We stayed at Marina's place for Columbus Day weekend for a family wedding. The price was great, the house was HUGE and very very clean. We had 8 people total (4) couples...and we all fit super comfortably, each bedroom was nice (so no one had to fight over who got the best room!). Although there is one AMAZING master bedroom with a huge bathroom and jacuzzi...which my husband and I luckily got since we booked the place. There are also 4 bathrooms which was great with this many guests. We all played pool at night and listened to music (they have a nice speaker set up). The house is fully stocked with supplies (no need to bring any dishes, linens, hair dryers, irons...they have it all!)
There is a tenant that lives in an apartment attached to the house, which we were unaware of when we booked, but fortunately there we no issues (and we tend to be a bit loud). So no worries there!
We would definitely stay here again if we are ever back in Staten Island, I highly recommend!