Booked this Airbnb for a work trip last minute. While the critical reviews seem more accurate to me than the positive ones, it had upsides: free parking, comfy bed, decent location, fast internet and a nice outdoor area.
It's no-frills though. There was a literal hole in the drywall. The fridge had yellow stains all over it. The bathroom felt grimy. The appliances were old. The furniture was rickety, and the host responded with what felt like pre-programmed messages. When I sent a question specific about my trip dates, they didn't even respond, but later sent me a generic message about hiking trails while ignoring my actual inquiry.
Maui was busy during my stay due to a global corporate event that booked out almost all of the hotels and inflated prices. As a last-minute place to rest your head and take a warm shower, this was a great place to stay. That said, I wouldn't recommend this place unless you're getting a great deal relative to the other hotels/rentals nearby.