We rent the apartment for 3 nights and we liked it. It is close to the Liberty park which is much easier than NY side to take the ferry. The apartment is well kept and very clean. It has a kitchen and we made our breakfast every morning. The smoke detector was very sensitive as it alarmed after we baked Croissants. It was not an issue any more after we kept the windows opened. The hosts are very responsive and even gave us coins for the laundry. No hesitation to recommend to anyone.