We had a lovely stay at the cottage. It was secluded and perfectly cozy for a romantic getaway with great access to the black sand beach across the street (some rock scrambling required).
Tim met us to check in and gave us a tour, which was really helpful.
The only drawback to the location is that it is a 15 min drive from the nearest town and grocery shopping. Plan on getting groceries in town before you arrive to have on site, or build in time in your schedule to go to Pahoa for meals. I would definitely go back!