I enjoyed my stay. The A train is literally right across the street which is very convenient. But I wish I had been more familiar with New York when I booked this place. I would have enjoyed being closer to the city. Make sure you look at the map before you book.
I fell absolutely in love with the dog, but all of my clothes were covered in dog hair. So just pack a lint roller.
Renting just the small room is not quite as private as I expected but it all turned out fine.