We stayed in Villa #2 and it was perfect. The space was big enough for my wife and 2 year old son and it was clean. I loved that they provided a beach umbrella, chairs, boogie boards, snorkel gear, and a cooler. Gal's hospitality was fantastic too. He walked us around the property, showed us the secret little beach and gave us fresh MANGOs. Eat the Mangos, they were too good.
Kihei was the perfect spot for us, not too crowded in my opinion and plenty food spots to walk to. The only minor issue we had is that the locals can get a little loud at night. They love singing at night but thats only because we're so close to the beach. I would stay here again with no doubts.