My friends and I really enjoyed our stay here. The apartment is huge and clean. During our two week trip of Ireland and Scotland, this was the most space we had and it was nice to have our own rooms for a few days. The neighbourhood is really cute. Lots of little shops, restos and bakeries. It's the kind of neighbourhood I would want to live in if I lived in Edinburgh. The proximity to attractions is also really good. Just a 20 min walk into the city centre and it's on the bus route if needed.
Eve was a great host. Good communication and availability. We arrived before our check-in time and Eve had no problem meeting us earlier to give us the keys (we arranged it ahead of time). The keys are a little finnicky and it took some practice to figure out how to open the apartment door on our own. Maybe ask Eve to show you when she hands the keys over. Once you know, it's easy to open.
The only other comment I have is that the space does have a student apartment vibe (ex. some of the furniture in the common room had stains on the upholstery), but that's just being picky. It did not impact our stay at all. Overall a great time in Edinburgh.