We had a great stay at Macy's! The home is immaculately clean and the location is perfect if you don't want a hotel or a car. We had plenty of places to walk during our short stay in Honolulu. Macy went above and beyond to help coordinate baby gear rental for us, and was welcoming for Christmas.
As others have said, the walls are thin and noise transfers easily. This wasn't an issue for us except that it was difficult to keep our toddler quiet for the sake of others. I share this so others can consider when planning their trip.