We had a wonderful time staying in Catherine's place. It is a quiet, centrally located apartment, most importantly very close to Royal College of Surgeons which is our main destination of the Edinburgh trip. Despite the cold weather, the apartment is warm and cozy, with an extra heater that's able to move to other rooms. There's a nice cafe very close to the apartment with great food, and a short walk to all different types of restaurants. Catherine is friendly and responded to our questions very fast. Overall we had a great stay.