Here's the pros
1) Willingness to help and fix whatever problems
2) Beautifully decorated home
3) Close to the beach/downtown
4) The upstairs bed is so comfortable

Cons
1) No living room--the description listed living/dining room but to be perfectly honest it's a small kitchen with tall a table and 3 chairs and window seat. My parents are older and like to sit around and chat with the family--not easy here.
2) Roaches--this is fully disclosed after you confirm. I stayed at 2 other Airbnbs on the island no roaches even though this is supposed to common. You'll receive a manual about all the bugs. It's hard to cook in a kitchen with roaches coming out the knife holder and dishwasher.