As for the review, I would go for the excellent rating.

Booked this for friends for my wedding in Brooklyn. Overall a great experience and a good host. He even let my friends stay in the apartment until 4pm on the day they left which helped loads.

Only small downside was the apartment wasn't professionally cleaned before arrival but that is to be expected given its not a formal rental apartment.

Overall great location, good price and our friends said they would definitely stay there again.