Amy's place was clean, in a safe and decent neighborhood, and spacious for NYC. However, there are a few concerns that I think potential guests should be aware of:

The apartment is above a Sushi bar which resulted in a couple of issues for me--there was LOUD music until 5 am every morning Thurs-Saturday. We did stay there on Halloween weekend, but I don't think that has anything to do with it. The bedroom is right above the bar, so even with the white noise machines, you can still hear it clearly. My husband had ear plugs on and he could still hear it. Just be aware of this and be ok with it, if you decide to book here.

The apartment also smelled like food, sometimes deep fried, because of the fact that it is right above the restaurant. This wasn't too bad, but just want everyone to be aware of it too.

Lastly, the water does heat up so just be patient!

I think there are people who will be ok with this place, but if loud music bothers you at night then you should skip it.

Amy was a good host though. No complaints there.