This place is AWESOME! It totally reminds me of the beach house I stayed at as a kid. This is not the most updated, super modern, fancy house. It's the perfectly rustic, very comfortable house right next to the beach (for reference - there are two houses and an alley before David's house). We could still see, hear and smell the ocean.
Their neighbors that live there full-time are super nice too.
The only reason I gave a 4 on the cleanliness is I wish it was better organized so we had room to put our stuff. But we had no problem making due for the 4 days we were there.
I put David's house in my favorites because I would not hesitate on staying there again!