This air bnb is in a prime location for a great NYC price. What I think wasn't clear is that you're not staying with the host, but in an apartment where two other rooms are also being rented out.
For me, this was not good as I had consciously picked a female host as I feel most comfortable staying with other women. My first day checking in I was directed by Bobbi to a room, and when I opened the door there was a guy in his boxers in there. Wrong room! It was a strange experience staying with fellow travelers of which I didn't even know the names. After a few days a new man with odd behavior appeared, without any warning from the host that a new person was moving in. I felt on edge the whole time and need to write this so others know what to expect.
For pros, Bobbi was very responsive. The home was clean and amenities great. The check in experience was bad, there weren't any keys in the lock box as promised and I had to go wait 2 hours at a nearby restaurant for Bobbi to come drop off keys. Had I not had a friend with a US phone number meeting me, I wouldn't have been able to contact the host during the arrival.