Anne and Allan are incredibly thoughtful hosts - highly communicative, helpful, and informative. Having a car was helpful as tourists, as their lovely location is several minutes from most of Edinburgh’s attractions. That being said, the airport is nearby so it would certainly be possible to do without a car. They even gave us a ride at one point during our stay!
The place is lovely, and the amenities are well worth the price - especially the hot tub (even if the extensive rules regarding its use are somewhat limiting), the ultra-comfortable bedroom, and the full kitchen. There may even be a few extra goodies awaiting guests!
Overall, this is a fantastic Airbnb option for your Edinburgh adventure.