This place was beautiful, well stocked, in an excellent location, and Catherine was an extremely attentive host!
We had a party of 6 adults (3 couples) who stayed for 5 nights. Check-in was a breeze, the house was perfectly sized, and we found it extremely well stocked for the beach, cooking, and sleeping. We spent most of our days out of the house hiking or enjoying the nearby beaches, using the home for breakfast and shared dinners. A few issues popped up during our stay, but Catherine was extremely responsive and on top of everything. The appliances are all relatively new and extremely well maintained. The neighborhood is generally pretty quiet, not counting the local fauna, and well placed near a grocery store, hardware store, and a little further down the road, to Hanalei.
A few things that future guests should know. Most noticeably, the house isn't air conditioned. This is listed on the advertisement and that is not uncommon for that side of the island, so we were prepared, just be aware that during the middle of the day it can get quite warm. There are ceiling fans throughout and additional standing fans in the master bedroom closet, so we mitigated it as much as possible, but if you are traveling with someone who is heat sensitive just plan for that. The back porch isn't under any shading/covering, so the outdoor seating is best used when it isn't raining and the sun isn't directly overhead. Finally, the loft upstair is up a relatively narrow iron staircase and is (unsurprisingly) the hottest place in the house. Again, this is all on the listing but keep it in mind if you are planning on having anyone with limited mobility in your party.
Overall, everyone in our group loved this house. We really can't recommend it enough and thank Catherine for being such an excellent host.