Mixed bag experience for us. Overall not a bad option but with some caveats based on what you are looking for from your stay.
Pros:
1. Large spacious house! Perfect for 2 couples or a big family, too big for just 1 couple. The master bathroom is top-notch. Would be a great value if you are traveling in a big group!
2. Plenty of free beach gear, board games, and water gear (snorkels, surfboards, etc.) You won't have to rent a thing on the island, except the car.
Cons:
1. Host never told us that there would be paintwork going on, on the outside of the house for the first 2 days of our stay. Workers put pain tapes across all windows and doors, which made the place dark even during the daytime and we had to go in and out through the garage door.
2. Even without the painter's tapes on the windows, the place was kinda dark during the daytime (it's a first-floor house in a corner). It's hard to get the hawaii aloha vibe from the house. The patio wasn't too welcoming either.
3. We specifically filtered our search for places with AC since we like to sleep cold but were disappointed to find out the AC was pre-fixed to only go as low as 75. We didn't get the most comfortable sleep thanks to the lack of cooling (the bed was amazing though).