We have traveled to NYC many times in the past, but we always stayed in Manhattan because of the convenience. I decided to give Forest Hills/Queens a try this time to keep our road trip budget in check. Cathy's basement is an absolute gem! We have found our go-to spot for all future visits to the area. What we liked:
1. Safety--we felt very comfortable walking the entirety of the neighborhood and leaving our car with out-of-state plates on the street for three days (other than moving the car for the street sweeper, we never used it while we were there).
2. Comfort--after long days in Manhattan, we enjoyed coming back to our room and settling in for a quiet night. The kitchen table was especially nice for when we ate in our room. I liked the pillows on the bed so much that I made note of the brand! It was a hot week in the area, but we had no issues with the temperature and felt comfortable throughout.
3. Location--I was worried that the distance would be a nuisance, but the subway station was a pleasant stroll away (you can also catch a bus close to Cathy's house to get there), and we found the F-train to be an easy way to reach the places we wanted to visit. Subways were frequent, and there are plenty of Express options to limit stops. We also had easy access to convenience stores and restaurants if we wanted anything while we were at "home."
4. Host--Cathy is a super host and was very accommodating to our needs at the end of an extensive road trip. I thoroughly enjoyed my interactions with her but also appreciated the privacy she afforded us throughout our stay.
I am done with Manhattan hotels and their "extras" (resort fees, parking fees, etc.). Cathy's spot is perfect for people who want to visit Manhattan but want to do so at a reasonable cost with some creature comforts. We will be back!