Book it; don't think twice. I hesitate to say this because then the secret's out, but I had to since Peter and Yi were such great hosts. The space was spotlessly clean, shower and pressure amazing, and has every amenity we needed including a kitchenette with coffee supplies, small refrigerator, and microwave. There is even a dispenser of reverse osmosis water to fill your water bottles. We didn't feel the need to use the AC but appreciated that it was available. They really put a lot of thought into the space - it felt more like a really nice hotel room. Although the Garden Room is attached to the main house where they live, it still felt very private. We also had our own lanai and bathroom. If you're a nature lover, consider keeping your windows and door open in the evening so you could enjoy the chorus of birds in the morning. We do not smoke cigarettes/cigars, but it is acceptable if you keep it outside. No issues with household pests. They were also gracious enough to allow us to store our luggage AND borrow beach chairs, towels, and snorkled gear before and after check in/out. (We had an early flight in and late flight out.)
I can't emphasize how awesome Peter and Yi were as hosts. They were so welcoming. We hung out with them a bit and they gave us firsttime visitors valuable advice/suggestions. Their suggested itinerary was much appreciated as we went on our Road to Hana adventure. They gave us full privacy and were very engaging when we sought them out. You can tell they truly care about their guests' experiences in their spaces as well as on Maui. Thank you for an unforgettable visit.
P. S. Beware of these pool sharks! They may have just gotten their billiards table, but don't let them fool you. 🙃