Location! Location! Location! Everything is nearby, within walking distance, shops, food, beach. To go sighting seeing nothing is too far. Besides the mountain and blowhole everything was reasonable amount of time. Nearby grocery store is short <10 minute drive.
Buying fresh local fruit on the island and being able to cut it up and have it at home was nice. Avoided eating out several times by making stuff at home (usually breakfast for dinner :) it had everything we needed to make easy breakfast.
Beach chairs were nice! Umbrella doesn't work so well with strong ocean breeze (but no surprise there).
Plenty of towels and linens. Fast Wifi. Plenty of cable channels on TV to watch when adjusting to time change (not much to do when awake at 3A lol)
A/C only cooled the living room, never really cooled the bed room. So it was really difficult to sleep in bedroom on hot nights (75+).