We had a great stay at Papakea A108 for our honeymoon. The resort is on the quieter side, which is exactly what we were looking for. You can easily walk over to the neighboring resort to eat at the beach bar, visit the gift shop, and put toes in the sand. Papakea building A is right on the water with an unbeatable view (watching the whales jump while drinking coffee on the patio!). My husband loved that the lawn was grass instead of sand, though I have to admit that I missed walking the beach and looking for shells.
The kitchen had everything we needed (pots, pans, coffee pot/filters, tupperware), and we alternated between eating at local restaurants and cooking in the condo (grocery store is walkable down the road!).
We would happily stay here again if we return to Maui. We'd likely book directly through Aloha Vacation Rentals to avoid the additional fees. We appreciated Tina's clear communication and very organized process (contract, payment, etc) and so would happily book through her directly.