My wife and I had a fantastic stay for our (kid-free) 10 year anniversary! It was the perfect little Amish built cabin, in the great location, close to downtown, but still had the spectacular views we wanted. Sharon and Davids hospitality is top notch! David met us upon check-in and gave us a quick rundown and they were very responsive with any questions we had during our stay.
The cabin isn't as private as I would have hoped as its located right next to the owners house. But the fire pit and jacuzzi are on the other side of the cabin, so it really isn't an issue at all. We loved all the small amenities... shampoo, coffee, board games, books, robes, fire wood w/ newspaper as starter, candle on the front porch, filtered water, bag of ice, tons of pillows, and so much more.
Its close to downtown, but we elected to get food to-go and eat on the front porch while watching the sunset over the mountains. The jacuzzi was very welcomed after a long day of hiking in the cold rain!
To future guests... we recommend hiking through the DuPont forest to all the various waterfalls and highly recommend any of the restaurants the host recommend as we tried a few and they were amazing! Also visit the Biltmore Hotel and GrovePark Inn (for dinner).