Great location for my daughter and I. Very close to Madison Square Garden, Penn Station, and subway. We also walked to Times Square daily.
Note that this apartment is on the third floor in a building without an elevator. This was not a problem at all for my daughter and I, but if you have issues with stairs and/or getting luggage up and down, you may want to consider staying elsewhere.
The apartment was clean with good wifi and work space. The rooftop garden had amazing views at night. The bed was small but comfortable. We didn't realize until our last night that the couch was actually a sofa bed, LOL! I guess we'll know for next time because we will definitely be back!