My husband and I and our 2 girls spent our spring break at John's condo at Kihei. The condo is literally less than a minute's walk from the Kamaole Beach Park II at Kihei. It is very conveniently located with the beach right across and a variety of little shops and local eateries along the road a less than a block down.
The condo itself was very spacious and very well-kept. It was a very good and comfortable place to come back to after a day of tiring activities. There were very clear instructions on how to use the TV/Washer-Dryer unit etc. John had provided everything someone might need for a couple of days of vacation thoughtfully. The condo complex comes equipped with a swimming pool if beaches aren't enough! John was also very helpful in providing clear instructions on check-in, things-to-do etc.
Just for the location alone, I would give John's place 5 stars. I would highly recommend this for anyone wanting to have a good time at Maui.