This is a nice place to stay. To clarify something that wasn't clear to me: unlike most Airbnb listings, this is not Jeff's actual unit (nor would it be the dedicated unit of anyone whose Airbnb listing you see for The Donatello). It's a shell listing for the hotel. People buy timeshares, then rent them out, and the hotel assigns whatever room (lower floors -- if you're a timeshare owner, you get the upper floors). When you book, you just get a regular hotel room, which is perfectly nice, but it's otherwise just like staying in the hotel (daily housekeeping and toiletries, bellhops to help with luggage, call the front desk for issues, etc). Don't spend your time trying to compare photos from different listings - they're generic. You could probably book with any of the (many) Airbnb listings that are for The Donatello or you could book through the hotel directly and I imagine your stay would be identical. You might just compare prices through all those mechanisms and see what gets you the best rate. You will have to endure a very brief and polite proposal for you to sit through a timeshare pitch when you check in. Once I politely declined, they didn't bother me any more with it. All in all, a good place to stay near Union Square.