Good value and location. But there were lots of details that made it less appealing in reality compared to the photos. We were greeted by a couple of dead roaches on the floor. (Sure, it's a tropical island and there's bugs, I get it, but the previous Maui rental we stayed at did not have this problem.)
My biggest problem was the sleeping arrangements. One bedroom had dirty linens and no fitted sheet, just a flat sheet folded around the bed. One of the sheets had a black clump in it that appeared to be a smushed dead bug, and I woke up to a live roach on my pillow one morning (!). I felt unclean and uncomfortable sleeping in that bed.
More minor: all of the bath towels are stained; a couple of windows were broken and would not close; a drawer in the kitchen was broken; the ice machine gave us trouble. Towels and linens are all dollar-store quality which would be OK if they had been clean. Not much attention to detail or cleanliness here. Ironically, the 'cleaners' show up 20 minutes before the scheduled check-out time and stand there pressuring you to leave early. I really wanted to love this place, but I didn't.