This is a very comfortable, clean apartment in a great location - walking distance into Edinburgh and a lot of very cool independent coffee shops, bars and restaurants on your doorstep - many with far more character than some of the chains you'll find in the city centre!
Phil was extremely good with communications as a host; we had no problems, therefore no need to reach out to him, but he made sure that we'd settled in fine and that we had everything we needed; also similar message when we were due to leave which was a very nice touch.
There is plenty of space in the apartment - there were 3 of us and our daughter is 12. Parking was plentiful and right outside which is great; also barely any noise at night and we all slept really well!