First the outstanding:
The outdoor space. Totally private, well maintained. Pool heats up super quick as hot as you want it. Jets are superb. Under a gorgeous 200 year old tree. Just perfect, really.
The Good:
Towels, bed, sheets, bathroom supplies, kitchen layout, black-out curtains - all top notch. Very dark and quiet to sleep. Daniels availability, Check-in process, Check-out - all super smooth and easy.
The OK:
The layout is poor with no common space. It was fine for us, but with another couple it would be uncomfortable. The space would work so much better as a 1 bedroom house with a living room instead of a 2 bedroom house with no living room. The design is poor and dated. The kitchen is so small it has no full-sized appliances (stove, fridge, oven).
Overall impression:
In our opinion, the outdoor space makes up for any other deficiencies. Enough so that we would stay there again. We feel that the price is very fair. Closer to the quarter would be twice the money at least.
Daniel was lovely - available but not hovering or over-bearing in the least with helpful suggestions for around town.