Campbell was a really great host. We arrived in Edinburgh with luggage after a transatlantic flight and we very much appreciated his flexibility in dealing with us.
The location of the place is great. We did not have a car, and did not miss it. The flat is in New Town, close to George St, within walking distance of the Royal Mile, the Waverly train station and the central bus station. There are many good restaurants and pubs right on the street and many more within an easy walking distance. It is central, but not overly touristy. We also made use of the bus that runs a half block away.
The flat is quite spacious and beautifully appointed with lots of common areas and space for separation, 2 bathrooms with showers. It works well for two couples or family, you dont feel on top of each other. We didn't cook much, but facilities are all there.
My husband and I are in our early 60s and it worked well for us but I suspect it would be unsuitable those with mobility issues due to the stairs and hilliness of the area.
We had a couple of questions about the water heating, but Campbell was very prompt with his responses.