Overall, staying here was a big disappointment for everyone that stayed.

It's a rundown condo that is in bad need of updates and general repairs. It's the ton of minor things that just added up to an overall poor experience over the 8 days.
The Good:
The location is great. Kind of in the middle point of a lot of places to go. The pool area is beautiful and it's right up on the beach. We spent the majority of our time outside here and had a wonderful time.
Now, the bad:
None of the windows close properly. It's either warm wind blowing in the rooms, or trying to sleep while listening to the whistling through the windows all night. Sliding glass door isn't mush better and can barely be opened without two people...sounded like it was going to blow inward a few times with the heavy gusts of wind....the screen door was worse so we just left it open.
Speaking of warm air and cooling, the AC in the living room is done and needs to be replaced. It's time. It's been mentioned over and over again in different reviews. It does not cool anything beyond a 6' radius. After spending all day at the beach, it's nice to come to a cool room at night. Wasn't the case.
Do not expect to sleep if you're an adult and staying in the guest room....my wife and I didn't and neither did my in laws who were nice enough to switch with us for a couple nights. The light has a short in the switch and doesn't work unless you find just the right "sweet" spot....that's a fire hazard.. Also, the fan switch next to it doesn't work either and the fan is stuck on low (no pull chain). This makes it very hot in the room with really no way of cooling besides the floor fan blowing the hot air. Why put a dresser in a room that has no handles and when you do manage to grab one, the drawer is broken? It you don't want us to use the dresser, turn it around maybe?
The place is also dirty. It's been "cleaned", but beyond the general wipe down, it's gross. Mildew growing along the wall in the bedroom bathroom. Dirt on the walls, floors, etc. For the price that each renter is paying for the "cleaning fee", the condo should be much cleaner. The ceiling fans were the worst.
I sent a message to Kelli and Michael about some of this and never got a response. I assumed they got it because the next day I asked about receiving mail and got a response right away. Take that for what it's worth.
There are certain expectations when renting a Air BnB, especially when it's an expensive condo in Maui. In the end we all had a wonderful time visiting the island and will be back. We will not be staying here, and based on our experiences, don't recommend you do either.