If you want to avoid giant resorts with loud neighbors and enjoy the comfort of quiet apartment condo, stay at Nathaniel's place. After full days of sightseeing and beach activities, we loved being able to come home and fully relax - not hearing another voice and getting deep sleep.
The apartment is a good size for a couple, and is well-stocked with everything you need - from snorkel gear to beach towels to a full kitchen. It does get pretty warm, but running the wall unit AC and ceiling fans will keep you cool. Location is great, as the main strip is about a 5 minute walk away. The building itself is a bit older, but is still super comfortable.
My only (very very minor) nitpick was that a few things could have used slight upgrades. The provided towels were obviously clean, but seemed a bit worn. Nice soap, shampoo, and conditioner would be thoughtful touches. The leather sofa can get sticky when it's hot, so a clean drape over it would have been a nice to have. Just a few suggestions to spoil travelers = ).
Overall, a great experience with responsive hosts! Would definitely stay again.