Alan is a extremely thoughtful and kind host who goes out of his way to assist guests and make their stay as good as possible. The apartment is lovely with renovated bathroom and good kitchen, beds etc. The location is good as it's very close to a subway line, but it is a little far if you plan to spend a lot of time in upper Manhattan in the museums and galleries. However value wise it is way better place than staying in a hotel or another airbnb place closer to uptown Manhattan. Really felt great staying in the apartment.