finally, the neighborhood is not great, and the J and M trains that are across the street are not good subway lines, and do not run regularly.