For us Sheri's place was a great match for our group of two couples. Plenty of privacy between rooms and both very spacious! Easy check in, good communication.
In hindsight the location wasn't ideal for us as the activities we ended up doing were all based on the south of the island. But Sheri's place itself was great. Heaps to explore and restaurants to visit in the area, but it you are going on tours see if they can be done on the north shore first.
Thanks Sheri!