Staying with Gaetano, Suzanne and Fellini was a wonderful experience.
We really appreciated the relaxed atmosphere at their flat and hanging out with them. Gaetano and Suzanne are great to talk to and very helpful hosts when it comes to recommendations for restaurants etc.
Not far from the flat, which is located right in the middle of everthing important (Penn Station, Times Square, Empire State building, etc.) you can find loads of great, not so touristy restaurants in and around Hell's Kitchen.
Our room was really cozy and very spacious for two people. Thankfully, the room is located away from 37th street, so the noise levels are astonishingly low, for a flat located in a quite busy area of town.
One of the highlights of our stay was Fellini, a lovely and very vocal cat, who always seems to be up for pets or playing around. If you are a cat-type person, you'll probably love him as much as we did!
Overall, we feel we got the best possible NYC experience out of our trip, and staying with Gaetano, Suzanne and Fellini certainly made up a big part of that.