What can I say? After a seamless arrival into Manhattan (thanks to the detailed info on the airbnb listing) we were warmly welcomed by Ed into their beautiful Chelsea apartment, offered a glass of wine and some food, then enjoyed a thoughtful tour of the apartment. The room and bathroom clean, tasteful, quiet and very comfortable. The shared kitchen very spacious with a unique view of the Highline. The daily continental breakfast was an excellent way to start the day. I have to say that although the amenities are perfect they do not surpass the hosts, Art and Ed! We enjoyed every opportunity we had to talk to them. They are kind, intelligent, gracious and full of unique stories and excellent advice about their beloved city. We feel so fortunate to have stayed with them...I just cannot recommend their rental enough. Erin