Pros: Location is amazing, lots of great places to eat and drink in the area. The place is exactly as describes, the apartment is quite large so lots of room, some dog hair but it is pet friendly which is why we initially chose this place although didn't end up bringing our pets. Everything you need is in the apartment. Easy lockbox entry, owner provides instructions well before arrival time. No a/c but has a wonderful breeze if you open all windows.
Cons: I believe construction is pretty typical of New York city, however they are literally building an apartment complex next to and behind this building, extremely noisy pretty much all day even on Saturday morning which was disappointing. No air-conditioning so later in the summer would be hard. The biggest frustration was the lock, the door doesn't actually lock, there is a gate that separates the business (lower floor) from the two apartments, so theres that but it was stressful knowing that the door was unlocked with all your stuff in the apartment. I didn't see any comments about this so be warned, I probably wouldn't stay here again just to avoid that stress.