Our stay at Carl's apartment exceeded all expectations! The apt. was just as advertised, very clean, and you cannot beat the location. You also can't beat the host!

Pros:
LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION! Walk to Times Square, Rockefeller Center, Central Park, Radio City Hall, all Broadway shows, and much more;
Clean apt., clean sheets, clean towels;
Fabulous kitchen/bathroom with everything you might need;
Carl (host)! - Inviting, clear, prompt, friendly. Carl provided a list of restaurants, rooftop bars, bars and friendly travel tips for the neighborhood - what more could ask for??

Cons:
No cons to this apartment. One word of advice would be to bring ear plugs if you are a light sleeper, but this goes for any apt. in NYC - you're just going to get street noise when you stay in such a great location.

If you're looking to stay in NYC - this is your spot! Enjoy!!