I went back and forth between three and four stars for this review. It's really more like a 3.5 in my book. Evan's place was decent for the price but there were several things that would make me not a return guest.
As seen in the pictures, the floors are bare and very cold. The bed is extremely firm. Even though I typically like firm this was so much so that I was sore the first night we stayed there. There is an upstairs separate place of stay and we could hear everything that was going on. Every footstep was very loud and we could hear voices. They weren't being loud neighbors! The guest weren't the problem, the place was. The decorations are cute but overall it wasn't the most comfortable stay. Evan's communication was also very stock - it was clear he was copy/pasting every message. It just lacked any kind of personal touch. May not bother some people but I enjoy the personal touch staying with an air bnb host usually provides. Check in/check out was easy. House rules in general seem very strict - noise levels, no early check ins or late check outs, no parking in the driveway. Not necessarily unreasonable things but just felt stern and unaccommodating. The use of the rouku device was nice. Evan also provided a water filter full of water in the fridge upon our arrival which we also appreciated.
Overall, it wasn't a bad experience but it wasn't great/memorable/special either. Kind of bare minimum - clean accommodations, safe neighborhood, a place to sleep and eat. That's about it though. Nothing particularly special about it. So if that's what you're looking for then you'll be happy with this reservation! If you're wanting a place with thoughtful touches, a personable host, and a homey comfortability then I would suggest looking for something else.