Overall, a four star review. Things we liked:
Spacious yard for dogs
Fruit trees
Gated parking*
Decent sized living spaces
Things we didn't like:
communication with host seemed more difficult than it should. Messages were ignored or not responded to for over 12hrs.
*Had issues where the gate wouldn't open or close as it was supposed to. Eventually, after messing around with the clicker each time, we were able to get it to work at some point.
Back yard contained quite a bit of trash that needed to be dumped (old desk, chair, quite a bit of paint cans, etc)
Heat wave in SD meant hot house, especially with only the single AC unit. However, we did find fans that helped a lot.
Overall, the listing helped us enjoy our time in SD and having a place that allowed dogs for an affordable price outweighed any negatives.