This was mine and my girlfriend first experience with Airbnb and we couldn't have been more satisfied with Cindy's hospitality and private apartment. She and her family were very welcoming and knowledgeable about Malibu and the surrounding areas, and were able to provide FANTASTIC suggestions on the best places to eat some food and catch some killer waves at the best places. We were also able to bring our dog and she was very welcoming to having him ( husky) and actually while we were out she was willing to keep and eye on him to make sure he was doing okay. The apartment was lovely/ clean and had everything you would need! The patio was beautiful and a great place to have a glass of wine and enjoy the sounds of the canyon. Cindy also provided a nice breakfast ( bagels, banana and yogurt) which was very sweet and came in handy. I would highly recommend her for your next AirBnb stay in Malibu!