We have stayed in Maui 4 times and this is by far our favorite place. It's true the apartment is on the older side and some of the appliances show some wear but you absolutely cannot beat the view and the balcony. Complete unobstructed ocean views and if you come at the right time of year you will see whales for sure.
Also the beach access is great. The beach was pretty quiet and clean walking sand.
We did get some noisy neighbors at one point above us and we let the building management know and they must have taken care of it because they quietened right down.
Jim is also a great host. We had a late flight and he was kind enough to give us a late checkout which made our stay even more special.