We decided to go with Kelly's home because of all the amenities and we didn't want to be around to many tourists. The room/suite was exactly as posted. The space was generous, and completely equipped with everything you could ever need. There was even extra shampoo, conditioner, beach towels, razor, shaving cream, beach chairs, snorkel gear, plates, cups, rice cooker, the list goes on.
You can really get comfortable in this space and we sure did. Another perk was having the Hukilau beach RIGHT across the street. It is not as crowded as the other beaches so it was nice to walk across the street and read a book, take a dip, soak up some sun first thing in the morning.
Since it is not right in the thick of things finding places to eat and drink nearby was a little difficult. The sun also sets on the other side of the mountain so when the sun starts to set, it happens quickly.
Overall we enjoyed our stay, and would love to go back.