Ten out of ten!
As long-term veterans of Air BnB, this would probably have to be the best stay we have ever had. If you want to be a bit out of the busyness of Manhattan, Stuart's place is brilliantly located in Brooklyn, just a few stops along the L line from 14th Street. Don't be put off by the Brooklyn address - its very doable and easy to get around.
My husband and I had 3 great weeks staying in this place and really could not say a bad thing at all about our experience. None of the common problems with noise, Wi-fi or under-stocked kitchen facilities which we have found in so many of our past Air BNB experiences. We even had a cleaner come in half way through to clean and change the linen etc.
Stuart went out of his way to look after us, even allowing a late check out on our last day to avoid an all day wait at the airport.
I would definitely be back to stay here again on our next trip to NYC.
Do yourself a favour!