They're not kidding when they call it the best view in Edinburgh. It is a stunning panorama. The place was clean and the hosts were easy to get ahold of. The location is incredibly central—practically next door to the castle. The kitchen was small and only partly supplied, so we didn't end up deciding to cook much. We experienced some plumbing complications while we were there, but my sense was that this was probably a one-time issue related to an appliance installation.