The Good: The view and location can not be beat. We were in town for gay pride and we were less than one block from he end of the parade. Host was communicative from start to finish, no problems there.
Reasons why we would not rent again: For a host who is so particular about the expectations of guests we were surprised at how many basic maintenance issues there were. Particularly in the bathroom. Sink handles came off and shower knobs too. Host was aware of the issues and offered a plumber to come while were there. We weren't in the mood to host a plumber while we were on vacation. Toilet paper supplied was inadequate for the amount of people staying there. Less than two rolls for six people for two days. There were sour towels. Dirty sponge in the kitchen that we were required to clean our own dishes with before we left. The dead bolt locking plate on the front door needed replacement. The screws came completely out of the door frame when we tried to line up the dead bolt to lock it at night. We did not feel completely safe because of that. The mattresses were dated and sunken in the middle. My personal impression is that this place is just a moneymaker for them and they aren't interested in upkeep.