Pele's Eye is a cute little suite with beautiful views of the south island. Reubon is a great host with excellent suggestions for adventures and hidden local spots. We loved getting to know him and Cougar, his friendly cat.
The road into Pele's eye is not for the faint of heart. If you are not familiar with driving rough, rural roads, be sure that you ask for a rental vehicle with good tires (and that you know how to change a flat)! Clearance is not an issue, but the rocks are sharp and numerous.
We would love to return to Pele's Eye someday (with a better set of tires).