Benjamin's is great, about three blocks from Utica subway station, allowing you access to everywhere via the subway system. The roommates were great, Pedro was kind enough to share his wine even when we had made a poor choice on ours.
Tip: get a roommate's phone number if Benjamin isn't there when you are staying. I left my jacket in a cab one night which had the keys in the pocket, fortunately the downstairs neighbour was able to let us in (thanks Casey!).