Highly recommend Marion's place. Very good size (bigger than it looks in the photos), immaculately clean, lovely furnishings, and quiet yet central. We walked everywhere during our Edinburgh visit and didn't need to take a single cab or bus. You feel like an Edinburgh local. Marion is a great host and doesn't forget the little things like coffee, tea, soap, etc. We really appreciated that there was binder with practical info and suggestions, and helpful notes and diagrams around the flat for how everything works. Most hosts don't do this so it was a thoughtful touch! Try the local restaurant Pantry for delicious, vegetarian-friendly breakfast. Overall excellent value and experience.