The Sugar Shack is incredible. Super airy and has an incredible bathtub. Waking up to birds + rain on the tin roof was honestly so relaxing.
Of note, my partner and I had our rental car broken into in Pahoa, one of the towns near the airbnb. Just be careful to take all of your belongings out of the car or lock them in the trunk; apparently, per the police department, its bit of a regular occurrence. However, the airbnb felt super safe and there are neighbors around.