Everything was on point. We didn't meet Catherine in person but she seems like a very lovely person. She recommanded us places and cafes to visit without us asking which made us feel very well cared for! The apartment was perfectly clean and the kitchen has more than the basics to cook (tea, coffee, pasta, oats, lots of spices...). It's located in a quiet area : no car noises, just birds. It's not too far from the main city attractions (about 20-25 min by foot to reach the Royal Mile) and you get to enjoy a nice walk by the canal. In short we would not hesitate to come back!