Gary is very responsive host and allowed my husband and I to check-in a couple of hours early, which was very helpful as we took a redeye flight to NYC. We were able to pick-up the keys and go grab some breakfast until the housekeeper was done cleaning. The key pick-up location was a 15-20 minute walk from the actual listing, so keep that in mind for planning purposes.
The place itself is in the perfect location for exploring Manhattan--right in the center of it all in the lovely West Village and close by several subway and bus lines. Because it is so central, there tends to be a lot of street noise, especially on the weekends. So be sure to bring ear plugs and an eye mask if you're a light sleeper. Also bring slippers or flip-flops for walking on the floorboards, which are a little uneven (to be expected given it's location in a charming but older building). Those things aside, Gary's place was a great place to stay for the weekend.