I thought this was quite a good deal for NY. I've stayed in 8-10 airbnbs in the city and thought this was one of the best deals from a value-for-money standpoint. It's a little further out from the city than many spots, but I enjoyed the quiet neighborhood. Still plenty of amenities right near by. I stayed during an intense cold spell and there was an issue with my room being warm enough but Shuly addressed the situation immediately. There are other renters, but they were quiet and I had no issues. The house is renovated, nicely decorated and very clean. I imagine it's even nicer in the summer and fall. Overall I thought it was a terrific value and would definitely stay again.