I have never given a host an even remotely negative review. My partner and I have never received a negative review. For this place, we stayed one night and arrived in the evening.
(1) In the evening, we touched the wall-mounted TV to adjust volume. It did not completely come off the wall, but it tipped forward in a really worrisome way. We could see that the TV had come off before and hadn't been mounted back in carefully.
(2) The next morning, the two of us sat on the couch to have coffee, and the a left leg on the couch suddenly collapsed. My partner fell. It was clear that the leg had previously come off and was sloppily nailed back in. The other legs had the same look. We took pictures of the broken leg and sent them to the host's company.
The host admitted that a previous guest had torn the TV off the wall and broken that same couch. Guests had stayed there since the couch was first broken and when we stayed there. The host said that they had ordered a new couch from Wayfair but that shipping had been delayed.
(3) The host's company does communicate responses quickly and said that they would fix the couch. We were communicating only a couple of hours before 11am checkout, so I messaged that we were leaving by 11am anyway. The host sent a repair person at 10am to fix the couch (again, by simply nailing the leg back on). We should have had one hour left to ourselves in the place. He was a very nice man but wasn't wearing a mask.
(4) We cleaned the place and made sure we didn't leave anything. We checked under the bed and saw that the legs had also been fixed.
(5) A more minor point is that overall, the rest of the place is a little older than it looks in the pictures. The place is more like a hotel with a kitchen. There is one comforter on the bed and no extra blankets at all, but there is a small space heater. All of this would be fine normally; we aren't picky. Given the other issues, though, I just want to note that in the review. Also, to be fair, I will note that we didn't have to pay the $50 dog fee in light of the issues.