Aloha! We stayed for 2 days, and really enjoyed our time at Ted & Dom's. There's nothing like crossing the street to be on the beach (and meeting the local characters!).
T&D has snorkeling equipment and beach chairs/umbrella so you can enjoy your time on the sand. And the sunsets! Amazing!!
While we had a car, a lot of shopping, restaurants and coffee shops are within walking distance, so you can really get a flavor for the area.
We would stay there again.