Pros: The location is great! The beach across the street is wonderful, there's a great little market nearby and the drive to Wailea and Makena are lovely and easy. The lanai is protected from the winds and rain and was great for sun bathing or reading in the mornings. The beds are comfortable. The kitchen is stocked with everything you need for cooking. Josh is quick to respond and helpful. Washer and dryer and soap is provided. Also, lots of towels and beach towels are provided and that was great.
Cons: The wifi isn't great. There's no cell service here (I have AT&T, so you might have better luck). The living space doesn't have any pillows or throws or anything to give it a cozy, comfy feel. Definitely read the fine print so you're expecting to pay taxes and parking fees on top of the nightly rate. The water leaks out of the shower like a river, but Josh said he's having that fixed, so hopefully you won't have that problem. We had a lot of rain and the roof was leaking, which created a lot of noise from the dripping so we couldn't sleep (Josh will probably have this taken care of ASAP so it shouldn't be an issue for you). Cleaning fee is steep and you're expected to do dishes and take out trash and recycling. Some dishes were put away dirty, which isn't a huge deal but just kind of gross. Also, toilet paper is only provided for the first 24 hours. That's pretty silly to me, especially for the high nightly rate. That should always be taken care of. There was no toilet paper in my bathroom and I learned that a little too late. Also, the way the upstairs is designed, the winds catch the rooftop and create a TON of noise. Napping is nearly impossible if you have any long days exploring.