It was cozy, central, 20 mins from nyc and exactly what we could have wanted. The bed was comfy, our host was responsive and everything was so convenient. I couldn't have asked for a better place.
The downside is that the neighbors were incredibly noisy blasting music and you could hear absolutely everything. I will add that it was New Years weekend and hopefully they are not like that other times of the year.
Regardless, it's nyc and you can't anticipate neighbors to be quiet. It's not the woods after all.
Thanks to the host for being wonderful and addressing every issue! It was so clean and comfy. I will be coming back every time I visit NYC!