There are no other words than AMAZING!
We rented it for a school trip in New York with a class of 7 students and we all loved it! At our arrival we had a problem with our luggage (it got lost in Iceland), and Elizabeth spent 3 days helping us out with it. She is really a fantastic hoast and always ready to help you out with things. The house is perfect for a big group of people and especially the little garden behind the house makes the stay really comfortable. One of the neighbours was listening to some soul/jazz music and it created a very cozy atmosphere.
There are really no negative points that I can tell! If I'm back in NY with a big group, I'll definitely rent it again :)