Our stay at Nick's place was good and worked well for our family. Communication with the host was great, check in easy. The condo is set back from the somewhat busy road and was very quiet at night. The bed was comfortable but the pull out couch was a bit dated and springs in the mattress were not that comfortable. The beach chairs, cooler and umbrella were a big plus. Full kitchen was stocked with some basics.
We didn't mind being a few miles from central part of Kihei, however the beach water quality across the street was unfit for swimming due to runoff, so we had to drive to swim. There was construction work at the pool most days, which made it noisy. The pool and hot tub were cleaned daily but was over-chlorinated and turned my kids' hair green - we didn't really mind, but those sensitive may want to avoid it.