Peter was a very attentive, mindful host. He was there when we checked in, and I chatted with him briefly when I checked out. The space itself is beautiful- the kitchen especially. The reason I listed it as 'okay' was because noise was an issue for us. In bed, you could hear clear as day the neighbors on the phone or talking back and forth, and even a child screaming/throwing a tantrum. It wasn't even like it was muffled, it was as if they were in the room with you. This is no slight against the host, as he was not the builder of the property, but it was unexpected, and made sleep difficult, especially if you want a quiet place to rest after a long day. If you're someone who can sleep through noise, then you shouldn't have a problem.
I also found the bed in the converted second bedroom to be quite uncomfortable.
This all being said, the set up was good, the proximity to the NoHo arts district great, and I never once felt unsafe. Pros and cons, just like any other property.