Our stay in the home of Shelly & Paul was comfortable and clean. We had a beautiful view of Malibu from the backyard and could have used the hot tub if we wanted. Shelly & Paul are outstanding hosts. Shelly was very quick in responding to all of my inquiries and offered great suggestions as far as romantic restaurants and places to go. She offered lots of sweet extras to make the space cozy and perfect for our overnight stay. Thanks again Shelly and Paul for having us. We highly recommend this air bnb!