I stayed for one week with my boyfriend.
The neighbourhood is safe and beautiful and just the perfect base to explore Brooklyn itself and Manhattan which is easily connected by subway and busses.
The house is a beautiful old brown stone building.
The Small bedroom is indeed tiny, especially if you are two persons with one bag each it gets very cramped.
During our stay Mrs Watson installed a shelf just behind the door - which forced us to squeeze in and out the door which couldn't be opened properly anymore.
Another drawback was the smelly and moldy fridge with leftovers from previous guests.
The cleaning lady comes only every two weeks, and finally when we took off the bed covers before we left, the mattress, pillows and feather beds were really stained and dirty.
(I am not a very fuzzy person and I am used to hostel-cleanliness)

Mrs. Watson was nice when we first met but we didn't see her much as we were away most of the time exploring the city.
Thats because we were surprised when she complained one morning about us being too noisy and we tried to be even more quiet when we returned in the evening!
Back home Mrs. W. wrote in her review about us besides being very noisy that we had visitors at her place which is not true!

It was my first airbnb-experience and booked this place because of the good reviews it had...well that was my experience.