I'll start with the positives. The apartment is clean and bright, and located in a quiet, lovely neighborhood near Carl Schurz park and lots of great restaurants. Comfortable bed, and good pressure in the shower. A management company takes care of the details, so communication is relatively good. Now for the downsides. The apartment itself is not very quiet. The walls are so thin you can hear people in the neighboring apartments, both from the living room and the bedroom. One could remedy this issue by being out in NYC all day and using ear plugs at night. Another issue was that "hotel-style amenities" were offered in the listing but not provided. This was Rishi's first time hosting, so it's possible he forgot them. But he really should have cleared his stuff out of the closets. There was no space to store our clothes and luggage, and no hooks for coats or other items. Ultimately our biggest issue with the apartment was building security. Next time we will book a place with a doorman.