the place was as described, but following the visit, Amanda messaged us saying there was a stain half way up the wall at the entrance of the house. she suggested it was either food or someone had been sick! considering my girlfriend and I (both late 30s) were in Edinburgh for a couple of nights, and were out most of the time, we were very surprised to hear this. the pictures she sent showed very light, historic marks at the entrance which you could barely see, and seemed like from an old water leak, and was totally illogical to suggest a any guest could have even done that! i tried to explain that this wasn't us, but it fell on deaf ears. didn't respond after a while, so left it at that. left a real sour taste after such a wonderful break to a beautiful city.