I highly recommend John and Simone's place. It is not a surprise that John is Super Host status. The apartment was clean and comfortable. John was very welcoming, showed us the ropes at check-in and even waited to meet the 2nd part of our party who had a later flight so those of us that arrived early could catch a show. We had no issues during our stay but John made it clear that he would be available for any questions, etc.
The location made it easy to get to restaurants, shopping, and all sites of NY. There is a market around the corner, a great pizza place 2 blocks over and Barney Greengrass for bagels was about 6 blocks away. Several other options as well, all in walking distrance.
The beds were very comfortable with down blankets and the shower offered great water pressure and hot water! TV with cable though I don't think we turned it on after the first night. John has a great selection of books for anyone wanting to kick back for a night in. The space was a great size for the 5 of us. We will definitely be back next time we visit New York.
Oh, there is an adorable older dog that greeted us when we arrived. Sadly, that was the last time I saw him. He is very friendly and quiet and prefers to stays with his "people". I am allergic to dogs but had no issues with this one. - assuming it might be his breed - though, not sure what he is..