John's place is exactly as described and as the photos represent. The room is very spacious with lovely high ceilings, and at the back of the building, which is very quiet. A lovely touch to offer breakfast items to guests. Very easy communication, and although we never actually met (we missed each other the whole weekend!), we found John very easy to deal with and his place a perfect location for us. One note is that the flat is on the third floor with no lift, but this was fine for us - if you're in Edinburgh, you may aswell get used to steps and hills! Thanks again, John!