This apartment was nice, clean, with good amenities, temperature control, overall quite comfortable. The host Jay was responsive and was kind to accommodate our request for early check-in.
Originally I was going to give 4 stars simply because the location is multiple miles away from the "approximate area" shown in the listing. This made a big difference for us because the access to public transit is not nearly as good as what was expected from the listed location.
If you're bringing a car, this is a great quiet location with free parking included so it won't be a problem for you. For us, we had to spend extra money on Uber, Lime, or walk 20 mins in freezing weather to the train station. In good weather it's actually a very pleasant and safe walk, so again if you're renting during good weather it should be no problem.
The reason I'm giving 3 stars is that I reported the incorrect location to AirBnb, and provided evidence showing the listing location is wrong. They told me the host fixed it but I can clearly see on the listing that the location is still incorrect. If this gets fixed I'd be happy to increase the rating to 4 stars, even though I incurred extra transportation costs that were not budgeted.