A mostly excellent experience, and I stand by my 5-star rating, but if you're planning to use both bedrooms (especially with kids), read all the way through.
Justin was an excellent host, and very responsive to all of our questions while we were staying at the Airbnb. The place was adorable and well-furnished, and we appreciated the small touches, such as the Keurig coffee maker. Also, knowing we were traveling with a toddler, Justin thoughtfully provided a pack-n-play and a high chair, which were delightful, and which we hope future visitors will benefit from!
When we travel, we tend to rent 2-bedroom Airbnb's rather than staying in a hotel, mainly so that our toddler has a place to nap and we don't need to hibernate. This was difficult, though, at this residence, because the 2nd bedroom is more of a "day room" with a bed in it, and a lot of light gets in. One of the windows has excellent blinds, but another has light curtains, and the glass doors to outside weren't curtained at all, so it was a very bright room. The doors between the second bedroom and the main house are also glass (albeit with curtains that block a little bit of the light), so after we put our 2-year-old to sleep, we had to hide in the main bedroom with the door closed, or he would see the light through the door and cry for us.
None of this had a huge negative impact on our stay, and as I said, it was a lovely, cozy little place with an excellent host, but I wish I had known how bright the second bedroom was beforehand.