We just stayed at The Cottage in the Woods, hosted by Brett and Merissa. They have done a lot of work to make the place adorable, make sure it is exactly as published, and give you tons of tips on what to do in the area. The location is perfect, walkable to downtown. It was nice to be able to hit a rooftop bar and be right around the corner from the place.
Check in was super easy and communication was fabulous! There is so much to do in the area we wish we could have stayed longer.