Toby's place was cute, quaint and comfortable. It was a perfect home base for everything my fiancé and I wanted to do on Maui - the Road to Hana, Ho'okipa Beach Park (where we saw many, many sea turtles and actually swam with one - on accident!), the shops in Paia, and Mama's Fish House (which is a quick one block walk away!). I would absolutely recommend Toby's place for anyone wanting a more authentic Maui experience.