Overall we had an ok stay at the surf shack. It looks like the pictures. It comfortably sleeps 6, however, doesn't comfortably seat that many people. There is one sofa which seats 3, and a chair which is sunken and not very comfortable. The other seats are bar stools. So I would say comfortable seating for at least 6 people is something that could be improved.
I liked the location it was central and we could get everywhere we wanted pretty easily. I loved that it was away from the chaos of the super touristy areas. There were fireworks every night we were there (9) and surprisingly loud chickens lol.
Unfortunately, there were roaches during our entire stay. This was burdensome on our stay and why I can't give higher ratings. Ants and "island bugs" wouldn't be so bad but the roaches were a problem. We didn't leave food out. we could barely make or eat a meal without roaches coming out. They were in the drawers, cabinets, on the floor, dishes, counter etc.. That part was miserable.