We had a great stay in Todd’s handsomely converted one-car garage. It’s one of four rental units on the property, but we hardly ever saw any other renters.
The bed, futon, and bathroom were comfortable. There’s juuuust enough room for two people, and you’ll be in your partner’s way frequently. You’ll stub your toe or bang your shin at least three times on the narrow passageway between the bed and the kitchen before you learn to side-shuffle.
Location was excellent, with quick access to the whole island. We eagerly walked to a few meals around Wailuku, but be advised that sidewalks are rare. Expect to walk along the edge of the street next to passing cars.
Todd could improve the space by leaving the porch light on for new arrivals, adding a small table/shelf over the bathroom trash for additional counter space, mounting a small TV with a streaming stick across from the futon, and somehow blocking the pillows from falling into the big gap between the mattress and the wall.