Pros are location (midway from airport and downtown, walking distance to western chicago eateries and shops, a lovely and charming part of the city to explore), and good communication from Joyce one of the hosts. She made check in/out easy and inside was a good size for 4 with all amenities as listed and clean.
For some honest cons.. my friends and I felt disappointed at the low quality of the couch sofa and thin pillows, lack of blankets, heater only working in the bathroom, and no drinking water. Maybe we are spoiled from LA with weather and all, but we were cold and just felt it was underwhelming on those points. Otherwise we got what we paid for I suppose.