We spent a wonderful weekend at George and Colleen's in-law apartment in the wooded hills of Oakland. It's the perfect location -- quiet, beautiful, seemingly remote -- but only minutes to the hustle and bustle of downtown Oakland. The apartment is very roomy, nicely appointed, and excellently maintained. Colleen (George was out-of-town) was a most gracious hostess, communicating with us without being intrusive. The bed was very comfortable. We loved the homemade muffins left out for us. We definitely will stay again!