If you want a true New York experience, book Troy's place. The location is right off Times Square, 15 minute walk to Central Park, 30 minute transit to Brooklyn Bridge and Statue of Liberty ferry. Very close to a ton of restaurants and bars.
Troy, was SO accommodating. He even carried our bags up to the apartment when we got there. He provided us with a multitude of amazing recommendations on things to do and places to eat.
The room was perfect for 2 people. The bed was very comfortable, and the en suite bathroom was furnished with every toiletry you could ever need. The room also had a sky light that was particularly cool at night, as you could see the changing lights of times square.
Over all, I wish I could give more than 5 stars!! I'll be staying here again on my next visit hands down!