In a word, my stay was perfect.
It started with a great deal, quick and helpful communication, and the most flexible and seamless check-in process I've ever had on AirBNB.
Every room exceeded my expectations. The sitting room was even more cozy and picturesque than the pictures showed. The master bedroom was comfortable, clean, and made up like a professional hotel. The bathroom was clean, well-stocked, and (is this a theme?) laid out by what felt like a professional. The kitchen was spotless, and the amenities were plentiful. I cooked every night, and her knives, pans, drawers--all of it was intuitive, easy, and enjoyable.
Parking wasn't as hard as I was afraid it might be (I'm a weenie and don't like walking very far in the cold).
The only con is ... that I now feel jealous and have some serious thinking to do about redecorating my own place! Five stars, six if I could, and I definitely plan to come back this time next year!