Justin and Shirley were lovely - as all the reviews state! We received excellent tips for the neighbourhood and loved our stay in New York. The location cannot be beaten. But perhaps we had bad timing that our stay took place whilst the cats were being litter trained in the bathroom, which is very small/not super clean. As I'm allergic to cats, we really had to work around this (and inevitable cat litter/odours/poo that go with this). The bedroom door doesn't shut properly so we had to wedge it shut with a shoe so the cats wouldn't go in the room and make me sneeze too much. On reflection, it would have been good to have known about the situation fully (especially the litter training), but Justin and Shirley were really nice hosts. If you don't mind cats and the occasional cat odours etc. this place is perfect for you! :)