I'd highly recommend staying at Jay's. His place is as advertised--surprisingly quiet! Impeccably clean, cute and cozy. Our bed was soft, and though it was a bit drafty, we had access to extra blankets, hot water for tea and coffee, etc. The location is great if you don't mind walking just a few blocks to catch a train or bus; also a leisurely 1/2 hour stroll to the major museums and central park. Jay was super kind and welcoming and regularly checked in on us, offering advice when needed and plenty of accurate directions for getting around. Would stay again; it's a great little corner of Harlem and Jay makes you feel at home, despite how busy his life is :)