A group of ten of us stayed at the house. We enjoyed the house--very spacious, great yard and pool. Dishwasher was broken at the time and some of the shower knobs weren't working all that well, but the place was mostly in very good condition. And Donna was very friendly and responsive.
I would give it five stars, but a month before we were set to arrive--five months after we had booked and fully paid--Donna emailed a contract she insisted we sign with all sorts of terms that were not disclosed on the listing. Her house, her rules, but AirBnB policies are clear that, if a host wants guests to sign a separate contract, any terms need to be disclosed prior to booking. These weren't. The contract asked for a large security deposit, listed all sorts of fines that she could impose if more than a certain number of people were at the house at any given time (ambiguous as to how many--in some places it said 10, and in others 14), etc. Donna said she was waiving the security deposit when she sent the contract because I had good AirBnB reviews, and the rest didn't end up being an issue for us, but we might have booked elsewhere had the contract been disclosed earlier. We had no intention of throwing parties or anything like that, but we had some family in town because it was the week before our wedding, and we might have wanted to have some of them over during the day. If this transparency issue were fixed, I'd give the place two thumbs up.