It was our first Airbnb experience. Overall it was great. My only problem was that I didn't read the house rules carefully, and was upset to realize at the last minute that we couldn't get in until 7pm. The hosts were very nice about our concern. Also, it sleeps 4 but only 3 adults. That worked out fine for us, though. The place is large and sunny, 2 things hard to find in New York.