This is probably one of the nicest properties I've stayed at in the NY area (where I've also experienced scams and bait-and-switch), so no hesitations about recommending Bobby's place.
Loved the keyless entry and check in. Bobby is also VERY communicative, which was helpful.
Some things I didn't like: the unit was sparsely appointed, e.g., no extra blankets, three towels and one wash cloth furnished for three people for a full week, three hangers (Bobby provided three more upon request), and a kitchen that didn't really have the cutlery or flatware to really prepare food.
The area was conveniently located to the Grove Street PATH (about a 7 minute walk), near a number of great restaurants (Kitchen Step, Wonder Bagel both highly recommended), a good French bakery two doors down, a corner market two more doors down, etc.
If you're looking for a solid, updated and conveniently located unit, this is for you. If you desire more homey details and really a home away from home, this may be a stretch.
Overall, Bobby provides a good value for a nice place to stay.