When I first saw this listing, I thought "what is the catch?" The brownstone exterior pictured was beautiful, as were the shots of the interior bedrooms. My expectations were high and since this was a surprise trip for my adult daughter for her birthday.
PROS:
When we arrived, the exterior was EXACTLY as it was pictured. As we entered the foyer area my heart sank a little as we saw construction materials and some of the areas that were being prepared for repair. I had hoped everything would be perfect. However, once we reached the third floor (we had the entire floor), we were all so impressed the entryway was completely forgotten. The rooms were perfect! Each room had a fireplace and it's own A/C unit. The beds were so comfortable we all slept perfect every night. As an avid reader, I pictured Jo March from Little Woman sitting in my room composing a letter or an article for publishing. The vintage furniture was beautiful and comfortable. Although we didn't use the kitchen, the fridge was stocked with water bottles fr us. We were so thankful for those cold waters! Manuel was so fast to respond to all of my questions. His sister, who lives on site, was so fast and courteous helping us with all our questions. We had the perfect stay. Even though this is in New Jersey, it was no problem getting to NYC taking the trains. This was an EXCELLENT stay! I will always check availability of Manuel's apartment anytime I return to NYC.
CONS:
The neighborhood is very nice, however, two streets over, not so much. We felt very comfortable walking to the Lite Rail in the morning, but always took an Uber from the Lite Rail to the apartment each night. The apartment is in New Jersey, which is actually a pro. However, the Exchange Place depot is closed on the weekends and starting July 2019, Garfield Street Stop (closest to the apartment) will be closed every day. As long as you are mindful of these closures beforehand you can plan for that.