I highly recommend Shelly & Tom's place of choice if you like a place that has the most relaxing atmosphere. They are very hospitable and welcoming. "Home away from home" environment.
They can provide you with lots of tips if you have never been to the island. Very comfortable bed, which is important to me! Great location.
Far enough from the noisy mainstrip, but you can walk down the short hill to the ocean.
I enjoy relaxing and watching the sunset on their lanai after a full day of outing.
I was looking for a private suite with a kitchenette, but their downstairs suite had hotplate, and set up adequately for me to make my own simple meals when needed.
It turned out to a good balance of having privacy and interaction, socializing, and having a cup of coffee with Tom & Shelly!