Really enjoyed our stay at Martin's place. Martin was a great host. Very communicative and responsive.
The home itself was great. The location and view are hard to beat. The view is incredible and waking up to the sounds of crashing waves was tremendous. Taking a walk around the beach and resort was awesome and peaceful.
A lot of the resort is abandoned/empty, which actually made things way better for us. Very unique experience to be in Hawaii and not be surrounded by massive crowds. The isolation also comes with some negatives people need to be aware of (Martin communicated all this to us ahead of time): There's basically no restaurants closer than ~20-25 mins away. There are a couple of convenience stores nearby but their selection is limited. All that comes with the territory when visiting Molokai. Not an issue for us, but something people need to be aware of.
The car rental was a nice option. It's an older car but it got the job done.