Overall we had a terrific stay.
The location is super convenient (a few
Minutes to Liberty Station, Shelter Island, Ocean Beach, etc), and the view is truly terrific. The layout is pleasant and there is plenty of space. The extra 1/2 bath is really nice to have as well.
Furniture was basic but honestly totally ok. The kitchen could use a few more items, but for us it was absolutely fine. Above all, the host is great and very kind, responsive and helpful. We really appreciated that.
The only challenge I had personally was the plane noise. This may not bother others (and my better half tuned it out just fine) but for me it was a bit of an issue. Did it ruin our stay? Absolutely not! But the planes do start around 6:30 AM, so if you are a light sleeper and want to sleep late, that could be an issue. At night, they seem to let up around 11:30 pm.
Also, there are blinds in the bedroom, but for me they did not block out enough light. An easy solve as I just wore an eye mask.
Overall it was a wonderful experience
and we were grateful (and lucky) to find it.