We had a lovely experience from the communications with Georgina and Mark before we arrived, to arriving and being delighted, to settling in and feeling at home. The conversion is so cleverly done, well appointed and spotlessly clean. Despite having neighbours through both walls we never heard them at all. The only slight negative for us was that we found it very warm, as the storage heaters keep pumping out heat, and we are not used to that. The first two nights we were very aware of the trains, but the third night hardly noticed them. The upside is that it was a short walk to the station and a return train ticket into Edinburgh was only £4.30. We can highly recommend this Air BNB and certainly hope to go back ourselves.