We had a great time on Maui. We really liked the location and amenities at Nanci's place - several bars and restaurants within walking distance.
As others stated we also were surprised about the arrangement with both bedrooms rented to separate guests - I don't think it was apparent from the description/the case when we booked our stay in December, but it is apparent now - and wasn't a problem at all, since our bedroom locked separately and the a/c unit was a good white noise generator.
The kitchen and bathrooms were clean and equipped well (there is even spf70 sunscreen that Nanci provided us).