Caroline’s place was right in the heart of Edinburgh which was incredibly convenient for getting around. It was comfortable, spacious and stylish. Practicality wise, it would have been nice if there were wine glasses and tea bags already in the cupboard. Cleanliness was fine other than some pastry flakes in the microwave that must have been from the guests before and something that looked like a blood stain on the pillowcase. As per all the other reviews, do bring ear plugs for the noisy pub goers.