Tory's place was very clean, nicely updated appliances, well stocked pantry, comfy bed, and the A/C really kept the place comfy. I can't speak much to the Aston's amenities (other than towel service which was great) as we mostly used this as a jump off point to do things in Lahaina (lunches, dinners, Warren and Annabel's, surf lesson at Outrageous Surf was awesome) or to head north (delicious dinner at Merriman's, Gazebo breakfast, snorkeling in Honolua Bay). Everything was at most a 15 minute drive away. If you start your trip here there is a Snorkel Bob's across the street where you can pick up your gear for the whole trip and drop off at any one of their several locations (get the upgraded fins and mask).
Check-in and check-out were a breeze.