Pros: great views, right next to Brooklyn Bridge and the historic seaport district. The apartment size is very ample for one person, spacious enough for two without being on top of another, and I imagine fine for 3 close friends. Rachel provides several amenities which saves you a trip to the store. Very beautiful apartment, fully stocked. Check in and check out was a contact free breeze. Host was communicative and helpful.
Cons: it's *somewhat* loud at night (it's NYC after all) which for some light sleepers might be an issue. Rachel provides ear plugs. Personally, I did not find any issues with it (even with construction happening on the week of my stay which is out of the host's control). Again, not an issue for me at all but if you're very picky and don't want to wear earplugs, heads up I guess.
Neither here nor there: Shower is in the main studio room so if there another guest you are staying with who you are not VERY comfortable with, they will need to sit in the very corner while you shower. So, only in that specific scenario is there potential for awakwardness and even then there is an easy workaround but heads up none the less, if you are reading reviews trying to decide.
In closing, I am very happy with my stay and found the apartment very clean and charming. When traveling I enjoy avoiding hotels if I can and staying like a local in a fun place and this hit the mark. Thanks again!