I had a fabulous stay in Gary's apartment. The check in was so easy and the apartment has the most brilliant location and is stylish and comfortable.
I had no problem with the sounds from 7th Avenue that some others have mentioned. If anything I found it a pleasant background (quiet) noise. The bed was incredibly comfortable and it was a pleasure to come back to after a long day out in the city. I had the best sleep I've had in ages.

I can't really emphasise enough how incredible the location is. Your right in the heart of gorgeous Greenwich Village and a short walk from Washington Square/ Soho/ Chelsea /The High Line etc..and a 10 min subway ride right into Times Square.

I'd book it again in a heartbeat and plan to do so next time I visit NYC

Be warned though, being 2 blocks from Magnolia Bakery is lethal!