I have never written a review that's less than glowing, but I think people need to know about noise level.
I used to live in New York and currently live in another large city; I know it's loud. I don't mind noise. I also know that some areas are quieter than others. It felt like our room was in the middle of traffic; loud cars and honking until about 3 am. There was a food cart right outside our window, a club next door, people standing outside our window conversing drunkenly and loudly. I think noise level needs to be stated in the listing.
Otherwise, the hotel was as expected. The roof was beautiful. Good proximity to the subway. The night staff person was very helpful.