This is a really great airbnb. We stayed for six weeks. When we arrived, the place was absolutely spotless and very welcoming. Check-in is straightforward thanks to José's detailed instructions. The best part is of course the beach being about 30 seconds away. And what a secluded beach - there's usually only a few other people there at any one time. Neighbors are friendly and happy to be there - our favorite was the pair of older guys that peacefully blow seashells like horns when the sun sets - such a nice ritual.
We went in the spring so the surf was occasionally still rough but we swam laps almost every day. Saw turtles every day. Saw whales a couple times. There is no lifeguard so just be mindful with little kids when the surf is rough - make a practice of watching the ocean for a while before entering. The waves at this beach break fast right at the shore, at least when we were there in the spring. There are better beaches elsewhere with softer longer breaks for boogie boarding or surfing. There is a point break just to the left of the condo where it looked like some experienced surfers caught some good stuff. We drove all over the island and tried out tons of beaches and didn't enjoy any as much as we enjoyed our little "private" beach in Makaha.
We worked remotely from the condo and the internet was fast and rock solid. Two of us on video calls, etc. There's a table in the bedroom facing the ocean that has a spectacular view, and then for a bit of separation there is another table in the living room area to work at. It is really special to go for a quick swim during the lunch hour. I loved working west coast hours in HI because you have so much daylight left after your work day! We brought laptop risers and other accessories so we could stand at the tables.
I saw the review from last year about bugs. Per José's guidance, we didn't leave food out and took the trash out every day, and we saw zero roaches during our six weeks. Just keep the place clean and you won't attract them.
The surrounding residential area is not touristy and is a little rough around the edges. You will see unhoused folks living in tents in the area. We felt completely safe in the condo and in the gated complex and did not have any interaction with unhoused people. In general, they seemed to just want to keep to themselves and live their lives in peace.
The local grocery store has everything you need and is a short drive away. Definitely rent a car if you're here for a while. The area is not too walkable and most people drive. I love bicycling but I would not feel great riding on the shoulder of Farrington Hwy which is the main way to get around here. There's also a bus that I wish I tried out because it actually looks like a good way to get down the highway. You will need to drive to get to other parts of the island.
We plan to come back. This is a great deal and the beach seemed like a secret paradise next to some of the touristy crowded beaches elsewhere.