Matt's house has a great atmosfere, I always loved coming home after a long day strolling through NY. It is a cosy small place very close to the public transport, which for me is a very important factor. Furthermore we found out that Amsterdam Avenue had a couple of great places to eat, and that is walkingdistance from the apartment
As expected from a NYC apartment, it can get a little noisy, you might hear some neighbours. I am from a city myself, so I dont really mind, but if you need more quiet, you should bring earplugs.
Our host Matt is nice and responds quickly to all my messages. We were on different schedules, both busy, so we did not see each other very often. When we did we had some nice conversations.
Overall I would highly recommend it!