Overall great value in New York. 10-minute walk to subway, then about 30 minutes to Manhattan. Hosts are very nice and they were flexible in accommodating my late checkout.
The only con for me was that it felt like someone was living there the day before we checked in: fridge was 3/4 full with food, freezer filled to the brim, the 3 closets in the home were all locked, and the host’s stuff was everywhere. We were there for almost a week, so this was inconvenient. This can be fixed by the host easily, otherwise it’s a great deal.