The place was clean and a really good value for the area. We come to Hawaii every year, sometimes twice, and move around islands and locations. This was the weakest place I've rented in years. Unlike most places near the water without a/c, you can't really get good airflow through this unit, especially if you're not in the unit because there's no way to lock the screens and anyone could wander onto the property. So it was really hot...and this was in February when the max temp maybe hit 80.
This was also the first AirBnB I've reserved that did not provide coffee, at least enough for the first morning before you can go to the store. There was like one scoop left in the fridge from a prior guest. No sugar or creamer at all. I read a few reviews saying there were beach chairs and equipment provided but I don't know what those people were talking about. There was only one camp chair (not a beach chair). There was a sad little umbrella that wouldn't stand up to any wind. No boogie boards (first place we've rented that didn't have all of the above). The beach towels were tiny and thin. And while there were like a dozen pots, there was only one small nonstick pan with which to cook breakfast food. So even though I was disappointed in the size and structure of the place itself, it was a good value, my main complaint is how little effort is put into providing amenities for guests. The reason we get a condo instead of staying at a hotel is solely for amenities like beach equipment and being able to cook.
I was also extremely disappointed that the property doesn't recycle. Even out in Hana all the condo complexes recycle - there's absolutely no excuse for it in the middle of Lahaina/Kaanapali. So while I wouldn't exactly NOT recommend this place, because it is a good value, you get what you pay for so go in with your eyes open.