Temple Tree Retreat has a beautiful location right on the lava cliffs. The stars, the surf, the coqui frogs, the unique architecture, and charming interior details makes this a place unlike any other I've been on the Big Island.
However, it feels more like the dusty property of an uncle from the '60s that could use some updates than a contemporary vacation rental managed by a realty company. The broken electronics, the dead switches, the rusty silverware, the general air of unkemptness isn't quite a dealbreaker, but it does tarnish the experience a bit. Our towels and sheets were stained (with what seemed to be rust, not anything bodily unhygienic or something that would really gross someone out), maybe half of the light switches didn't work (which we didn't realize until it was pitch black out, which was an issue), and there was a weird hodge podge of tablewear and cookware in the cabinet by the bedrooms, but nothing in the kitchen. I think I would be more likely to chalk this up to a quirky experience from an eccentric owner if this place wasn't managed by a realty company that goes out of its way to suggest it will do anything to make this a "five star experience" while actually failing to respond substantively to any texts we sent.
All that said, the locations was beautiful, the master bed was comfortable, and we had a good time.