Very disappointed.
Pros: Views are amazing, we were able to leave our bags in the apartment before the check-in time.
Cons: Cleanliness (hopefully I can attach photos to this review), there were bugs in the cupboard (my mother found them when looking for a coffee filter), the oven was disgusting, the extra bedding left was dirty (make-up and dirt marks). The fuse blew. No where in the listing did it give instructions on the heating (Catalina had a storm the night before so it was extremely windy and cold), we spent a little over an hour wondering why the thermostat wasn't working and had to contact the host and wait another hour or so for someone to bring us firewood (which should have been left for us upon arrival) - there's no excuse why my elderly parents needed to be in this freezing cold apartment for over two hours. They should also add that this is a 4/5 floor walk up/down, accessibility was an issue for my mother.
When AirBnB helped me to reach out to the host to get a refund for the cleaning charge of $125 (this is the first time I've ever asked for an AirBnB refund), the host rejected immediately without further discussion. We left this place better than how we found it (& I have the pictures/video to prove it).
I'm sure this place was worthy of being a Superhost at one point, but it's definitely not now. Don't waste your money - book a hotel or another AirBnB.