Four of us (two couples) went to Kihei for a relaxing beach vacation so we wanted an Airbnb close to the beach. The location of this Airbnb was perfect -- just a 5-minute walk to the Kamaole I beach. Keith & Tim also provided fantastic beach amenities including snorkels, chairs and a blanket. (Pro tip: use the snorkels to see turtles in the coral north of Charley Young beach.) We loved eating most of our meals on the lanai (porch/balcony) because of the beautiful ocean view. We cooked most of our meals in the Airbnb and were more than satisfied with the cooking equipment (pots, pans, strainer, cutting boards, knives, dishwasher, etc.). We had a unique code to enter the Airbnb so we didn't need to worry about passing around a key, which also simplified our stay.
We had one unfortunate issue: Keith asked us to sign a contract via DocuSign. Airbnb's policy (https://www.airbnb.com/help/article/465/can-hosts-ask-guests-to-sign-a-contract) is that Hosts can request contracts, but Hosts should note the contract in the listing's description and Hosts must disclose the actual contract terms prior to booking.
Keith's listing didn't mention the contract and Keith didn't send the contract until after we had arrived. In the end, everything worked out, but it was an unfortunate and stressful miscommunication.