Location wise, this place is perfect. Close to the airport. Central to both the north shore and south coast and waimea canyon etc. The bed was really comfortable. Pool area is great. The beach is pretty horrid though but there are some good beaches within driving range. After paying for checkin, cleaning fee, parking etc, it worked out to be about the same as booking.com
The thing we certainly missed the most though was not having a kitchen as it is a hotel. There is a coffee machine but no microwave, stovetop etc. but it is something we love about airbnb. Would certainly stay here again.