We loved the house and awesome back patio, but not the neighborhood.
Schaefer's house and patio was everything we signed up for: super cute, well-designed, clean and comfortable. All linens and towels, floors and other things were fresh and clean, appliances were new, and Schaefer was responsive and helpful with a few requests I had. We didn't mind not having a dishwasher... it gave my two kids something to help out with while on vacation. The bathroom was small, but fine for me and two kids under 12 (just have to be careful not to open the bathroom door into someone). The beds were also some of the most comfortable I have ever slept on in a vacation rental! We ate out in the back patio most nights, but kept our voices down as the rental is directly between an apartment complex and another small home, and you can hear neighbors' conversations easily. At night, we closed the windows and ran the AC and didn't have a problem with noise. It was a treat to have a turntable and some records at this house...my kids now want to buy vinyl!
The neighborhood isn't like Talmadge, Banker's Hill, Mission Hills or North Park. Instead, it's a run-down, questionable area that might be up-and-coming some day in the future (like North Park was 30 years ago, minus the Craftsman and Spanish-revival homes), but clearly not just yet. There were people loitering and smoking at both curbs flanking the front of the house our first night, and some randoms wandered around occasionally. A few homes have been cleaned up in the area, but otherwise it's not great. It took me a while to feel comfortable with the neighborhood, but I may have been on alert since I was traveling by myself with two children. I was fine driving in and out, but really wouldn't take the kids for a walk there like I have in other areas mentioned.
This rental was a good find, but just be aware of the neighborhood. The house itself was awesome!