Our party of four adults really enjoyed Hale Roselani for so many reasons-
*Location: Having been visiting Maui and Islands since the 1980's, our favorite area hands down is the North Shore, and Haiku is the perfect location-close to Paia (with its fabulous Mana Foods market, restaurants, shops and gas station), the awesome beaches of Ho'okipa (windsurf/surf mecca, and oh, so many honus/turtles!), Baldwin Beach, Kaulahao beach which is small, has honus and shade as well. It is also pretty much the last "stop" before really getting started on the Road to Hana. The Kahului with the airport and Safeway/Costco and more is a half hour away.
*The house itself: In a great little neighborhood, spacious, comfortable, well equipped, with a huge lanai. The beds are great, the a/c in the two bedrooms also welcome during hotter temps, the well-behaved and friendly neighborhood pooches, and fruit trees (we missed avocados and mango season, unfortunately, although the breadfruit tree was full).
*The hosts: Ashley and Scott were super helpful and amenable, and made us feel welcome from the get-go.
I, personally would love to return to Hale Roselani hopefully soon. Highly recommended!!