I want to be fair and start by saying that I believe getting high quality lodging in New York in a great location at a fair price is an impossible job. At this BnB, we had a great location and a fair price. The overall quality of our experience was lacking.
Things we loved: 3 beds, a bathroom with shower, plenty of plugs, and the location. You can walk to everything.
Things we hated: VERY cold, no heat control, beds do not have comforters. There is 1 top sheet and a thin blanket. I don’t think it’s asking too much for the host to add blankets. We ran out of toilet paper and asked the hotel for more and they said no. How absurd is that! So we went and bought our own.
Not the host’s fault: SMOKE IS EVERYWHERE. Our whole floor reeked of it, and it seeped into our room. One of us has asthma and she couldn’t breathe. I spent the whole night vomiting because this is what cigarette smoke does to me. We told the front desk and said they’d try to find who was smoking but couldn’t do much.