So this review needs to be broken into 2 parts - what you get and what you may expect. In short, the place is fantastic if you're willing to make a few small accommodations.
Pros: Location - there is none better for the U of C. Safe area, one block from campus, 2 blocks from several restaurants, coffee shops, pubs.....I lived in Hyde park as a student for 6 years and this place place is closer than any of my dorms/apartments ever were to campus. We had 2 independent bedrooms, a bathroom, fridge and microwave. It even has parking, which is key. The people who manage the facility are very helpful and pleasant - in short, I will always be looking here first any time I want to visit campus.
Cons: These are really a matter of perspective - if you are looking for a 5-star hotel with a front desk, marble bathrooms, and daily linen service, this is not it. It's like living in a home - the facilities are all well above average, but they are not brand new. The bathroom shows a little age, but everything works well which is what we needed. This is a religious house that has intermittent Jewish services during the day and evening on the main floor that you may need to cross through, but the people are very nice so you barely notice it. In short, the negatives were minimal, especially when compared with the space, facilities and location you get.
In summary, I really enjoyed my stay here and will definitely be looking to stay here any time I come back.