This was my second stay here at this Air BnB and I cannot recommend it enough. It is unequivocally my favorite place to stay on the island. It's cheaper than the resorts and it's more private and tranquil than the resorts, plus the western view from the hot tub (which is functionally private) is unmatched. If you're looking for a tranquil and romantic paradise getaway, this is it.
Hutt is also a gracious and charming host who truly understands good hospitality. He'll offer recommendations and come by to chat, but he's not intrusive and is happy to let you enjoy your time without interruption if that's your preference.
Overall, I cannot recommend this place enough and I know I'll definitely be back in the future.