I have stayed in many different privately owned rooms at the Ala Moana Hotel and also the hotel itself. Renting is not much different other than you don't get your room cleaned every day and the bellman cannot enter the room without you there (as it is private property). That said, I'm a little biased because I know the staff well already and absolutely can't stay anywhere else. However, it's not for everyone. Read on..
If you are looking for a centrally located hotel that is NOT in Waikiki or doesn't boast room service, restaurants or enormous rooms, then this is the place for you. The rooms are small - I won't lie, but you're in Hawaii, how much time are you spending in the room?!?! The beds are doubles so are also on the smallish side. I think the rooms are perfect for 2-3, 4 is a little cramped. But you can't beat being able to walk to the mall or Ala Moana Beach Park, or get everywhere within a few minutes.
Eva and Mr. Melo are excellent hosts. I asked some questions and always got friendly, prompt responses. The room is clean, well appointed and doesn't have a ton of stuff in there like some other private rooms I've stayed in. I appreciated the simple nature of the room, while also offering a fridge, microwave, coffee maker and utensils.
I will definitely look to rent from Eva again! Thank you!!