Staying with Harriet and Alejandro was my first Airbnb experience and it was a good one. I was only in Edinburgh for two days, so ended up outside of the flat for most of my trip, but the host's communication, advice, and reception was quite nice and relaxed. I was a bit exhausted when I arrived but Harriet put me at ease immediately.
The room was just fine for my needs and I have to say, along with many others, that SHOWER was an amazing experience. The floor massages your tired feet, the water pressure excellent, the fixtures high tech, and afterward, the floor tiles of the bathroom are heated....can't ask for more than that.
Would gladly stay here again. Only caution, you need to learn some basic bus directions to navigate this neighborhood and the city in general. And there are lots of cobblestone hills in Edinburgh, a beautiful city of history and lore.