Absolutely 5 stars for location if you want to be in the west Village. We loved staying here. Daniella was amazingly helpful. We had a health emergency and she helped us cancel and rebook. We will be forever grateful for her accommodation of our situation. Daniella responds very quickly and answers any questions. Her check in instructions were very clear.
Pros of this unit- location amazing, reasonable price for the expensive area, Very comfortable bed - yay! The unit is spacious - more than other ones I’ve been in in NY. Lots of closet and drawer space- it’s great to be able to unpack a suitcase. Surprisingly quiet for its location and the building is also quiet - only noisy one weekend night. There is a work station which is great if you are working remotely. Restaurants and shops galore. Very close to the subway. You can walk down Horatio right to the water in minutes and ride along the riverfront. Wi-Fi is good.
Cons- the unit could use some TLC. It’s an old building for sure so I always keep that in mind. Hard to clean these old places but it wasn’t very clean. Kitchen is very sparse. No microwave. So you can heat things in the oven except there are no pans to put in there. Bathroom is okay for size and the shower is good but leak under the sink and the shower/bath drain plugs up (we had to clean it out and plunge it) A couple extra towels would have been nice. The bathroom needs a bit of a spruce up - holes in walls and peeling bathtub surface and there were some grotty toiletry items left in the medicine cabinet.
These things are easy fixes which would make the place more appealing but they didn’t really affect our stay because the pros really outweighed the cons. I would stay again in a heartbeat because the whole village experience there was so great.