There are definite pros and cons to weigh out. Pros: great location - walk to French Quarter without being in the French Quarter, easy to park, fun neighborhood (Who Dat for breakfast), and nice amenities like the front porch and backyard spaces. The place is clean and cute, and the hosts were very responsive and accurate with directions. Cons: biggest cons are uncomfortable sleeping - I found the downstairs bed way too saggy and short (I'm 6'3") and my wife found it only OK. The upstairs bed was somewhat better but there are skylights meaning you're up when the sun comes up. Other big downside is very weak internet. There were other more minor cons that probably fall into "quirky" (e.g. heat dishes in the bedrooms instead of central heat, small kitchen with no sponge or dish drain, a steep staircase to the upstairs, a "living room" outside the upstairs bedroom, heat dishes instead of central heat). With better beds and internet this is a 4-5 but our group's consensus is 3 stars.