Couldn't rate Hilary's place more highly! Really attentive host who shared her knowledge of Edinburgh with us. Fantastic breakfast included with a view of the beautiful garden and I particularly enjoyed the homemade yogurt and bread provided. Really decent sized and comfy bed. The location isn't right in the centre but at the bottom of the Arthur's seat hill which for us was great to have that slight distance from the bustling centre but still very easy to get a bus or taxi into town.