Alan is a kind, thoughtful and efficient host. I loved the situation of his flat near the Botanic Gardens, on the Water of Leith. If you are travelling by car his apartment is very easy to get to, and park. If you know Edinburgh, this is very important! Alan made me tea on arrival, and gave me good advice for where to eat etc. Alan also made me coffee and toast for breakfast. Alan obviously has a lot of experience of welcoming people to his home. He's good at being there when you need him, and also he knows when to give his guests space to relax. I'd definitely stay with Alan again if the opportunity arose.