We had the most wonderful stay in Catherine's apartment. The flat is a 15-20 minute walk outside the city centre so it's easy to wander into the city. It's peaceful along the canal and we slept so well. The apartment was very clean with everything that we could have needed including guidebooks and cooking essentials. Catherine was the perfect host, giving us brilliant tips on where to go and being flexible with how and when we checked in. I'd highly recommend the apartment for your stay in Edinburgh.