We really enjoyed our stay. The apartment was beautifully decorated, well equipped and spotlessly clean. It's large and comfortable, with lots of room to spread out and relax and even a small garden to sit out in. Newhaven and Leith are easy walking distance, with a fantastic fish and chip shop in Newhaven where you can get a takeaway and eat at the water's edge. Edinburgh centre is a bit further, but still walkable, and we had a great time, visiting the Castle, Camera Obscura World of Illusion, Real Mary King's Close and lots of cake shops. Gareth was friendly and helpful. We would highly recommend Gareth's place.