I would highly recommend this for anyone who wants a true NOLA experience. You're in a neighborhood, and still have easy access to the streetcar and various other locations.
Add to that the fact that D is an awesome, welcoming host who wants you to feel comfortable, who keeps a spotless house and will provide tips on anything you ask for (getting around, things to do, even cooking!!) AND his dog is a total sweetheart. I truly wanted for nothing.