Josh's place is a sum of all the good reviews you are reading and more! Great value, great location, great living space and especially great host!
The beach supplies that are left at your disposal are an excellent touch in order to let you enjoy Maui without the hassle of renting equipment.
The location is perfect as well. Quiet and not a far walk or drive to any beach along the west shore in Kehei. Lots of great restaurants and shops nearby too.
Stop looking for that perfect place, you just found it!