Agreeing with many reviewers here.
Pros - Location location location: steps from Central Park, subway, Whole Foods, walking to theater, and bars/restaurants in Hells Kitchen. Communication and check in was excellent. Apartment was quiet (except for radiator clanking) from street noise. Good price.
Cons - Space is classic NYC "snug". Living room is awkwardly set up and furniture desperately needs an update. There are windows but they are mainly of courtyards and not much light gets in. Rooms are overheated and need to crack a window, but that's NYC.