We were originally hesitant about booking this place, as it had only one prior review at that time, but we're SO happy we did! The apartment was super cute, cozy, clean, and comfortable, with nice early 20th century charms such as radiator heating and parquet wood floors. The location was fantastic, just steps from nice little isolated beach on Lake Michigan. We left the windows open and loved going to bed and waking up to the rhythm of the waves lapping on the beach. The apartment came fully stocked with great coffee and tea, all necessary kitchenware and cooking gear, and even a full collection of condiments and spices. Finally, Ata's communication was flawless. He responded immediately to every message we sent in a way that was clear, helpful, and friendly. We had a lovely stay and definitely look forward to returning!