It was our first time staying in an airbnb and Mellow Yellow was a comfortable stay. It was so close to restaurants and the bays and a very short driving distance for anyplace you'd like to visit in SD. It does sit on a busy street so car sounds in the afternoon and early morning could be a bother. Parking for us wasn't an issue, we stayed a few days during the week so I'm not sure how it would be on a weekend. The kitchen has few amenities so if you plan on cooking in you may not have all the tools and equipment you need. The beds and bedding was very comfortable and clean and that was very important for me. It was overall a nice stay.