We recently stayed at Eric's and overall had a good experience. On the positive side, the location is fabulous and very, very NYC. The space is also wonderful with lots of light, tons of entertaining areas and generally comfy, functional stuff (couches, beds, etc). On the negative side, there were a number of quirky, problematic things. The oven wasn't working properly, some lights weren't functioning, hot water was an issue one day for showers and we couldn't find any large towels. But we are pretty flexible, so overall we had a great experience and would probably rent again in the future.