We loved this place - my two teen sons and I stayed 4 days on our first visit to NYC. Things we loved about it are the cozy, homey feeling; the ease of getting into Manhattan and around NYC in general (1 minute walk to the station, where you can catch subway and elevated trains virtually anywhere.you want to go). The beds are comfy and the apartment is well-equipped. There were tons of restaurants and easy walking distance from the apartment, but we didn't find any that really excited us. Worth a trip to Astoria or further for really great food options.
The only issue we had was low-water pressure in the shower, which Sally said wasn't typical and might have been because there was an unusual draw on the water. we don't think others would experience this issue.
Sally herself was a delight and treated us like family. She even sent the boys with a bag of cookies on the plane ride and we had several engaging conversations with her while we were there.
We'd definitely return!