If you're lucky enough for Hugh's place to be available, stop right now and just book it. My wife and I stayed here for two nights during our honeymoon and got everything we were looking for and more. The views are unmatched. It's in a private, gated community so it's really quiet. You'll get access to a private beach, swimming pool, tennis courts and a putting course. Then there's the golf cart. Hugh gives you the keys to his golf cart to use while on the island (you do not want to know how much they are rent)! Oh and Francisco picked us up when we arrived and dropped us off when we left. Just amazing. We're looking forward to visiting Catalina again in the future, but only if we're able to stay at Hugh's.
Book it.