Our stay at VooDoo Villa was excellent. This was our first Airbnb stay, and we're so glad we did it.
The place was clean and exactly as described, the hosts left snacks, some breakfast items and beverages for us, as well as spare toiletries.
The neighborhood was fine - it has the feel of a neighborhood that's on the rise again. All the people we met in the street were friendly.
Walk to the Quarter was only 10 minutes or so, and only 20 minutes down to the river, which was nice - we were able to save a few cab fares. (Basically, cab rides ran about $10 with tip for two people).
Jeb and Scott were very responsive when we had a few questions, and were also able to help us out on checkout day. Our flight was cancelled and they held on to our bags for us while we went for lunch and formulated a plan to reschedule travel and accommodations for that night.
One of the only potential downsides is accessibility - the apartment is up one flight of steps, so folks with ambulatory issues should keep that in mind.
The only other trouble I had was food prep - the knives were rough. Please don't consider this a complaint; it's more of an observation that may prove useful to serious home cooks. In reality, you'll be staying in New Orleans - where there is a lot of excellent food to be had - and you probably won't spend your vacation cooking. We choose to make most of our breakfast meals at the Villa so we could relax and save a few bucks.
Other than that, the kitchen had enough pans, utensils, and things to be functional, and the electric stove was one of the better ones I have cooked on.

Thanks to Jeb and Scott.