Overall it was a good stay and worth the price but here are the pros and cons. Also, it was our first time doing airbnb so not much to compare it to! We did go to the city for entire day and were only here in the morning and at night.

Pros:
*Sylwia let us drop off our bags early and we saw she was cleaning and washing the sheets which made me feel happy about that
*There were good food options nearby (NY bagel, The coffee shop, Dunkin Donuts) when we needed breakfast before heading to the city

Cons:
*The walk to the PATH is not that short. There were several times where we got a cab or UBER because it was very cold out and the 15 walk would be too much. The first portion of the walk feels safe but towards the end I did not feel that as much at night only. If you are going to NYC everyday though, the PATH is essential and is quick once you are on it. You can get off on 33rd Street as the last stop.
*Every morning we were there we were woken by loud talking/yelling in a foreign language. Every time around 9-9:30 am. They weren't even trying to be quiet. Not sure if it was them or other airbnb guests though but it was loud and annoying.

Night time was very quiet and peaceful though it was very hot in the room. We would wake up sweating. I'm sure we could've asked about it but we were out as soon as we were up and showered but just in case you will be in the room you can ask her about it.
Sylwia was also nice enough to let us alter our stay 2 days before and cancel our last day so we could stay in the city for our last night since we wanted to be as close as we could to everything. Overall it was a good experience and if you are like us- with a lot to do in the city- you will barely find yourself in the room.