I went on an off-week so the price was reduced by more than 50% so I got a really great value for the price. It is in kind of a sketchy neighborhood, and my local friends warned me to be careful when walking there at night (a sentiment which I'd echo).
The place is beautiful, but there were a few things that I would've expected more from here. There were no hand towels, no hand soap (only hand sanitizer), the soap in the bath didn't have any caps, one toilet had poo streaks, and the master bathroom had oily(?) walls which were very visible especially after a shower. It is also situated on a noisy street, so you will hear traffic and loud talkers throughout the day and night in the living room and master bedroom.
Also, I really wanted to check in early since I was coming from NYC, and only heard from the landlord the morning of check-in that I could come at 9am. But by that point, I already made my travel plans to arrive at 5pm.
Overall, I'd actually give it a 3.5, but since you can't give half stars, I gave it 4 overall because the place has great potential. It could just use a little TLC.