My wife and I spent 9 nights in 1207 at Valley Isle Resort. The view from the unit's generously-sized lanai was dazzling, looking directly across the shimmering strait to Molokai. This time of year, the sun sets directly between Molokai and Lanai. Gorgeous! It was the end of whale season, but we watched whales galore almost every day.
The unit was clean, well-stocked, and everything worked. Not having AC was no problem -- we always had the lanai door open and sometimes opened the front door (it has a locking screen door) for good cross-ventilation. Keyless entry meant one less thing to think about. I thought taking the elevator coming and going might be a hassle but it was just fine. Never waited more than 30 seconds.
Miso Phat sushi and a convenience store right across the street, and Maui Brewing is a 2-minute walk. The bars, shopping, golf, and cuisine of Kapalua, Kaanapali and Lahaina town are just a short drive (if the traffic is heavy, you're still only 15 minutes from Lahaina, 5 minutes to Kaanapali or Kapalua). The quiet beach directly accessible from the resort has a little shade to go with the narrow strip of sand.
My Perfect Stays are easy to work with. Communication was great/fast, nothing confusing, no ridiculous or oppressive rules. Got a few emails from them and a phone call the day before we checked out. We were VERY happy with My Perfect Stay's management of our reservation.