Taking my parents around Hawaii for their 80th birthday so everything had to be just right in terms of cleanliness and comfort and charm.
Puolani cottage exceeded all my expectations. It was so adorable in photos but even more enchanting in person. The personal touches -
the stuffed octopus on the computer desk to the miniature Christmas tree on dining table - really made the cottage feel less like a vacation rental and more like home.
The cottage is ideal for two but I found it to be quite comfortable for three. There was enough room for privacy as well as gather to cook /eat meals. My parents really enjoyed the bed and I thought the sofa was really comfy too. So much so that we slept in both days we were there!
Communication with Mark was superhost level - friendly and proactive with clear info about eruption updates, checkin /check out procedures , house manual.
Definitely try to stay here if you are planning to visit Volcano National Park!