We really enjoyed our stay! The hosts provide a lot of extra little things that we appreciated: beach chairs & toys, as well as laundry and kitchen items that are not always provided with other rentals. We really felt at home.
The location is excellent: very close to Brennecke's Beach and a short walk to Poipu Beach.
Only area for improvement in my view was the pool area: the hot tub was not heated, and periodically there was a strong sewer smell there.
Overall, we really liked the place and would stay again.