I almost jokingly gave Tracy 4 stars just to break her 5 star record. But I couldn't do it -- this apartment was so clean, so well appointed, and so beautiful that I had to give 5 stars. The kitchen was so well stocked that we cooked every night; it even had two trays to bake pizzas on! And two casserole dishes for making nachos. I couldn't have asked for more kitchen appliances.
The only thing I would recommend is to check for cheaper prices at this condo, Kihei Bay Surf, on other websites -- a couple of people we met in the pool had found better prices than us on local Kihei apartment rental websites.