We've stayed in a few airbnb's so I'll touch on the things I find most important!
The location is great - a few blocks from breweries, a short walk to Magazine St and the Canal St streetcar. We used the streetcar to get downtown and back without any problems. Parking on premises (Especially in NOLA, this is invaluable!)
Bed was comfortable which is really important after walking all day.
Environment is clean and chic without sacrificing on the historic charm. Silly but I fell in love with the doors and hardwoods here. Also a huge plus is the living plants, not very many airbnb's bother to include them but they made the entire place a refreshing.
We also enjoyed the throwback games - I mean, Nintendo... rock 'em sock 'em, am I right?!