If I could give 4.5 stars, I would. The biggest negative was the upstairs apartment. I definitely won't hold that against Annelise and Ian, their listing describes this as an apartment, but, for single-family home dwellers, having noise above your bedroom at 5:30am when you are on vacation, it's a bit of a negative. Nothing the hosts can help though.
The house was very clean, well furnished, and comfortable for our family of 4 (2 adults, 18yo, and 10yo). We had a great time using it as home base while we explored Chicago for a few days. The blue line is 2 blocks away and there are many great food options for breakfast and/or dinner within walking distance.
We had a great time and wouldn't hesitate to stay again, and with luck, there wouldn't be small children in the upstairs apartment.