First off, the location is awesome. Very close to a subway station for quick access to the rest of NYC. Plenty of cool spots to eat in the neighborhood, etc. I feel like the apartment itself could use a little work. It wasn't as clean as we're used to seeing from Airbnbs, had a pretty strong musty smell, water leaking from shower fixtures, etc. I'm totally fine with a smaller/older places and this is a less expensive listing, but it could use a some TLC. Would be five stars for me with a few fixes.