We've rented places all over the world and Amanda and Tanya were the best hosts ever--answered queries quickly, greeted us warmly, and left us an amazing array of snacks. They're thoughtful in every way. City Island's a good distance from midtown Manhattan but it's charming and friendly and much cooler than the city in summer. The cottage itself isn't fancy but it has a history and its own charm--it feels roomier than the pictures suggest, with an especially big kitchen, and we were completely comfortable there.