Amanda and Tony's place was great. They took care of many small details that made the apartment feel like home. Communication was always fast and check-in was very easy. We picked it because of the excellent location (tons to do nearby, but also accessible to O'Hare and downtown via the Blue line.
As the listing mentions, the train is audible in the apartment. Light sleepers (especially in the living room) might be somewhat bothered, but in the bedroom we had no trouble falling asleep (even without the earplugs that were kindly provided just in case).