If I were only rating Stefano I would whole hearted give 5 stars. He was terrific, very responsive and helpful. I rated the over all experience at 4 stars mostly because I don't believe in grade inflation, and five stars for me indicates nothing could be better. I had a some problems with the wifi, which I will note that Stefano was very active in trying to address, I also thought the mattress on the futon couch was a bit worn/thin (I would not have wanted to sleep on it, we only used it as a couch). For my enjoyment of the place these were relatively minor annoyances. On the positive end of things the renovations in the bathroom and kitchenette were really well done. It was our first time cooking on induction burners (we love to cook and use gas at home) and they were great. We had most breakfasts and dinners at the airbnb and were able to make delicious meals even in the small space. We made use of the beach chairs and bogey boards Stefano keeps in the garage. I definitely felt that we had more of a local Maui experience staying in Haiku (this is a bonus for me). One small complaint is that you really have to have a car to get anywhere. You do not need to drive far to get to amazing places, but you also can't just stroll down to the beach or to small town center. I think Stefano indicated it in the posting so I wasn't surprised. The outdoor space around the buildings is lovely. We enjoyed our morning coffee outside. Over all I would say stay with a Stefano you'll have a lovely time.