We absolutely loved Robert's place. It was my myself, mom, brother and nephew that stayed here and we were surprised how comfortable the beds where. I don't think we have ever stayed at an Airbnb place when all the beds are comfortable. In the room with the bunk beds they were queen beds. My 6 year old nephew slept on the top bunk easily. I did sleep one night on the pull out sofa and like most sofa beds, I didn't feel the bar. It was a pretty soft mattress, but unfortunately a little too soft for me. If you like a soft mattress this would be perfect. The sofa is a little firm, but nice and long in order to be able to sleep on. Could easily put a small self inflating mattress if it was a little too firm and if the pull out sofa sleeper was too soft.
Robert has thought through so many areas. There are Tupperware, muffin tins, mixer's and most everything you need to cook meals. It has really nice big refrigerator and freezer. We cooked a majority of our meals there and it was so nice to be able to save some money that way. We also really enjoyed the courtyard and table outside almost every day.
The neighborhood was quiet and easy to walk to Shelter Island. We booked a cameraman trip that left from Shelter Island and it was a short walk and so nice not have to deal with parking. There is also a lot of good food places within a block or two. Two Harbors Pub had really good burgers and fries and my brother liked the Sushi Lounge.
Robert was also very responsive to any questions and the last morning he brought a plate of really yummy bakery items in the am.