Good points: Space, three good size double bedrooms and a large lounge. Location, directly on the subway to Manhattan and JFK, 20-40 mins to downtown. Local area also has many shops, bars and Italian eateries. Check-in, Matt was there on arrival and helpfully provided a lot of info.
Bad points: Fixtures and fittings, some of the bedding and towels were unacceptable, worse than a cheap hotel. This was fixed 24 hours after arriving. No lid on the toilet cistern, shower difficult to control. Generally the place is a bit old. Noise, the main bedroom is on a busy junction, expect sirens, hip hop, shouting from the people who hang around the subway and 24/7 shops. The other bedrooms are at the back and quieter.
I see these comments are repeated in other 2019 reviews, but nothing has been done about them.
Overall the 3 of us had a good stay for Halloween and the NY marathon and the place is mostly ok for a few days. It’s below the standard of other airbnbs I have visited and that’s probably reflected in the price, it is good value.