The location is great and it's decorated well. The bathroom could use a redo/deep clean, but it wasn't horrible. The hosts are also very responsive, which we appreciated.
However, if you are sensitive to noise, especially staying for more than a night or two, this isn't a good fit. It's an old building and you can hear the long term tenants upstairs, who play music nearly nightly and are generally noisy (somehow both very early in the morning in boots/heels and late at night with guests). The hosts did contact them after we complained, and the music went from insanely loud to bearable after, but the building is just really old and not soundproof at all. We even heard the tenant downstairs sneeze (he is very nice, by the way).
I booked before the recent reviews posted saying something similar, maybe the tenants upstairs are newer than the older reviews.