Andy is an outstanding host. I would rate him a 5+ for always being friendly, patient and responsive, and quickly resolving any issues. The location is great for a car-free location in SD--lots of good eating within walking distance, and access to public transportation to many of SD's attractions. The place is very well equipped with all the cooking equipment and supplies one could wish. However, the reason I would not give this place 5 stars is that the furniture in the downstairs living area was uncomfortable and not completely functional. The unpadded bar stools were too low to eat comfortably at the bar ( and I'm 5ft 6 in., so don't think my height was a factor) . The miserably hard couch was not placed so that 2 people could comfortably watch tv. The dining table/chairs functioned ok, but were wood and metal, and not comfortable for lingering over a meal. In fact, the only piece of comfortable furniture downstairs was the desk chair. No elevator from parking to unit--10 stairs.