We spent 5 nights at Rosaly's apartment and everything was fine! Room was clean and we felt comfortable there. Bathroom, that is shared with the whole family, was clean too. We appreciate that we could use also the kitchen. We barely saw Rosaly at home but we were often seeing her mother who was very kind. The only problem was that she didn't understand English. There lives also a little boy, who is loud sometimes even during night. It didn't bother us because we were tired after all day of walking and fell asleep easily, but someone may not like it. Apartment is close to subway, Whole Foods, Starbucks, Chipotle, etc... Overall we really enjoyed our holiday in NYC and we would definitely recommend accomodation at Rosaly's :)