This was a toss up between 4 and 5 stars. The only reason I would have given this a 4 star is because of the smell of the cleaning solution. It was a very strong sent and it took about 2 days to air out. If I had a short stay I probably would have given 4, 4.5 was more accurate so I rounded up because it didn’t bother my husband. I’m pregnant so that could have been a factor. I also couldn’t find extra pillow cases. Other than that, the dogs were not a bother at all. I think the sounds of the ships were more bothersome than anything, but it was only for one night. Overall, great stay and loved the location. I would stay again if the scent of cleaning solution isn’t that strong again or doesn’t bother me in the future.