I cannot recommend Sean & Taryn's place enough. I stayed here with my wife for a very short 3 day, 2 night staycation since we live on the island of Oahu.
As a couple, and travelers with very little time, this place was perfect. Although it is not a beachfront property like many other options, and is not located in the resort areas on the West side and in Kihei etc, it is centrally located and is perfect for doing day trips.
For example on our first day before check in, we arrived in the morning and immediately started our day and spent it driving along the entire West side, ending the day at Whalers Village, then coming home before around 9. We enjoyed their beautiful home just for the evening. The bed was very comfortable and the room looks exactly like the pictures, if not better. One of the house rules is no loud noise after 9PM and that is completely understandable. It was nice to lay out on the pool area in the evening to enjoy the evening air and look at the stars.
Then the next morning, we left very early to do the Road to Hana, came back, stopped by Haleakala for sunset, then went home again for the night for light dinner and rest.
On the last day, we had a late flight. So we did early morning snorkeling at Black Rock, then spent some time in Lahaina. We had to check out at 10AM that morning, but Sean and Taryn were kind enough to allow us to borrow their towels and return them before we left.
They are very prompt with their communication and if you have any questions regarding your stay in Maui or something about their property, don't hesitate to ask. Again, highly recommend them. If all that doesn't attract you, the average price for other Airbnbs and hotels that I looked up at the time were all at least $300 more than what we payed for.