We had great time in Gareth's apartment! Everything is perfect, we can't find any flaws of it. We really felt at home cuz the apartment was so well-equipped. And it stands in the city center and there are lots of shops and supermarket just within few minutes walk, yet you can still have good sleep at night, which is perfect. Gareth is also very helpful and nice. We'll definitely choose Gareth's apartment next time we visit Edinburgh.