Melanie's place was great and very central for all of the exploring we did on our trip. I stayed there with four family members and my partner. We loved that it was only 20 minutes from the airport and outside of the touristy areas. There were a lot of great places to eat nearby in Kihei. We were able to explore the west side of the island for an entire day, Haleakalā another day, and spend a day driving and exploring the Road to Hana.
The bathrooms were nice and clean and the kitchen was convenient. Loved spending time on the balcony watching sunrises and sunsets and it is quite roomy. The pool and jacuzzi downstairs are great too though we only spent a little time down there since Maui has such amazing beaches!
My only quip was that we had originally booked for six people early on, and when I looked at the listing on a later date, the maximum was for five people. This made sense as the second room in the loft has a smaller bed (and it can get quite hot in there if you don't have the door open), so this would've been more suitable for one person. I had specifically searched for accommodations for six adults but since it is updated to five max now, should be fine.