We were frankly super surprised our experience was not as nice as other reviewers. First impression: The complex is a bit older, so don’t expect a “posh, luxury vibe” but is nicely maintained and we did feel safe. (E.g. There were some very nice cars in the parking area AND bike with flat tires). Pros - REALLY wonderfully close to the shops and restaurants in Lahaina, but far enough away not to be noisy; very nice neighbors and pleasant pool/grill area; thoughtfully updated; host did respond when we reached out each time e.g. on supplies and brought them the next am. Cons - dishwasher had water in the bottom of it when we arrived, but I tried it anyway right away as some glasses looked dirty. It leaked on floor - luckily I was right there and stopped it. Owner came by to fix and then next day - after we found the range and cooktop did not work either - the repairman fixed it. As compensation, Tabatha gave us a $75 credit for the appliances not working.
Ok, stuff happens but: dirty, (floors - bring slippers, multiple couch stains, bathroom smell we could not get rid of even though I tried cleaning the floor and around toilet ourselves). Description says kitchen basics - there were none; listed washer/dryer - but was not in unit, was in other building for a charge; listed hot tub which is empty (for weeks?) and apparently will not be fixed soon due to shortage of supplies per neighbors. Much needed AC is super noisy making it difficult to sleep. There were 2 rolls of toilet paper in the unit for a 6 night stay for 3 adults. When we asked for more the host brought one more roll. . . We waited a couple days and specified 4 more rolls please, (which she quickly brought). We would stay here again as the host was very friendly and responsive, the issues are (assuming) very fixable and the location was exactly what we were hoping for.
Also just a heads up especially if you have kiddos - note, there are not sidewalks in a couple places to get to condo from downtown area. Just part of being in Lahaina!