Would definitely recommend for a break on the road to Hana! Great half way point for us (we did it backwards and drove from Wailea and stayed here one night, then finished the road and stayed in Paia the second night.)
Go to the pizza place/farm at night (but stop in the center and get alcohol before you do if you’re planning on drinking.) Also everything closes early so plan accordingly.
Sharon’s place was great. It’s exactly as described; a rescue farm for animals. There are some cows, goats, chicken, ducks, a pig, and two dogs. She was very responsive and helpful. The cottage is directly next to her house and was comfortable and clean. There are small critters, like some ants, but that’s to be expected in a location like this, and wasn’t bothersome. It was a little loud at times like when it rained, or when the sheep were expressing their opinions, but again, to be expected and totally fine.
I would highly recommend staying with her and would definitely stay again.