Positives: location is excellent. It's Oakland so you will get some loud music blaring from a car or something, but it is walking distance to an amazing set of restaurants. The WiFi is excellent; 2 of us were working from there the entire time. It is nice to have a backyard, though sparse, to walk around in.
Negatives: the kitchen was quite dirty when we arrived. I think the dishwasher is too old to truly work so most of the dishes still look dirty. The silverware drawers hadn't been cleaned in months and the pots/pans were really worn. The pillows weren't the most comfortable and the beds could've been better. It was serviceable, but didn't feel the value was there for the price.
Neutral: Oakland is *extremely* sparse with AirBnB's, at least when we looked. So honestly this was still probably one of the better options and that's why I still gave this 4 stars.