I give it 5 stars. Like everyone said, this hotel is old, shabby, and has a slight smell. I knew that going in so it was no surprise. My room was clean, comfortable, I had no issues, the parking is free, and the wifi is fine. It’s a decent price for downtown SF.
It’s in a good location as I was able to walk to the Pier to catch the ferry to Angel Island (highly recommend hiking the route described on bahiker.com). There’s a great brunch spot around the corner called The New Spot on Polk.