First, the place is beautiful and very spacious. I was there with my parents, husband, and four-year old daughter and we had lots of space. True as advertised, it is a beautiful, historic house but with all the trappings that includes, such as doors that do not completely latch and only one shower with poor water pressure (there are two other bathtubs with hand showers that had better pressure). The location is also great, a lot of restuarants and a grocery store in walking distance and a short drive to other attractions.
But, communication with Mitch was not great. I sent a message a few days before leaving that was never responded to. When we arrived, I called Mitch twice trying to find the air mattress pump (I had previously communicated with Mitch about air mattresses, so I was surprised to have even had to search all the closets to find the air mattresses, I expected them to be out). Mitch never responded to either of the voicemails I left. Two days later, he finally contacted me and said he had not seen my messages, which I believe for the AirBNB app ones I guess, but he was texting me from the phone number I had called so I am not sure how he missed my voicemails and missed calls. In addition to the air mattress issue, the house was missing basic cleaning supplies like dish washer soap and sponges. Mitch said he'd reimburse us for those (yet to be seen if this happens).
All of that said, I would likely stay here again if I am back in Asheville, I would just adjust my expectations re. supplies and communication.