First of all, Floyd is a very responsive and kind host! I really appreciate every of his efforts.
For the Airbnb community I like to highlight some points:
The apartment is worth 5 star because of the great location next to Paia, where we ate 3 nights, and where a nice groceries stores can be found. It is also a nice starting point for Road to Hana.
Besides of that, the apartment is just functional. Is is not very special nor really nice.
Notice that washing clothes costs extra if you are not staying more than a week and cannot be done by yourselves. Even if you wanted to wash by hand you had no opportunities to dry the clothes. Thats unfortunately a negative aspect which should be taken into consideration.
For more than two people the apartment is just too small. We didn't care much because we were almost the whole time exploring Maui - but the sofa bed is very uncomfortable and not nice to sleep on. The bed linen is of synthetic fabric which we didn't like either. In the mornings it can get loud, because of the other apartments' guests. The doors are not well isolated.
A/C is not really fast and therefore not a nice plus if it cannot be run during a longer time frame (again add. fees). But in the nights a chilled wind cools the apartment fastly - wasn't a big deal.
Huge bathroom with 2 sinks but not really good air circulation: gets hot, sweaty and stinky. Shower O.K.