Anthony's place is in a beautiful location on the beach in Makaha. "Tony" is friendly and stayed out of our hair for the duration of our trip, but did seem welcoming and available if we ever needed something.
The accommodations are basic, but nice. No AC but you are right next to the beach and the fan creates a nice breeze. A great spot to homebase it for surf adventures on the Westside. I recommend renting a car to explore the area. Tony's place makes it easy because there is gated parking and a remote to open/close the gate.
The only thing I would recommend improving is the way you have to pay the mandatory 15% Hawaii state tax. Airbnb leaves it up to hosts whether to include it in the advertised price or collect it separately after the hotel has been booked. Anthony has opted to collect it separately which made the process more tedious in my case, as I split my payment into two payments and the Airbnb system does not allow any secondary payments (such as the 15% tax) until after the final total has been paid. That would be fine, but Anthony was very insistent that the tax be paid immediately and it wasn't until after ~30 minutes with Airbnb support that I figured out that was not possible within the Airbnb system.
Not Anthony's fault, per se, but the process would be much easier if the 15% tax were simply included in the list price of the accommodations.
Other than that, no complaints!