PRO: Location is excellent. Clean and well-maintained. Front porch (actually back porch) is a wonderful place to sit. Communication fine, check-in very easy. Helpful collection of maps and local information.
CON: The basic listing is rather misleading. Headlines are "Charming Cottage," "Entire House," "Entire Home—You'll have the house to yourself." Now, if you go on to read the fine print, the place is accurately described—but it is not what "charming cottage" normally means in Airbnb usage. In reality, this is an improvised studio apartment in the lower level of the house on top of the hill, reached by a flight of steps from the street below and behind. The problem is that this former basement space (even with the nice back porch) is not adequate to be a freestanding residence. There are no separate areas, not enough room for the bed, no place you could really sit at a table. Granted, the place does not easily fit into the limited Airbnb categories. But people who expect a "charming cottage" will risk being disappointed.