I really can't say enough good things about this rental. It was everything described, and the owner and his wife bent over backwards to make our stay special. I did hire him to make us dinner (for our anniversary) and breakfast on one morning that I didn't want to go out.
My wife and I spent a LOT of time in the pool and on the back porch. We were able to walk or bike to an awful lot of things we wanted to see (including a great museum just a few blocks away).
The house is gorgeous inside, with high ceilings and a lot of woodwork. There are giant wooden pocket doors between the front bedroom and middle bedroom. While the house is a very old house, everything that counts inside has been updated (new kitchen, bathrooms, etc.). The middle bathroom shower even has a button to turn it into a sauna. There are several different seating areas outside, plus a putting green in a well-landscaped back yard.
This was the most complete place I've stayed in (in terms of what you need). There were a ton of towels, a very well-stocked kitchen (all the way down to bottled water in the fridge and spices to cook with), bug spray and sunscreen, pool floats, etc.
Like *every* house from the time period, you can always find little things that need maintenance if you look hard . . . but I honestly couldn't have asked for a more perfect place in a more perfect location.