Pros: price, cleaniness, privacy, great hosts. Great location! You can’t beat the price when hotels in manhattan for one night were $300+
Cons: train track noise. To give you perspective, the train is so close you can even hear the voice over when the train opens and closes. The house faces the train tracks. Trains run 24/7. We did eventually fall asleep but it was much louder than anticipated.
Bring earplugs and you should be fine! Can’t beat the price and location!