Mahbuba's apartment worked very well for us.
A nice bonus was nice the fire hydrant out front for loading and unloading.
Hot water and water pressure was great. We hardly needed heat, but that was also nice. We did not use the stove, but we used the hot-pot, microwave and coffee-maker every day.
I gave 4 stars on cleanliness because people coming from outside New York City should understand that it is very hard to keep anything clean in NY. The living space, kitchen, bathroom and bedrooms were spotless. Only the stairs and window glass were not spotless. I only say this because when you rent Mahbuba's apartment do not be disappointed with anything. The living space was very clean.
Beds were very comfortable.
There was the usual NYC street noise but this is a quieter than average side-street. One bedroom faces the street and the other bedroom faces the backyards.
It would be our pleasure to stay with Mahbuba again.