TL;DR: there are better places to stay that are closer to places you want to see for about the same cost.
They didn't have toilet paper. We told them when we arrived and they immediately apologized and said they would send someone over, but it never showed. We followed up and they said someone brought it and didn't hear from them after that. I got the impression they didn't believe us when we told them it still wasn't there. We had to get our own after a long day of traveling. The next day they graciously called to apologize and said it was left at the wrong house but still no one ever brought it by. They also did offer to reimburse but it seemed silly for one roll of toilet paper.
Also basically the photos made it look nicer than it was. Kind of harsh lighting and random cables from the TV/internet were bunched up in the corner. The appliances and bed linens were nice and my boyfriend thought the bed was comfortable (a little on the firm side for me).
And not as walkable as we were hoping, although it was a cheap Lyft ride to Frenchmen street, etc.