Overall I would recommend staying there. The place is spacious and clean with a nice size lanai, well stocked pans/pots, and plenty of linens. We were very comfy there and it was a good base to explore the rest of the island. The location is close to grocery stores and in walking distance to a great hike. There's plenty of beach equipment to use, and though we did not use the amenities there's a nice pool nearby.
Like many of the surrounding places to stay it feels a little generic. I wouldn't describe it as cute, but it's comfy for a few days stay. The bed is also a bit too large for the space, which made using the drawers difficult, however there's a large enough closet that this wasn't too much of an issue. There were a few supplies that were missing like extra toilet paper, detergent, and cooking spices. But if you don't mind purchasing your own you'll be fine. We did run into some issues with Wi-Fi, and because the owner was on the mainland it took 24 hours to get back up and running. But once that was resolved we didn't have the same issue again.