The place itself is good and decent. I wouldn't call it spectacular, but it's pretty clean and has all the amenities listed in the description. It's a pretty old house though, so expect it to smell and sound exactly like an old squeaky house.
My main issue with the stay was expectations vs reality with the location. The description of this place (and a lot of reviews of this place) were saying "public transportation to NYC within 15-20min"/"just 20 minutes from Times Square and the bus stop is 2 min from the place" - this is not true at all! In fact, it usually took us 30-50 minutes to get to NYC (or back). There is only one bus going directly to NYC (route 119), all other routes don't go directly to NYC and involve changing to a different kind of transportation. The bus stop for route 119 is 6-8 minutes by feet from the place, not 2, and very often the bus either a) was full - then it went by the stop without actually stopping b) was late on the schedule c) had giant lines at the Port Authority bus terminal in NYC (weekdays around 6 pm) etc. Not even mentioning that route 119 doesn't work Sundays (we had to combine a different bus and PATH train to get to NYC through Hoboken, that took like 1 hr to get to NYC), also route 119 has 1 hr intervals between buses late evenings and on Saturdays.
My point is, the description of this place was quite delusional and provided an impression that you will be always within 15-20 mins from NYC center and will be able to get there any time at will, which is not true at all. This was probably my main gripe with the place, and if I had known beforehand that we will get in so much trouble with getting to NYC, I would have never considered NJ at all and would have stayed somewhere in Brooklyn or Manhattan instead. This was our first time in NYC and a lot of our precious time was wasted waiting in the lines for that stupid bus, or standing on the bus stop under the rain and watching how a full bus drives by without a stop, only to see that the next one only comes in 15 minutes.