We adored this flat in the West Village. It's an older building and the entry/communal hallway felt somewhat run down (the tenant trash bins inside are unfortunate) but the apartment itself is decorated beautifully and has tons of charm. Very clean. The beds are comfortable and so many of the things you'll need (hair dryer, iron, even lotion) are already there for your use. The bathroom is very small but as three girls we utilized the many mirrors and outlets throughout the apartment to get ready. The neighborhood is perfection. Very safe and convenient. You're directly across the street from mundane necessities like Dunkin' Donuts, CVS, and the subway. And then you're surrounded by block after block of gorgeous West Village brownstones, restaurants, cafes, bars, etc. So many options!
We were out late most nights so didn't have a problem with the bar noise some of the other reviewers had.
Our hosts were very responsive. When the shower head broke, Neil came over within a reasonable window and did a temporary fix. They were lovely to work with.
I would highly recommend this rental to anyone!