I stayed at Tony's for one month. It was a delight. The room is clean, cosy, well-organized, with its own work station and bathroom. The furnitures are taken care very well, and the bed is amazingly confortable. The flat is huge, with beautiful views both of the city and the ocean. The place is worth the price, I am sure. Also, Tony is helpful, friendly, and has plenty of recommendations about places to visit, Scottish history, art... I took his advice many times and had a good time in Edinburgh and elsewhere in Scotland. Tony is always making sure that we are happy and confortable. He is a really good host, and I feel luck to have chosen his place for my stay in Edinburgh. Also, every morning Tony served me a nice continental breakfast, which was a good surprise, since it was not published on Airbnb when I booked.
I would highly recommend Tony's place to anyone going to Edinburgh.