We had a great stay at Gary and Marianne's! It was a wonderful jumping off point for a week of exploring Haleakala, the upcountry, as well as the North Shore (Paia). We enjoyed the proximity to Makawao and the local shops and restuarants there.
Gary and Marianne were very communicative, and welcomed us when we arrived a bit late due to a late flight. They also answered questions we had in advance of arrival promptly.
Highly recommend for folks looking for a more quiet stay away from the super touristy areas.