My wife and I stayed here during our NYC trip for our anniversary. Favorite things included the proximity to Broadway, Central Park and decent restaurants and grocery. I guess the only negative thing I can think of is that, even though the street below is a small one, there's still some noise at night. Of course, this is coming from someone who lives in a place with virtually NO street noise.
Oh, one other thing I liked was that there's a train that goes directly from JFK to a station very close by. Switching trains with luggage is no fun so that was a plus.
Ana was a great host. She communicated with us well and gave us some hints on where to go in the neighborhood. The place was clean and well stocked.