We stayed 9 days in the cottage at John and Maggie's property, it's a lovely location just up the hill from the sea with long views down to the ocean from the hot-tub. I like this area of Maui, it's convenient for visiting upcountry and starting the Hana highway.
The house was fine, very spacious lounge/kitchen area, good facilities. Wifi was fast and reliable. Only thing we missed was not having a dishwasher. John and Maggie were around if we needed anything, but didn't intrude. Occasionally we saw other guests in the gardens, but there's lots of trees around to make the place feel secluded.
Happy to stay here again if we're back in Maui, good value.