My father and I really enjoyed our stay here! We were hiking across the John Muir Way and the comfy beds, laundry, and excellent shower were all quite welcome amenities! Julie was a gracious host, flexible with check in and check out, and included a nice book of nearby restaurants and things to do.
The place is a bit too far to walk into the nightlife of Edinburgh, but an Uber/Taxi can get you anywhere very quickly!
Overall, it was a lovely stay. Would return!