We (3 friends) spent one night here while visiting New York on a weekend. It was a very cozy place, but it got a little crowded for such small living quarters, especially in the morning when everyone had to use the restroom. But the hostess was accommodating and kind, and even offered us coffee and tea in the morning. Everyone we shared the place with (2 other guests, the host's daughter and her friend) were very friendly. Also, there was a cat that roamed freely around the apartment and may keep your feet warm at night (which was definitely a plus to us).
The place was clean and the neighbourhood it was situated in was less touristic, while still offering plenty in terms of places to eat and drink. We had a fun evening, and a nice breakfast the next day in the area. So if you don't mind being at quite a distance from NY city center and the dorm-style arrangement, we would recommend it.