We loved this place. It is in a completely amazing location on the Royal Mile, with a great view of the old city Tollbooth, and of the church yard where Adam Smith (among others) is buried, and of the garden in the close. The apartment is comfortable and clean, and the rooms facing the street have double-paned glass, which makes the place quiet. The kitchen is great for cooking in and Richard was kind enough to leave us with some breakfast supplies. I will try to stay there again the next time I'm in Edinburgh and can't recommend it enough.