It looked like somebody had attempted to clean the place but left it halfway there. There was dirt on the floor, chips on the sofa between the cushions, the dishes were half-washed, the towels smelled like humidity...
The listing was advertised as a place for 6, indicating that there were two beds for two couples and a sectional sofa for an additional two people. I assumed the sectional was also a sofabed (my mistake), but there was no way two adults could sleep together in the sectional. When I contacted Abby, she told me that technically the description was correct, as two people could sleep there, which was definitely not true. We ended up having to buy an air mattress for one of the people in our group to sleep on. She mentioned she would change the description listing to 4 people, so this might be moot
Beyond that, the rooftop was unkept: the barbecue grill was covered by a broken fabric that had puddles of water on it, the plastic chairs had been sunburned, there were several cigarette butts on multiple ashtrays, nobody had swept the place, etc. The rooftop is divided into several sections, one for each apartment in the building, and most of the others looked much better, at least from the outside.
The kitchen is advertised as fully equipped for entertaining, but that is also far from true. There are barely any wine glasses, there are a handful of (varied) forks, only 3 or 4 knives, only 4 large plates...
From the list of amenities, there is no gym beyond the weights and yoga mats and there also is no iron.
The apartment is located in a fairly nice area in Brooklyn, and the building itself is quite nice.
If you are not looking to fit more than 4 people and are not planning on eating in much or entertaining, this is a very good place to stay at. The biggest downsides of the place itself were that it was not as clean as it should have been and that the rooftop was not usable. The apartment itself really is beautiful and generally well kept.