We had a good experience with Sandi & Gerald's Ocean Breeze condo. For reference, we are a family of 4 with two kids aged 10 and 13. There was plenty of space for us and the condo is clean and very useable. Sandi, in particular, reached out a couple of times before our trip to offer help. This was much appreciated.

What we really liked:
* short walk to the beach.
* Chairs and snorkeling equipment in the deck box; sizes are limited obviously.
* useable kitchen appliances and equipment.
* two baths, and a separate bedroom for the kids.
* Times market (not the best, but works).
* At least two good restaurants within walking distance.

Other:
* The lanai is nice but the view is very limited and offers a narrow angle to the beach and Haleakela. For the full sunset effect, you will really need to be at the beach itself (but its quite a short walk).
* This part of Kihei is not quite as decorous as the resort-laden areas to the north and south. It doesn't have the character of Lahaina; but it is cheaper than either.
* No coffee :( or soap :( We did not expect to be shopping for either on the first day.