This place was fine for one night but having stayed in other AirBnbs in Edinburgh, this one lacked comfort.
The location is great - exactly halfway between Edinburgh and Leith, 20 minutes walk to either. There are lots of cute shops and cafes nearby. When we stayed there was a ton of roadworks happening outside and lots of the road is blocked off with barriers. No problems with noise when we stayed but I can anticipate this being quite noisy in the week.
This room is the largest in a 2 bedroom apartment, where all the rooms (including the living area) have been converted to air bnb rooms. It's on the top floor of a Georgian apartment building, so there's no lift, which was a hassle for my friend with a suitcase.
There isn't much privacy as the apartment is old and noise carries. The door for this particular room is frosted glass, as others have mentioned. Perhaps to be expected in an old building but all the floorboards are very creaky. We came in late when we stayed and there was no way to avoid loud creaking as we crossed the landing to use the bathroom.
Speaking of the bathroom, it's functional and the shower pressure is good. But there's only one and you're at the mercy of other guests. On the morning we were checking out the couple next door hogged the bathroom for the 25 minutes before the check out time.
Small things that added to a lack of comfort - no towels were provided in the room - we had to help ourselves to them from the cupboard on the landing. One of the overhead lights in our room needed a new bulb. There was nowhere to plug the bedside lamp in (no idea how they got the picture in the listing). Basically the whole place looked and felt more tired and less personal than comes across in the photos. Agree with other comments that the key safety box is very fiddly.
Again, fine for a night but the photos are somewhat misleading.