Alisha's place is perfect if you'd like to get closer to locals and/or if you'd like to save some money (Four Seasons hotel is 3 times the price per night!). The place is big and comfortable, 5 min walk from the central square in Lanai City, where you'll find cafes, restaurants and grocery stores. There is a shuttle service that will take you anywhere on the island for $10 per person per ride. The shuttle drivers are very chatty and they know a lot about the island. I recommend staying at Alisha's place and use the shuttle to go to the beach!