It was an absolute treat staying here, clean. comfortable, easy access to local tourist spots and everything we needed. We felt right at home and could get comfortable and relaxed during our stay. Not an issue with the accommodation or hosts, and down to personal preference but being close to the castle meant for some great views, however, if you're a late/light sleeper the early tourists at the castle may wake you up. I couldn't recommend this place enough to stay in in Edinburgh!