Stay here. This is a well-run, well-maintained place, and Michelle is a knowledgeable, attentive host.
Top floor of a 4-floor lovely home. Shower water pressure great (give the hot water time), towels always available; hairdryer good quality. Bathrooms clean. Linens on the bed looked new, pillows fluffy. On firm-vs-soft, the mattress tends toward the latter. Neighbourhood is vibrant, varied and has many grocery shops nearby. Check-in (and out) a breeze.
For my stay, the other guests were quiet, though I could see how that could not be the case with less-than-conscientious guests, since noise can travel. (But I think Michelle is discerning in the stay requests she accepts.)
All in all, this spot, and Michelle as host, has the ratings it does for good reason.