A very solid experience.
Great location - balcony and pool face right onto the ocean, very short walk to restaurants and grocery store, easy access to the rest of Lahaina and a very short drive to the hotels in Ka'anapali, where I was attending a conference.
Very nice bathroom and great shower. Some steps inside the bathroom that could be a bit of a fall risk for less sure-footed travelers. Kitchen well lit and up to date with a full oven and microwave and the other basic equipment needed for cooking.
Outdoor area was very well attended. Pool well maintained and clean, open 9 am to 9 pm. Included two gas grills which were a great option, although shared with the entire facility so not always available.
The main drawback was the temperature. We were there in late June, a hot time of year. The cooling in the unit relies on a small portable air conditioner that, even with the ample ceiling and portable fans running, was not up to the task of cooling the bedroom at the other end of the unit. After an uncomfortable first night, we spent the rest of the week sleeping on the fold-out in the living room where the AC unit was located. On the positive side, the fold-out was comfortable, and fortunately it was just the two of us, so this was an option.
I'd definitely rent again, especially in the cooler season.