Cathy's place is a good value for the space and location. It is very clean and much larger than most air bnbs I stayed in. She is available for quick communication and she left a lovely welcome snack and breakfast items. I would definitely recommend this place.
I do feel the need to add one bit of information that I was not aware of until I arrived. Although, this space is separate and private, it not only shares a very thin wall with another one of her air bnbs but THEY control the thermostat. The guests that were there when I was staying there were not "party" loud but they talked late into the evening and even "ocean sounds" on my phone couldn't drown them out. Plus, they had the heat turned way up so, even with the windows open it was too stuffy to sleep as comfortably as I would've preferred. The space I was in has a couple of wall a/c units and space heaters but turning on the air conditioner in the winter wasn't a solution that felt comfortable.
All in all, I still believe it is a very comfortable, spacious, clean air bnb that is in a great Valley location with an attentive host.