Jay was a great host and my wife and I both agree that we'd stay here again in the future. Our only caveat would be that they asked us to refrain from eating food in our room. This was clearly stated in the rules so we knew this going in. So it would not justify me lowering it one star. We just realized how annoying this was as it forced us to always eat out. With this being a relaxing vacation, we found ourselves wanting to just stay in their beautiful house and room and not leave. It would have been nice to eat and watch TV in bed.
Also, I did read one comment about the curry smell. I noticed a tiny smell as we entered the house (didn't bother us) but our room smelt like watermelon chapstick, which was amazing. They have an open floor plan in their kitchen/family room so it's impossible for them to trap their cooking smell. But they went the extra mile to make the rooms smell amazing.
And, of course, their shower was ridiculously amazing.