Had an excellent experience in Edinburgh (Fringe), and at Ross's flat. Unbeatable location. Centrally located to all of the best Fringe venues, and literally 2 minutes walk from the National Museum of Scotland (amazing museum generally, and also hosting Fringe events).

We had to ask to change our expected arrival time as we were driving from the Highlands with some unexpected travel changes, but communication was excellent and we were graciously met at the flat at the new time we proposed with no issues.

Flat is spartanly furnished but is maximally functional for travellers. No tchotchkes or frills, besides a few on-point travel guides and books. It is probably good to know that the apartment is top floor with no lift. But even a gimpy middle-aged dude like me had no issues with the stairs. Spacious rooms and huge amounts of useful horizontal surfaces (shelves, cabinets, tables) in hallway, bedrooms and kitchen.

Was initially concerned that noise would be an issue, since (due to the great location) one side of the apartment has windows facing heavy pedestrian traffic. However, those windows have effectively three layers of insulation when closed up, and we experienced no street noise whatsoever (also, since flat is top floor, no noise from neighbors).

If we are lucky enough to return to Edinburgh again, would definitely put this at the top of our list to book!