Our party of 8 adults and 3 toddlers stayed at this 3bed/2bath cottage comfortably. On our first day there, we had to air out the cottage since the place doesn't have A/C. Other than that, the cottage is located about a minute walk from the beach. It has a washer and a dryer, which was a plus for washing the dirty clothes and towels, and a bunch of beach gears/toys for us to use, which was a big plus. The cottages in the area were well kept, and the place was quiet at night, per the community rules. Carol was quick in returning my text when I needed to get a hold of her. Fortunately for us, the parking is right outside of our cottage so it made getting the luggage in and out of the rental cars fairly easy. There's a 2 cars per cottage limit there, but they did accomodate our 3 rental cars.
I'd say you can't go wrong booking this place. The location is amazing, and the place is really nice. We would definitely stay again if we were going to Lahaina in the future.