This spot was just fine for what I needed - a place to sleep before a horseback riding tour the following morning. I would stay again if the need arose. There was a little confusion around check-in time, the listing says 4:00, but the guide I received after booking said 3:00. I asked and was told 4:00. After arrival, I saw in the kitchen that it also said 3:00. So...just some inconsistencies there, but I went with what I was told.
The room was as described, it had a nice blackout curtain, and ear plugs were provided - thank you! The pillows were very hard for me personally, but might be great for others.
In hopes of helping others avoid this, I would highly recommend calling restaurants to make sure they are open for dinner before arriving in Honokaa. Based on the guidebook it seemed like there were many dining options, but to be fair nowhere did it say they were open for dinner per se. Perhaps needless to say, there was nowhere open, even the Public House (which google said was open until 10). I ended up eating at the Minit Stop gas station, ha. They make fried chicken and whatnot. The market was open but by the time I'd walked and then driven around looking for open places I was way too hungry to grocery shop and then go back and cook. So, keep that in mind and learn from my mistake! :-)