The appartment is perfect, it feels clean and warm. The location is a 10, you can see the castle throught the window of the livingroom and the grassmarket area is unbelivable. You are a few minutes away from everything but at the same time this narrow street or "wynd" it's private enough so you don't have lots of people walking throught. At night it can be a bit noisy, but it's not a big problem. I would definetly repeat if I come back to this awesome town. David was a great host and he helped us with everything we needed.