My wife and I loved staying in Rose's place near Central Park! We made a last minute reservation to stay with Rose for one night and it was so worth it.
Location: Perfectly located halfway between the Theater District and Central Park. We had tickets to see Wicked the night we checked in - it took us 3 minutes to walk to the theater! We walked to Central Park in 5 minutes the next morning and the subway is also about 5 minutes walk. Couldn't be a better location.
Reserving & Check-in: Rose was very accommodating and was okay with our late check-out. The check-in was silky smooth - we were early and she was having her place cleaned so we were able to leave our bags with the doorman, we returned a couple hours later, picked up the keys and entered her tidy apartment.
Accommodations: The bed was comfy, the room was warm, despite there being snow on the ground when we woke (it's the middle of April and it snows in NYC?) The bathroom was spotless, the shower had great pressure, was hot and there were fresh linens. The cleaning person obviously takes pride in their work.
Overall: Excellent - we'd stay with Rose again.