Our (4 month) stay at Teresa's condo was wonderful. The place is aesthetically pleasing, comfortable, clean, provides a gorgeous view off of the lanai (a view which can be seen from the dining room and living room), has a lovely cross-breeze (just keeping the windows open keeps the place cool and pleasant almost always) and has all of the amenities one could desire. The surrounding complex/resort is kept up incredibly well and the other residents of the complex are friendly and welcoming. Teresa was amazingly responsive and unerringly pleasant to communicate with.
The only issue we had is the loud rooster crowing that begins around 4am and can last for several hours. Thankfully, the bedroom windows mostly block out the sound when you close them (though this gets rid of the splendid aforementioned cross-breeze). If you are a very light sleeper, this could be an issue. That said, this issue is in no way Teresa's fault, and is probably an issue wherever you stay in this resort (and, I suspect in most places you can stay on Molokai - where roosters abound).
If you are coming to Molokai, I have no qualms about highly recommending a stay at this little slice of paradise.