Unfortunately, I was unable to get a good rest at this place, so I had to relocate to a new place. Be sure to check out the sound of the coqui frogs (search for it on YouTube) before you choose a place to stay on the island. Some (or most) people seem to really like it, but be aware that they can get real loud.
This place has no closeable windows, only meshes and it feels like you're sleeping in nature. Sounds like a great experience on paper, right? Well, I really didn't click with the coqui. Their loud, piercing whistles almost drove me insane. And it felt like they were right next to my ear too. Gary and Patty were nice and provided earplugs and a noise machine to mask out the outside noise, but it didn't really help in my case.
Too bad, because the place seemed very nice otherwise. It was clean, and Gary and Patty provided a lot of extras like umbrellas and snorkeling gear to help in your exploration of the island. If you don't mind or actually enjoy the coqui sounds, I would easily recommend the place.