Gary's place is a gem. Unassuming from the outside, it is a pleasant surprise to walk in and see how well the space was designed and decorated. Gary put a lot of effort into making this a welcoming and cozy place to spend time. Even though the temperature hovered in the mid-90's, the air conditioner in the main living area kept the space livable.
The location was great. We had a rental, but chose to use Uber to go downtown on Saturday. $9.50 for a one way Uber X ride. There are some restaurants and churches within walking distance. Gary's recommendations for breakfast (The Universal) and Mexican (Patzcuaro's) were spot on; both places were fantastic.
Even with 2 couples in the space and sharing one bathroom the unit didn't feel cramped. And there was enough hot water for all of us to shower consecutively without running out.
Gary was quick to answer any questions we had and was a great host.