Overall this is a solid place to stay, and Josh couldn't have been a better host in terms communication. I would say there was one major con, with some very appreciated pros.
Pros
Location: could not be better located. 7min walk from the Red Line, right on the 22 bus line, 10min walk to a bunch of awesome bars, restaurants, etc. We felt more connected to the city than we have staying downtown and in the Loop. It is a bargain for the price based on location alone.
Elevated Basics: the bed, shower, wifi, and temp control were all solid, comfortable, and worked great
Communication + Security: the instructions on getting in and out were clear, Josh was a great communicator (our wifi went out at one point and he was very on top of it!) and we felt secure with the locks and access to the space
Cons
Noise: this was our single biggest challenge. The unit above (Airbnb managed by the same hosts) is a larger unit, and two nights of our stay was rented by a group of maybe 8-10. It was severely loud in our unit for the duration of their stay - walking, pounding, talking, partying - and we were relieved we hadn't planned to be in the unit a ton, both during the day and night. This was not an after-hours issue (both Fri/Sat nights they only partied until 10-11pm before going out) but just a building structure issue.
Overall comfort: the unit isn't super cozy - concrete floor, older couch, projector instead of a TV, basic furnishings - which to us made it just a place to crash at night. If you're looking for a home to lounge around in, I'm not sure I would recommend this place.
Overall, this Airbnb is a bargain for location - but I would likely recommend it only for folks planning to be exploring the city most of their trip and just crashing here.