There's good and bad news.
The good: Johnny is a nice guy and was accommodating in allowing me to drop my bags off early. He also volunteered to carry my bag up the 3 flights of stairs. The location is also great, and the price is reasonable for this location.
The bad: It was extremely hot, and most of the apartment was not air conditioned, only my tiny room. So, I would get drenched with sweat from walking up the stairs and even just going to the bathroom or grabbing a snack. Obviously, this would only be an issue in the summer. The room was also very small and dark and (to me, admittedly not used to NYC apartments) kind of depressing.