I've seen how the host responds to other reviews with the same exact concerns I had: snidely, and my booking experience was the worst I'd ever had in over 10 years in Airbnbs. I've never seen a listing with extra pet fees before and stayed in many, and the fees were more than a night's stay. They're also buried in the description, which is the longest I've ever seen, and not in the house rules; had I known you can even list extra fees in a description, I'd have read every word, but it opens by saying to read the house rules (and when you book, it says you agree to house rules and not to every word in the description). Descriptions aren't places for agreements, but Airbnb and host wanted me to either stay here or take my money anyway despite saying upfront this gets a bad review. In the past, I've booked places where there was a miscommunication or other issue and the host was happy to cancel with a refund if it meant not forcing someone to stay there that didn't want to be there or just taking their money and not caring. I was a host and did the same.
The location was good, and the decor nice save for marketing yourself as Synagogue, in an actual former synagogue, and using custom art that's entirely Christian (including pop art of Jesus). I'm Jewish, and that's horrendous. Don't do this, and include something about the history and culture of the place that doesn't involve Christianity. I was excited to find this place and just overall had a bad time. The exterior door, too, doesn't lock, with a note on it saying it will be fixed "tomorrow" -- that note was there all 3 days we were (two nights). And after $250 in cleaning and pet fees, the rug in the living room was dirty from prior guests and we were asked to do the dishes and take the trash out.