I live in nyc and rented Katie’s apartment for an out of town guest. It was perfectly clean, great location, Katie responds almost immediately to any questions.
A note about some of the negative reviews here: NYC, and The Lower East Side particularly, is a loud and dirty place full of all the good and bad things that come with being in the city.
That said, Katie’s apartment is clean, and quiet compared to some other NYC apartments I’ve stayed in. Highly recommend.