It really is a great value. Personally, I enjoyed being in Kapaa much more than visiting Poipu. That's me though- I like the local vibe and laid back atmosphere. If you're looking for a manicured resort, this isn't it. This is the place that reminded me of Pacific Beach in San Diego. Everyone was so chill in town and extremely welcoming. I would recommend ear plugs for the roosters- they get going around 2:30 am.