First of all, I put 3 stars to our stay, but I could have put 2 or 4 stars. Edward is a really kind person, he really takes care of his guests. But the apartment is not so good ! The appartment is really dark, there are few cockroaches, the bathroom is quite old and not so perfectly clean! BUT, the apartment has a great location and for this price you can't find any hotel in NYC. For students, it's a quite good location !