My wife and I stayed at Dan and Jarrets place for 5 nights for our first ever trip to NY.
They gave clear and regular communication throughout and were quick to introduce themselves in person upon arrival. The flat was clean and well equipped, and the subway station is just a 5 minute walk.
However, we found the plug to be broken on the bathtub and so couldn’t fill it. The flat was also very cold at times and there were no instructions on how to turn the heating on. Both minor issues on the face of it, but I fell I’ll during the stay and these would’ve really helped.
Lastly, the location was not great. It’s hard for me to criticise, given that the hosts accurately advertise the location, but I found the location sketchy and very inconvenient. Travelling into Manhattan became a chore, travelling back late at night was worse.
The flat was great, but next time I’ll just book a place in Manhattan, or Williamsburg for the Brooklyn experience.