Staying at Shaila & Alex's place was GREAT! Was not too far from numerous things and the communication and recommendations they provided was GREAT! We went to Brooklyn Cider House, Nana Ramen, Fat Doughnut, Turtles all the way down Bar, and Milk and Pull while we were in the area, all were AMAZING and walking distance from the brownstone.
I think the few cons we had were that in the morning (like 6AM), we could definitely hear what sounded like banging or cutting on a counter and pots clanking, in addition to a child crying and at times we could hear the conversations upstairs which would wake us up. In addition, there was one bathroom which was perfect and fine, however, I do wish there was a floor length mirror in the bedroom so two people could get ready at once in a more convenient way. HOWEVER, overall we had a really great time! We would definitely stay there again!