Susan's place was perfect for our trip. We stayed with our young daughters whilst touristing in New York City. The location is excellent - only a short walk to the subway and then a direct train into Manhattan. We tried a few local restaurants (La Passatore and Hi Noodle) and both were great.
The apartment was spotlessly clean when we arrived and the space was just the right size. we especially loved the back yard for relaxing in once the kids were in bed.
Talking of which, the beds were really comfortable and the choice of pillows much appreciated.
I'd recommend this place for anyone wishing to see New York without staying in Manhattan. Perfect for kids too. Our girls loved the playground in the park opposite the house.