My boyfriend and I stayed in Anna and Simon's for a weekend. We loved Edinburgh but found the apartment to be a little disappointing, it was smaller than it appeared online. However it was clean and comfortable and fine for a weekend when you are not spending much time inside. If I were to travel to the city again I think I would look for accommodation closer to the royal mile as opposed to the castle. Anna's directions to the apartment were perfect and we found it easily. Unfortunately they could not accommodate us with a late checkout as there was a cleaner coming in between 11 and 3. It would have been helpful if we could have left our bags there until 3pm but in the end we used a locker service in the bus station. I also thought it was quite expensive for what it was but it was pretty good for what we wanted.