Pros- location is excellent. Having two baths and an in unit washer and dryer was great. The fish pond beach near the unit is great for kids. The beach you can see from the balcony is very Rocky, but no rough shore break like other Kihei beaches.
Cons- kitchen pots and pans are absolutely trashed. The 10am checkout is early and completely inflexible. The unit stocks extreme basics as far as toiletries goes and that wasn't clear to me till after booking. The soaps were watered down to an almost comical degree. The snorkel gear was all broken and unusable.
I'd give 3.5 stars if I could. I have never experienced such an inflexible check out process in either an Airbnb or a classic hotel. I feel the price of the unit warrants better gear like cooking and beach accessories.