Our stay at Catherine’s apartment was fantastic, it was exactly as described and really clean.
Catherine was extremely friendly and always responsive and we had no issues with a late check in.
The only comment we have is that whilst the street Catherine’s apartment is on felt safe and quiet, when we walked from the subway late at night we didn’t feel completely safe. We opted for taxis when coming home later in the day. Having said that, this could be an issue anywhere in NYC.