We spent 5 nights in these accommodations, 2 adults, 3 children and a small dog.
We give 3.5 stars because:
It's a great location, easy 30-min walk to Castle Rock with tons of restaurants and grocery very close by. The beautiful cemetery across the street is a lovely place to explore and let the kids and dog run free. The bedrooms are absolutely beautiful, the beds were comfortable, and we all had good nights' sleeps. The kids thought the black and gold bathroom was "so fancy!" (it was adequate).
HOWEVER, the photos on the site are misleading - we think that perhaps they have a 2nd airbnb with similar furnishings - the photos on the site are not of the common area. It was a very difficult space to make meals/hang out/work. (What "dedicated workspace"?)
The two biggest concerns were the strong pee smell in the entry (every time we opened the inner door, we could smell it; otherwise the flat was extremely clean), and the broken kitchen faucet - very loose and hard to use. We messaged the host about it, but he said that to fix it, he would have to replace the entire countertop, and he was planning on doing it later, which didn't help us.
The washing machine works very well, but there was no drying rack, and nowhere to hang wet clothes.
Overall, it was a fine place to stay. Definitely not luxurious, and "charming" is only applicable to the bedrooms, not the common area, but it was fine.