We had an amazing stay! There were six of us and plenty of room for all. Pleasantly surprised by all the beach gear, chairs, floaters, etc. The beds were comfortable - even the sofa bed. I was prepared for the teens to complain about it after the first night because those usually aren’t comfy, but they said it was great! The kitchen was well-stocked. They even had vinegar which came in handy for a sea urchin incident. The views were incredible and everything was walkable - beach, restaurants, etc. We only used the rental car for trips to Safeway, Hana and Lahaina. Would stay again in a heartbeat. Absolutely lovely.
Thank you, Viktoria!