We really enjoyed staying in Sugar Shack 3, away from the crowds, amongst the coffee growers. Loved the gardens, outdoor dining area, bamboo furniture and very comfy bed. Bathroom clean and well set up (...occasional amphibian visitors!) Kitchen had everything we needed, but fairly basic.
Kelly had some top suggestions re: snorkeling spots and local food stops and was quick to respond to questions.
I recommend arriving during daylight, as even though instructions were very clear, the driveway was a little hard to see with our dark, rainy night arrival (we were delayed).
If you are squeamish about critters you may not enjoy staying here, as you are surrounded by nature. Also internet was sometimes intermittant.