We absolutely loved staying at Lily's cottage. Beautiful house with everything you could possibly need. Eric was easy to communicate with and when we had a small issue with an appliance he arranged for it to be taken care of immediately. Koloa is a great part of the island to stay in - you feel away from the hustle and bustle but close enough to the convenience of a cute set of shops and a couple of great eating options, all just a ten-minute walk away. The island is easy to drive around to explore and Lily's cottage is a great base to do so from. I would stay here over the more touristy north every time. The house decor is perfect - cosy but stylish. And the outdoor seating areas are amazing - we really didn't make the most of them! Hope to return one day.