Pros:
Very modern and comfortable living space, with a great kitchen space.
Quiet at night and was able to get good rest (you can hear the train passing but it is not that loud, and in the rooms not audible)
Spacious and good value for 3-4 people (with 2 full sized beds)
Probably ideal for a group, that does not mind being a bit farther from things and prioritize a comfortable interior.
Cons:
Was impossible to find parking (we arrived on Friday late night). We circled around several blocks for 20 minutes and could not find any spaces, so we had to find a parking garage and ride share back to Airbnb. If you are driving, this is definitely something to keep in mind.
Also note that although it is technically Brooklyn, it is still 1 hour 10 minutes train ride from most attractions in Manhattan. If you're staying out late, it can be a grueling trip back.
Not too many places nearby to walk to for food. Some streets seem a bit rough and not the most pleasant to walk around at night.
There are two gates, one front door, and the upstairs door leading to the Airbnb. Total of 4 gates/doors that you have to go through to get home, and 3 of them require physical keys to unlock. So it is a little tedious having to do this every time you leave and return. The keys are also not labeled, so it took trial and error to figure out which keys went to which doors. If you are checking in at night, this is a bit stressful.
The first night we got in, we found a small cockroach in the kitchen. The host was very quick to respond and someone came to set up traps the next morning (which did catch one roach, when I checked).