For those that require a place to sleep in Kihei that plan to do activities outside of the unit for most of the day, this place would be fine, especially if you're a deep sleeper.
This is the second unit from South Kihei Road, so road noise is fairly consistent. Without A/C, this means that you have to keep windows closed if you want to reduce the noise to sleep more soundly. I'm glad we were visiting in the Winter, but I'd imagine it's uncomfortable without cooler temps. The unit is South-facing so the sun beats down on it all day and makes the main bedroom pretty stuffy. The internal bedroom was cooler and we used that.
Regarding the beds: all were decently comfy! My only issue there was the lack of usability of the top bunk since it was 6" over the recommended height and had no usable guard rail space due to the mattress being so tall. If you wanted to use this for kids, it would be impossible to do so safely until they replace it. For adults, it's a "use at your own risk" situation aka don't sleep there if you're prone to rolling!
The floors were very dirty when we arrived, but they offered to have the cleaners come the very next day. We declined and I mopped instead to reduce interactions with other people on our trip given COVID. I'm guessing this was not the norm since the unit had other good reviews, but I feel skeptical of those reviews now. The rest of the cleanliness was just OK. The age of the unit and dirt-stained grout tells me that it's been a long time since a very deep clean, something which this unit could certainly use.
The pool at the unit is shaded for half the day and the water is relatively cold. If you want a place that has a great pool area to lounge in, however, it was rarely crowded there. The BBQs right next to the pool were great for grilling our meals as well!
The beach nearby has lots of coral and good beachcombing. Waves are small and both the beach and adjacent fish pond are great for kids. A beach umbrella in the unit would have been a bonus to enjoy the beach more fully since there's no shade there, but we managed and had fun.
Overall, given the relatively high price over the holidays, street noise, lack of A/C, view of parking lots (the photo from the lanai is not accurate as it's taken at an extreme angle), cold pool, and griminess, we'd definitely find somewhere else to stay in the future.
Pros were the good communication from Dan, ease of checking in/out, usable kitchen with supplies, and fun exploring the nearby beach. If this place is fixed up a bit and A/C is added, it would be great for a cheap stay!