We had a spectacular time at Rhonda's place in Bedford-Stuyvesant. For most of the week, I stayed there with one guest. Then, my BF joined us for the rest of the booking. It was a little tight with three adults, but we made it work.
If you're going to be sightseeing in Manhattan, Rhonda's apartment is an ideal home base. That said, during rush hour, it can take >60 mins to get back from Midtown. Also, the apartment is a >10 mins walk to either subway line.
Staying at this place allowed us to explore Brooklyn as well as Manhattan. Bed-Stuy is an up-and-coming neighborhood, so it still offers good value. At night, the streets can be a *little* bit dicey.
The kitchen is well supplied, so if you want to cook, you can.
Rhonda is very friendly and accommodating. Staying with her is like staying with family.