Pros: The location is convenient, host is responsive, and check-in is easy. It met my needs to be in the area.
Cons: There's not actually enough space for 3 people so I don't recommend this for more than 2 adults, light sleepers, or anyone planning to cook. You'll also just need to be mindful of older NY building issues like plumbing and take your trash out every day. You can keep stuff in the fridge but not the freezer (it's completely full of frost).