We just got back to NYC from New Orleans and really enjoyed our stay at Sylvia's place. I would definitely stay there again if we get back down, which we hope to do soon! A few things to mention... This place is a definite find for anyone going to New Orleans for the music, it is ON Frenchman St and across the street from one of the best clubs. In sayin that... if loud music and late nights aren't your thing... this isn't your spot. The average time it got quiet enough where we could go to sleep was around 2:30am. Which wasn't an issue for us, but if that's gonna be a problem ... something to consider.
However, In saying that... the major highlight of this spot is the balcony deck. You can sit outside and people watch day and night. You can get home from a long day of exploring and sit on the deck and listen to the music from across the street. It's a true treat.
I've read reviews about people staying here with their kiddos.. and Im not sure I'd feel like this spot was safe for familys. It's attached to a club, the door is next door to the entrance of a club, there were alot of people just staying on the street all hours... but for any grown up I don't think you would ever feel unsafe.
So to summarize, if you're going to New Orleans and hoping to really get into the scene and live it up... this is a great spot for a couple or single traveler.