This was our first time using airbnb and I have to admit to being a little anxious about it. Our experience with both the airbnb process and with Susan's apartment was excellent. We are airbnb converts now, and recommend this economic and fun way to travel to everyone.
Susan's apartment is in a lovely area; it felt safe and quiet (well, as quiet as NY gets!) but was also very near to restaurants, bars and shops. The apartment was very clean, and the photos in the listing are a reliable representation. It was really nice having the whole place to ourselves (two adults and a child). We especially liked getting coffee and bagels and walking up to Central Park for breakfast, and sitting on the rooftop deck in the evening!
Susan's arrangements were simple and efficient, and worked very well for us. This was a perfect home from home and we hope to stay here again.