Cataldo's flat is definitely a 5 star experience! It is even more beautiful in person than the photos depict. The apartment is spacious, beautifully decorated, very comfortable and spotlessly clean. It was stocked with everything I needed and more - a very thoughtful host. It is about a 30 minute walk from downtown 'old' Edinburgh, and just a five minute walk through a beautiful park to catch one of many buses running to town and back. Transportation was never a concern and I felt 100% safe walking the streets and through the park by myself at all hours. There was also an excellent market just minutes away by foot. I highly recommend Cataldo's beautiful flat to anyone visiting Edinburgh - I will definitely return!