I was charged with planning a trip for 10 of my girlfriends and they all wanted to visit New York. I live in Brooklyn so this task was perfect for me. I booked John's Clinton Hill listing and it looked just like the pictures. My guests arrived at different times so having a key code on the door as opposed to an actual key made it much easier for everyone to move about and not alter our schedules to let people into the building as they sporadically arrived.There were plenty of towels for my guests, coffee available in the kitchen, and lots of space for us all to just hang out. As we didn't have cars the apartment's proximity to restaurants and markets made satisfying a diverse array of cravings pretty easy. The only con I have is the access to the train...we would have liked being closer to popular train lines. We used Ubers for most of the weekend.
Overall great experience.