Nice room on 16th floor with a beautiful view over Empire State building. There was some noise from the trafic not much but you Could hear it all day also at Night . The lock to the door was not ok, you could easy open it with a nail from outside. The appartment was ok but a bit old. There was no lock on the door to the bathroom. The neighborhood was a bit boring with few bars, restaurant and supermarket. There was 500 m to the subway and 30 min walk to Penn station. So the location is ok. The host was very helpfull. We only saw him a couple times even though he has a room next door. In total a good place to stay if you only need a place to sleep.