We had a great stay at Luux's place! The apartment was absolutely spotless and the location was great for getting around town.
I know some people mentioned that the area did not feel super safe, but we didn't experience that at all (even when arriving at 11:30pm). Yes, there are a lot of homeless in the Times Square area, but that's just the way it is and I had no issues even when walking alone at night as a single female. The apartment is very near the intersection of 8th Ave, which is a bright and busy corner.
The apartment is perfect for 2 people and we appreciated having the table in the kitchen to work from, along with plenty of drawer and closet space, and space in the bathroom cabinet. It's easily accessible and up one small flight of stairs. The building itself felt clean and well-maintained.
Check-in was easy with the lock box.
My only minor notes: I generally prefer a firmer bed and the mattress was extremely soft. An extra pillow or blanket is always appreciated and next time I'd probably remember to bring my little clip-on reading light as the only light in the bedroom is overhead. Again, these are just nit-picky things.
All in all, a great bargain and a solid choice!