Zuffina's place has a good sized living room, which is the highlight of the property, and hence you get a fair bit of space. However the apartment is chock-full of the owners possessions, so there is almost no space to hang your clothes or put things away. We booked a bit last minute (about 1 month before staying) so there wasn't much choice available.
The area is fine, is it just off a main street - we stayed for a week, and some nights were a bit noisy. It was great to have Central Park a short walk away, and its feasible to walk from the apartment through the park to the museums in less than an hour. Subway takes about 30 minutes to get downtown, and there are some nice restaurants in the area meaning you can eat locally some evenings after a long days sightseeing.
Overall Zuffina's place is an OK budget-end Airbnb.