Given that this is essentially a resort booking through a different model and not someone's home, I think it's only appropriate to judge it as such. For a family with young kids looking for a week plus stay, this would be the perfect place. It was large and well appointed. For a short term stay, for those looking to explore Maui, it was not the greatest location. Everything was a 15+ minute drive (and 2.5 hours from the airport during traffic) and the beach resort had no beach access (although there was public access just a short walk away. The room was nice, but the carpet had a moist/musty odor. We didn't expect a perfect view, because the listing said it didn't guarantee one, but we expected a "scenic" one, as per the title of the listing and the photo. Instead we got a grand view of the valet stand.