Lucy's place has a large balcony with beautiful view of the bay. That was the highlight of the house. There are 4 rooms that are on the small-ish side but fine for a weekend. Each has a double, queen or king bed. Apartment only has one shower, which is a bit difficult with 8 people staying, but also a separate bathroom downstairs. Bathroom downstairs has a bit of a shoddy door, would be great if they replaced that. Apartment also has access to a large shared terrace behind the unit, but the balcony offered a much better, private view.

Positives: View (AWESOME), large TV and well-stocked kitchen, W/D unit, large dining room table and a large L shaped couch and second couch made the living area feel bigger than it actually is, which was great. Neighborhood seemed safe enough. Alarm system and 3 locks on door definitely helps with not having to worry about break-ins. 1 parking spot in front of the apartment is helpful, but otherwise, the parking around there is 2 hours only unless you park on the special street that Lucy mentioned. Not a problem on the weekend though at all (only enforced M-F and not on holidays). Pet friendly. Neighborhood has some restaurants within 2 blocks walking (Chez Madam is DELICIOUS!). Check-in was a breeze with keypad.
Negatives: Seemed a bit expensive for what it was. Probably spiked prices since we stayed NYE weekend. If it wasn't for the beautiful balcony view, I would definitely have felt like we overpaid, as accommodations were basic otherwise. On other weekends, hotels may have been cheaper. Additionally, it felt somewhat uncomfortable that it seemed more like the owner's home than a rental with their family photos all around, shoes under the bed, some closet space locked. I always feel a bit odd when staying in a place where it feels like the owner's live otherwise in full-time. Finally, it's definitely clean but not hotel-clean quality, as the apartment is somewhat dated (I think probably normal for Airbnb in SF). So if you are looking for squeaky you could lick the kitchen counter clean, this is not the place for you. :)
All in all, nice place to spend NYE. Thanks Lucy!