Overall, we enjoyed our stay and Nicole & Matt's place. There were a few things that would make me hesitate to book another long-term stay, but this would be a fantastic place a for a shorter-term stay! We would stay with these hosts again.
PROS
-Amazing location. In the heart of Wicker Park, walkable to tons of restaurants, bars, public transportation.
-Parking!
-Large space
-Fast WIFI!
-Comfy master bed
-Super responsive hosts
CONS
-Only one key and trouble accessing the lockbox
-Living room and floors were very cold. We used a space heater, but had to stay bundled
-Upstairs noise. When there are guests staying upstairs, the master bedroom can get pretty noisy. I think it might be an airbnb because we heard a lot of activity late at night. White noise machine helped drown this out thought. Heavy sleepers are probably fine.
-Sparse kitchen. Perfect for short term stay, but not ideal for cooking if staying for a few weeks (more just an FYI)