All in all this hotel was completely *fine*. We checked in on a Thursday night and check-in was fairly smooth. The daily charges for pool/wifi/mini bar weren't applicable as the pool and mini bar weren't available.
The first night was a rough sleep, our neighbors evidently had quite the fight and were breaking things. Of course this shouldn't reflect on the hotel, just a part of the review. Be respectful to your hotel neighbors.
The gym was open by appointment only and just available to those in your room during the appointment. We were able to get an appointment at any time we wanted and the gym was not lacking in equipment and appeared clean with additional sanitizer/wipes for use.
We could not get a late check-out unfortunately but they held our bags while we finished enjoying the last few hours of our vacation.
All in all I have no complaints. The photos you see in their listing are certainly taken from flattering angles though we didn't feel cat-fished in any way. I would definitely check out a location on the West Side next time, though.