We chose the Aloha Loft because we have a young toddler. The space, bathtub, kitchen, laundry, and proximity to Foodland made life with a toddler on the island so much easier! And the beach towels, cooler, and chairs allowed us to pack minimally. There is a playground by the Foodland we visited a bit, and there is a scenic view point less than 5min walk away.
There is a bit of road noise and, of course, the chickens, but we were able to keep windows open at night and drown them out with a noise machine/ipad app. Definitely recommend and would book again when we go back!