My fiance and I have stayed at Tina and Tim's place twice now and it was lovely both times! Easy to check-in, very clean, very spacious, quiet, a nice walking distance to the subway and once you're there, it's incredibly easy to get to Manhattan & Brooklyn.
When we travel we love it when we start to feel like locals, and Tina & Tim's place really made us feel like we had our own little apartment in New York. When we come back to the city, this'll be our first choice for where to stay!