The apartment was great, all essentials provided and was nice and warm in these cold Edinburgh winter days. Location was convenient and a reasonable walk to city centre. Presence near running water of leith was quite magical. Communication was excellent, and detailed instructions on check-in, apartment and check-out were provided. There was an issue on check-in with the key to building front door not working but Barry was very responsive and despite my check-in being around 9pm, he attended and sorted things out. Prompt response from host throughout stay.