So here's my take - I was between 3-4 stars because it worked out great for us, but could be improved. If you want a no frills big house to meet up with friends or family, this is a great place. It was big, he was great about allowing our party (20 including kids) to stay, getting in the house was easy and he didn't bug us during our visit (very easy owner to work with). The kids LOVED the big backyard to run around and play on scooters. Lots of seating in the living room and kitchen. The "bones" of the house are great and the beds were comfortable.
The downside is the house could use some TLC. The floors were dusty and looked like they hadn't been swept. The backyard furniture and kitchen was covered in dust and had spider webs all over it. We couldn't use anything outside really. The walls could use a good painting and the future was worn. The kitchen lacked supplies like a can opener so it was hard to cook meals there.
For our purpose it worked out great in terms of needing a big house for a large group but there were no amenities besides the basics. The price is amazing and we got what we paid for, so I gave it 4 stars. For this purpose, we'd stay there again, but I'd bring more to fill in the gaps the house lacked.