Amazing!
Location was brilliant - close enough to the city to walk (20 - 30 minutes to Old Town or New Town, around or over Carlton Hill) but not so close as to have issues with noise or crowds! I walked everywhere, but there were frequent bus services from the main road nearby.
Dave was a friendly and conscientious host - always happy to drop some local knowledge and answer questions. He was well organised, and check-in was a breeze. Also, the provided Breakfast was very useful if you're trying to get the most out of the short winter days!
Overall a very professional set up and friendly atmosphere. I would definitely consider staying here again if I'm ever back in Edinburgh!