Pros:
Amazing location.
Bikes/beach accessories.
On site parking.
Easy communication.
Early check in accommodated.
Nicely decorated.
Cons:
No trash bags.
Full dishwasher on arrival - all dishes inside needed to be rewashed. Dishes/cups/utensils inside cabinets and drawers also needed to be washed before use. There was a strong chemical scent inside the cabinets as well.
Mattress/pillows had a musty smell.
Terrible mosquito problem. We understand mosquitoes and bugs come with the territory of island living. Our situation was nuts. They were what seemed to be an endless amount of mosquitoes throughout our stay no matter how many were killed. There were dead mosquitoes on the walls from the prior stay that was not cleaned up. We had to purchase bug spray and continuously apply while in the cottage. We were uncomfortable the whole time.
Not sure these cons really justify the cost per night even if the location is ideal.