We arrived late at night, but Caroline had left the lights on for us which made for a lovely welcome. There were lots of essential grocery items left in the flat, so were able to make a cup of tea (with real milk!) when we arrived. The flat was comfortable, clean and in a perfect location: this area of Edinburgh has a lovely village feel and is an easy walk into the City Centre. If you're not up to the walk, there is a frequent and reliable bus service from the end of the road. I would have no hesitation in recommending Caroline's place, and hope to return myself one day.