Pros: Great space, decorated perfectly for the square footage. Very clean. Follow Jen's directions - not the link that you get on the website (this took us 40 minutes out of the way, one way). Jenn's directions are correct. Snorkel and boogie board available. Awesome little electric cooler that was PERFECT to keep our water and cold coffee cool until morning. We forgot to buy ice, so it was extra great to have that!
Cons: A bit off the beaten path for us. It's about 5 miles off rt 11, 2 of which are slow going on gravel. The internet worked at night, but didn't work in the morning when we were trying to make plans for the day. Just use your phone, right? Um, no. No signal. That may be fine for you, and it's still a great value.