I will start with the good:
Nice to have bedside tables and lamps on both sides of the bed. Having 3.5 bathrooms was great. There was not a hair dryer, as advertised on the listing, in the house. I messaged the host and they were responsive and quick to deliver one. Also, someone in our group forgot a toothbrush. They had a stash of travel size toiletries in the linen closet, this was a nice touch. The dining room table was large, plenty of room for 6 people. The back patio area is great for a nice day.
The not so great:
The house itself is in need of some repair - kitchen faucet, door handles, etc.
The neighborhood is not the most desirable. Not many places to eat or grab a drink within walking distance.
The biggest hiccup was the number of guests and the way they charge for that. The house sleeps six, and is advertised accordingly. Originally, we had only intended to have 3 guests. Lucky for us, more of our kids were able to join us, taking us to 6 guests, most of the nights, but not all. When I changed our reservation to 6 we were charged $100 extra per night by the host + additional Airbnb fees. There was no forewarning of this. No confirmation, just a charge on our credit card. Needless to say we were surprised. I contacted the owner immediately, she said that the rate goes up $50 per person per night for any guests over 4. After much back and forth, us expressing that this is not transparent, she agreed to refund the additional charges, which we greatly appreciated.
Our measure of satisfaction with a property is whether or not we would stay there again and/or recommend it to family and friends. Overall, it was "just fine" and we would not recommend this property.