Short version: The space is great, and the description of the property is accurate. If you are a group of two, with no expectations of bringing a friend over or concern about near constant surveillance/monitoring, I think you'll have a great time. The view is lovely.
Long version: We tangled with our hosts, who live on the property about 15 feet away, because I forgot to tell them that our party of two was now three (BTW-we were celebrating my sister's 40th, and my brother was the third last minute guest). The property accommodates four, but there are charges for any guests over two. This is clearly indicated in the listing, and that fault here was mine, and we readily accepted the additional charges.
I thought things were fine after this, but I guess we triggered some red flags for the host and owner (who does not live on site). We got email messages that we'd been letting other guests spend the night (we had not - when watching the tapes of the property, the owner got confused because my brother was wearing a hat in one tape and not in another. This is that somewhat unsettling surveillance level I mentioned.) We then got emails about not letting anyone on the property at all to visit, even though prior to booking we had asked if we were allowed to have people on the beach out front who could use the house to change and grab refreshments. Understanding that the host and owner were anti parties, we directed people to meet us at the public beach at the end of the street, but a couple of people were confused and still went to the property first. The hosts, who live in the converted garage, seem very attuned to people pulling into the driveway (which said my sister's name and I think caused some of the confusion for the guests meeting us at the public beach). This was further compounded by more miscommunications between the host and myself, which finished in the host reprimanding my sister as she walked one guest on the property so he could get a sandwich. She told my sister that she had no idea who this person was and he couldn't just come on the property... however, not knowing who is coming onto your property seems like something you have to accept as an AirBnB host. The host's position is understandable, but we found the tone of communications and general sense of being watched and being treated like a bunch of irresponsible teens trying to get away with a kegger or something to be unpalatable. We decided to leave a day early. It's an example of two different types of communication styles and personality types, not a reflection on the property itself.
If you read the other reviews, you'll see that we are an exception and not the norm, and only a handful of other reviewers had problems with the hosts. I think if you don't accidentally or intentionally break the rules, you'll have no issues. If you're from out of town, I think violating the guest rule would be unlikely anyway, but if you are a local, just don't make the mistake we did.
And once again, the place is otherwise what you expect, and aside from a bathroom door that didn't close, the first few days were problem free. It all just ended on a sour note. I've learned that booking a property with a host on site is just not something I want to do ever again.