Great location, very close to the subway station. The place is clean and located on a quiet street.
I gave a 3-star rating because I was a it annoyed by a couple of things. First off, there is not clear sign where the parking spot is. You kind of have to guess and if you get there late you may not get a response from the owner on time.
The apartment has basic furniture, nothing fancy. That's ok. However, I find it unacceptable to not have hand soap and toilet paper in the bathroom. When I asked the owner to supply hand soap I was told that CVS is close by and I can get it myself. That was certainly not the reply I expected given the cost of this rental. I understand that people have different preferences but the place is supposed to have basic things like soap. There is no soap in the kitchen either.
Lastly, one of the nights, it seemed the owner had a party upstairs so there was pretty loud base until 11pm. If I were them, knowing that people with little kids are renting the apartment downstairs, I would have probably kept the music at a more reasonable volume.
Other than these issues everything else was fine.