Clean. Comfortable. Great location. Amazing hosts. 5 stars.
Absolutely amazing place. The space itself is stylish and comfortable; the appliances are all new and up to date. The location is great: parking is easy (just be mindful of street cleaning), the bus is literally outside their door, the train is a short walk away, and the grocery store is just down the street (but bring your own bags so you don't get charged for one - Cat thoughtfully provides some). And the area is safe; I traveled alone and ran around the neighborhood a few times and never felt uncomfortable.
The cherry on top during my stay was the hospitality that Cat and her partner provided. I cannot say enough great things about them; they truly made me feel like family during my stay. Cat was very responsive to my texts, in fact she was even proactive with regard to street cleaning and keeping me up to date on any changes there.
I am already recommending their place to my family and friends that visit NYC.