Great location, a quirky but comfortable apartment, and excellent communication from the host! We had two couples staying for a weekend and were very happy with the stay. Beds were comfortable and clean, and there were nice modern appliances in the kitchen. There was a surprising amount of light in the morning for a semi-basement apartment, which was nice. The couple in the back room were woken up one morning by a garbage truck right outside the door, but that's a risk of city living I guess! Also, parking on the street could be tough to find on weekends - we parked once on a nearby street and once managed to snag a spot at the end of the block. Just be aware that you may have to troll a bit for parking, and many streets nearby are permit-only. But it is also very convenient to the Division stop on the Blue Line.
Overall, we had a great stay and would definitely recommend for anyone wanting to be right in the heart of Wicker Park / East Village. Thanks to Jacob and Benjamin!