I came into New York for the marathon and Amgad's place was the perfect place to stay! It is stylish and clean and a short driving distance to the start in Staten Island (for the start village). Amgad was communicative every step of the way and my mind was always at ease. There is a grocery store up the street and a convenient coffee shop.
If you're trying to get to Manhattan it is a bit of a trek but absolutely worth it, especially for the price. He offers travel solutions and the parking space was clutch!
The house is older so you will hear people walking above you but it isn't disruptive and he implements quiet hours (I got a great night's sleep the night before the marathon!).
If you're looking for an affordable place to stay in your visit to Jersey or NYC, this is worth the price and then some.