This review is based on just a one-night stay.

PROs:
Marco texted to let me know that the unit was ready waaay before the 3pm check-in time. The apartment was clean, not carpeted (yay!), had a strong AC unit in the corner, and fully furnished. And by furnished, I mean with everything you could possibly imagine: towels, toiletries, Wifi, TV stocked with DVDs, and even snorkeling gear. There was also a folder that contained a descriptive list of places to see on the island of Maui, fun things to do on the island of Maui, and good places to eat on the island of Maui. We didn't follow through, but thanks anyways. BTW: the apt is also right across Sugar Beach - very convenient for anyone who wants to swim, snorkel, or just feel the sand tickling between your toes.

Oh! For those worried about mosquitos (Maui = tropical island), I didn't get a single insect bite staying at this unit! Most impressive. Blood-sucking bugs are naturally drawn to me and tend to feast on me like a buffet luau...

CONs:
We forgot to ask Marco to pull out the sofa bed for my brother! By the time we were ready to sleep, we couldn't figure it out, and it was so very, very late, I felt like we shouldn't be bothering his apt manager anymore. This is NOT Marco's fault - totally ours - I didn't have enough foresight to give him a head's up. We also couldn't find any extra bedsheets or blankets to put over the sofa, so my brother had to use beach towels. Again, NOT Marco's fault - it could've been avoided had I just ASKED during daylight hours. Finally, the batteries for the remote controls for both the TV and DVD player were out of juice; oh well, we weren't here for the TV anyways.

All in all, a great place to stay. I'd recommend this to people in the future.