Pros:
-Great location- walking distance to many beaches, shops and restaurants
-Clean place
-Nice bathroom
-Responsive host
-Comfortable bed
Cons:
-The bedroom/main room is very small. Maybe providing square footage would set proper expectations.
-There is no view. You can't even see out the window, but if you could you'd be looking at the parking lot.
I've paid less in Maui for much better value (even within the same building). If it was 20% cheaper I'd give it 5 stars