The place itself is cozy and lovely. You can watch stars from the balcony and hummingbirds frequent its feeder. It's in a great location: quiet and most of the attractions of avalon are maybe 5 minutes walk away.
Jeanie's hospitality blew us away. The apartment had been furnished with some Valentine's day chocolates. She offered an early check in and picked us up from the ferry so we could spend more time on the island without worrying about our bags. On the last day of our stay the weather was rough and she offered us an extra night in case our boat was cancelled.
If it's available we'll definitely be staying at the Happy Yellow Triplex on our next visit to Catalina.