This is a guest suite with a private entrance, but it's still a suite below David and Judith's house. It's a nicer place to stay than some other AirBnB listings since no one lives here regularly (so no worries about seeing other people's toiletries, etc) and Judith has added lots of touches to make every guest comfortable (lots of hanging space for clothes, ironing board, kitchenette with fridge, microwave, and full set of dishes, etc). The deck is huge, feels totally private, and is a fantastic outdoor living space.

Only downside in the stay was a slight confrontation with Judith. House rules say deck lights must be turned off by 10:00pm. One night I turned them off a few minutes late, and at 10:10 Judith came downstairs upset. I guess her neighbor complained that the lights were still on at 10:05. I sympathize with the neighbor, but as I had already turned the lights off, the confrontation was not necessary.

Judith apologized a few days later when we checked out, however. Because the apartment was so nice to stay in otherwise, and that deck was so fabulous, our stay still deserves 4 stars, and I would still recommend it to others. Just be sure to turn the lights off before 10!