Paul's place was amazing and incredible. Stylish. Sparkling clean. Full of character. Even though it fronted onto a busy street, it was still quiet and comfortable from a noise level standpoint. Paul left us some very thoughtful touches including some snacks and drinks when we arrived. Very strongly recommend without reservation. The only thing I can nitpick is that on the listing it says that shampoo is included but only bar soap is provided and no shampoo. Otherwise, would definitely stay again if ever visiting Edinburgh again!!