I stayed at Carly's place for 2 nights, while on a tight schedule business trip in NYC. But even during those few hours I actually spend inside the apartment, I really enjoyed it. The apartment, while not big is very tastefully furnished and makes you feel at home. The bedroom is in the back and is very quite, which I'd consider a luxury for Manhattan. The little kitchen has everything you need to get your breakfast or dinner done. The location is great and just two blocks from the Central park, where you can take a nice break from all the hustle and bustle of New York. Tones of great restaurants and shops in the area. As an experienced traveler and AirBnB user I can also say that the value of this apartment is exactly right. While searching, I found a lot of places, which looked pretty bad and outdated, while priced at near NYC hotel levels. This is not one of those places, it actually stands for everything I love about AirBnB - you get to stay in a comfortable and great looking place, understand better the way the locals live, while paying much less than for a night in a 3-star hotel situated in overcrowded touristy areas. This is for me a 5 star travel experience.