Judy's apartment is possibly the best holiday rental I have stayed in whilst in NYC and I have seen a few!
It is light, very spacious, comfortable, full of cool furniture and everything you are likely to need on your trip, from guide books, maps, toiletries, hair dryer, washing machine...you name it, Judy has it. Judy herself and her husband are the perfect hosts, helpful and super responsive yet respectful of your privacy. The neighbourhood is packed with great restaurants and quirky shops and excellent transport facilities but I'll stop right here - if this apartment becomes too popular it may jeopardise my chances of staying there in the future :)