I will echo what many other reviewers have said.
VERY comfortable beds and bedding. And QUIET. That is the highlight. And I would rather have comfortable beds and the below annoyances than terrible beds.
Other said "No frills. The bathroom could use updating."
Let me clarify some of the details about this-
-1 thin bath towel per person
-Nowhere to hang towels where they could dry (bathroom door opens to kitchen so cannot air out bathroom without blocking the refrigerator)
-Toilet seat held up with a rope (weird)
-No side tables for more than 1 person per bed
-Bare walls, place feels cold.
-Lack of hospitality in general.
-Poor attention to detail.
I know that in New York, no one needs to go above and beyond to get rentals filled. But we have stayed in many STRs in the area that make us feel welcome, but not this one.
Location is easy. Nice coffee places on 4th and 5th Ave. Easy to get to subway.
I hope this helps future renters with expectation setting.