Short:
Pros: space, kitchen, backyard
Cons: location, furniture, cleanliness
Long:
Pros: When my husband and I first arrived we loved the amount of space we had for the price. The kitchen was beautiful, too. We cooked breakfast one morning and everything was great. Our last night we are a meal in the backyard, something I didn't think existed in New York City!
Cons: I did not feel the price reflected the location: distance from attractions, restaurants, grocery stores, etc. Other B&B's in better locations like Chelsea, downtown Brooklyn, and Williamsburg are the same price. The couch and bed were very uncomfortable (we had to see the chiropractor after getting home). The curtains were not conducive to a private bedroom. Finally, the floors were dirty when we got there, like it hadn't been swept in a couple weeks.