Colin is an extremely thoughtful and gracious host. Colin was flexible when we arrived later than expected and spoke with us about the ins and outs of the cities various neighborhoods. He also took the time to furnish his AirBNB with plenty of resources to help visitors explore the city (e.g. guide books, umbrellas, granola bars).
With regards to the place itself, Colin furnished it very tastefully, giving the feel of a modern hotel with vintage details. He also stocked the bathroom with toiletries and invested in a Sleep Number mattress.
As for the location, Colin's place is located in a residential neighborhood about a 30 minute walk from the French Quarter. There are a few dodgy streets along that walk, but that's pretty standard for any city. Maintain a certain level of vigilance and don't walk around swinging cash in hand and you'll be perfectly fine. The walk is extremely interesting and gives you a great view of the area outside of the touristy district.
10/10 would recommend Colin's place for any couple looking to visit New Orleans for the first (or second or third) time!