This is a basement apartment below a cafe/restaurant so don't expect much natural light. Overall, my experience was okay. There was a strange, musty odor during my stay, throughout the apartment. Also, the inside of the lockbox was dirty/wet which caused the keys to be dirty/wet when I picked them up. While the light in the hall outside the apartment was a functional motion sensor, there are two doors into the apartment itself and the light between those doors did not work. The apartment was clean but not spotless. The amenities within the apartment were as listed and of decent quality. I stayed on a Friday night and there was also significant noise from above during the night, which might be an issue for some guests. Parking can be difficult around this area, if driving. The close proximity to Penn Station is a major plus. I would not personally choose to stay here again as I believe there are better options nearby at a similar price point.