We understand part of the pricing for this room is due to the high demand and limited supply of housing on the island. But we thought that investing just a little more time and money into the place with a few extra amenities would make a huge difference in the quality of experience for your guests. Some things that we would have loved would be:
Real bowls/ plates and silverware (would pay off for you in the long run too!)
If you cleaned the floor with a different cleaner (it was extremely oily and sticky)
Paper towels
Touching up the paint
Updated printouts of information (they had the wrong Wi-Fi password, things about COVID before July, said there were scuba masks, etc.)
The bed not creaking so much
Two chairs at the table
A bedside table
A freezer or mini fridge with a freezer (we bought ice cream before we arrived, and it all melted)
A Keurig or other single serve coffee maker
More organized cabinets
Etc