Natalie's place is great and I would definitely come back. it was very clean and the layout is ergonomic. the kitchen is well equipped, and the sink is big. the bed is very comfortable.
There are two big caveats that did not bother me but I could see how some might be bothered. One, the stairs are steep and outside. Fortunately, the stairs are covered and protected from snow except for the bottom two stairs but carrying your belongings up and down the stairs could be daunting for some. Two, the shower is very small. The stream however is strong and the water warms quickly.
Overall, this over garage apartment is very comfortable, grows on you with time, and was a very good deal.
PS Natalie is very friendly but not at all intrusive, always a welcome attribute.