The positives:
- The hosts, Stacy and Simon, were super friendly and hospitable. They went out of their way to accommodate us (for example, with an early check-in). They sent over a long list of recommendations which were really helpful. They always responded quickly to communication throughout the trip. Check-in and out was totally hassle free with a code for the door and a safe for the key.
- The communal space and the room is stylish, the bed is comfy, and there is a useful kitchen with private fridge space for your room, the kitchen is also stocked with useful things like coffee, tea etc. that you are able to use.
- We found the price to be really good value compared to other NYC options.
The negatives:
- This flat has 4 different airbnb rooms (the hosts live in the flat downstairs). There is only 1 bathroom between these 4 rooms. As far as I am aware, these rooms are all double rooms (at least 2 definitely are). Therefore, 1 bathroom is shared between 6-8 people. This meant we didn't go a day without spending some time - sometimes a lot of time - waiting for the toilet/shower. This obviously wasn't a holiday-ruiner but was frustrating as often it added on 20-30 minutes to our morning.
- The apartment is 3 minutes walk away from a subway stop, and is also located conveniently for access to JFK airport. However, if you are planning to visit the main tourist sites of New York, this airbnb is located pretty far out. It will take 60-90 minutes by public transport to any of the major attractions. The immediate area (Cypress Hill) was also very residential - it didn't seem to have anything going on in terms of cafes, restaurants, bars - you will have to travel. Therefore, in my opinion the location wasn't great for a typical NYC sightseeing holiday.