Outstanding and do-again...both this beautiful, comfortable flat and the wonderful city of Edinburgh. Our family of 5 spent New Year's in Edinburgh and it was fantastic and memorable. Don't miss the Torchlight Procession if you have the opportunity to be there over Hogmanay. We walked everywhere and on the occasions where we needed a taxi, a taxi stop is just down the street, around the corner. Paul and his wife are perfect hosts and the flat had everything we needed with comfort and good taste. The communication was outstanding as well. I highly recommend staying here and we look forward to coming again.