It's not surprising that the vast majority of reviews of Paul's property are positive. They all list/cover the 'basics' with deserved superlatives. What I'd like to do is provide a little more granularity.
First, the location. It's in a great spot to take advantage of treks to the northern part of the island as well as the western shore. We never had to drive more than 30 minutes to find something fun to do. If you want to visit the eastern half of the island, it's accessible as well.
The property itself is situated on a hill facing southeast. The views are stunning (the pictures do do it the justice it deserves but it's even more impressive in person). While we were there, the public beaches were closed due to a passing tropical disturbance. Suffice it to say, we were just as happy spending the day by our private pool and taking in the vistas. The grounds are manicured extremely well and you are never left wondering where you are. The home is appointed to the nines. I'd compare it favorably with any Four Seasons I've stayed at. The indoor and outdoor furniture is very comfortable and the interior is roomy. The kitchen's appliances look new and the bed afforded me 4 extremely pleasant night's sleep. There's everything you need in terms of kitchen accessories (there's even a martini shaker for those who might be interested!). On top of that, as others have mentioned, there are beach chairs and an umbrella as well as a travel cooler (with ice packs in the freezer). There's an excellent fresh fish market just down the hill that we took advantage of to BBQ on 2 of the nights.
Paul and Paula were accessible and looked to offer tips as to things to do and see (we were particularly interested in hikes). They're responsive and courteous - just 2 very pleasant people.
If you're looking for a great Big Island experience with a partner or significant other, this is your spot! We hope to be fortunate enough to stay there again in the future!