We booked the Dovecot Cottage almost a full year ago, when our daughter was accepted at the University of Edinburgh. We stayed in Edinburgh last summer at another Airbnb and were really disappointed with it, so we wanted to pick something that would be amazing. Obviously, this cottage LOOKS amazing on Airbnb, but it truly IS even more amazing in person. We looked forward to this trip all year, mostly because of where we were staying, and it was so nice to arrive and have everything even better than expected. Sarah was so accommodating - on everything from check-in to shopping recommendations (needed things for uni!) to sightseeing tips to general heating questions. The cottage is surrounded by her beautiful gardens and is super private and quiet. Inside, it's so well done, she has not overlooked anything. It's an easy walk to the center of town, as well as the university residence halls and Arthur's Seat. We truly enjoyed our stay and will book again on a future trip to visit our daughter.