Overall our stay was pretty bad. I wouldn't normally leave such a terrible review, but I emailed the property owner after we left, and never got any message back, so here it is.
The major issue that I emailed the property owner about, that no one ever responded to, was that there was a strong mildew smell coming from the basement. There is a ton of moisture in the house with the windows open without air conditioning. There is mold on one bathroom door frame I saw. (I didn't inspect the basement because the smell was too strong) In the morning the tile floor would be moist throughout the house from rain overnight. Two of us had allergies so bad we had rashes, sore throats, and congestion. We thought we had COVID and had to go for testing and quarantine during our vacation. All of our symptoms cleared up as soon as we left the house.
The pool is also unbearably cold. My 200 lb tough guy husband couldn't even take the cold. If you're going in the winter, you should plan on not being able to use the pool. Maybe it's better in the summer.
There were other more minor maintenance issues like the roof leaking in the kitchen, oven is broken, ice maker is broken, water filter in fridge is overdue to be changed so water trickles out, toaster is broken on one side and doesn't work right on the other, sliding glass door lock fell off the wall, toilet flapper valve has a leak, and a few other things that we called the property manager about on Day 2. The property manager was very nice and offered to come fix everything, but with COVID going on, we decided to live with these minor problems. We didn't realize at the time that the mildew/mold was going to become such a huge issue with a COVID scare or we would have left.
People should also know that it's an open ceiling layout to let heat escape through the roof since there is no air conditioning. This just means that you can hear EVERYTHING throughout the house. I was in the shower and had a conversation with my husband doing the dishes in the kitchen. You can hear everything through the ceiling. So just think about that from a privacy perspective if you're traveling with another couple or you want privacy from your kids.
A positive thing to say is that the beds are comfortable, you can hear the ocean waves crashing at night (the bugs and birds are a bit louder than the ocean, but it all sounds cool), and the porch was lovely.