Arthur's Place on Dean St. was great! It was very clean, comfortable and true to the pictures. I felt the space was "large" for a New York City apartment. My family of 5 was very comfortable and had plenty of space.
Arthur and the other host were very responsive, even my late night questions were answered right away.
Our stay was just for a weekend so we did not use the kitchen but it appeared to be well stocked. The beds were comfortable. The AC worked perfectly and all the rooms were of a comfortable temperature. The place was true to the pictures.
We felt safe walking in the neighborhood which seemed to be relatively quiet. If you get an opportunity to use the backyard space please do. It was a great place to relax and hang out after a day in the city. It was quiet with a nice evening breeze. As our stay was short we did not get an opportunity to use the amenities like the grill and fire pit but had I had more time we definitely would have utilized this space more.
I would recommend staying at Arthur's place