Overall it was a decent place to stay in the New Town of Edinburgh. First, will start with the negatives so you can determine if there are any deal-breakers for you. The place was COLD, even with all the heaters going. The windows allowed in lots of cold air and due to them being old, there was no way to fully close them. Every night there were drunk people yelling and screaming outside. Sometimes til 11pm. Other nights til 3am.
Now, to the positives. The decor was cool! You could feel the charm and history. The place was large and spacious with high ceilings. Overall the location was fantastic, allowing us to easily explore the New Town with only a 15-20 minute walk to the heart of Old Town. Finally, our original AirBnb for Edinburgh canceled on us due to "maintenance issues" at 10am the day we were supposed to arrive. Jeremy and his team were able to get us booked last-minute to arrive the same day.