This is a great place in a lively(and sometimes noisy) neighborhood. The host, Felo, is very cool and personable. When I met with him to get the keys/learn about the cats, he walked me around the neighborhood and showed me all the best local spots. His recommendations were greatly appreciated. Felo's apartment is very close to both the A and 1 trains, making it incredibly easy to get anywhere on the west side of manhattan. His place is also near some INCREDIBLE parks, which are great for exercising or just taking a walk with friends.
Living with the cats was a treat and an educational experience. All the cats were friendly, but Rojo and Bambu were definitely the nicest/most social. When Felo says this place is "For Cat-Lovers Only," though, he's not kidding. Having never lived with THREE cats before, I was amazed at how much hair there was. The hair was impossible to escape. Right after you cleaned it all up, it seemed like more would just appear out of thin air. Even if you're not allergic to cats, the ever-present dander might get to you over time, and you'll probably find yourself eating a cat hair or two(or many more). All in all, though, it's worth it to come back and cuddle with Rojo, Bambu, and Pantera--the three kings of Sherman Ave.