We really enjoyed our stay at Mary Jo's place! The AC units worked really well and kept the condo cool inside despite the 90+ degree heat outside. The bed was very comfortable and we slept well every night. Check-in was easy, the unit was not too far from the available parking, and we had everything we needed inside. There is some construction going on in the lot next door, so during the day there was a lot of beeping and other noises which seemed to be especially audible in the condo due to the minor spacing in the window between the glass and the hole cut out for the AC exhaust. If you're looking for a place to hang out at throughout the day, that might be an issue, but since we were out exploring most of the time during the day, it wasn't too much of a bother
Also, it was in a great location in Kihei, which after doing some exploring, seems like the best place to stay for what we were looking for. Just a 10 minute walk up the street were some restaurants, bars, and a market area with a decent number of vendor booths. We got food and drinks a couple nights during happy hour at Three's Bar and Grill. We also booked a water bike tour + a kayak + snorkel tour which were both at Makena Beach 15 minutes south