Booked a weekend in Edinburgh for my 30th birthday and decided to go with Rebecca’s apartment as it was a central location and seemed well kept and clean. Those things were true, it was walking distance to most things but the apartment is right by 3 strip clubs (obviously not Rebecca’s fault) but definitely something to note, it can be very very loud at night and would not say it is a family friendly area (a cab drives even described it as the “pubic triangle”). The apartment was clean and tidy but the building common areas could use some tlc, foul smelling rubbish was left in the hallway and the rooftop is bare (I’m sure there was a picture when I booked the apartment and it certainly was deceiving). The apartment (especially the beds and sofas) did smell like smoke, it was engrained in the place so smokers have definitely stayed/lived there previously. The apartment served its purpose and Rebecca was easy to communicate with, however I wouldn’t stay again and if the noise or smell would bother you I don’t recommend.