Just got back from a week-long trip to NYC and stayed at Jim's place with my dad. Here's my quick summary.
PROS:
Great apartment to share with at least one more guest. Lots of in-home amenities!
Amazingly convenient neighborhood in which the place is located. You want markets, restaurants, or subway stops (with only one stop into Manhattan!)? All are located right around the corner from Jim's place.
Beautiful waterfront park just a 5-min. walk away with incredible views of Manhattan from across the East River.
And Jim, the host, is very accommodating and helpful. He'll most likely walk you around the neighborhood to get you acquainted with the surroundings!
CONS:
That I don't live there!