We stayed at Scott’s for a week. The apartment is in a fantastic location in SOHO and we found getting around very easy. There were two subway stations in easy walking distance and you could connect to a number of the lines.
It is a 4th floor walkup, that’s over 50 stairs every time so definitely worth noting. It was a little tricky to get our large suitcases up and down but only had to do that one time each.
Scott organised for his housekeeper to meet us and give us the keys. He was quick with replies when we arrived in NYC about how we could access the apartment. No introduction to the apartment and the keys for each of the 3 locks weren’t explained but we figured it all out ourselves fairly quickly so not an issue.
The space was spacious for 2 people and bright with big windows. We liked the outlook and the views of the city. As other people have noted yes it is loud (traffic noise and car horns throughout the night) and yes it is bright. Bring earplugs and an eye mask if you are a light sleeper. The bed was on the smaller side as it has been noted before but we managed fine with 2 people. There is a large comfy couch as well (we didn’t test that for sleeping however). Big TV with lots of channels and good air con.
There was no hand soap or body wash in the bathroom so we had to buy some for the week.
One issue with no hairdryer which we required for an event. We ended up having to buy one after communicating with Scott about it. Scott reimbursed us for more than the cost the week after we had left.
Perhaps missing some of the usual touches that people may be used to with Airbnb but very very good value for NYC and overall a great space in a fantastic location.