Kaimana's place is the best. It's a great location if you want to be in Lahaina and walk to places for food and drinks and spend some time snorkeling on the west side of Maui. Kaimana and her staff were all very friendly, helpful, and accommodating and made my stay awesome.
There are many animals who were a treat to be around. It was always fun to watch the chickens and tortoises and come home to friendly cats with cheerful greetings. At the end of the day it was nice to sit with those sweet cats and relax on the couch. All the dogs on the property are very chill and well-behaved. And despite the many animals, it is very clean and there are no odors inside or out.
The room I stayed in was clean and had everything I needed - clean linens, soft pillows, towels for the shower, a beach towel, outlets, multiple ceiling and window fans (it was very hot when I was there and these helped), space to store my things, etc. I only heard the roosters once or twice, when I woke up after 7am, but could usually hear them when I was up around 6 if I left my room and went downstairs. The shower set up is a little odd at first glance, but in practice it was completely fine throughout my 9-night stay with 2 other guests who rotated through the other room.
I would highly recommend Kaimana's place and would love to return on any future Maui trips. She is a great host and I love the Lahaina area.