We enjoyed our stay at the Red Vic! It was super quirky, fun and unique. The location is amazing- right on Haight St - walking distance to tons of bars, restaurants, Golden Gate Park, etc. We met a few of the people that live there and they were super friendly and welcoming. We also got to meet the resident dog Friday (a Golden) which was an extra perk.
We personally loved our stay, but there’s a few things you should be aware of before you book. The bathrooms are shared, and people live there, so they aren’t necessarily pristine/hotel quality. Our bed was a little harder than I’m used to (we stayed in The Conservatory), and there was some noise/conversation at night, which might be an issue if you’re a light sleeper.
For us the location and unique vibe made up for the other “discomforts”. If you’re looking for a place with a fun, unique vibe in a great location this is it! If you want privacy and quiet this may not be for you.