John was very prompt with his responses throughout the booking process. He was keen about getting all the details of the apartment right (making sure everything was provided for) given he's a pretty early AirBnB user. We were impressed!

The flat is a great little place in Edinburgh - a bit of a hike up some stairs, but a great size for our group of 5. There was definitely enough room for another single. I also think this place would work well for a longer term stay (we only stayed one night).

The location was excellent - it's in a central location and 20 minute walk from the Golden Mile / Edinburgh castle. Lots of little coffee shops and a few pubs in the area. A short walk from various restaurants. We didn't have to take transit anywhere! A cab ride to Waverly took ~10 minutes (in traffic) and was something dirt cheap like 6 pounds.

Overall, we were impressed, and I would consider staying there again for a future visit.