The apartment looked exactly like it was shown in the pictures. The overall cleanness was good. We did not get to meet Paul, but we were given the opportunity to check in earlier then the mentioned time, which was a great thing for us. His brother, Chris also provided us with complimentary food. It was located in the central area of Edinburgh, just a few minutes away from Waverley station (central station where all the "Hop-on Hop-off" buses and buses that go to the airport stop). The view at night was great. Overall we had a great stay . I definitely would recommend staying in this apartment.