I highly recommend Harriet’s place. It’s an interesting and well-maintained example of 19th century planned Victorian housing, and feels very safe and secure. It’a great location to experience how real residents of Edinburgh live, away from the touristy center of town - yet EASY enough to get to the center via bus or walking alongside the waters of the Union Canal. Harriet is an experienced and gracious host, clear with her communications. My stay was excellent!