Best host ever! David thought of everything, including "welcome" magazines for my two boys that were amazingly appropriate and appreciated. David's communication before the trip was terrific and prompt, and we took several of his suggestions for restaurants etc. (enjoyed our meals at both The Beer Kitchen and the Last Drop). The location of the apartment was fantastic - the view of the castle is amazing (and was a PERFECT place to watch New Years Eve fireworks), and Grassmarket is a great neighborhood. We loved Scotland and hope to return soon. Other recommendations: the Rabbie's tour to the Highlands & Loch Ness was excellent; for Hogmanay, we really enjoyed the Torchlight Procession but ended up skipping the Ceilidh (& Street Party) due to the idea of standing for a long time in cold temperatures with kids and a mother-in-law.