We had a great week and the apartment had all we needed. We were very happy! Metro is a short walk away, train goes all the way to Times Square. Apartment is cozy and there's lots of space.
Two minor things, both nothing the host could control: The Internet was down for the last day. And each step in the flat above is clearly audible, so it's not exactly quiet. But these are just minor things, overall we had a great stay!