This is a comfortable place in a great neighborhood, with beautiful views of the mountains from the front yard. There were a few issues, but Dorothy is one of the most responsive hosts we've ever encountered, and responded within minutes of our contact with her. There was a lot of breakfast food waiting for us in the kitchen - cereal, eggs, bread, jam, coffee, bananas, and a bowl of fruit, which was a nice surprise. Note that this isn't a free-standing unit; it's the back of the main house, separated by a door. Very private and comfortable, but if there are toddlers running up and down the hall or throwing tantrums in the main house, it can be noisy. A few things need to be dealt with before we'd come back, but once they are, yes, this is a lovely place to stay. And again, Dorothy is the most responsive host we've encountered. A solid four stars, easily upgraded to five.