Wonderful apt, very well decorated. The location can't be better. Right where you should be but a bit away from all the noise up the street (we were there during Fringe). The beds were confortable. It was a very nice place for 4 adults and 1 child. A little issue with hot water in the kitchen but I know the plumbing will be redone this Fall. If you stay on a Friday, you may have to deal with the music from the bar on the other side of the street. Some people mentioned the smell from the fish n chips restaurant downstairs, we didn't smell it at all. Communication with Carol was very easy. She was quick to answer our questions. I would definitely go back when I return to Edinburgh.