My girlfriend and I chose Poppy's place for our accommodation for our first anniversary trip (and my better half's first ever trip to the US, let alone NY), and it did not disappoint!
When we arrived somewhat earlier than anticipated (in part due to the easy transportation links from JFK), Poppy was more than happy to let us check in early. The apartment completely matched the description of a charming Brooklyn brownstone, and included a large kitchen and bathroom as well as the combined bedroom/lounge space (which had a large TV with Apple TV player to boot!). It was tastefully and comfortably furnished throughout, and suitably warm against the dump of snow that had come in over the previous weekend. The bathroom included all the essentials that a traveler might need, and the kitchen meant that we were able to cook to our heart's content.
Poppy was able to give us lots of helpful tips about how to get into the city from the nearby C-train and J/M-train subway stops, and continued to be very responsive both in person and on the app.
Pro Tip to future guests - with the diagonals of Broadway and Fulton St cutting across the block system, make sure to check your maps when coming from the subway to ensure you're not taking 2 sides of a triangle as we did!
All in all, I'd say that this is the best Airbnb I have stayed in to date, and a great place to base yourself, especially as a couple, if you want to explore New York.