David's place in very charming and quiet. Our first impression was a bit disappointing, as you enter the building and head down two flights of stairs to a dark, musty hallway, but once inside the unit, it was just as promised. David's instructions for checkin were very clear. Overall, his response time was slower than we've encountered with many other hosts, but we had no major issues. The area was very quiet and pleasant but was a bit further than the main tourist areas of Edinburgh than we had anticipated. That was on us, though!