My husband and I visited with another couple over the New Year Holiday. We stayed at Lindsey's for the value and because it offered two separate bedrooms. Overall the location was great, the neighborhood is quiet and safe to walk around in all directions. Shopping is only two blocks away on Magazine street and NOLA Brewery (which is awesome) is a few blocks in the opposite direction. We had a lot of fun exploring the area and found it really easy to grab an Uber or Lyft at any time of the day/night- each time it only took about 4 minutes for their arrival.
We happened to be visiting during a random cold snap so we found spare blankets in the closet that got us through. We ended up using the window units for heat as well but found that the electric heater provided was missing wheels so it was difficult to use. The only other issues we had were a wobbly table that only sat 3 (we had 4 guests, and lousy weather, so a place to sit and chill inside would have been nice) -the living room only sat a few people on the couch as well. This wouldn't normally be an issue for a guest visiting during normal weather because there is so much to do around the city and outdoors. And last, as other guests have remarked, the pillows are pretty flat so bring extras.
Overall- I would stay here again, I felt like the place was comfortable and Lindsey was incredibly responsive.