We LOVED Tracy's Tropical Treasure! Depending on what you like when you travel we would totally recommend this place. We like clean, cute, relaxing and the ability to prepare some of our own food. This place has all of that. The pool is plain jane concrete did not use. The beach directly across is scruffy but no problem because we drove to different beaches. We stayed in the Marriott as well on this trip and we much preferred our stay at Tracys to that. The beach is of course nicer over there but the room was dated and super expensive.It is so nice to be able to do some food (esp since we are vegan and like to eat healthy) and not have to eat out every meal. Tracy is a pleasure to deal with and I would only stay here if coming back to Maui. BTW our room at Maui coast was better than Marriott.