Cleanliness: Super duper clean. Loved it. Place was like new.
Accuracy: Everything was as in the pictures and as described. Wonderful. However they did have an iron but no iron board which was disappointing because I wanted to use the iron.
Check in: Host forgot to give me the check-in details. Emailed him on the day, no response - had to call him and ask him to send me the details through the email which he immediately did.
Location: Not bad. Around a 10 min walk to the PATH. There's also a direct bus that goes to Port Authority in Midtown but it comes every 40 mins.
Value: The place was quite reasonably priced for its location. Especially for a place with 2 large bedrooms which is tough to find in the NY area.
There was only a half roll of toilet paper when we arrived. We were a party of 3 and stayed for 7 days. We asked if there were more and was told to buy our own because of 'logistical problems'. There was also only one garbage bag provided and no tea towels to help clean. We had to buy our own. So if you plan to stay for a few days, it would be advisable to bring a bit more toilet paper/plastic bags or you might need to make a supermarket run for a few essentials.
But these are just a minor points. The overall apartment was well worth it. Clean, and location was good. Would come again.