The good: bed was super comfy, you can hear the waves crashing from the bed at night, it's a great sized space for 2 people (I don't recommend more than 2), and the location is a great, central spot in Maui. Kitchen was well-stocked with pans, utensils, etc. We did not have any issues with parking (although the spots are VERY compact and we witnessed two different individuals throw their car doors open and hit the cars next to them and act like it was not a big deal-- it IS a big deal if you have a rental car).
The not-so-great: cockroaches in the bathroom in the early hours of the morning (on multiple days), lipstick stains on glasses in cupboard, other guests can be loud outside your windows at night (we were woken up at 2 a.m. on two of our nights there) and other guests will "reserve" the few lounge chairs by placing their stuff all over them and then disappearing for hours.