For me this was great, as I know the neighborhood well. The apartment is especially appealing because of all the light from huge windows. The terrace is huge, and part of this apartment, not accessible to others,you will find. And in good weather you can stay outside a lot. There is also a gigantic roof space with chairs, tables, umbrellas etc with easy elevator access. Beds and bedding are perfect, and the other resident, Lana, washes dishes and launders towels etc. Fridge has plenty of room for your food purchases. Shopping is terrific, both at the great Zabars, a couple of clocks away, and at West Side Market. Restaurants of many kinds abound. Lincoln Center is two stops away on the 1 train, theater district just a bit farther, and the Met Museum just across the park on the M86 bus. All is secure here, both in the neighborhood and the building. Andrey is available by phone, and is responsive to any questions or needs.
I took a chance because there no reviews yet. (He just started on airbnb.) My fingers were crossed, and my gamble was rewarded. One caution: If you are one of those renters who like to engage and socialize with the host, this will not be for you, as Lana has limited English, and does not have local information to share. She is a resident, and is helpful about how things work, but her personal time is not part of the package.