An amazing stay!! I stayed here on holiday with three other family members. The description is accurate, and maybe even better than described. The beds were so comfortable. Also - great towels! Gareth was such a gracious host and made check-in easy, even as our travel schedule kept changing the day we arrived. He met us on check-in and was available for any questions along the way, including recommendations on travel and general Edinburgh/Scotland questions.
I think some people who haven't been to Edinburgh are a little hesitant to stay in an Airbnb that isn't right by the city center.... But this is a small city, really, so it was only about 1.5 miles (2.4 km) to walk into town. And there were two busses that took us directly in and out of the city center when we weren't up for the walk. But, if you're on holiday in Edinburgh, having this beautiful walk is a plus, not a minus, in my opinion. There's a lot more to the city than the center, so this lets you soak in more of it.
We felt safe the whole time, even while coming back rather late some nights (all of us are female). And the bar around the corner - The Bonnington, became our nightly gathering place. Very friendly service, great food, and we made new friends! This bar was an unexpected amenity.
I've stayed in a lot of airbnbs around the world, and I think that this is probably the best deal I've ever found on here - really high quality stay, at a very reasonable cost. 10/10 would recommend!