I don't know what the previous reviewer (Jocelyn) could have been thinking. My wife and I have stayed in a couple dozen Airbnbs over the past few years, and Andrew's place was among the best of them. It was clean, comfortable, and (just like the listing says) charming and cozy. Couldn't imagine a better place to stay in NY/LES.
I'd specifically like to call out Andrew, along with his co-host Rachel, for their hospitality. They were extremely responsive as we coordinated how to pick up keys/etc., and provided a lot of very nice and thoughtful touches to help us feel at home in the apartment. You can tell they're real quality people.