We are new at this, so still learning.
I'll start with what's not great:
Also the sign to find the place is in a terrible location - we passed it twice trying to find it!
It's not a hotel - so nothing gets replaced like toilet paper, etc. We would prepare for this ahead of time next time so not necessarily a comment on this property!
There weren't enough forks for 6 people but they responded within 24 hours with a set of new ones so no problem there... but there weren't enough soup/cereal bowls or cups either. We made do as we didn't want to complain about everything and somebody had left a travel mug so that was our 6th cup. As long as you are versatile you'll do ok! There were many many glasses and enough plates, but it would be nice if they say 6 guests and there were at least 6 of each item.
One of the chair legs was broken and we reported it but it never got fixed so we did our best to fix it.
What's with the rule with $100 fine for hanging clothing to dry on the balcony? Using the dryer heats up the place making the AC so very necessary. Perhaps this is a rule everywhere in Maui?
The stove really needed to be located on a wall so there could be a fan so the heat of using the stove doesn't heat up the room so much.
Other than that, the place was nicely stocked with many extras like condiments - that would have been nice to know!!! We would not have bought near as many condiments had we known this.
There are also nice Hawaiian decorative and useful touches like Whale shaped measuring cups, silicone hot pot holders, a blender, and a garborator (which i didn't know was there until the 2nd last day - maybe put that in the notes)
It is a good location - not beach front but one could say 'across from the beach' beause it is just a very short walk to the beach - the walk across the long parking lot is equal to the walk across the street to the beach.
Nice beach - part rock and part sand, with water station to wash off your feet, and beautiful view of the sunsets! There are delightful kitties that roam wild but are very friendly and we found to be delightful! We did BBQ a couple of times at poolside and use the hot tub and found it all quite accommodating. Nice security guard - good to see him to often - felt watched over!