We were very grateful to find Etta's apartment for our weekend in NYC - it is in a beautiful and pretty quiet area, very close to the subway.
The apartment is cute and dozy, and we had everything we needed. It was not what you'd call sparkling clean, but everything was very serviceable. The water pressure was good, the internet worked very well, etc. We didn't end up spending a lot of time in the apartment because we were busy being tourists, but it was a nice place to come back to to sleep. I will say that the mattress is very creaky, but we slept well.
Overall, despite any minor drawbacks, considering how difficult it is to find a place to stay, I think Etta's apartment was great value, and we'd be happy to come back there again!