This is a clean, spacious flat in an exceptional location in Edinburgh. It is basic and no frills. Katie was very responsive via email when I booked, but we were a little disappointed that no one met us at the flat on our arrival and I had to call for telephone instructions to enter the flat. We had trouble initially getting the heat to work, and had to purchase soap and toilet paper for the week. It was low season and cold outside, so very little noise during our stay, but sound really does carry. It didn't bother us, though. It was a fair price for the stay.