We loved the Love Shack and Carter and Shelby were very responsive. Very comfortable beds and couch. We enjoyed eating on the lanai and reading in the hammock. Wonderful quiet beaches and great sushi within walking distance - we had a terrific stay!!!
Note to those with tweens/teens - most of the activities and beaches my kids wanted to do were in Lahaina or near Black Rock so that required more driving than I would've liked. Not a deal breaker - just be prepared. Good news: more excuses to stop at Leoda's for pie!!!