It's hard to beat this location at this price - fifteen minute walk from Penn Station, a block from the 4/5/6, and a relatively quiet neighborhood after dark. Elliot keeps his space clean - we had a clean room with fresh sheets and a newish window unit. Bathroom was clean and uncluttered. Remember that this is a New York apartment! If you aren't used to a subdivided apartment, it may feel cramped; but what you're getting is location! Pro tip: hot water in the shower is on the right, and it's threaded backward :)