Our experience was not that good. But the opinion may differ from person to person.
We did not have much problem with the house though.
BAD OPINIONS
1. We had a check-in problem with the lock box. The pass code and the lockbox both were incorrect. It might be because they handle many properties so it was a miscalculation on their part.
2. Although the place was very good, it was on the 2nd floor with long stretched stairs so it feels like 3 floor up.
3.We had a mice in the room. I was told that there are mice in many apartment around Edinburgh.
4. Walking to the city center is a long 25 minutes uphill walk, so its a tedious walk.
GOOD OPINIONS
1. The Place around is quite and beautiful.
2. The place is good for stay. Neat , clean and lots of amenities.
3. Few Sight Seeing places are nearby the Place.
4. Bus service to the center is just around the corner.