Overall this was a clean and well-maintained unit and I think this place would be great if there were just a couple of changes.
One thing that we were really looking forwards to was the kitchen which had every appliance you could ever need, but we weren't provided any basic cooking needs such as oil, salt, pepper, etc. We were leaving Hawaii after our two day stay there, so buying these basic cooking needs, although cheap, seemed really wasteful.
The no A/C was disclosed in the listing so I can't be too frustrated with this aspect, but for how hot and humid the nights are, this place should have A/C. Additionally, opening the door to try to let some cool air in made it hard to sleep since the ocean was so loud.
Similar to the kitchen, there were tons of beach supplies provided (snorkel gear, boogie board, fins), but then for the most basic beach need: beach towels, there were only two for our group of four.
This wasn't really a big deal, but I think I should mention it – in our group of four, by the time the third person showered, there was no hot water left. Each person was only taking around a five-minute shower. Again, not really a big deal because it could be mitigated just by spreading out when everyone showered.
The final thing was that the check-out time was kind of early (10AM). Again this was disclosed in the listing so I can't complain too much; however, someone came to kick us out a couple of minutes before the already early checkout time which kind of put a sour taste in my mouth.