This place was okay. We thought we were splurging on something really lovely for our honeymoon, but it was a bit more basic than we'd expected. Totally fine if basic is what you're after, but we were hoping for more comfort and luxury.
There had been a storm and blackout the day before we got there, so I guess it was hard to clean before we arrived... the bathtub was really dirty when we got in, with lots of hair on the shampoo bottles and in the drain. Some of the pillows also smelled of mold—probably due to the storm that caused the blackout. The wifi did not work very well.
Also, I recommend renting a car, as the road to town is dangerous to walk—there's no sidewalk, and cars go really fast. Also be aware that there aren't many swimming beaches nearby.
Paia is a really sweet town, though! And our stay was good enough. Just want to warn anyone looking for a luxury place to stay within walking distance. :)