You won’t find many places cheaper than this. For that reason alone, I would say stay here! The location is a bit out there, account for an hour or more drive time to anything you wish to see.
The place itself is very cute and offers more than I had anticipated. We had a few hiccups upon arriving our first night and sadly, there is zero cell reception so we had to just go without until the following day when we went into town and could reach out to our host. They responded very quickly and fixed everything we had asked before we had returned later that evening. Fantastic response time and super helpful, just know you won’t be able to call about anything from the cottage itself.
Lastly, the place is not private. The pictures do help depict a sense of isolation but in reality the street is littered with makeshift homes, abandoned cars and some people living in perhaps less than ideal situations. This did not effect our stay in the slightest. You’re paying a fraction of what most do when visiting Hawaii, this is bound to come with some setbacks. I didn’t care that the neighbors and garbage were all around but for some, this may be a bit of a unwelcome surprise.