La Casita is a great place to stay - I would definitely stay there again.
The accommodations are clean, bright, and cozy without being cramped. The hosts are friendly, attentive, and genuinely want your stay to be pleasant. The location is very close to Old Town and a short walk from some great restaurants. The neighborhood feels safe and the Casita itself is away from major streets, so there wasn't any street noise.
I didn't use the private outdoor space for morning coffee but that's definitely on my list for next time!