We enjoyed our stay at Floyd's place. The kitchen was large, clean, and stocked with olive oil, salt, pepper, and even to-go containers. It was great to have access to beach chairs and beach towels, and the private (and covered) hot tub was nice for when it was too rainy to head to the beach. We also appreciated the location: the apartment is close to Paia, some lovely spots in Haiku, and of course, all the beautiful beaches along the North Shore.
There is significant noise transfer from the upstairs guests, and it can be quite loud depending on their level of awareness/conscientiousness. If you are a light sleeper, I'd suggest booking an upstairs unit instead.