Absolutely great. I cant think of a single thing wrong with this place. The host is helpful and kind, the location is by far the best in town. Everything is within walking distance from shops and markets to the meet up spots for most of the city tours. I saw in a past review someone mentioned a smell. I noticed it too but it was faint and not a bother at all, it goes away once you start living, and Im pretty sure its the smell of authentic old building in the heart of Scotland. This place is perfect if you want to be comfortable in Edinburgh. The bed is fresh, clean, and well covered. The guest book is so helpful and well witten it made a huge difference in our experience. Zaza's cafe downstairs has delicious food and friendly staff. I cant wait to stay here again next year!