Overall it was a great value for NYC! It was warm and cozy (even on some very rainy days), the owners were very communicative with any issues, and it's just a six minute walk to the subway.
A couple things to note if you're considering the place: the pull out couch is really uncomfortable so I wouldn't plan on having someone use that. They won't sleep well. If you plan to go into the city, it'll take you 45 minutes to an hour via subway. We knew that and planned for it but it might be a rude surprise if you're not familiar with the area. The place is next to Little Caribbean so there are a lot of great Caribbean hole-in-the-wall spots. But if you're not an adventurous eater, and don't want to cook at the Airbnb, you'll have mainly pizza and fried chicken to choose from.
Overall we had a good stay. Thanks!