I think the most important thing about an AirBNB listing is the accuracy of the listing. I give this four stars and offer these thoughts.
First, the apartment is in a great neighborhood--I lived a few blocks away years ago--so it was nice to be back.
Second is access--somehow I received the code to enter the outside door but didn't get the code the inside door--fortunately I was able to reach the host by phone.
Third concerns how the apartment itself. It appears that the original apartment was divided into three--ok, I get it, space is expensive, and the listing was accurate--a single room plus bath. As for furnishings, there was only one wine glass, there was only one bedside light, the bathroom didn't have racks or hooks, the towels were mismatched. The bed didn't have a top sheet--only a conforter that was torn. We couldn't close the bathroom door with the bathroom rugs that were on the floor--this is easily fixed by cutting a half inch off the bottom of the door!
Finally, we received an email during our stay promoting another AirBNB property that the host owns--a beautifully furnished catamaran. I'd encourage the host to focus on making a few improvements to this unit--it could easily be a five star unit--and less on promoting other properties!