Overall: Pretty Good. This is the perfect place to stay if you want to get away from it all and don't mind driving 3+ hrs/day to get to the good beaches (or simply, don't care about visiting beaches).

Cons:
1. Location is VERY out of the way. It's far away from most things to do in Maui. Example: to get to any of the "top 15 beaches" in our guidebook, we'd have to drive 1.5 hours. We found ourselves driving a LOT.
2. Road to get in is a narrow dirt path with large potholes. You share this road with oncoming traffic, which gets awkward at times.
3. Showering (outdoor shower) was a bit stressful because there were mosquitoes out there.
4. Taxes are not included in the price, so have cash on hand. We were not expecting this.

Pros:
1. Romantic, secluded cottage in lush jungle setting.
2. Sharon is very nice, and we were never left wanting for anything.
3. It's a great place if you want to avoid others and don't mind driving a lot.
4. It's close to Hana (which we didn't particularly care for, as there were way too many tourists and mosquitoes while we were in Maui, but is still worth checking out)