We were 6 friends and our stay at Jim's has been really pleasant.
The plus of the house were the spacious rooms and living rooms, the location ( 1,5 minutes max, from the door to your towel facing the ocean), and Jim's availability ( he was very quick to handle the bug situation we had due to the recent hurricanes ).
On the other hand, the house can get pretty hot during the day, the tableware was scarce for 6 and Jim's need to collect taxes (14%) came a bit late.
All in all, we had a great experience on Maui and Kihei.