Drew and his co-host Migan were great hosts - very responsive, friendly, left helpful instructions and recommendations for things to do, places to eat, etc. They even left a bottle of champagne! Great location, just a block from Madison Square Garden, Penn station, and the Moynihan Train Hall. The unit was quiet and very spacious which is nice to have in NYC.
Other than that, it was OK. It was very old and very worn. The mattresses were firm. The spiral staircase creaks, some lights didn't work, not a huge deal. But the unit was very HOT (we stayed in Dec). I'm a small petite woman who gets cold very easily but I was sweating in there. The heat is controlled by the building so we couldn't adjust it. We ended up sleeping downstairs with the patio doors open.
The bathroom was the worst part - the bathmat was dirty, there was hair in the shower drain, the shower made a very loud noise when first turned on every morning, the sink was dusty and very small (not much counter space at all)