I'd recommend it a 100%. The place in itself is clear and clean. It has everything you might need for your stay, as well as kind thoughts through items, brownies,..
The house is about 15mins away from the ferry to Manhattan by bus, which is not much. It is located in a peaceful neighbourhood.
On the other hand, Carrie and Ken are two sweet people who will care about their host and suggest you places to visit or to eat. If you need anything, just ask.
Besides, Carrie is easy to reach through the app.
As our first Airbnb, it was an excellent experience and we enjoyed this place which felt a bit like home.