In terms of location and value, you can't beat this place! My husband and I really enjoyed staying in Kihei, where it felt a lot more local and there were plenty of great food options, unlike the resort areas in West Maui. We found our food spots and an excellent local cycling gym to get some exercise in to offset all the delicious food we ate! Also, given the crazy vacation revenge sprees everyone was going on, Christy's unit was very reasonably priced compared to other options I considered. Design wise, it was modern and "tropical glam," as Christy describes in the listing, and a step up from a lot of vacation rentals I researched!
In terms of the unit itself, it was overall fairly clean and well maintained. The surface areas were all dusted, and the refrigerator was like new! The white sofa looked a bit dingy from a lot of use, but we put some towels over it -- no big deal! (Side note: I really appreciated the extra bath and beach towels Christy provides in the hallway closet!) Finally, as a heads up to those that don't wear shoes indoors or have sensitive feet, the flooring/rugs were not conducive to standing/walking. The floorboards are "real" wooden planks vs. hardwood flooring, so the floor was uneven and grainy. The texture of the area rugs were rough on the feet. That being said, you can always wear shoes indoors or socks/slippers to offset the potential discomfort.
Overall, we had a great experience at Christy's and would recommend her place to others!