We have mixed feelings on our stay with BethAnn.
First of all the rules are simple rules in the end and easy to follow. BethAnn has signs everywhere what you need to do.
We were quite surprised that someone who has so many restrictions and rules for guests, doesn’t stick to the rules herself. BethAnn has a very different day and night rhythm then most others; most of the nights she goes to bed very early and we respected her quiet hours. However she wakes up at 4 am and starts cooking (you can hear all the noise with pots and pans, she is not considerate with that as well as the smell coming into the bedroom), FaceTiming out loud (not using earplugs or anything and after asking if she could make less noise she apologized but just continued FaceTiming again). Also she watches movies in the middle of the night without being considerate about noise.
Furthermore, we only got 1 towel pp for the entire stay of 6 nights. When asking for new towels, BethAnn told us we could wash it for 3 dollars at the laundry service.
You are able to walk to your room/bathroom after 8PM. You can’t go to the lanai with the nice view in the evening for a ‘late’ dinner.
The room itself is ok. Bed is comfortable but be aware that you are sleeping next to the hallway which can cause a lot of noice. That didn’t bothered us.
The location is perfect. Right in the middle of the whole island and that’s perfect to visit all the nice places you want to go. Especially snorkeling spots and you are next to the Harbour for your whale watching excursion.
The car (if you have rented one) needs to be parked on the street next to some bushes. Be aware as the trees leaves a sticky stuff on your car that attracts cockroaches.
You can’t park your car anywhere else and when we mentioned this to BethAnn she only was surprised but was not searching for a solution.

In the end we think you can get better value for money at other accommodations.