This was a very spacious and extremely well located apartment. Keith is a super friendly and helpful guy. The pictures are accurate. Beds were comfy. Being so close to the Barclay center means public transit access is excellent. The neighborhood had the regular big box stores at Atlantic Mall, but also lots of fun independent shops and restaurants. As others have mentioned, if you're in the front room you know you're on Atlantic Avenue, but I'm a light sleeper and had no noise troubles in the bedrooms, which are in the back. Keith checked on us often and even offered to send out laundry for free! It being October, we needed both the heat and the A/C on different days, and they worked well.
I'm not giving it five stars for a few reasons. There was a glitch at check in which meant that I actually picked up the keys to, and entered, the wrong apartment. A bit unnerving. The place was adequately clean, although not spotless, but the kitchen particularly is crazy cluttered. Papers, empty boxes, plastic bags and candles - I think I counted 12 candles - filled some of the cupboards. Three coffee makers - 2 drip and one press - took up space on the counter. The dishwasher was broken. If the kitchen were better organized there would be a lot more useful space, which would help it be a 5-star apartment.