We chose Barbara's place because of the location and reviews. It's a block away from Prospect Park and the subway is around the corner, so coming and going from Manhattan was easy. That said, people who do not like noise are going to find it unpleasant as it is a busy neighborhood with constant traffic. However, Barbara is such a lovely host, we felt like visiting relatives, leaving us coffee and bites for breakfast and basically letting us be. She provided us with maps and other info, along with snacks and water to grab should we need it. All in all a comfortable stay.