Our stay at Shelly & Tony's apartment was great! A big space (we were 5 people and it didn't fill too crowded), a short train ride from Manhattan (10 min walk to the path station) with all the necessary amenities in and out of the apartment (there's a big shoppingmall with all we needed just 10 minutes walk away).
We had a small issue when we arrived, which Tony solved quickly and thoroughly. Absolutely recommendating to stay there!