We chose the Brenners' place because of its location near Golden Gate Park and Ocean Beach, and we weren't disappointed. Their front door is just across the street from the park! We spent several really nice afternoons just walking around enjoying nature. One great walk is south to the shops on Judah and then west to the beach and north along the beach to Land's End. You would want to plan a ride back after the long walk though.
The beds were clean and very comfortable, and there was a place to hang our clothes. Keep in mind there is no door between the two rooms so this isn't the place for a ton if privacy (except in the bathroom of course) but there's enough separation to feel like you have your own space. It was very handy to have the kitchen. The main room has a large window that overlooks their gorgeous succulent-filled back yard. We loved sitting in the sun back there and watching the hummingbird that hung out in a nearby tree.
The Brenners were flexible with our check in time because we just let ourselves in with the code, which made it hassle-free. The only issue to consider with this spot is proximity to public transit if that is important to you. My brother lives in Pacifica and drove us around (by car it's not an issue at all) but by the end of our stay he was complaining a bit because he already lives far away and it's not super close to downtown (it's really not far in a car though). You might need to budget for some Ubers if you don't have a ride. Anyway, I loved this location because it's in my favorite area, close to natural beauty. And the shops and food on Judah are very walkable.
Great experience, thanks Brenners!