Small but reasonable space for two couples, amazing location and courteous hosts. Our husbands caught a fish on an excursion and Valerie and Larry were kind enough to hang out with us and allow/show us how to use their grill (not part of the standard amenities). it was fun to chat and our fish turned out absolutely perfect!
Space is small, and you need to be ready to listen to the sounds of the neighborhood with open window sleeping (not different than most places in HI). (This might be different than a resort experience, but not different than any other local place to stay.)
There are a TON of water loving amenities that we just didn't have time to take advantage of... beach chairs, snorkel gear, kayaking... and the tools to pack it on your rental car if you want to drive around with this as base camp. I'd be back in a heartbeat with enough time to take advantage of these perks at Valerie and Larry's place!