This is a basement apartment, but it is super clean and doesn't smell basementy at all. It is also very private. The location is ideal: We could walk to everything in West Asheville. The weather went from warm and sunny to rain and then a snowstorm during our stay, and we were comfortable and cozy the entire time. The scampering of the little one upstairs was not a bother at all; the apartment is surprisingly quiet! Katie responded to all my questions quickly and we always felt taken care of. I'd definitely stay here again.