Overall we had a great stay. Of course, the number one reason to choose this place is the view. It is amazing! We used the lanai for breakfast, sunset viewing, and general lounging. The location is pretty good, halfway between Kapalua and Kaanapali but also a little tough because there isn't a beach to walk to (we knew this though). Really, our only hesitations were in the kitchen where we felt the stove top needed to be replaced (some of the burners don't work well). Plus we felt the kitchen could be better stocked with a tea kettle, for instance. The bed is comfortable but the sheets didn't fit well and kept coming off. The beach gear is great and useful but we had to rent snorkel gear because we didn't find the snorkel gear at the place very good. And also we couldn't find fins! One big thing to note: there are no beach towels. This is a huge bummer because you'll either have to spend about $17 for each or pack your own which is bulky and takes up space.
Overall we liked this rental! It was quiet, comfortable, and had amazing views but with a few updates and changes, it could be spectacular!