We stayed in Evans cottage during a family California roadtrip. The accomodation is great, very clean, nicely decorated and with incredibly comfy beds. The kitchen has everything you need. The location is also perfect, the beach is close and there are several possibilities to eat and shop nearby.
Only one thing I would mention is, that the cottage looks a little bigger on the pictures. The two bedrooms are directly next to each other and you have to cross the large bedroom to get into the smaller bedroom. However that was absolutely no problem for us.
We were 4 people. If you also plan on using the sleeping couch, it will be a little crowded.
All in all, we would definitely stay there again.