We mainly chose Robin's place because it was one of the cheaper options in Edinburgh, where accommodation is pretty pricey.
Communication was great - no one met us when we arrived but we were given very clear instructions so check in was no problem. Unfortunately there was no toilet roll when we arrived, but we highlighted this to Robin and he said that he should have noticed and usually provides it. It wasn't clear to us how the shower worked, but we called Fruszina and she was very helpful. Tea and coffee was available in the kitchen - we didn't cook at all but the small kitchen seemed well stocked. The bed is really comfortable.
A big negative for us was that the house is not centrally heated. There were two plug in radiators - one in the kitchen and one in the living room - but that really isn't sufficient for Edinburgh in February. We moved both radiators into the bedroom and only used that room during our stay. We would expect the lack of heating to be advertised so people can make an informed choice about whether the slightly lower price is worth it. We managed, only using the place for morning showers and sleep at night, but if we had travelled with some older guests or needed to stay in the flat more it would have been a serious problem.
The location is not bad - it is a 20 minute walk to the edge of town but we generally got Uber taxis home in the evening for less than £5. Fruszina and Robin were both in good contact during our stay.
If you can survive without the heating it's a decent price for a trip to Edinburgh.