We booked out both suites at Noah's Hideaway over Christmas, the Koa suite for my wife and I, and the Eucalypt suite for my parents.
The suites are both beautiful. The Koa's style is a bit more modern, and the Eucalypt's is more on the classic side. Since there are two on the property, you may want to check out both to see which suits your tastes better before booking. Or bring some friends/family along to take the other one, like we did!
The pictures do the property justice, it's really as great as it looks. The suites, common areas, pool, hot tub, sauna, and game room are all wonderful. The deck overlooks a golf course. It's maybe a 10-15 minutes walk to Whaler's Village for shopping and restaurants, and the beach - close enough for convenience and far enough that if you turn off the patio lights at night, you get an incredible view of the stars.
The breakfasts had a delicious mix of hot and cold food (something different every day!), usually an egg dish, some muffins, fruit, juice, coffee/tea. We always left stuffed and ready to take on the day. On the day we had an early snorkeling trip planned, Fadi insisted that we let them make us some to-go boxes so that we'd have a proper breakfast before getting on the boat.
What really elevates this place to 5-stars are the hosts and their absurdly generous hospitality. It's a true Bed and Breakfast. Fadi, Cath, and Noah (their young son) were actively engaged in our visit to make it the best experience possible. Noah is such a little charmer - he ran around the garden picking flowers for my wife and mom. Fadi and Cath spent some time chatting with us over breakfast most mornings, and gave great recommendations for activities.
When we decided to go for a hike at Waihee Ridge, they warned us about the mud and lent us mud chains to put over our hiking shoes for better traction. It ended up being so slippery that those chains made a huge difference. At another point in the trip, mom's luggage broke, and they offered us an old spare.
My parents are overbearing perfectionists (the kind of people that might actually send food back at a restaurant if they think it doesn't have enough "flavor"), but Fadi and Cath went out of their way to accommodate them and handled their eccentricities with exceptional grace and warmth. My parents actually enjoyed their stay - something that _rarely_ happens when they travel!
We all had a wonderful time here, and would try our best to stay here again the next time we're in Maui.