The Tortoise and Bird Refuge is a real gem. Kaimana and Michelle were friendly and hospitable and responded promptly to any questions. They live onsite and take good care of the place. When I was curious to know more about the animals, they showed me around and let me hold the baby tortoises! I also got to borrow their snorkel gear instead of having to rent.
The refuge is located within 15 min walking distance to downtown Lahaina and less than 2 min to Baby Beach where I enjoyed eating breakfast while wading into the ocean every morning. The water only goes up to waist height in the protected area but you can swim and snorkel.
At night, the room is cozy and perfect for curling up with a book. During the day, there's plenty of sunlight and you can see a patch of ocean through windows on two walls. I was woken up by rooster crows but got used to it by the third morning.
The parking situation involves occasionally having your car trapped in by the host or neighbor's car, but they make sure someone with keys is available at any time to let you out.
If/when I visit Maui again, I would stay here.