Pros:
The house is lovely, comfortable, and well-appointed. It's in a quiet location and has great amenities (for the most part).
Cons:
The internet is unusable at times. It hangs for a minute without loading the web page, then starts to load. This made surfing the web difficult and also inhibited us from using the smart TV to watch movies. Fortunately our group had plenty of plans that didn't require internet, but still this should be fixed. Another recent review also mentioned internet problems, but the host doesn't seem to have addressed it.
The host didn't leave enough toilet paper for our group for the week. I had to contact the host about receiving more toilet paper. This type of thing just shouldn't come up; there should be enough TP for a week so that we don't have to worry about it.
There were some communication issues. The emailed check-out instructions say to strip the linens from the beds, which is unreasonable given that we're paying a $200 cleaning fee. I actually contacted Airbnb to ask what their policy was on things like this. But then the welcome binder at the house says not to strip the beds. The host should just email the correct information from the get-go.
In addition, communication with the host during our stay (i.e. about the internet or toilet paper) was slow. The way it works is that you speak with an intermediary "super" who may have to contact the owner and then get back to you. This increases the amount of time it takes to get help or answers. Definitely less convenient than other Airbnb stays where you talk directly to the person who can help you.
Overall:
Overall this was a pleasant stay. I wish some of the cons had been better and would love to see those things improved.