This was a perfect place for us. Seith's directions on getting the key, though seemingly a little tricky in writing, were spot on once you got there. The stairs are a bit difficult to manage with luggage but I was there with my wife and daughters so there was a bit of over-packing going on. We had one little challenge with a bed and the TV but Seith handled it promptly and without imposing on our activities.
We found the place to be both spacious and quaint. The neighborhood is in a good location and the place to be if you like Indian food with "curry row" just a down the street. Being close to 2nd Ave made finding transportation easy and you are within walking distance of anything you need.
The townhouse itself was clean and undated. You can tell Seith keeps on top of making sure his guests are comfortable and have what they need. The Hotel W it is not but, but if you want to bring your family to NY and live more like a local than a tourist, I would recommend.