Pros:
- 3 shared bathrooms/toilet;
- helpful host and quick responses;
- well organized;
- close to penn station, in 30 min. at most you are in downtown manhattan;
- close to a wondeful mexican restaurant;
- clean place;
- provided shower gel.
Cons:
- it's undoubtedly closer to a hostel than to an airbnb: the comfort of your stay mostly depends on the other guests (for instance, during our stay, at midnight one of the other guests was yelling at the phone);
- the room is not like the one you see in the pictures: there is no sofa, but only two separate beds (we didn't manage to lift the second bed from the ground, so it was pretty much like a futon);
- AC was really noisy;
- expensive for what you get.