My husband and I spent a week in the Seashell Cabana, overall a very nice place!
The inside was clean but we had the visit of a few crawlers, which is very normal in such a tropical place! The patio was pretty dusty and dirty due to some construction work and the gardeners blowing everything every other days.
The apartment is nice and cozy, the only bedroom is big enough and the bed is very high, so be careful if you have back or knee issues, or if like me you are on the shorter side. I had to climb in and out of bed, which was fun only for a few days.
There is everything you can need in the kitchen and bedroom / linen cabinets - very convenient! Lots of storage place for your stuff also.
Conveniently located a few minutes from downtown Lahaina, close to the beach and ocean side, very quiet at night!
The neighborhood is peaceful and respectful, you can lounge outside in the hammock and take a sweet nap when the closest pool is quiet.
Under normal circumstances, I would think it's overpriced for what you get - pictures are edited and very bright. Even though the place is definitely charming, it is not as luxurious as it looks like in the pictures.
But, in the area, with covid and the touristic season, it seemed to be in the average prices and at least you get to stay away from the swarms of tourists you could run into in big hotels and resorts.
Peace and safety has a price! :)