Pros: Truly fantastic location right of the royal mile within feet (or meters if you prefer) of great restaurants and bars. Great value stay. I would stay again.
Cons: I'm not docking stars because i think I got exactly what was described (and exactly what I paid for), but just for your awareness....it is an older and not recently renovated building. It's fine for a casual visit, but i wouldn't book a special occasion here. Second very importantly for digital nomads, the internet is slow. You can't effectively work from here. Casual browsing is fine, video WebEx is not.
Again...I would stay here in the future for a casual visit if i didn't need to work.