Sam's place was perfect for our 24 hours in Manhattan. He was very helpful with parking suggestions and accommodating to my family of 4. The previous reviews were also helpful - location of key (I liked its location; made it feel extra anonymous), hallway smell IS NOT the apartment's smell, small square footage (but the 3 beds made it possible for my husband, 2 kids and me to get a good night's sleep), and the location is ideal, safe and quiet. Thank you, Sam, for helping with our kids' Christmas gift of seeing Phantom of the Opera before it's off Broadway!