We rented Cathy's place for out-of-town friends attending our wedding. The place has been renovated and secured quite nicely compared to other houses on that street. Our really good friends live in the area, so it was already familiar to me before I booked. While my Orange County in-laws (who ended up renting in Berkeley) might've been a little wary of this particular neighborhood, we know it's fine, and it was more than substantial and comfortable enough for our friends.
The property is gated and the deadbolts are all auto-locking, which is a nice touch. Having a space to park in front was also really helpful. The place is well stocked with lots of towels, sheets, blankets, and even plenty of house slippers conveniently located by the front door. Lots of light coming through the windows brightens the space, which decor-wise, could honestly use a touch of warmth (although, this aspect will likely improve over time, as is the case with many AirBnb properties).
The backyard is quite spacious and great for relaxing and having a meal or drink with friends. The garden (at this time) looked like it had taken a beating from the Oakland sun, but the passion fruit covering a low pergola is super healthy and impressive - wish I could've hung out back there more than just a few minutes!
Since I was only at the AirBnb for one night and the morning of my wedding, I cannot speak entirely for my friends' 3-night experience. All in all I think they enjoyed their stay and had no complaints (they did note that the first day they heard a lot of noise upstairs from things moving around, or up and down the stairs a good part of the day).
I also personally didn't get to meet the owners, but my friends said Cathy's husband spoke to them and he seemed pleasant.
Overall I am satisfied with this rental and thankful that this place ended up being a good value with no added stress on my wedding weekend. =)