This was my parents' first Airbnb and they were over impressed!
David's place was adorable, comfortable and immaculate. The place was decorated nicely. There was tea, coffee and linens for us to use, cable TV was a win as I didn't want to miss GOT. The futon was comfortable even though I didn't put it all the way down and my parents said the bed was just right. They enjoyed walking around the neighborhood and loved it enough to want to stay a second night. I had to break the news that that was not how Airbnb worked.
I would definitely book David's place again and encourage you to also.