I have a bit of a mixed review of Nathan's place. First the good, the home itself is very nice. The remodel job on it is quite good. Also, the location is great. Within a few blocks is the fun part of Broadway with it's quirky shops, bars, theater, and restaurants. The one down side to location is that it is near some train tracks and you can hear the trains during the night / early morning. I just put on some white noise on my phone and it was fine. Also, don't be afraid to explore by the train tracks, there is a cool museum brewery (jam band oriented) for drinks and a great southern bbq place there.
The reason why I called it a mixed review was because of the house rules which I found a bit too controlling. They stipulate not eating on the couch or beds, not having friends or anyone over for a visit who is not on the AirBnB agreement (I just for overnights but in the home at any point even for dinner), and there may have been one more. Maybe this isn't a problem for you but if I'm paying a few hundred dollars a night for an Airbnb, I want to feel comfortable in it. People want to be able to watch Netflix and have a snack. I probably won't choose to stay in homes that have this much rigidity.
Outside of that issue, this was a great stay.