My wife and I found Evan’s place quite comfortable. The layout of the apartment accommodated us well. The living room couch and recliner were comfortable. The kitchen was fully functional, very clean and pleasant to cook in. The deck was also a nice place to hang out with breakfast, dinner or at cocktail hour. The bed was comfortable and the bedroom was quiet. The neighbors were all very friendly and helpful. It’s very close to the airport which is a plus and a minus. As others have mentioned it’s under the departure runway so it’s intermittently noisy between 6:30 AM and roughly 9:30 PM. This wasn’t an issue for us, since we came from Michigan and we were up early sightseeing most of the time. The ocean beach/point Loma peninsula is a great base of operations. Cabrillo national monument (bring your N Park pass) is a fantastic park to wander and whale watch. Also, the Windjammer whale watching cruise should not be missed. It departs from Shelter Island 10 minutes away.