Jay's place is acceptable for people who are exploring the city, not really staying for a long time. Also pets have to be throughly discussed with him even though it said pet friendly. As a fellow New Yorker the place is very private, although it was a very noisy apartment. Other guests were pleasant! But the apartment is not very comfortable to eat in, there's nothing to clean up with. The Room was accommodating, spacious, and neat, TV, wifi.