Location, location, location. Just yards (seriously) from the sites of Old Town off the Royal Mile, but still quiet enough to get some sleep after a busy day. Clean, comfortable space with all the amenities. The landing outside the entry door provides attentional space to admire the Writers Museum over breakfast or a cocktail (there is a screen for privacy). The only downside would be if you have difficulty navigating circular stairs for two flights, if not you will be rewarded with a base to explore Edinburgh that is almost as fun as city itself. We stayed during the Fringe Fest and it was still reasonably quiet. Melanie was quick to reply to questions and information/pictures were accurate.