We stayed in Sylvia's apartment for the thanksgiving weekend.
Pros
Price
Neat and tidy house
Comfortable bed
Close access to liberty park and Ellis island
The Statue of Liberty ferry is about 5 mins from the place
Couple of good quick eat places close by
Cons
Location is kinda shady but there always was a cop car outside the house and that was comforting
PATH station is about 10 bucks in cab
All in all we had a very good stay and would definitely stay here again given a chance