This review is for a separate unit at Maui Hill since we couldn't stay at Josh's unit due to a last-minute maintenance project by the Maui Hill group.
First things first, booking and communicating with Josh was a breeze. We were super excited about the prospect of staying at his unit because of the modern decor, amenities, AND proximity to the beach. It's a ~10 min walk to the beach (when you're carrying umbrellas and toting a baby) and centrally located in Kihei. So 10/10 for Josh, and we'd love to try to stay at his unit in the future.
The actual unit we stayed in had a great view of the ocean and some of the amenities of Josh's unit. It would have been nice to have the streaming options on TV and the bose speaker, but you're in Hawaii, so you're enjoying life outside as much as you can. The decor was outdated, and there was a lot of carpeting that didn't feel particularly clean. The front desk wasn't as friendly and organized as they called me a couple of times to fill out forms over the phone.
All in all, we would return to Maui Hill, especially for Josh's unit and the location, but we're wary of the curt and disorganization of the front desk.