The carriage house has been one of my favorite Airbnb's to date. The location is ideal: 1. in the alley so it is very quiet 2. right by the grocery store (I also walked the .5 to Trader Joe's) 3. right off of 6th so straight shot home from the mountains 4. coffee shops, yoga/pilates studios, fancy dinner places, dive bars, adorable wine shop, etc. all less than a 10 minute walk.
I was personally worried about noise since this is above a garage but no one parked in the garage the 2 months that I stayed at the house.
I have been trying to think of the con's of the space and I think my only 'con' would be that there is no outdoor space. The Juliet doors open to the alley but you couldn't sit outside anywhere. It was not a deal breaker but was a bit of a bummer on cool mornings/nights.