Stayed at Andy's place with a group of friends to celebrate my 40th birthday and couldnt have picked a better location. Plenty of space for 5 adults. We never felt crowded or on top of each other. Andy was very hospitable, leaving a celebratory spread of snacks and bevvies, allowed for early drop off of my bags (even though i didnt end up needing it) and even allowed for delivery of a birthday gift sent from one of my friends!
The only little issue brought up by some of the guests was being able to hear the walking/running and moving of things upstairs in the early morning hours. So if you are a light sleeper you may want to bring some ear plugs. But if you can sleep through early morning raucous like me (mom of 3 boys) then you'll be fine!
Close to the Q and the 2/3 its a straight shot into Manhattan and Times Square. If im ever in NY again with a large group, I'd definitely stay here again!