Was in town for a few nights to see some shows, and I'm easy so I went with something relatively inexpensive. Checkin was easy, and they even let me into my room a half hour earlier than scheduled. Staff was very friendly and responsive at all times.
The room was very basic, but had a fridge and microwave. Bed was comfortable. Bathroom could have been a bit cleaner/in better condition, but nothing outrageous.
The area isn't the best. I'm a large man, so I didn't feel unsafe, but I could see other folks having a different experience. But it is *very* convenient to Times Square, Madison Square Garden, and any Broadway or off Broadway show you'd want to see. I walked everywhere, only hopping in a cab when my feet hurt or I was in a rush.
Definitely a 'get what you pay for' situation, but I got more than my money's worth. Would stay again.