We really enjoyed our stay!
Pros: good communication with the hosts, easy check-in, close to a subway line, comfortable bed, clean room, felt safe (location-wise), Central Park is within walking distance.
Cons: the bedroom is towards the street so it is noisy (it didn’t bother us because we live in a city, but could definitely be an issue for those used to quiet when they’re sleeping), aside from Central Park, it is a subway ride to anywhere you want to go, was a little uncertain whether to expect the hosts to be at home any time, and we did wish we had taken more of our own toiletries as there wasn’t much there.
Overall we really enjoyed and appreciated our time there and would recommend the spot to others who are going.