We had a wonderful stay at Josh's Brooklyn loft. When we arrived, we found it as pictured and described. I was happy to have read the reviews, since I had an expectation that the neighborhood and building would feel a bit iffy, but once the inside the loft it is beautiful and feels safe and secure. The neighborhood ended up being perfectly situated for us. Walking distance to everything Williamsburg has to offer. There is a full grocery store and wine shop steps away, and we found dozens of restaurants, coffee shops, Domino Park all within walking distance. The loft is literally ON the train line, so public transport could not be easier. Another review said the train was loud in the apartment. We did not have that experience. We could not hear the train. The apartment was maintained, clean, well stocked. In other reviews I had read the place was dark. I do not know where that comment came from. It's not as bright as the photos, but I would describe it as a light and bright space. The furniture is old and eclectic. We found the furnishings charming, and as pictured. Furniture did not feel uncomfy or unclean -- just antique-y. It was easy for us to get in to the loft and Josh communicated efficiently with us. We drove and enjoyed the free onstreet parking. All in all, we will rent this place again, especially if travelling with a group, which we were.