My friend and I really enjoyed the stay with Bob. Bedrooms were great, place was well stocked with coffee, tea, hot chocolate. Common area was cozy. I wanted to give him a 4.5 but that's not possible. The only reason for not giving the place a 5 was that the fireplace was not working and we really would have liked to use it one night. However Bob did say he was waiting on the repairman to come, I'm sure it will be repaired soon. I would definitely like to stay again if/when I return. Thanks for a great time.