I had a great experience! Beth and Jake are very helpful and responsive.
The cottage is a great place to stay if you want to be close to Downtown Honolulu yet not pay for overpriced accommodations in the Downtown/Waikiki area.
A few of the things that I loved about staying at the cottage were:
10 minute drive to Koko Crater Trail and Hanauma Bay,
35 minute drive to Kailua Beach,
15 minute drive to Downtown Honolulu,
Free Parking,
Talking to Beth (she is really nice!)