Stayed in Cara's place for 9 nights with my husband. It is a really great place if you want to explore the whole island by car, snorkel in Hanauma Bay (5 min away). It took us about 15 min to get almost everywhere we wanted and around an hour to get to the other side of the island. Uber to Honolulu would be about 22 usd one way, in case you want to party all night :) Tons of grocery stores and cafes are about 5 min drive away.
The place is really quiet, very clean, with a soulful touch to details and 2 cats who came to visit us. We love cats :) There were also all the needed small items like an umbrella ( we had to use it a lot), iron, shampoo and etc and a local pineapple!
Cara is a wonderful host and I dont know how she managed, but she always answered all our questions within a couple of minutes.
We would definitely recommend this place for a romantic getaway