We had a great stay and were very comfortable here. I'm a superhost and a bit picky so read this review with that in mind! We did love the place and I think it is very well done. That said, it was a bit sterile for my taste, with not much in the way of any personal touches. You do not meet the host, and communication seems to be with remote/virtual assistants (usually someone different every time). So if you want a personal experience where you connect with a local and feel welcomed this might not be a good match. One small example, I needed to buy a plug adapter and asked for suggestions on where to go. The person replied promptly but obviously just googled it for the closest electronics store (some 30 minutes away) - a local would have told me to try the Tesco (which is where I found one). Also, you have to interface with an outside website, and they require you to register with your ID. I am already verified through Airbnb, so I felt uncomfortable with the 3rd party aspect. The site also tries to upsell you bonus items like snacks or meals and such (I provide those free for all my guests), and they promote a car service from the airport that was double the cost of a cab. Aside from all that, the place was beautiful, the bed was comfortable - we slept really well - and we really loved the location! It is away from the high energy and party vibe of old town, very close to anything you might need, with lots of nice walking areas (a sweet little riverwalk, the botanic garden, etc). Bus service was super convenient! Overall I definitely recommend this for a great stay in beautiful Edinburgh. We really enjoyed our trip!