My stay at Jack's appartment was on the one hand very pleasant and enjoyable, but on the other hand there are some thigs that I was dissapointed in. Contacting the owner was always very quick and without any problems - a very good experience. When I arrived at the appartment there was some fruit and a personal message waiting for me on the table, and there was some welcome food in the fridge waiting for me, which I found very thoughtfull and endearing. The location for me was great - 15 min walk from the Royal Mile and right next to Arthur's Seat. There is also something amazing about the appartment when it comes to sleep quality - I slept very well my whole stay there. My main gripe with my stay at Jack's appartment was the cleanliness situation. The appartment was obviously only maintenance-cleaned and has not been properly cleaned for a long while. All the daily used surfaces like the kitchen table, sink, the bathroom and shower were clean, but things that one doesn't wipe or wash after every use were quite dirty. I'm also pretty sure neither the towels nor the bed sheets were changed after the previous guests which was a bummer (although I did find newer towels in a place indicated by the owner). So overall my stay at Jack's appartment was a little bit of this and a little bit of that, but it has a potential for a very nice place after the owner has a long talk with the cleaning-person.