Amy's place is wonderful! It is spacious and has almost everything in it -- it felt like home. Everything is high quality, from the bed, the sheets, etc. It is also very clean. The location is a little further from New York if you are looking to go to the city -- it might take around 1 hour with public transportation. During our time there, we mostly Uber-ed or rented a car. Although, it can be difficult to find parking there so I would recommend just Uber-ing.
The place is also very close to the Statue of Liberty if that is something you're interested in seeing. 4-minutes drive from the house and you can visit a beach-side where you can see the statue's shoulder/back for free!
Amy is also very flexible and easy to talk to. Our experience staying there was very smooth thanks to her detailed directions on checking in and out.