We very much enjoyed our time in Edinburgh during the 2019 new year's eve. Phil was a great host, always attentive. He gave us a thorough introduction to the apartment and many tips about getting around in Edinburgh during the festivities. The apartment is lovely, clean and spacious. The heating system, kitchen, and bathroom worked perfectly.
The location is excellent.
The only small drawback is that for those sleeping on the sofa in the living room, the noise coming from the street/neighbours can be a bit disturbing, but nothing serious. The other two bedrooms are very quiet and spacious.
We definitely recommend this apartment and Phil as a host.