We really liked this apartment. It looked very nice and the location was perfect! Noe valley and nearby Mission district are lovely neighborhoods that are fun to explore and - best of all - the J train stops right before the door and has a great connection with downtown San Francisco.
Communication with Will was very smooth.
Now, a lot has been said in previous reviews about noise. The train does ride by, but we weren't bothered by the noise at all. If it hadn't been for the comments in reviews here, I probably wouldn't even have noticed it. There is some noise from upstairs, though. This was only during the daytime and not at night, so wasn't a problem for us.
As far as parking goes, that was a problem. The ad said that parking in the street would be "not difficult", but this was not correct. During daytime we could only park for a maximum of 2 hours. We were forced to park our car in a garage, which cost us an additional $27 per day.
However, if you don't bring your car, this place is perfect and I would definitely recommend.