I have stayed at several Airbnbs but have never wanted to return to one on a subsequent visit--until staying at Tina & John's garden cottage. The other reviews you have read about this place are spot on. I'll just add that I particularly liked the fact that the cottage sat in the owner's backyard. Tina & John were right there if I needed anything, but they gave me all the privacy I wanted. And knowing they were just a few feet away gave me an extra sense of security. When they built this cottage, they did it right. It has so many nice touches, you'll want to come back again and again. I only hope this cottage is available for my next trip to Oakland.