Jon's place was truly superb. It is as beautiful as it looks in the pictures, and there are many amenities that I hadn't fully appreciated until I arrived. The kitchen is stocked almost as well as my home kitchen, and I cook quite a bit -- this was such a joy as I prepared dinner for our family many of the nights we were in town. The beds were super comfortable with nice plush comforters and pillows. We travelled with a toddler and the curtains in the master bedroom are total blackout -- particularly helpful in the Scottish summer when it remained light out until 10-11pm! All of the furnishings were of the highest quality, and the hosts gave a really nice touch of a welcome voucher to an exceptional Italian food emporium and restaurant of sorts around the corner that we ended up going back to multiple times for different odds and ends over the course of our stay. Having a second bathroom when traveling with two couples is super convenient. The location really cannot be beat -- splits the difference between Leith and New/Old Town. It's just 5-10 minutes walking to some great sites. Lastly, Jon was a pleasure to coordinate with. He is quick to respond and also accommodating. My *only* comment on possible improvements regards the HVAC system -- we had set the temperature to 21 deg C but the master bedroom remained 24 deg F at night, which was a little warm for us. Cannot guarantee that it wasn't something we weren't doing right in fiddling with the digital controls. 5/5 would recommend and would definitely stay again if back in Edinburgh! Excellent value for such high quality!