Overall Value
Overall the price-to-value tradeoff was average. If I go back to Maui I plan to find another place, but I'm happy with our stay overall.
Cleanliness
In general the house was well cleaned and prepared before we arrived. The bathrooms looked remodeled recently and dishes/sheets/floors/porches were all as they should be. The trash outside hadn't been emptied for what looked like weeks. Front yard looked scraggly. Neighborhood/cul-de-sac is very unkept.
Accuracy
My biggest complaint is that there are hidden fees with this property. When calculating your expenses, you can factor in another $250-$300 for "TAT" & "GET" Hawaii taxes that are creatively hidden in the depths of the description of the place. Not until I left did I hear about this charge.
The bedrooms are actually really nice and comfortable. The pull out couch is not comfortable - If you're taking a trip that would require an adult to sleep on the pull out couch, I would recommend considering other options. If you're going with your family, maybe the kids could stay on the couch and be fine (disclaimer: I'm not a parent so take this comment with a grain of salt).
The photos make the lot seem more remote, but the house actually resides in a pretty cramped cul-de-sac that is not well kept. Check out google street view to get a better feel.
Another primary challenge we had was the lack of kitchen supplies. Small pans, lacking cooking utensils (pizza cutter, etc.), bowls, etc. We had to get creative with cooking.
Washer/Dryer machines onsite which was a nice touch.
Communication
Great communication time, left out a basket of treats and a handwritten note as a welcome to us. Really helpful. Other than the surprise of the fees/taxes, communication was great.
Check-In
Location
Location is pretty good. I expected it to have a view of the beach or sunset, but the beach is only a 15 minute walk away which was doable. The little town area near their house has great restaurant, coffee, dessert, and shopping areas as well as places to find deals on touristy attractions. I strongly recommend Lava Java's Blended Iced Coffee - it was a daily staple for us. Pretty good access to the beach and other activities.