I knew as soon as we met Andrew we had made the right choice in staying here. He was warm and friendly and engaging. He even left us two bottles of sparkling wine as a honeymoon gift on the bed. (Such a thoughtful touch!) He was so interesting to talk with, full of knowledge about Scotland — and whisky — and it was such a pleasure getting to know him. His place was immaculate; you couldn't find a better location near the Royal Mile. It was perfection. We wound up spending half a day with him, as he took us to a whisky tasting — all on his own time! While we can't complain about the accommodations or location, Andrew really made our stay in Edinburgh one we'll never forget. My husband still says that was his favorite part of our three-country trip. I can honestly say we left Edinburgh with a new friend.