My son and I stayed at Tony and Micah's apartment while we attended a basketball tournament at Barclays Arena in Brooklyn. We were extremely pleased with the space. It was clean and well furnished; had comfortable beds, a well-equipped kitchen, small but nice bathroom and tub/shower, very good WiFi and TV, and excellent security. I have no complaints about the apartment. Multiple reviews I read before renting mentioned the rumble and noise of the nearby subway. The "noise" was almost inaudible, and the "rumble" did not affect our experience at all. I suppose if you are super-sensitive to such things you may want to consider another place, but my experience is there is noise and rumble of traffic and trains all over NYC and finding a totally quiet place could be difficult.