John's place is in a great location in Kihei with easy access to local grocery stores, restaurants, and bars. It's centrally located on Maui so you can easily hit west Maui and still get to the road to Hana and the summit to Haleakala without a bunch of extra driving.
Great kitchen if you like to do your own cooking. We felt like the AC was a must for us (highs in the high 80s and lows around 70), and definitely worth the extra fee. Really nice bathroom and shower, bring your own shampoo and conditioner.
John was super responsive when we needed him and was extremely helpful. The staff at the building is also very helpful if needed.