This is a beautiful apartment that is a great budget choice for a trip to NYC! I loved the mix of charming original old building features (like the shutters or the bathroom tiles) mixed with modern comfort (like the soft rug and sparkling kitchen). The beds were so comfortable (even the couch futon!), the linens were soft and cozy, and the little personal touches like live plants, cooking basics, and a welcome bag made us feel right at home! it was nice to be able to login to our own streaming accounts on the TV. The host has excellent communication and the check in process was seamless. It's an easy walk or a cheap Uber to the PATH station to go to Manhattan.
The only thing that I hadn't considered before (and this is 100% my fault, not a problem with the listing or the host) was the lack of a seating area to relax in at the end of a busy tourist day. Maybe a "living room" is a Midwest thing that isn't typically found in tiny NYC apartments? I didn't think anything of it when I didn't notice one on the listing, and just assumed that it would be there. There is only a futon couch and a little armchair. We had four people with us, so the futon was made into a bed the whole week. Again, not a problem...just something I was surprised by, and want other guests to know in advance.
Thank you again for sharing your home with us!