If you know what to expect, this place could be great. Liz is a fantastic host: she explains things thoroughly, responds quickly to questions--and even got us a new coffee maker upon request. The apartment is recently renovated, exceptionally clean, and spacious for a couple. It is bright and fresh. The location is fantastic. It's quiet, convenient to the elevated, Loyola, and the waterfront. And the rental is very reasonably priced.
That said, it is important to know that this is a "garden-style apartment," meaning you're 1/2 story below ground. Normally, you'd look out at the flowers growing outside the windows; only here, there are security windows that give lots of light to the apartment but that you can't see through. I found the effect slightly claustrophobic. Luckily there are openings in the windows, so the fresh air made it in. The entryway is down a very steep flight of stairs that may not be accessible for all guests. The ceilings are 7' high, and there are some beams in places where it's lower. I'm 6'2 and had to duck to get into the closet and back bedroom.
If you know all that in advance and are OK with it, this place will be excellent. It feels very safe. The process of reserving, checking in, and checking out was flawless. And the price was right.