We loved staying at Natalia and Serge's place. Although I grew up in NYC, never had a chance to really visit SI before, except to take the ferry back and forth as a child, and then with my kids.
SI was a great base to visit from. We loved taking the ferry each day into Manhattan, with the great views of the city and Statue of Liberty. And then back again at night for a equally stunning night view of the skyline.

The house is historic and grand, with an labyrinth of rooms and doors, and some wonderful furniture. There was room for 8 of us, and it was certainly a bargain for that many.

I highly recommend both the home and staying in Staten Island, for a different and convenient NYC experience.