We stayed in Chesters apartment for ten nights. The apartment is very clean and spacious. Also easy to reach by subway, which is four blocks away.
Two blocks away there's a big grocery, and there are deli's almost on every corner which is convenient if you need something when you get back late at night.
We had a great time in NYC (our first time) and staying in the apartment. A month before our trip our initial apartment was cancelled by that host, so we were relieved we could book another apartment on such short notice. This apartment was a bit further from Manhattan though. The neighborhood is fine, we never felt unsafe, most nights we got home around/after midnight. It might be a bit noisy during weekendnights (especially when the weather is good, as it was during our trip) because the neighbors like to hang outside and play music. But we were so tired that it didn't keep us up at night. One time the Wifi was down, but Chester fixed that quite fast. Chester was very friendly and let us know during our stay that we could get fresh linen if we needed to.
Final verdict: if you don't mind traveling a bit longer to Manhattan, and don't mind some music at the weekends it's a great place to stay!