Pros: The space itself was really nice. It's basically a hotel room (I think it's literally a hotel just listed on Airbnb). The location is great, very close to Central Park and train lines. Service and staff were excellent.
Cons: There is NO kitchen. When I rented, the listing said "kitchen" and all basic utensils "pots, pans, etc." However when we got there. There was only a microwave and a mini fridge. I rent AirBnb bc I don't like to eat out all the time when I'm traveling. I like to cook meals. However, there was NO stove, oven or freezer. The mini fridge had a tiny freezer "slot" but you couldn't fit much in there. So it really limited what I could cook and negated the value of AirBnb vs. a hotel. I paid a TON for this AirBnb and with the same amount could've gotten a nice hotel.
Overall: really nice place, excellent high end hotel-like service and quality but no kitchen (just microwave and mini fridge) and for the price you pay, you could literally get a nice hotel in Manhattan. So not great a value and not great if you plan to cook meals.