We loved our stay at the cottage on Pipeline/North Shore. It was EXACTLY what we were looking for; private, on the beach, comfortable and clean. It had the rustic feeling of staying at a cabin in the woods. The redwood was warm and the deck and views were amazing. Paul was kind and helpful and greeted us upon arrival, gave us some information about the place, then left us undisturbed. We felt relaxed and rested and didn't want to leave. Mahalo Paul and Josh!