My husband, our youngest 3 children, and my sister recently stayed at the Maui Eldorado vacation rental and enjoyed our stay.
Pros:
-good location; 10 minutes from the great shopping and restaurants in Lahaina off Front Street
-spacious; accommodated 3 adults, 2 children, and a baby comfortably
-great for people who loved to go jogging/walking
-the pool was very close to our unit and was great for children (would be nice if it was heated though)
-there were free golf cart rides to the beach cabana
Cons:
-we had to purchase laundry detergent; there wasn't any that we could find
-loading and unloading luggage was difficult; wished parking was closer to unit
-knife set could be better quality