We had a terrific time at Shanna's place. The place for very clean and comfortable. The breakfast was great. Shanna and Galan gave us all sorts of local tips and were wonderful hosts, extending themselves in innumerable ways.. We enjoyed their lovely garden. The neighborhood was nice. The house was wonderfully accessible to Edinburgh. Half the time we walked into town and the other half we took one of numerable buses to get into town. Because they have two rooms, we were able to stay there with my son and daughter in law and enjoy a holiday together. We thoroughly recommend this place for a stay in Edinburgh.