We enjoyed staying at John and Maggie's. However, this review is for the green cottage. There are two cottages on the property, yellow and green. After our reservation was made, the listing was updated to reflect the yellow cottage, which caused some confusion.
Our favorite thing about the cottage was the kitchen which had a nice selection of utensils, cooking equipment, toaster oven and a full refrigerator. This is really nice because Upcountry Maui is a sort of rural, so we didn't go out at night very often and we were able to cook at home. They have a nice covered BBQ with covered breezeway connecting the green cottage to the BBQ area.
We used the convenient laundry facilities and the very nice new TV. We also enjoyed listening to the wide range of nature and rain sounds at night.