Pros:
Excellent location. We went an hour + in multiple directions and felt like we had a great home base. At the same time, the kids jumped on the bikes and rode to town.
Communication: Susan and Lynn were very warm and responsive. Within minutes for any requests or questions.
Amenities: We really appreciated having beach towels, chairs, umbrella, cooler, bikes (even sunscreen).
Air conditioning. YAY. and lovely landscaping.
Cons:
The place is dated and has signs of wear that are not apparent in the pictures. This ranged from some decor to more foundational things like finicky gate and broken door (which is scheduled for repair). It's also definitely not an "estate." It's a solid home. Which is awesome as long as you know what to expect. No need to over sell.
Goodbye before you arrive. Lots of emphasis on what you must do/clean when/before you leave. Which felt unwelcoming, especially given the cleaning fee.
No welcome book with house details or other welcome details like coffee, water, cookies, wine- as we've experienced in homes all over the world. Not required but pretty standard at a certain price point of home.