We really enjoyed our stay here. The room was clean and the house orderly, directions to the house were fantastic and Rina went out of her way to help us, including giving us blankets to watch the sunrise (which definitely came in handy as it was freezing up the top of the crater!).
Although Paia is further out from the main tourist attractions and beaches, it was actually a really great place to stay and relax. The restaurants were fantastic but not overpriced, the shops were good and best of all, you weren't getting hounded by people selling things every five minutes.
If you want a quiet, relaxing place to stay that is still walking distance to fun shops and restaurants then this is the place for you.