We had a great stay. We spent most of our time there on the lanai enjoying the view. The unit and the complex are immaculate and very well kept. The location is good as far as access to either West Maui or South Maui. The unit is very well stocked with everything from the kitchen to the coolers and beach gear. Other than food, we didn't want for anything.
We were there during a time of high winds for all of Maui and this area is known to be windy in particular. But it was never unpleasant. It was nice to be in a location that was not a big commercial / touristy area, like Lahina or South Kihei. Easy to visit those places but nice to come home to the quiet of Maalaea.
We'd be happy to return and highly recommend Gail's place. I'd also like to recommend Hawaiian Rent a Car - really easy and fantastic service, and Snorkel Bob's - very helpful with lots of convenient locations.