Two words: ocean view. For this reason alone, Cathy's condo was worth every penny! To be able to spend serene mornings on the lanai, listening to and watching the ocean waves just outside our window is something that my husband and I greatly enjoyed. We even spotted a turtle one morning!
The condo was furnished well with a lot of nice amenities--boogie board, a copy of "Maui Revealed", a cooler, lots of beach towels, and lots of kitchenware if you want to cook dinners in (which we did a couple times!) Cathy also went the extra mile by sending us a welcome packet about a month before our vacation, with some coupons for restaurants nearby and other info.
The location is also a bonus since it is central to lots of the main sights of the island. Some other reviews talked about the wind, but to be honest, we did not think it was exceptionally windy. While we did not use the complex's pool and spa, we did use the BBQ area, which was also convenient----grilling only feet from the ocean is pretty spectacular.

Whenever we return, we will be staying in this Hawaiian haven. Highly highly recommend!