Unfortunately I couldn't make the trip but my brother and sister-in-law stayed so this is their review. David was a great host and communicated really well with us which helps so much when you are visiting a city you have never been too before. He showed us everything we needed around the apartment and provided us with basics bread,milk,juice and cheese as well as a selection of wines as it was New Years which was really lovely. We highly recommend David's apartment and thank you so much for making our short time in Edinburgh memorable.