Unit 308 at Ma'alaea Banyans is a great place to stay if you're looking for a quiet getaway. The property is situated on a quiet street which is generally safe (we had our spare tire on the back of our rental jeep stolen on the first night from the parking lot - but apparently that happens anywhere). Neighbours are friendly; some younger families but mostly older couples; beautiful view of the ocean; comfortable breeze most days; convenient appliances to make you feel at home if you're cooking/doing laundry etc; comfortable bed and bedding. Do note that major grocery stores are approximately 20 min drive away in either direction; you will need to buy bring or rent your own water activity gear; the shoreline directly in front of building is mostly rocky (there is small sandy stretch) but there is a beach at the end of the road. One of the best things afoot Maui is that you can drive to so many beautiful beaches, cliffs, hiking trails, etc quite easily (definitely rent a car).
This isn't the place to stay if you want to be super close to fancy restaurants/busy bars or shopping. But it is the place to stay if you're seeking a peaceful vacation, and want reliable comfortable accommodations for great value. Thank you Cathy for the helpful communication - everything went smoothly and we really enjoyed our stay!