I am 43yo professional who lives in London, I was by myself on a two-weeks trip and stayed in Jimmy's place.
* Location is perfect: my commute to New York City (bus 119 / other options - 25minutes), commute to Jersey City business center (10 minutes by Hudson–Bergen Light Rail), EWR airport - the closest and very comfortable commute again.
* Safe neighborhood (other residential houses around, with families living there, a few houses were nicely decorated with Halloween things coming up, in the morning/afternoon I could see children walking to/from school, parents with children, etc.)
* Quiet location (no major roads), a park nearby - good for morning run / exercises
* Facilities - the place has a few (i think 3 in total) private rooms with very spacious kitchen (oven / cooking facilities, big fridge w ice-maker, coffee-making machine, kettle, micro-wave), long bar-like bench-top (you could eat / socialize while sitting by the bench-top on stools), additional common sitting area (couch w coffee table) , one bathroom (good stream hot water), separate laundry area (washing machine and dryer) - Everything have ticked all my boxes.
* Value: great value for money (if you need to explore New York City - this property is a great value for money - taking into account safety, convenient commute, and dollar value for money. In the past I stayed in some other airbnb places in Bronx - similar budget - that was very disappointing experience)