Pros: lots of closet space, plenty of towels (though only the one bathroom), close to the water, a solidly short walk to the subway station. Host was very responsive when there were hiccups. Quiet (for NYC) and big for an NYC apartment.
Cons: advertised as two fulls and one queen bed but the number of beds is actually four. The “queen” is really a twin with a trundle bed underneath. Can’t even shove them together to make a wonky single bed because they are different heights and having the trundle bed pulled out traps the people sleeping in the other bed in the room (not enough space to even awkwardly get by). So that was disappointing, since we were three couples travelling together and a couple just…didn’t get to share a bed, one person was in the living room with the trundle.
Also one of the bed rooms does NOT have AC or a fan, so that’s a choice between comfort and the privacy of a closed door.