I suppose the best review one can give is to say next time I am in NYC, I will stay here again if it is available.
The host communicates effectively. The location is excellent if you are looking for that area of the City. The house is 150+ years old so that adds to its character almost as much as the owner has.
I’d live there in heartbeat but if you want the Hilton then your tastes and mine differ, that is merely an observation not an editorial.
The host states up front she does not interfere or necessarily interact with guests but if you need anything including transportation tips etc. she is completely accessible.
It is very reasonably priced, in fact from my past experiences in the city I consider it a value.