I highly recommend staying at Jamie's place. It has all you need for a nice stay in NYC, including a full kitchen and a good elevator!
1.) Cleanliness. Jamie’s place IS scrupulously clean-bathroom, kitchen, bed, towels- everything!
I stay at many Airbnbs in Manhattan and Europe and cleanliness is not always a given since you are living in someone's personal home-no worries here.
2.) Jamie is a superior host. Great communication and very responsive. Sincerely friendly and helpful.
3.) Location- very close to Penn Station (Easily walkable with my 2 pieces of rolling luggage.) with multiple options for affordable train to airport and subway system. Many restaurants and grocery stores in the area. I felt very safe and actually did a lot of walking- even at night.