Lisa/rebekah's place is in a very nice gated community with a private beach and a nice club house. The place was clean and met our expectations. 3 bathrooms is a plus. Enough linens and beach towels were provided as well. Except for a few ants, there were no other issues. Every room has a box air conditioner.
Although it is in Lahaina, it's a bit of a long walk (25 min) to downtown. So we ended up driving all the time. Also the list price does not include taxes and parking fee etc. By the time we added all the fees, we ended up paying about $500/night for a 3-night stay. So not a good value for the money and hence 3 stars for value. They do advertise at lower prices, so if you can book at a price you like, then go for it, but keep in mind there will be additional 15% in taxes plus 11 dollars a day for parking.
All in all, I fully recommend Lisa's place.