Pros:
Good value (of course relative to our budget)
10 min walk from Penn Station
Friendly and flowing reception, accommodating staff
Elegant and comfortable modern design
Several lounging areas
Efficiently street-sound proofed rooms
Quasi full wall-size panoramic window pane
Cleanliness and quality materials (Beddings, Towels, Toilet, Shower, Lighting, Flat screen, etc.)
Practical electro tech
Very well thought out use of movement and storage space in the room
Comfortable firm mattress
An overall feeling of being generously welcomed
Con:
I wish we could control the temperature in the room.
Not Arlo’s fault, but the disregard and vulgarity of some guests:
The description on the AirB&B website states that no pets are allowed, yet the first of the two nights we stayed in the hotel was ruined by the incessant howling and barking of a dog that some guest must have left in the room while they were out partying.
The second night was more briefly ruined by a guest howling and throwing up their excess alcohol.
What can you do! Humans!
Aside from those mishaps which can happen randomly anywhere, overall, we highly recommend this hotel.