Overall the property was amazing. We would stay there again, but here are the pros and cons as we saw them.
Pros: Great house, very nice, very comfortable. Had everything we needed, pool toys, cooking equipment, binoculars for whale watching, etc. Beautiful landscaping. Wonderful view. Excellent communication from the rental company. Plumbing problem was addressed immediately.
Cons: HOA rules dictate quite time at 9pm, so staying up chatting on the back porch made us worry we were being too loud constantly. Especially since we heard the neighbor below yell at another neighbor for their dog barking briefly. If you are sitting on the porch furniture, or in the pool, it is fairly private, but if you are standing next to the pool or elsewhere in the backyard, you are on full display to the neighborhood.
The cons were not enough to dampen the excitement of of trip and we had wonderful time.