We had a great time staying at Amy's place! It's a cozy little space, but was perfect for us. Beach gear, snorkeling gear, and a cooler was all there and the beach is right across the street! While this may seem like an odd thing to write about, it's important if you have long hair :) - the water pressure in the shower was unbelievable.
I would definitely stay here again if we make a return trip to Maui!