The apartment was very clean and inviting, and the view from their balcony was truly amazing. Furthermore, Lisa and Gary prepared a small gift for us since it was our honeymoon, which was very sweet :). We felt absolutely welcome and comfortable at their place. The only thing that future guest should keep in mind is, that the dryer takes some time to dry the laundry (we had to run it 4 times for one batch). An overall 5/5 star stay!
PS: If you want to rent some bikes, you should check out http://www.mauimolokaibicycle.com They have a fantastic and very, very heartwarming service! 6/5 stars! Thanks again @ Jimmy and Phillip!