We loved our stay at Cherie's cottage! It was very comfortable for four of us, and makes really excellent use of a small space. We found all the kitchenware we needed for cooking and eating, and also found beach chairs, towels, some snorkeling equipment, and even a pair of walking sticks.
The location was perfect for us since we were visiting a relative nearby. I think it would be an excellent location for anyone who wants to be away from the bigger population centers. It's quiet, and the stars are incredibly bright. It's a reasonable drive to the volcano or to Hilo or to Kona. The nearby town of Naalehu is charming; it's even a pleasant walk from the cottage, with great views of the ocean on the way in, although it's a bit hot for walking if you're doing it on a sunny day.
There are a couple of cottages on the property, and you may be aware of the other guests, but everything is spaced out far enough that this isn't a problem.
We recommend this place most highly to anyone who wants to get away from it all on Hawaii, and I expect we'll stay there again someday!