Great and comfortable flat with great views of Arthur's Seat and surrounding area. Felt quite at home with welcoming gifts of snacks and pointers for getting around town (loved Carrie's recommendations for restaurants and cafes - for any gluten free folks check out The Manna House, also if you're not gluten free, it's great). Rated the location 4/5 stars because some renters will desire a quick, rapid access to attractions, but as a plus this is good neighborhood where we could escape some of the tourism after a short walk away from the "downtown." Overall, great relaxing room to come back to after hiking around the city.