Had a great stay at Graeme’s place. It was a lovely location next to the Botanical Gardens, but only a 30 min walk into the city centre. We did get the bus back from Princes’ Street one day & it only took 8 mins (plus stopped a minutes’ walk from the front door.) Beds were really comfy, good living room space & our toddler was fine in the small, single room. It had no external window & let a lot of noise from kitchen through so maybe not great for an adult. Good for kids as secure & all on one floor. Kids’ playground 5 min walk. Nice sitting area in kitchen, but only 4 chairs so we took in turns for breakfast! Graeme was v quick to respond when we arrived & the smoke alarm was beeping. Sorted v promptly. Would recommend as a location if you don’t mind a bit of a walk or prefer to be out of the hustle & bustle. We were there for the half marathon & ended up at North Berwick for the day which was beautiful. Only downside was that kitchen could have been a little more equipped, but other than that, everything was great.