Location of Macy's place is so great! Right at the base of Diamond Head, it's a 6 min drive to the Diamond Head Hiking Trail and a 5 min drive/15 min walk to the beach. Several fantastic restaurants within walking distance (I recommend Bogart's Cafe for breakfast), and the area is just far enough away from Waikiki to where you don't have to deal with a swarm of tourists and traffic everywhere you go. It was perfect for us.
Check-in was super easy, and you get your own parking spot, which is a premium in this neighborhood. The apartment was clean and comfortable, and I appreciated the shampoo/conditioner and body wash available in the bathroom. Also had beach chairs and beach towels for us to use, which was an unexpected perk. And on-site laundry (with detergent!) was a huge plus!!!
The only drawback is that the walls are VERY thin and you can hear everything the neighbors next door are saying, as if they were in your apartment. If you are not on the same sleep schedule as your neighbors, this could be an issue. Because of the thin walls, there are also "quiet hours," which sucked for us because we're nocturnal and like to stay up late watching TV. We felt very constrained by the quiet hours (and annoyed to be awoken by the conversation of our neighbors at 6am). But other than that, this is a fantastic AirBnB that I would return to, despite the thin wall issue. I'll just bring ear plugs and wireless headphones next time. :)