Five stars all around. Clean, well stocked kitchen (for baking, grilling, coffee, juicing, you name it). It exceeded our expectations in cleanliness, convenience and the host's professionalism. The hosts were responsive and honest - when a chair rack broke in the garage, they responded by saying it was obviously an installation issue, and not broken by us (which was true) and they reassured us that we will not be held liable for it.
Location was amazing - a beautiful 5 minute walk through the Grand Wailea to the beach front, 10 minute drive to Makena beach, ~15 minute drive to Safeway or Foodland and 25 minutes drive from the airport/Costco =) We rented a 7 passenger Suburban and it fit in the garage.
The gated community was a nice bonus. The pool is amazing, and the hot tub was perfect for the cloudy/breezy days for the kids to splash around in because it wasn't too hot, and the sand pool and everything else about the enclosed pool area was perfect for the family to spend the day! The picture doesn't do the pool justice, because it was much bigger and grand than we had expected.
Overall, it was such a lovely stay. Nothing negative to mention and thank you for an amazing time!