Awesome = location. Walkable to downtown and nearby parks. But it's just far away from Main Street, so you don't have the noise and traffic.
The kitchen had the standards: coffee, tea, oil, spices, etc... It was great to have dog towels and a bowl. There were plenty of extra towels and sets of toiletries (soap, lotion, shampoo...).
There are a few things that weren't 5-star level, BUT they are minor maintenance items that might be fixed at any time. I think it's only ~2 hours of work of generally minor things.
Fans: one didn't have a pull cord for the fan speed, which was on high speed; the other was very short.
The screen door to the backyard: The screen is broken/ripped; the hook-latch is stripped from the door.
The bathroom faucet has a drip.
There isn't much space for clothes or things in the bedrooms. We used one room and bed as storage — just tossed our luggage on the bed for easy access. The shared closet has some space, but it's not easily accessible.
Overall, it was a great location at a competitive price for the area. A few tweaks would bring this up to a 5-star rating.