Many things about this property were really good: the location, the value, and the nearby/walkable amenities. We really loved this location. However unlike other AirBnb's we have stayed in this is run by a property management group and the basic supplies left for us were meager. We completely ran out of toilet paper by day 5. I tried to call to see if we could get more for 3 days before that and no one picked up. There weren't enough dishwasher pods or paper towels for our stay (4 pods and 1 roll). I don't know if it is normal practice to have to provide our own toilet paper ( we eventually went to get some) however I have stayed at AirBnbB's where not only were enough of the basics provided there were also many little extra's like coffee, butter and in many cases a welcome surprise like fresh fruit or chocolate. N Having access to the beach chair, cooler, snorkel and fins was a bonus, however any of the island information provided by the hosts was 18 years or more outdated.
In addition, the place was only adequately clean. The carpet was stained in places and tired. Dust was collecting along all the baseboards which I cleaned myself. No one had cleaned under or behind the fridge in a really long time. The paint was scuffed and tired. In the kitchen there were areas on the wall and side of the fridge that were still splattered with some residue that I also cleaned.
The front and back Lanai's were wonderful to sit in though it also didn't look like there had been much attention paid to them in the last while either. This was one of the more affordable places I looked at for a family of 4 so I guess you get what you pay for.
In summary, I have appreciated AirBnB's not run by property management companies considerably more, they are cleaner and have many more personal and extra touches for guests.
Also in summary, though this is the most I have ever critiqued a place it is still a good place to stay, I would still recommend it, and I would stay here again. It just didn't blow my socks off like many of the other places I have stayed in!