Pluses
1. True, exotic Hawaii experience.
2. Next to nearby orchards, beach, tide pools etc.
3. Friendly and helpful hosts.
4. Reachable by phone/text.
5. Stocked with some food/amenities like: wipes, coffee beans, honey, salt, pepper. (nice)
6. Cooking possible. (nice)
7. Some basic utensils provided. (nice)
Minuses
1. Unreliable wifi.
2. The place is not spacious enough for two adults for > 2-3 day stay.
3. The bathtub does not have shower curtain (there is a curtain to cover the bathroom though).
4. Inconvenient to wipe water off the wash basin after use.
Neutral:
1. 20 min drive to grocery shops.