I am reviewing only to notify others of what to expect, because I feel like the other reviews painted a rosier picture than what was.
First, the place wasn't super clean. We take shoes off in the house, and within minutes our feet were black. We actually purchased a swiffer to be able to adequately clean the floors. There is mold on the shower curtain. The bed wraparound was literally yellowing in patches - it looked like someone had smoked in the room for ages. Same with the curtains, which were yellowed and dusty and we hated to touch.
Second, the place just didn't come as stocked as we expected based on the advert and others' reviews. There wasn't snorkel gear - even though that was clearly stated. There were only 2 beach towels, despite us notifying the hosts that there were 3 of us staying. There were only 3 sets of regular towels, meaning we did laundry every day to have enough towels for all of us plus a bath mat. And basic cooking supplies - like cooking oil and pepper - were nearly out and forced us to purchase. I don't stay in an Airbnb with the expectation that I will need to buy the most basic of living supplies. If I wanted that, I'd stay in a hotel (it would be cleaner!).
Third, communication was not great. When I booked the place I asked specifically about toddler-friendly activities on the island. Never received a response. Then upon check-in, I realized that we didn't know where we were allowed to park; I messaged the host and heard back the next day. Finally, there were no instructions about where to take garbage, or how to leave the place upon our exit, which we just had to guess.
The positives were important, but fewer. The location of the complex in Kihei and next to the beach is fantastic. And the location of the apartment within the complex is also very convenient.
All in all, would not stay here again.