You can't go wrong with Gillian!!!!
Exceptional accommodations. Extremely clean, bright and a pleasant place to relax after a long day of sightseeing. Gillian is a wonderful, friendly lady who cares about her guest, and makes sure to accommodate your schedule.
We stayed with her 3 nights, and felt like we were leaving a good friend. She is very knowledgeable and helpful, and couldn't make us feel more welcome. Her location is perfect as she is an easy 2 blocks from the Haymarket train station and trams, and the buses stop just around the corner. You can get anywhere easily, yet return to a quiet friendly neighborhood at night. Great restaurants also within a 2 block walk!
Gillian should be your first contact for a place in Edinburgh.