We really enjoyed staying at John and Maggie's place. We stayed in the one bedroom cottage and it was absolutely perfect for us. The cottage was very well equipped and had everything we needed, plus more. The cottage was stocked with many essentials such as paper towels, napkins, toilet paper, soap, shampoo, etc. The kitchen was also well equipped with coffee maker and grinder, toaster, microwave, pots/pans, plates, cups/mugs, etc. There was even spices for cooking! The cottage also had beach towels, snorkeling gear, ice chest, cooler bag and body board. The washer and dryer also came in very handy.
We also enjoyed their cat, Trouble. He enjoys roaming the grounds and would often greet us during our morning coffee on the patio. He is not allowed in the cottages and would not attempt to enter, even if the doors were briefly left open. Trouble was very sweet and friendly.

The location was also great! It was close to everything and yet far enough to enjoy the peace and quiet after a long day. We were able to reach most ends of the island within a 1 hour and 30 minute drive; with the exception of the drive to Hana. Although Hana Highway is nearby, the drive to Hana is lengthy due to the many sights to see and stops along the way. The beach was about a 15-20 minute drive and the airport is about 35 minutes away.
We highly recommend John and Maggie's place! We hope to be back on our next trip to Maui.