Sandy was a great host in NYC! She met us upon arrival at her apartment and the both our bedroom and her apartment were very clean. We had our own room with a key for our door so we could lock up our belongings and access to the entire condo. Location is also good in, you are 15-20 minutes walk or commute to most of the place you'd want to see in NYC, and areas like SOHO, little Italy are very walkable.
The only drawbacks to the place are the obvious & are stated in the listing - you are sharing the apartment with other people (one tennant and one other room rented to an airbnb guest). Our experience wasn't bad having others around, but you never know what you'll get I suppose.
Overall, would definitely stay again given the savings relative to some other NYC listings!