Cleanliness
The place was mostly clean. And I say mostly only because there was a little animal hair (I'm assuming dog hair) on the kitchen and living room floor but not enough to really complain about. I only mention it because my kids have asthma.
The bathroom was spotless. As was the bedroom. All the linen and towels provided were clean. Both the front and back outside area was neat and tidy with beautiful little homely touches.

Accuracy
The description given on the listing is accurate for sure. This lovely little beach cottage was just perfect for my little family! It is definitely a great place for a couple or a couple with 2 small children. Caroline has thought of everything! Board games, kids toys, books, beach toys, bikes, "fire pit", grill, outside bar, plenty in the kitchen to actually cook with, and more. There is some complimentary coffee and condiments.
Check-in
It is a self-check-in place. A keypad to get onto the property through a small wooden gate, and another keypad to get into the cottage. It would have been nice to have the option of parking on the back road and using the back gate to enter though...Possibly something for Caroline to think of for future guests. But easy in and out nonetheless.
Communication
Caroline was very thorough getting check-in and check-out info to us and did so in a timely manner. There is a great information book in the cottage and the house rules are also published on the listing. Caroline was very prompt getting back to me with any questions I had. She went above and beyond when we left our little one's sound machine at the cottage and we were able to get it back before leaving San Diego.
Location
The cottage is located on Balboa, which if you don't know the Pacific Beach area is a busy road. Thankfully once inside or when sitting out in the "backyard" the noise of traffic was not an issue. It is within walking distance of some stores and restaurants. And if you're up for it, a little longer walk to the beach - otherwise you can bike it. There is ample street parking in the front of the cottage and a little in the back.
Overall we had a fantastic stay at Caroline's place and we will definitely make use of one of her cottages again.