Being right on the water was amazing & worth a lot. We saw whales daily and loved the beach and pool. This part of the island is so central and great for exploring all that Maui has to offer. Melanie's communication was top notch - proactive as well as responsive - she got back to me right away when we had a question during our stay. The place itself is cute and very functional. It is cozy and lacks privacy (if that is important, consider another place), but it was perfect for our group of girlfriends who enjoy togetherness. When one person is up, all are up pretty much.
The new taxes make everywhere expensive and the value seems to be less and less each time I come to Maui. Three years ago we stayed in a much bigger place with two extra bedrooms for the same price. I don't think this is a reflection on Melanie, but the value for what is basically one big room with a loft, open ceiling bedroom and pull-out sofa bed was low in my opinion. The other factors somewhat make up for it.