The flat was perfectly placed for me, far enough out to escape the busy city centre but close enough to get in with a short walk or even closer to get to Arthur's seat and Carlton Hill.
I loved going for runs in the hills in the evenings watching the sunset and heading home.
The flat is well furnished and feels safe, it does need a little TLC to bring it up to match the listing, but a few simple fixes would do the trick.
The corridor does smell of stale smoke unfortunately, though there isn't much to be done to control that I don't think.
Overall a good stay and with a bit of TLC it would be brilliant.