My daughter and I were in New York for college tours. Bill's apartment was perfect in every way: very pretty and impeccably clean; super-comfortable bed; deluxe appliances; large patio; close to subway; good (if gritty) neighborhood with shops, cafes and restaurants nearby. Bill was the perfect host, very responsive to all questions and concerns, left bottled water in fridge for us, plus shampoo, plenty of towels etc. great Airbnb experience, no negatives.