I don't like leaving bad reviews but wish we'd seen a review like this before we booked:
First, the good: My wife and I stayed at Pele's Eye for two nights during our honeymoon and we really enjoyed the location (close to South Point and Green Sands Beach) and getting to meet Ruebon. Ruebon was friendly and accommodating.
Now the bad/ugly: If you are afraid of creepy-crawlies this is not the place for you. The outdoor bathroom is well-designed and, for a couple of Montanans, pretty novel during the day. But, at night, we unexpectedly experienced a cockroach infestation in the thousands - on the floor, walls, ceiling, toilet paper, etc. And with cockroaches came their predators (scorpions, geckos, giant centipedes) which made the enclosed bathroom space pretty unusable. We were surprised the first night when we tried to take a shower after a day at the beach and couldn't step without there being cockroaches underfoot. We ended up going without showering that night. The bugs also left their excrement everywhere they went - which was everywhere in the bathroom. We don't know if this is an ongoing issue due to location or if it recently has become a problem, but this was our experience and it was shocking.
Now, this was not an issue during the daytime. Only when the sun went down did the bugs come out. Also, this was never a problem in our bedroom, where we never found a bug. So, if you aren't bothered by thousands of insects when you use the loo or can avoid needing the bathroom or shower after sundown this place might be for you.