This was my first experience with AirBNB and I can't imagine a better one.
The space is charmingly decorated and truly felt like our home for the few days we stayed. The Edgewater neighborhood is delightful, best breakfast just around the corner from Scott's and the train and lake a very pleasant walk away.
Scott and Jill were gracious hosts, who were very considerate/flexible when we needed to check in later that evening. Their dog is a sweetheart and I only wish I'd had more time to get to know them!