I really enjoyed staying at the Box House Hotel.
Not to mention all the kind staff, the kitchen and the bathroom are just like my dream house. The room was super clean and was exactly same as the photo (I could say even better than the photo!)
There's a shuttle service so it's easy to go to either the city or Williamsburg :) (They do pick up too)
I would love to stay again if I go to NY next time.
Highly recommend