We really enjoyed our stay at Micah's place. It is so close to the subway, area is good and the place has most things you would need. We got into New York much earlier than planned and Micah was so lovely and let leave our bags early before check-in which was incredibly useful! Only downside was the noise from upstairs, there are plenty of earplugs left for guests which is great but if you don't like sleeping with earplugs or if they fall out while asleep then you will probably be woken by the noises and footsteps coming from above.
Overall though we had a really great stay and it was a great spot for hanging out in Brooklyn!