We stayed here over Christmas. The location was fantastic - close to Arthur's seat and less than an hour's walk to the city centre (or 10 mins in an uber). The kitchen was better equipped than some of the other reviews suggested - I managed to cook Christmas Dinner for 8 with what was provided. Unfortunately, a lot of the crockery/pans etc were dirty, and we had to wash them before use. The cleanliness in general didn't meet my expectations. There were cobwebs and dust on light fittings and radiators, the bins in the front garden were overflowing and there were empty beer cans on the table in the back garden. The property is in need of some TLC. The biggest issue for us was that the sliding doors didn't close properly making the living room quite cold. Email communication prior to our trip was poor however when I had an issue during the trip my text received an immediate response. Based on the photos and the price, our expectations weren't met, however we still enjoyed our stay.