John's place was perfect. He was very accomodating with getting us a key, even when he found out our flight didn't get in until after midnight! His place was very clean and well taken care of. He has really great taste. I loved the art and decorations around the apartment. The 5 story walkup helped us burn off all of the amazing NY meals we had. Elizabeth is one of my favorite streets in NY. It is super cute with lots of shops and restaurants close by as well as walking distance to a number of other neighborhoods and trains. I hope his place is available the next time I am in NY!