Great location, lots to walk to, felt very safe.
And the place was very clean, and well appointed, with off street parking!
The place was great in general, but there were a few issues that reduced the value of this place to me.
This is a ground level apartment of a duplex. The people that lived upstairs sounded like they played field hockey every night, and one Friday night they were up making noise on the floor until late into the morning. I am not a light sleeper, so it was not horrible, but it was far from ideal.
The towels are really old, they should be replaced. And the Wi-Fi is a bit weak. The shower handle sticks. And sometimes the door code doesn't work and you have to re-enter it a bunch of times. These are things that are really easy to address, and I am sure the host will at some point. So it is certainly a 4 star, and with a few tweaks the host can move it closer to a 5 star.