‘Stop looking and book this place’ is the best advice/review-summary I can offer. I won’t bother to repeat what all the other reviewers have written (about great hosts, great location, great space, sparkling clean, how the beautiful photos depict exactly what you’ll find when you check in, etc., etc.).
In addition to all the other reviews I will offer that at Lily’s we experienced something that we have not otherwise come across in over 30 years of booking condo’s and BNB’s in Hawaii: hosts that have equipped their cottage with a combination of great (and tasteful) artwork, expensive and effective ceiling fans in every room, expensive throw rugs, nice towels, heavy duty steak knives and cutlery (and very nice kitchen appliances) and expensive glasses and cups that you’d be happy to have in your own home - including a coffee grinder and a better than decent coffee pot (something you can never seem to find in most Hawaii vacation rentals)! In short, at Lily’s you feel as though you’re staying in someone’s very, very nice home that the owners have given a great deal of thought to decorating and equipping - as opposed to the typical marginally-furnished vacation rental.
Eric and Lily have obviously worked very hard to equip and maintain a very high quality BNB.
I hope that you stop looking - and simply book a stay at Lily’s Cottage. There’s a reason virtually every review gives Lily’s 5 stars.