I'll start with the good things -- the Airbnb is a ten minute walk from a PATH station and various restaurants / nightlife on Newark street, so it was very easy to get anywhere / anything we needed. Moreover, there was a Key Foods and laundromat nearby which was great for groceries and laundry. As listed, most amenities in the Airbnb are available, e.g. kitchen utensils, TV with Netflix, Wi-Fi, air conditioning, etc.
However that is the extent of good things about this listing -- there were many problems during our stay that warrant it a less-than-ideal rating. My roommates and I stayed for approximately a month and when we first moved in, many things were unusable. The kitchen sink wouldn't drain, one of the showers didn't have hot water, and one of the bedrooms had an unsealable opening to the outside (which created a problem for my asthmatic roommate when people outside smoked next to our place). Thankfully, Alfredo sent in people to fix these problems, but the repair people would come in at unpredictable and inexact times (e.g. 7:00pm when they were estimated to come sometime in the "late afternoon"). Moreover, it was often hard to get a hold of Alfredo as he would often take a day or longer to reply to my messages through Airbnb.
Moreover, to elaborate on one particular incident, when one of my roommates was accidentally left at home without a key, we asked Alfredo if it was possible if he or somebody could come by and lock the door. To this, Alfredo lectured my roommate, calling us "irresponsible" and stating that we had been "asking for too much recently," with most of our requests being fixes for things like those listed in the paragraph above. Granted, it was our fault that my roommate was left without a key, but Alfredo's response to our request (which he simply could have said no to), was inappropriate and frankly, unprofessional.
For what we paid and understood from the listing, the Airbnb did not meet our expectation. Communication with Alfredo during our stay could at best be characterized as rough, though thankfully, the bulk of our interaction was concentrated in the first half of our stay, as we worked through the various repairs that needed to be made. Though we made it through our stay with relatively few problems outside of the repairs, I cannot say I particularly recommend this listing to others at the price we paid.