The positive:
Accurate pictures, great location 2 blocks from the metro and Sonia responds fast on the app.
The negative:
Cleanness, the bathroom was filthy and rusty. When we arrived, they started "cleaning" the bathroom which was just Lysol and Clorox spray. The sink had no water, so we had to fill with water a glass from the kitchen and take it to the bathroom to brush our teeth. There were like 4 soap bars all over the bathroom from previous guest, some of those bars had hairs on them. If the place is shared, there should be a dispenser. There was fungus and mold in the faucet and other parts, which says that there is rarely, or never, a deep cleaning of the bathroom. The house had a funky smell, once again of lack of regular cleaning. Our bedroom smelled like armpit. There was a second bathroom in the first floor that was "under repair" but I believe it has been like that for a while, the host don't prioritize the well being of the spaces for their guest.
There were 2 host, Brian and Sonia and they just screamed at each other, for me it was kind of funny but for my parents not so much.
If the place was cheaper I would have passed it by, but not good value for your money if you expect at least a decent place.
VERY NOISY at night since there is a train rail one block away, if you are a light sleeper its an issue.
Overall, if I was traveling by myself as a 28 year old I would be more relax, but I was taking my parents (60ys) for their first time to NY and they felt disgusted by the state of the house.