My wife, kids and I spent the weekend in Edinburgh for the weekend and stayed in Carols apartment. The location is very central to all of the sights and very east to walk to. The apartment was clean and served its purpose well. The only thing that surprised us was a bit of a fish smell from the restaurant that is below the apartment but we got used to it quickly. Overall, we enjoyed our stay and Carol was very easy to coordinate with. Definitely would recommend for a weekend trip to Edinburgh.