I would definitely recommend Caroline and Scott's place!
Caroline was very helpful and communicative right from the start and answered any questions I had quickly and thoroughly. The space itself is very nice, the private hot tub is amazing after a day of relaxing at the beaches. Everything that you could need was provided. It's nice to have such a private space a little out of town but a quick ride to everything. Next time I come to the Big Island I will certainly be booking their place again!