Haleakala Cottage was an amazing experience for my girlfriend and I and would highly recommend it to anyone interested in staying on the North Side of the Island away from all the big resorts and heavy tourism.
The home was exactly as described with new kitchen appliances and the staff was impeccable. They give you privacy but are available when you need them and Lori is extremely responsive over text. She gave great advice on things to do both in the area and around the island in general. She also left fresh eggs from the local chickens for us as a treat for our first morning's breakfast and also a bottle of wine.
Pro Tip: Don't try and do too much when you are staying at this location. It's remote spot on the map offers a very unique and private experience but isn't ideal if you plan to spend all of your time on the other side of the island (as the commute hours can add up. Plenty to do in Paia with great beaches, local, restaurants etc. This cottage is also located right off of the beginning section of the Road to Hana and helped us get a jump on all the traffic for our journey down the road.
One of the best BNB experiences I have ever had and will definitely be returning.