Pros: The decor is fun and the overall building is charming. We loved that there was enough space for our bachelorette gathering as well as private bathrooms in 2 of the rooms. Beds were very comfortable! There were also plenty of towels, extra blankets and pillows as well as plenty of dinnerware.
We went to get drinks at the restaurant and the bartender was so kind and conversing, giving us tips on where to go for our bachelorette. He also gave us a tour of the entire building and told us the history of it!
When we checked-in, the restaurant workers were also helping us with our bags which was very kind.
Cons: For Airbnb "plus" we did expect this stay to be impeccable, but the basic amenities such as paper towels, aluminum foil, parchment paper and coffee were not present. None of the TV's worked and the photos also showed robes in every bathroom but that was not the case.
Like other reviews said, be mindful this is on the 3rd floor, so it is a trip. The keys/locks are also a little difficult.