For us this is a five star place and we would rent it again. While there is no clear view of the ocean, you can get a glimpse and hear the waves crashing against the breakwall. The condo is located at Carlsmith Beach Park which is a lovely area but requires a short drive into town if you are in need of groceries or want to dine out. There is one restaurant across the street open a few days a week for dinner. For us, that was not an issue, we much preferred the lovely out-of-the-way quiet spot. We were also able to see green sea turtles daily.
As many others have noted, the complex is older and dated but has been well maintained. Roxanne has decorated the unit with lovely artwork. The kitchen is a galley with older but serviceable stove and refrigerator. There is enough cookware and utensils to cook a meal but there are none of the basics (seasonings, oil, etc.) to do the job, so purchasing those things if you are only staying a short time is not very cost effective. The screened in lanai is a wonderful place to have breakfast or an afternoon/evening glass of wine. No bugs!
The only issue we encountered was the check-in. So dark in the lock box area we could not see the combination and did not know how to open the lock box.
For us, this is a five star. Others may find the things I have noted to be a drawback. We would definitely stay there again.