I'm new to AirBnB and sort of evaluating the whole process, particulary service to price as comprable market rates. Nick's place is very nicely done, and provides the amenities one needs to accomodate a nice private used space. However it wasn't completely private from the rest of the house, so you do feel as though you are simply accomodating as a guest in someone's hosue; which does change the mood and emotional feel of your stay - not quite enough separation, no matter how nice and accomodating they present. As such I would just evaluate the cost / night just a bit lower. But it's a beautiful place, and I'm still getting acustomed to the AirBnB process and experience.