We enjoyed our stay at Melanie's place. It was a beautiful building right in the heart of old town. There are quite a few narrow steps to climb to get to the apartment so just be prepared for that. The interior of the home was lovely as well. As it was during the Edinburgh festival, it was a bit noisy at night, but nothing unreasonable. Our only issue was that there were incomplete linens for the pull-out couch -- perhaps verify in advance if you need pillowcases etc. for it. The main bed however was just fine.