We loved Beth's place. It's so clean and uncluttered, yet cute, cozy and homey with lots of thoughtful touches. I loved the detailed directions for everything - something that a lot of hosts don't provide. We didn't have to fumble our way through anything. One thing to note - my 6'8 son was with me and when he stood up straight the top of his head pressed against the ceiling. If you're over about 6'6", you will have to watch your head. It really was not a big deal at all but just something to know if you're a giant like my son.
About Red Hook: we loved it. Everytime I visit NYC I'm reminded of how overloaded the city makes me feel; coming back to Red Hook where it was so much quieter and low key was so enjoyable. We used the ferry to go over to Manhattan and came home via the subway and the 61 bus, which dropped us around the corner from the apartment. 100% would recommend Beth's place and Red Hook. I would love to come back and stay again.