I have mixed feelings about this one. The apartment is very well laid out and makes great use of the space. The bedroom is adequate for a double bed (not a queen) with a nice dresser to store stuff. The kitchen is well stocked. The sitting area is comfortable. The bathroom is clean but a little dingy. The location in Leith was great for us (near my family) but will be too far from central Edinburgh for some. There is a ton of road construction going on in the general neighborhood right now.
While the apartment is adequate, the stairwell and entry up to the 4th floor (66 or so steps) is particularly grim. There is no elevator. The windows overlook a fairly noisy corner so not everyone will tolerate sleeping with windows open. (In Scotland, this isn’t a big problem most of the time).
Entertaining tidbit: There is a charming/annoying resident seagull that lands on the window ledge near the breakfast table and constantly begs for food. He squawks and taps on the window to get your attention.