We had a great stay - the location was perfect for us due to it's proximity to Columbia. The hosts were very kind and went above and beyond to accommodate my son as well when there was a gas leak at his apartment. This was our first time at NYC so we don't have any previous experience to compare against but I think this room is best for 1 person or a couple - very little room to move about, however this could be at par with other NYC apartments. The bathroom was clean and very well maintained though a minor addition of some kind of lotion would be wonderful, but no big deal.
The hosts were very nice and friendly but unfortunately we did not get enough time to interact with them much.
Their two dogs were cute and energetic, though I'm amazed how they can stay so quiet!
If we visit the area, we will be sure to stay again!