I picked this place because I needed somewhere for my in laws to stay in the area. It is near amazing savings and works for a shabbos user. There are separate keys despite needing a smart phone for the doors during the week (it could be he could work it out if you didn't have one).
I can't tell you much about the inside because my in laws were there but it seemed fine.
We had a problem with the doors checking in. The code that we got an email for only works for the 2nd floor door (where the apartment is). My father in law stood outside for an hour and a half trying the app on the outside door which is a simple button code (which we were not given until we called). Once my father in law gave up on it, he called me and I came over. It took me five minutes till I realized that there was steps to the actual door and this must be a separate code. I called the owner and got through after several calls and he gave the code right away. It could be I missed it in his email but I never saw it...
Also, a big one is that there was no AC in the second bedroom which was really big. There also wasn't in the kitchen but that is more standard for new york. My sister in laws slept in there at night and it was HOT but they couldn't rest in there during the day. Probably not a problem in the winter but still. To be fair, I never asked the owner about this since I found out about it after the weekend as my in laws didn't want to burden us with it during our celebration. Could be it is temporary despite not saying so in the listing.
Lastly, Im giving it 3 stars instead of 1-2 despite these big things because I think it's a solid Airbnd and would use it again if I knew about these things before. Especially if the AC in the bedroom was fixed. There was nothing wrong with the actual accommodation itself.
Oh, and there wasn't soap there according to my in laws but it could be they wanted more than an All in one soap...not sure.