Positive things first:
The accommodation is very well located near a bus stop to the city (about 15 to 20 minutes).
Check in and check out was uncomplicated, I also could shorten my stay since I had to travel home earlier than previously planned.
Besides, if I had questions, they were answered very quickly .
No to the negative ones:
The whole house (which is run by a company that rents small flats for students) was kind of shabby and unclean but I expected a cleaned room since the fee for cleaning was quite high. The towels and the bed seemed to have been changed (although the towels smelled strange) but the floor was definitely not swept nor was a vacuum cleaner used - I found (without particularly looking for it) many disgusting things you definitely do not want to have in your room. After I had complained about it, I was quickly promised a cleaner the next day who obviously did not come. That's why I roughly cleaned the room myself as good as possible with a broom I found somewhere.
I was told that the management would be informed but was not compensated in any way.
For me it was very disappointing and frustrating since Edinburgh itself is a great city and I definitely had other expectations after reading the airbnb description.