We had a great time staying at Paul's flat. It was in a great location and had a easy meet up with Paul for a key handover who is very friendly and welcoming and is great with communication.
The car parking space meant we could leave it behind and go everywhere on foot. To get into the centre on foot you have a choice of a half hour scenic route through Holyrood Park below Arthur's Seat or a slightly shorter walk through Newington with its fab selection of world food restaurants into the Old Town in about 20 mins.
The flat was warm, cosy and very clean, surprisingly quiet too and has one of the best bathroom views of any Air BnB I've stayed in!
Definitely a recommended place in Edinburgh