Giving a somewhat lower rating on this one:
-Based on description, I was expecting to arrive at a place that was just deep cleaned and that it would be deep cleaned after I left. There were a few issues when I arrived: soap scum in bathroom, coffee area sticky and picked over, stale smell in house similar to going to a grandma's house where that grandma cooks a lot and doesn't have adequate kitchen ventilation. Hand marks on doors from lots of use between cleanings. It was ok but still noticeable.
A few other issues:
-Shower either too hot or too cold (I had a similar problem at my home when I accidentally ordered a $120 on demand water heater instead of a $250 one that had better reviews).
-Coffee maker uses tiny capsules based on instant coffee and makes no more than 1/2 standard size coffee mug at a time.
-Too many signs giving an immediate impression they want guests to put way more than average effort to protect the property from normal wear and tear, and to save tiny amounts of utilities. There were some references to being earth friendly, but this didn't feel like a sincere motivation because there was a halogen desk light that probably uses more energy than all the other appliances put together, and a single-use coffee maker. It seemed like avoiding normal wear and tear was the true motivation.
-I feel like a lot of the signs were basically a diary of things they didn't like about past guests. Just to take one example, there was a big sign next to the bed that said 'please don't lie with bare body on comforter'. I didn't want to do that anyway - but I did notice the comforter was easy to slip right out, would have been better to just get a duvet bag to protect the comforter rather than make a somewhat resentful sounding sign that sort of pollutes the experience, especially when there were 10+ signs.
Overall, I felt like the description of "obsessive about cleanliness and comfort" related a little too much to expectations they were placing on their guests, rather than above-average benefits the guests could enjoy.