The apartment itself is nice and as it looks in the pictures, but there are 2 other air bnbs above and below and you can hear everything from other guests staying in them. If people don't respect the 'quiet time' then it can be hard to get to sleep. We had to put earplugs in. Amgad did ask the other guests to keep the noise down but they didn't. I understand it's just due to the age of the house and building materials used - but if I had the choice again I wouldn't stay in that kind of house.
Getting into NYC took a long time. Walk 10 mins, get the Light Rail, change onto Path then maybe change again onto another subway line to get where you're going. The Light Rail is also not always very regular so we had to take taxis a few times. Also, Light Rail and Path are not covered on the unlimited MTA travel card and you cannot get free transfers between them - so we ended up paying a lot more money for travel than if we were staying within the MTA travel area.
Overall the experience was just OK. Apartment was nice, but the noise from other guests and the distance from the city meant it wasn't a great experience.