Victor's place was exactly as it appeared in the photo's. Clean and comfortable. In this regard I would give it a 5 rating.
I gave a 4 since there were a few things missing that would have made a initial difference on the 1st day. These included: problem with the water in the bathroom sink; no dish towels to use for the dishes in the kitchen; left had side door of the closet in the bedroom didn't open; the wet leaves on the stairs to the apartment were very slippery; no instructions of how to use the TV. Victor did respond via Airbnb email and by the evening of the 2nd day he looked into the water problem which could not be resolved; gave us dish towels; opened the closet door.