My wife and I stayed at Charlotte's apartment for 6 nights. The apartment conforms to Charlotte's description on AirBAB, and it has satisfied all of our needs during our stay. The place was quiet and peaceful, and the bed was so comfortable that we had an easy time to adjust our heavy jet-lag. We particularly like the view of the back garden (not part of the apartment) when we sit in the kitchen during breakfast time. Our impression of the neighborhood outside of the apartment is safe and convenient. There are several wonderful restaurants just few minutes walk from the place; a major department store is nearby; 10 - 15 minutes walk from the Waverley station. See if you can find the statue of Sherlock Holmes. We feel lucky to book the place for our first AirBNB experience, and we fully recommend Charlotte's apartment for your visit to Edinburgh