I'll first start with the positive, Caroline is a nice host, the place is exactly as described and pretty comfortable and the location is quite good, although a bit far from the main attractions of Brooklyn and Manhattan. However, Caroline and her mum are not kidding with the house rules! It's almost military and made us feel very uncomfortable. I was visiting with my mum and brother and we are all very used to travel and often stay at Airbnb. We expect to be respectful of the host house like it is ours but this was too much! I'll give one example that made us even regret to book this place. We were having dinner and after giving us a couple of minutes we were asked to leave the common area while they are checking in other guests. We thought this was very rude but it is indeed in their house rule so we had to go back to our room... Looking back, this rule was probably the reason why we had to wait (under the rain) what felt like a long time so that other guests could clear the common area. We discussed this with Caroline and agreed to disagree on this rule. I'm surprised nobody commented about all those rules. Now you are aware and can decide for yourself if you would be comfortable there. There is no hard feelings but we would not stay there again and won't recommend to friends!