Dawn's home was perfect for us. Had everything we needed and was well equipped. She was great about communication, especially given my email issues once arriving overseas. While not located in the hustle and bustle, it was an easy 15 minute walk to the botanical gardens, 30 minute walk to the Castle, and 4 minute walk to shops and pubs. If we return (and I hope we will) we hope to stay here again. Clean, well-appointed, spacious, and to us Americans, it seemed very Edinburgh. We loved it.