Wow, what a great place! The location couldn't be any better. The house is a block (or less) from the main drag in Lahaina, but it is still on its own quiet street. So much is walkable from the house, yet you still have privacy and quiet when you need it. The house itself was great and served all of our needs. We visited with a 1 year old, and rented a crib, high chair, toys, and sand toys from Maui Baby Rental. We kept the crib in the living room. Dedicated parking is also a huge plus. We would stay here again in a heartbeat without even looking at other options in town.
Lahaina itself was exactly what I was looking for, with a nice walkable commercial district and lots of options for coffee and food. We visited Pu'unoa Beach/Baby Beach, which is a 5 min. drive or ~20 min. walk. Star Noodle and Cafe Cafe Maui were our favorite food options.