This is, indeed, the holy grail of Airbnbs. I didn't think it would be possible for it to live up to the wonderful reviews, but it actually exceeded them. We spent 4 nights there and waking up to the gorgeous view and drinking the yummy coffee from the French press was all we needed for a couple of hours (bring a good book and you will be overjoyed). I often look for places with a kitchen, but this place didn't need one since there is so much amazing food nearby and the ability to make coffee and store things in the mini fridge was all we needed. Carole and Chris provide every single detail imaginable so you won't be wanting for anything.
This is one of those places that is both convenient for stepping out and seeing the sights AND so lovely that it becomes a treasured part of your trip. We spent a lot of time just enjoying the space. One day, I went off shopping on Melrose while my husband was content to just relax there. I think that says a lot about how wonderful it is. We will definitely be back!