My husband, sister and I had a great stay at the apartment. It had everything we needed, including milk, snacks and breakfast items, which were very welcome! We liked that the first page in the welcome folder was the wifi password - incredibly handy as my husband had an urgent work meeting first thing the next morning. We arrived very late on our first night and so didn't meet Paul, but he left very thorough instructions so that we could enter the flat and communication was excellent - no question was too much trouble and was answered very quickly. The location was perfect and ideal for what we wanted to do (Edinburgh Castle, Real Mary Kings Close, dinner at the Balmoral) and we wouldn't hesitate to book again, or one of Paul's other apartments, if visited Edinburgh in the future. One thing to note is that the apartment is on the 3rd floor is up a stone spiral staircase. We only had hand luggage so it wasn't an issue for us, but something to be aware of if you have lots of luggage or less able people in your party.
Thanks again Paul!