Ed and Art are warm, responsive and well-prepared hosts and their place is the most amazing comfy clean spacious artistic well-decorated centrally-located penthouse apartment in all of New York City. They communicated well and clearly about checkin; they provided clean linens and brand new *individually wrapped* toothbrushes (Ed is a Dentist so I guess dental hygiene is a passion of his); coffee, cereal and fresh fruit were laid out every morning; and they each told me neighborhood tips and interesting anecdotes. Ask Ed to show you the view from the roof!