Perfect in every way. We loved our stay with Johanna in her lovely home. From very helpful directions from the train station, to putting out breakfast for us, to sharing tips about things in Edinburgh/ off the beaten track, to the comfy bed - this was a five-star AirBnb experience. If you enjoy staying in a real person's home, having a comfortable place to launch your explorations of the city, and don't like fussy-mussy, then book here, if you can find a free window. We will be returning to E some day, and we will be staying with Johanna for sure (as well as recommending her to friends if they plan on a visit). PS - cats! We miss them already.