We are rating this 5 stars because it was perfect for what we consider important. Josh was an outstanding communicator. We told him we were foodies and he gave us several recommendations which were all spot on. Check-in was super easy - Josh’s instructions were easy to follow (where to park, how to locate the apartment suite, etc.). The location is very convenient- maybe 1 - 1.5 miles to the downtown area. And the backyard was wonderful. We spent two early evenings before dinner sitting on the chaise lounges with the wine he left for us just enjoying the view from the backyard. We were also allowed to bring our pup and she enjoyed sniffing around the backyard as we sat out there. We ran into their dog, Fenway, who is super gentle/friendly/polite and unbothered by strange guests. The bed is very comfortable, the decor is very cute, and everything is very clean. So for us - definitely 5 stars. I will say that the reviews about the low rafters in the bathroom are true. I’m 5’9 and maneuvering my hair dryer was awkward in the bathroom so if you have a high maintenance beauty routine or are 6’0 you might not be a fan of the bathroom. But again - for us this was a small downside when we enjoyed everything else.