I usually start with positive comments, then move on to the negative, but there were so many positive things to discuss that I'm going to get the one semi-negative item out of the way first. Plus, this might be a deal-killer for some people, so it's better to discuss first.
The location is just a little bit sketchy, though that is not unusual for the New Orleans Garden District, where nice blocks and rougher blocks co-exist side by side. It's not terrible, but someone with more delicate sensibilities might not love it. I didn't mind it, because I'm used to living in a historic "emerging" neighborhood.
One big up-side to the location is that you will be one block from the St. Charles streetcar. Very convenient for hopping on for a ride one direction to the French Quarter and Central Business District, or the other direction up to Camillia Grille. There were several nice restaurants within walking distance, as well.
Speaking of historic, I love historic structures like this. I would guess it was built in the late-1800s. It is fairly basic, quite cute, clean, and tastefully decorated. I don't like places with too much decorative clutter. This place has everything you need, while keeping the decorations minimal and tasteful. The wifi worked well and had a good signal. There was cable TV as well as local channels, though when you are in N.O. you probably aren't there to watch TV. One bedroom had a queen-sized bed, while the other bedroom had two bunk beds, so you can get a little separation from the kids, if you need it. We slept only in the queen-sized bed, and it was very comfortable.
My highest compliment goes to the owner, Erik, for being so responsive. Every time I had a question or needed something, he was quick to reply through the Airbnb app.