Location and amenities at apartment were good (apart from a can opener that was not functioning correctly at the time).
This listing, I believe, is being managed by a support team (who I don't believe are David and Amy) and an additional third party app (an inconvenient, extra step) called "Airsorted" where you get information about check in and such. I believe this affected how impersonal I felt communication was through the AirBnb app.
If you are not traveling by car, and have no requests that need to be handled during your stay, I think you might be able to find this apartment a home away from home near the heart of beautiful Edinburgh. I was honestly let down however by feeling "managed" by this support team instead of feeling like I was able to liaise directly with a trusted, local host during our experience here.