We stayed six nights at Sylvester’s apartment and enjoyed our stay.
The apartment was very spacious for the four of us. The kitchen was basic but practical. Lovely woodwork throughout the building.
The neighborhood is great (many restaurants, subway and a supermarket just a few steps away) and so is the location, as Manhattan is just a short subway ride away (15-20 minutes tops).
(Do note the apartment covers the entire third floor, but only the master bedroom and living room connect. The small bedroom, kitchen and bathroom open only onto the landing/hall. The bathroom and kitchen are therefore unlocked and accessible from the landing, which was unsettling to us at first, as we were worried about theft, but everything was fine.)
Overall a great value for a NYC stay and we would definitely stay here again!