There are a lot of positives about this loft. Location, the host, amenities like espresso machine, projector system, plenty of towels, washer and dryer etc.
Unfortunately there were a few biggish problems that caused us to enjoy our stay less and lower our rating. The biggest one is the amount of mold in the shower. John said he thought it was a bad grout job, but this felt disingenuous as it was on the surface of the tiles as well as on the grout. The second one was the elevated train that ran immediately behind the unit. He discloses this in the description but says it is a problem only for the back bedroom. This is inaccurate as it was loud and even vibrated the bed in the other bedrooms as well. (Especially the master) He did offer earplugs, but for light sleepers this would be a big problem. (Our teen slept through it without issue tho. Just depends on how sensitive you are)
Finally, the master bed itself needs a better frame or support system. It creaks very loudly when anyone moves which is problematic for a couple.
Overall, tons of Promise plus a great host, but the mold and noise of train greatly diminished this property for us.