Positive: very easy check in and great communication with Andrew, the apartment is quite new and decently clean, with a nice Bathroom, one big room with a fantastic bed and a very useful kitchen.
The location is great, just 4 min walking to the Subway and 15-20 min to times square, a great alternative to the crazy Manhattan prices. The area is pretty humble with a few shops around but some streets can be creepy at night so if you stay out until late better grab an uber or Taxi to drop you off.
Negative: The Sofa/Bed is terrible, the mattress is old, it's been used a lot and definitely needs an upgrade asap.
This apartment is perfect for 2 people, but if you rent it for 3-4 people and 1 or 2 of them have to sleep on it it's going to make a big difference, we had to sleep on it for 6 nights and it was very bad.
In addition, the apartment is very lacking in wardrobes, apart from the one in the bedroom, so another problem if you are 3-4 people, no room for everyone.
Finally we found the toilet seat broken, but looked that it was already broken and they tried to fix it with some glue that of course didn't work, and that kind of thing needs to be replaced asap​ because they are really important for the comfort of your guest. We also have same problem with the rubbish bin, it was a big and modern one in the middle of the corredor but it was broken and we couldn't not close the lid properly, so we had to put some weight on top of it all the time to keep it close, that kind of things need to be fixed quickly, especially in those kind of apartments that has guest coming in and out all the time.