Overall: 5 stars and would definitely stay again.
Pros: Great location, walkable to shopping and old town. 4 grown men all slept comfortably. Very nicely redone house. AC worked fantastically on a warm weekend. Easy check in and out. Host had great communication.
Cons: Very few. Parking might be an issue if you have more than 2 cars. We managed to park 3 small cars in the driveway but 4 would not be doable. Road noise is as loud as promised outside, but did not interfere at all with our stay or sleep. Yard is mostly dirt, so not usable.