The Plumeria Cottage exceeded my group's expectations. It had a quaint atmosphere; it was comfortable; it had all the amenities we needed; and the porch with the grill was one of our trip's highlight.
My group's main goal was to do as much outdoor activities as we could, and the Plumeria Cottage's location allowed us to achieve that goal. It was also a comfortable drive away from Honolulu, so we encountered no issues on the few occasions where we wanted to go to Honolulu city.
Personally, I loved the strong water pressure in the showers. It was rejuvenating after a warm day filled with hiking and snorkelling.