Pro: The place is smaller, cute and clean. Located in front of a larger house but completely separated and quiet. The other house is split with a few other Airbnb'ers but never heard them or actually even seen them. Located in a great spot, very close to beach and Foodland, though does not have great views of the beach or landscape. Martin was amazing and very proactive/reactive/responsive. He left my new bride and I a bottle of wine and a thoughtful note.
Con: I do have to mention, unfortunately, that we did have to exterminate two large cockroaches. There are traps everywhere and it wasn't that big of a deal but the wife definitely wished she was informed of this before booking. We are from NYC and roaches aren't rare to us but still, these were massive.