We stayed at John and Chris's place for our honeymoon and had an incredible time. The place is a mother-in-law suite below the main house with separate entrance that gives you privacy.
Hot tub was an awesome addition for relaxing at night. The lanai was great for eating on. The elevation makes a huge difference on temperature compared to Kona.
John and Chris were great to stay with. Very helpful and made good recommendations for things to do on the island. They were great to talk to and so helpful.