We would definitely stay again! The place is charming—a bit dated, but not rundown, besides you're in Hawaii, go explore! The location is amazing, we walked most places in town. Gregory and Candy were very welcoming and communicative.
The hotel / resort staff were the only frustrations we had and that was mainly because they were really bad at explaining things/giving directions -- they made everything seem more complicated than it actually was. For instance, the parking garage is under the building next door and the entrance to the garage is on the main street. They gave us turn-by-turn directions and showed us a picture of the building (making it seem much further than next door). We figured it out, but it was unnecessarily confusing/stressful.