When you write "Would stay there again", i think it's often just said, but not done. I stayed here again, and it was as great as the last time. Clean and nice rooms. Friendly check-in (we had to leave earlier than anticipated, so we didn't checked out with them). Public Transport ist great. You don't need a rental car there, as with the A and C lines you are really fast in Manhattan ( i would use A from Utica when you want to be in the city fast , and C to Ralph Ave. back when you have walked miles) . I would definitely stay there a third time.