Tom and Vicki's property was great, and I can't sing it's praises enough. As hosts, Tom and Vicki do things right, and make it easy for guests to travel to Hawaii.
Staying in Haiku is really a treat if actually being in Hawaii is your thing. Places like Lahaina and Kihei or Wailea are lovely, but very touristy. Haiku and this property are more private and closer to what living in Hawaii is really like (I've got some perspective here, having lived in Kihei).
I could go on, but here is the summary: rent this place. You won't be disappointed.