Overall, a lovely stay. If you want something a little quieter than the Whaler/Sheraton resort area but still close by, this place is great. The walk to the beach isn't long at all (less than 10 minutes), and the cabana is on the other side of Black Rock, separated from the more populated part of the beach, where boats were landing on shore, etc. The kitchen was fully stocked with pots/pans/utensils, which was handy.
We had literally only one complaint, which is that the walls are thin. One other commenter had complained about a noise coming from the bathroom wall, which we also experienced (someone running their laundry, we guessed). If the folks next door were having a conversation, we could hear it. But the worst was a very obvious low frequency hum coming from one part of the room (our guess: the downstairs guests running their ceiling fan - it sounded electric). Someone came by to check it out after we called the front desk, but they didn't actually do anything about it. So we ended up just moving the bed to mitigate the problem (yes, it was THAT annoying). Just something to consider if you're a sensitive sleeper!