I stayed in this appartement on Maui for a week with 3 friends. It was perfect for us. The sleeping couch is more comfortable than it first looks like. The appartement is like it's shown on the pictures. It was super clean when we arrived and everything was as it was described (check in, ...). We loved all the (beach) gear that was available and the well stocked kitchen is great to cook in. The location is great too. I would say you do need a car though to get around Maui. To get around Maui the location is great because you are kind of in the middle of the island. Having the beach just across the street was awesome - to go for a short swim in the morning, enjoy a whole day there being close to the appartement or watch the sunset.
Denise replied to questions super fast!