This was a beautiful place, and I really appreciated the extras, especially the boogie boards, noodles, fins, etc. to elevate our experience on the beaches! The lanai was also gorgeous, and we spent a few mornings drinking coffee there before embarking on our day.
A few hiccups we had were: the numpad lock was finicky (but was quickly resolved), the old AC said 66F but it definitely felt warmer (in the low 70s), wish there were coffee filters that went with the coffee maker (unfortunately, we had to go out and buy a whole pack for the few days we were there), and some of the other appliances/dishware could use a checking up on every once in a while (e.g. the espresso maker had serious limestone/mineral buildup that didn't feel safe to use).
The issues were minor compared to the overall experience of our stay. I wish Kihei had better weather at the time we were there, but this place is close enough a drive to all the other beautiful places on Maui that it was okay!