My husband, son and I had a great stay at Surfers Hale! The location was so easy with a few restaurants, a market and the beach all within a minute or two walking distance. And just a short drive away was some of the best beaches and snorkeling we found on Maui (Napili Bay is the best)!
The place was very clean and bright, just as the photos depicted. The kitchen is small and minimal when it comes to cooking supplies but worked just fine for a vacation home.
A huge plus was to have a washer/dryer right there in the place as we often had very wet, sandy things to deal with at the end of the day. Also, there were beach towels and beach bags there for our use which was convenient.
The only con was that the fold out bed was very uncomfortable. The mattress is extremely thin and the bars of the frame underneath could be felt when lying down. It worked fine for our 11 year old because he is small and slept sideways on the bed. It wouldn't be great for a larger person (over 70 lbs) or two people.
Surfers Hale is a great value though and would be perfect for a couple or family with a young child.