I definitely recommend Floyd's place. First of all it's in the perfect location if you are definitely going to do the road to Hana or the red sand beach. If you have a car which I recommend, it's close to a super cute area called Paia. Surf beaches are all very close to here. And it's about 40 min drive to some of the resort locations. We split our vacation and did both. I def recommend getting a place with air conditioning. I also liked that it was close to a couple of grocery stores and you can make your own meals with Maui being so expensive. The apartments are all nice (we stayed in two different ones) and described accurately. We stayed over Hurricane Lane. Everything held up perfectly and Floyd was really helpful to make sure we had everything we needed. We had no problems with communication or anything for that matter even during a hurricane! I recommend going the extra mile and checking out Island Fresh for a meal or yoga! We had an amazing stay regardless of a day or two of bad weather. Thanks again Floyd!