You may notice that Umauma Experience has 2 different listings - so just to be clear we stayed in the smaller 3 bedroom house (the one without the pool). I love Airbnb and hate to leave less than 5 star reviews for any of the listings, but this was very much earned based on our experience.
Pros:
The house was in great condition, there are AC units to keep you cool, a nice big garage to park your vehicle, and most of all the cost was fair (for comparison we stayed at the Naniloa for 2 nights before staying here and that cost us more than our 5 nights here). Perhaps for you this is enough and my cons can be disregarded...
Cons:
Location is further up than Pepeekeo as listed (it's in Hakalau), cell service is not very good (they do provide a landline for your use), wifi instructions were lacking so we weren't able to connect our own devices easily (message/text management prior to arrival to provide you network name and password) and the kitchen lacked some basics like cutting boards.
***Here's what our major disappointment was*** We arrived around 3pm (check-in was 2pm) to find bed sheets were in a pile by each bed waiting to be washed, dishes still in drainer not put away, countertops were dirty. Obviously the house had not been cleaned since the previous guests left. Cell service was spotty so it was hard to get through to management - she apologized and said her regular cleaner was sick and had not even called in sick, so she had no idea they didn't do their job. (I would think it still falls on her to assure that the property is ready for the next guest!) She said she would send someone right away and that there would be compensation of some sort. I asked for the kids to use the pool at the house next door and she said ok - however my kids declined because it looked dirty to them. I think it's just a different kind of pool than they are used to (we have a pool at our house) but that's something to consider for your own kids if staying at the other property. We had arrived with groceries and in order to load them up in the fridge so that they wouldn't spoil, we had to clean the fridge out ourselves. The cleaner arrived and she said "I don't usually do this - I'm just helping out" which to be honest is not reassuring when the house should be thoroughly cleaned between guests... We left for a few hours to get out of the way and returned to what seemed to be a clean house, although the last cycle of laundry was left in the dryer for us to fold and put away ourselves (towels). There never was any follow up on "compensation" and based on management I'm not surprised. I didn't want to make any demands because I regularly use Airbnb and decided it's better to just leave an honest review.