We really enjoyed our time there. It's a fun, big house with amazing views from the huge back porch. We really appreciated the "DIY whenever you want" continental breakfast (yay, pancake griddle and pre-made batter!), and it was really nice to eat it outside, looking at those views.
Emily is very warm, friendly, and personable, and it was interesting to hear about her history on the island. As some reviewers have noted, it's a few miles outside of town, but that was definitely more of a bonus to us than a drawback - very peaceful and chill, not urbanized at all. Great place, great deal!