We really enjoyed Valerie's cottage. The location is great, right near Paia with tons of great food and close to some cool beaches as well. Valerie was very welcoming and invited us to hang out on their water-front area and watch the turtles.

The cottage itself is really cozy. Paia's a bit of a walk along a mostly sidewalk-less road or 2 minute drive away. The listing mentions this but the highway noise is quite noticeable. There's a constant woosh woosh of cars on Hana highway competing with the sound of the waves. You definitely won't feel secluded from an auditory perspective, but otherwise it was a fantastic place.