Lilly is a good host and was excellent with respect to getting back to me with questions and concerns. The place is nice (Bedroom/bathroom were great) but not having a kitchen to cook was a deal breaker for me. Additionally, the street was noisy and the bars/restaurants below dumped lots of bottles early in the morning. However, that might be the trade-off for staying in the heart of the city. My stay at several other airbnb's in Scotland, directly after staying at Lily's place, in my opinion, were a better value.