I would definitely stay here again next time I come to Maui. Not exactly in the thick of the tourist Maui which was perfect for us. You really get the feel of an authentic sleepy surfer community in this area. Baked Coffee, Nuka Sushi and Sip Me Espresso were all highlights for us. Somehow the rain made the whole thing even more cozy in the cottage. If you are looking for something off the beaten path with a relaxed local vibe, I'd highly recommend Amy & Joel's sweet little cottage.