Karen's place is bright, has a nice view out the back and is very close to everything you need to visit in Edinburgh. It is on the 4th floor and there is no lift so not suitable for families with small children or elderly. There is a leak in the living room roof so I would ensure this is fixed before you rent the flat. The dishwasher also needs to be fixed, after 2 attempts to get it to run more than 5 minutes I gave up and hand washed the dishes.