This place was private, secluded, clean, well-furnished, had all the amenities we needed, and was only 50 minutes from Volcano National Park. We, too, appreciated the binder of recommendations and ate at the Punalu'u bakery, visited the black sands beach and saw turtles before visiting Volcano. We recommend arriving in daylight to get an appreciation of your surroundings and locate the place (it's pitch black at night - wonderful for stargazing.)