We greatly enjoyed our stay at Lucy Fan Ohana. My husband and I stayed for a week. The apartment was as described. We didn't get the chance to meet Tim but he was very helpful and responsive by text. Judit was welcoming and helpful. She has some good life stories and if you have a chance to see her Lucy collection you're in for a treat. The kitchen was well stocked and there was an abundance of Maui related information. The living area was comfortable. The bedroom is upstairs via a spiral staircase, if you have mobility issues it could be an issue especially using the bathroom in the middle of the night or if you have babies or toddlers. There was a choice of mini coolers, beach chairs, boggie boards and snorkeling gear available for use.
The location is great for a slower pace and less tourists than the south and west parts of the island. It's a great location to start for a one day drive to Hana or to go to Haleakala for hiking, sunrise or sunset. Haiku is a quiet little town with lots of great places to eat. The locals were very friendly. It's close to Makawao and Pa'ia which are both always hopping with people and have a variety of shopping. There are not a lot of great beaches on this side of the island but we did enjoy Baldwin Beach. If you want to surf, windsurf or kitesurf this is the place to stay.
We would recommend Lucy Fan Ohana to our friends and would stay again if we return to Maui.