Had a great stay at the Red Vic. I've never stayed in a place quite like this one, and it is true when they say "international guest." It was great meeting different people, and I enjoyed the shared dinners.
If you're looking for a single room with little to no guest interaction then the Red Vic might not be the best choice. But if you're a single traveler who enjoys the company of others, and a community setting then the Red Vic will deliver.
The Peacock Room was interesting experience as guest rotated in-and-out of the hostel room. A second room (Hula Hoop) is connected onto the Peacock, so there can be traffic at times. I enjoyed meeting my bunk mates, and we all seemed to have a respect for each other's spaces, and personal belongings.
Overall it was a great experience. I enjoyed interacting with the hotel guest along with the permanent residents.