Had most wonderful experience with Caitlin in the Upper West Side. The room and the flat are exactly as described and in the pictures - charming, tidy, clean and spacious - perfect abode for anybody who is looking to rest after an eventful day in the surrounding that are pleasing aesthetically. The neighbourhood is great, only a few min walk from the subway, a throw away from the glorious Central Park, with pubs, bars, burger places, noodle bars, all kind of shops shops, delis, foods stores, bakeries, old bookshops and even those looking for a bargain designer find will not be disappointed. Caitlin herself is lovely, very knowledgeable, great personality and full of tips for anybody looking to discover New York. This was my first trip to this amazing place and usually when you go somewhere as much hyped about as NYC there is bound to be 50% so so experience but I am pleased to say for me it was 110% amazing and the place where I stayed certainly had an impact. Thank you Caitlin for beautiful memories.