The good: Rosalyn is a very kind and responsive host, willing to accommodate things like early check-in. The place has a really good location walkable to poipu-area beaches. Internet was great.
The bad: the space is very modest, was quite dirty, and in need of top to bottom renovation. The kitchen had a couple large sticky stains when we moved in that I scrubbed out. The bathroom had hairs from the previous guests. Any surface that is not touched regularly (eg the top of a picture frame or blind) has a 2-month supply of dust build up. The kitchen was missing some basic supplies like a cutting board. A broken dish was left in the plate cabinet. The bedroom ceiling fan is missing the chain so the only way to turn off is to throw the bedroom breaker switch. Carpets are fraying and wood is splintering all over. The pool is okay for kids only.
Bottom line: if you go in with budget-expectations and are getting a price to match then go for it. Things that mattered most to me were good.