Went back and forth on four or five stars. Overall the place was great. Good location, easy to get into, good amenities in the apartment. Biggest thing that kept this from being five stars were two things: 1) Sound insulation was basically non-existent in the unit. We could hear all of the neighbors in the units above and next to us, including some louder arguments / yelling on the weekend evenings late at night. 2) Some of the details / finishings and polish that come through in the pictures were just a bit off in person. For example, at one point during the stay, some lose material fell from the ceiling, presumably due to some raucous neighbors above us. Similarly, there was a fairly large crack in one of the walls, presumably from some aggressive mardi gras partying before our stay.
Overall, the value combined with the included amenities and great service made this an AirBnB I would recommend to friends, but couldn't quite give it five stars due to the things mentioned.