We love Edinburgh and we are very happy staying slightly out of the city as we like to walk and prefer peace and quiet. This is a lovely apartment which is a very good size and close to good places to eat and walk.
We did have some issues and unfortunately these weren't resolved. We couldn't close the window in the 2nd bedroom, which meant it was cold in the evenings and quite noisy at times (morning seagulls, late night fireworks during the Tattoo). The advertised hairdryer couldn't be found - first-world problem, but when you have rubbish hair....
Rather than communicating directly with Joshua, you deal with an agent via text message. I didn't like this and I suspect it impacted the ability to get issues resolved. I want to deal with real people, to let them know if we have an issue (and to know that it will be fixed) or to let them know everything has been great and to say thank you.