I had a wonderful stay with Robert! He was welcoming and made both arrival and departure very easy. I was out all day every day I was there, so I didn't see much of the flat's occupants, but I did meet the cat, who was also very welcoming. The flat is in an interesting old building, and everything was clean, well-kept, and quiet. The room itself is wonderful - I loved the lofted sleeping area, the bed was comfortable, and the view is stunning. The neighborhood was very good, too - convenient to the center city, the university, and Holyrood park and the palace. And it felt very safe, especially since there's a big police station right down the street.