PROS: amazing location (walking distance to Kihei's best beaches and to many great restaurants and stores); very comfortable bed; the air conditioning and ceiling fan worked great (I would cool off the room using the loud AC, then only use the ceiling fan when sleeping); the shared spaces are fine (well-equipped kitchen); communication with Nanci and her cleaner was great.
CONS: it's not ideal to share an apartment with strangers, but it worked fine (both bedrooms are lockable and on different levels); the key situation (there are 3 key lock boxes) was VERY confusing to me and the other guests (to avoid a potentially stressful situation, be very clear about the keys before you arrive); the hot and cold water are backwards on the washing machine; it's a long walk from the *always full* parking lot to the apartment (the free street parking was usually a shorter walk).