Magic shack is fantastic — in a great location where you can walk down to magic sands beach and neighboring restaurant via private walk-through path at the bottom of the hill, or drive easily to anything on the west side of the island. The other highlight for us was the outside porch (complete with hammock that’s perfect for evenings after beach days) — amazing. That swing seat inside is also fantastic. PS: Jason left some great recs for food- be sure to check them out!