We ended up booking the Magnolia House at the last minute due to some unexpected changes to our previous accommodations. We could not have asked for a better experience. First, the hosts, Darwin and Danforth were absolutely wonderful. Danforth greeted us and immediately gave us a tour of the home. Afterwards, he walked with us toward the ferry and gave us thorough directions to get to Manhattan. The house itself was so comfortable and also eclectic. It was really a great get away after a long day of conferencing. Breakfast in the morning was also great. Darwin was a fantastic breakfast host. If staying in Staten Island I would definitely stay at Magnolia House again. Quite honestly, this has been one of the best AirBnb's I have had to date.