If I could summarize our experience in Elizabeth's place I would say: Details.
When looking for a place we were looking for certain amenities and we liked Elizabeth's place because she had all of those, but after we arrived and during our entire stay we kept finding small details here and there that made our stay extra comfortable and extra enjoyable. We actually loved it so much that we wanted to stay longer but there were other guests coming after us so it wasn't possible but I'm sure we'll be back.