I stayed here with my girlfriend and her family and on the whole we really liked it. It's in a great location, and the place is pretty cute. We had a few minor problems that prevented us from leaving a 5-stay review:
a) The house was significantly smaller than it looked in the pictures and what we were expecting based on the price. We were a bit worried that it would be too big for a group of 4, but that was definitely not the case. We were comfortable, but don't expect a lot of extra space.
b) Upon arrival, the house was only set-up for 2 / 3 people even though we paid an extra $150 or so for a 4th guest. Once we contacted our host, they showed us where we could find additional bedding to set-up a fourth bed.
c) We were only given a half roll of toilet paper for four people over a four-night stay. That ran out quickly, and when I contacted our hosts to ask where we could find more they said that they were out and that we would have to go out and buy some. I thought that they should have at least provided an extra roll just in case. The day after I let them know we came home and they had left us a couple extra rolls.
d) The pictures suggested that the host would leave a bottle of wine or some snacks for us upon arrival, but nothing was provided. Of course we wouldn't have expected anything had they not mentioned it in the pictures, but we were a tad disappointed when it turned out not to be true.
Again, all of these were relatively minor problems, but I thought they were worth mentioning given that the place isn't exactly cheap. Aside from these small issues, we really liked it here.