This is a great apartment in a wonderful location. You are a short walk from almost anywhere you'd want to go in Edinburgh and there are many amenities located a very short distance from the apartment (market, coffee shop, etc.). Joanne is a great host, very communicative with clear directions and a sense of humour. Our only complaint, a mild one, is that picking up and returning the key wasn't very convenient, but that wouldn't stop us from renting the apartment again in the future.