Three of us spent six nights at Shay's place in July 2022 and have only good things to say about the experience.
At the end of a cul-de-sac, Shay's house is surrounded by quiet other than some of the usual suburban noises.
We found the house to be very comfortable and spacious. It has a well-equipped kitchen and an efficient laundry center. Shay provides guests with a large tv monitor with a wide range of channel/streaming selections as well as a wireless printer. In the back there's a large patio and a gas grill. As she modestly points out, it's not a luxury hotel; on the other hand at Shay's place you get amenities that you'd be hard pressed to find at any hotel. A well-stocked grocery store is a short 700 m from the house.
Shay responded very quickly to a few questions we had during our stay - virtually no lag in communications - and was as helpful as one might possibly want. Perhaps I just don't understand the criteria, but why is she not a "super host"?