I stayed at Mel's place for several days. I found it clean, tastefully decorated and adequate for my stay in Edinburgh. Mel was a gracious host and made every attempt to make my stay as comfortable as possible. The flat is situated on a major bus route and is therefore perfect for city logistics. I would recommend staying at Mel's place if you are looking for a place away from the tourist traps of the old city. Several fantastic restaurants and cafes in the vicinity make it just perfect for a Edinburgh getaway.