If you choose Room #4, pray to God you have quiet house guests. My wife and I literally had a group of people in their 20s pre-gaming in the room next to us, playing music very loudly during Quiet Hours. This room offers poor insulation between each other, and clearly an afterthought during remodeling. Henley took care of the issue when we notified him, but when they came back from the bar, they were just as loud. I even heard an acoustic guitar. This experience has scarred us from renting rooms, instead of entire houses.