Overall, I give the house 3 stars. The location is great.
However, the day of check in I did not hear from the host - I had to reach out for check in instructions. The A/C was not on when we arrived and the house was 85 degrees. It took hours to cool down the house, and even then the A/C doesn't work well. It never got below 75 in the house and was 81 during the day.
There is clear water damage on the ceiling, and it looks like mold. The bathroom has a terrible smell, so we purchased some room deodorizer. Neither TV was working, and the on-island caretaker wasn't able to help.
Overall, we were pretty disappointed and ended up checking out after 1 night, instead of our booked 5.