My wife, two children (a 1 year old and a 3.5 year old) and I had a great time at Gary’s house.
First, a bit about my interactions with Gary over the 3 nights we were staying there. He checked in on us in advance of our stay and during our stay via text message to make sure things were going well and when we had a question along the way, his responses would come no longer than 30 seconds from when I sent it. Further, it is clear that Gary has a very close relationship with his label maker (one remote control had I believe 4 labels on it). There were labels all throughout the house and this actually just goes to show the length Gary has set up his house to ensure that his guests find everything they need with as much ease as possible.
As for the house itself, it is very nicely furnished and is very clean. The backyard with pool, hot tub and TV are as nice if not nicer than the pictures online. A comparable hotel arrangement with private pool (if such thing exists) would cost thousands per night.
The location of the house was perfect for us. It was one block from Magazine Street and my wife and I are foodies, although our choice of eating establishments are limited nowadays because of our young children. As it turned out some of the more enjoyable family friendly restaurants in New Orleans are within walking distance of Gary’s house.
Honestly, if I lived in New Orleans and wanted to spend a night or two in a house with a beautiful pool and hot tub I would certainly be tempted to stay at Gary’s again and I already have a friend who lives a mile away from Gary’s house considering renting it.