The perfect Hawaiian anti-resort.
Every night, we went to sleep with the sounds of waves in the distance and woke to the sounds of birds. Walking 5 minutes to Make Horse beach, we would share this perfect place with maybe 10 other people. Driving 5 minutes to Papohaku Beach, we shared a mile and a half-long beach with maybe 5 other people. Each night, we would grill local fish, beef or vegetables and sit on the lanai watching the sun go down through the trees.
Do not come here if you are expecting much in the way of dining choices, a gym, or air conditioning (which really wasn't needed). If you are going to complain that you can't find your favorite salad dressing or that there aren't enough "activities" to do, Molokai is not for you.
Do come here if you want peace, lovely people, and absolutely no crowds.
We go to Hawaii a couple of times per year and this was our first trip to Molokai. It won't be our last.