My husband and I stayed at Jim & Judy's place for 3 nights at the end of May. The condo and its grounds are very high-quality and well-maintained properties. The condo itself is very tastefully decorated and outfitted with top-of-the-line items for guest use and enjoyment--stereo system, beach chairs and umbrella, lanai, etc. The property is very luxurious, with a large swimming pool and two private beaches where we saw turtles swimming regularly and from where we enjoyed watching the sunsets. Between the pool and the beaches, we really didn't need to go anywhere else for the relaxation we were looking for on this trip. However, the place is also close to a fantastic farmers market/ grocery store, wonderful public beaches, and some great eateries. Jim was very prompt in his communications with us, and had everything ready to go upon our booking, including a Google map identifying everything we would need in the area. We especially appreciated his recommendation to Star Noodle in Lahaina, which we dined at twice!
Being from Vancouver, we were not accustomed to how hot it gets in Lahaina. There are ceiling fans throughout the condo and a great cross-breeze if you open the front door and lanai screen. However, we did have to use the air conditioner when we slept which is rather loud, so we had to use earplugs (as the air conditioner is actually only in the bedroom).
I would consider staying at Jim & Judy's again and heartily recommend its accommodations to others.