Teddy's place is half a street or so from the Grove subway station, making it VERY convenient. I could get to manhattan in about a 20 minute subway ride or so, and to my work location in just one subway stop. The neighborhood was adorably decorated for the holidays. Some of the streets looked like a Hallmark card - large lighted snowflakes going across the streets, with large Christmas light deers and Holiday Trees. (It's probably best to stay there in December if you want that experience. Somehow it made even a snowstorm feel okay and cozy!)
A few pro tips: The stairway is just wide enough for a very large suitcase. I packed light and small based on other reviews, and was glad I did so. There are three flights of stairs to go up, all somewhat steep but not terrible. When I got there, the room was cold because the windows were open. Be sure to check that when you go in. It warmed up sufficiently (and I used an extra blanket until it did so). The Taqueria Downtown just a few steps away was a great "I've been flying all day and just want food in my belly!" stop. Also just down the street - the Dessert place with yogurt also sells fudge. It's a must if you want a fun treat other than yogurt.
Giving this a four because: There is no breakfast as the amenities showed. (May cost you more than planned. Hopefully he's updated this.) I reached out about breakfast and also because I couldn't find any bathroom soap. I didn't hear back for a couple of days due to a cell phone issue on his end, though I think he could still have responded through the website. I get it, though - we all have issues. Also, the instructions for the heater weren't provided, so it was a bit chilly the first evening. I'm guessing he also puts some instructions out about the heater for future AirBnBers, so all in all I think he's just working out some of the kinks in things.
Great spot - totally recommend.