I've been lucky to have had many wonderful stays at AirBnBs that have gone above and beyond, but I think I was the most charmed by this stay. When I look at reviews for anything, I do a little digging through negative/more "balanced" and informative reviews, but the few bad reviews I found for Peter's really seem like guest issues than host issues and I suspected it to be as such. I love AirBnB because at best, it's cheap versions of hotels/unique stays/and stays in places that feel more like a home. We loved Peter's because it's obviously the latter. It's a previous office space/guest house that has been hand built and converted into an AirBnb with love and care.
There is a wall of charming thank you notes and letters (and more scattered throughout the space) from previous guests. There is a pair of scissors that say "Dad's" on it on the desk. There are books on the shelves that hint at the life of its owner (but also various books from previous guests- I feel like the right person could just come here and read their whole stay). It was never built to be a cookie cutter hotel room, just an extra space from someone who is a very thoughtful and considerate host. Staying here was like the best version of staying at a friend's bought you a case of beers and some snacks before you arrived and made sure you were set up to have a nice time. I like a good hotel room, but they often feel sterile and cold. This was the opposite of that, and from sheer charm alone, it will be difficult to top this stay.
On a more practical note- Peter's is wonderfully located and we actually tried to drive to some of the nearby restaurants due to being ill prepared for a cold front...and after spending 15 minutes looking for parking, we drove back to the house and walked 10 minutes since there are plenty of amazing restaurants easily within 15 minutes walk. Just walk! Save your $5.50/gallon gas! Haha.