Beth made our uncertain arrival time easy by leaving a key for us. Overall, the accommodations are very nice. Super comfy bed and my uncle, who slept on the futon said that it too was comfortable. There's a full kitchen which we did not use. The locations is fabulous! After checking in, we walked to a restaurant down the street and had a delicious dinner.
A potential downside to Athena's loft is the steepish stairs leading up to the apartment. It was okay for us but people with mobility issues should be warned. Similarly, the shower requires some flexibility/steadiness getting in & out of the raised claw-foot tub. Furthermore, if you're over 5'11" or so, you're head will likely reach the ceiling while showering.