We have enjoyed staying in Ian's flat. We liked the cosy atmosphere in this apartment. Sitting in the big window and watching on the the street or the river was a highlight for us.
For our purpose the flat was also nicely located. One day we have discovered the old town including the castle using the Lothian family day ticket for the bus.
The other day we just having a walk through Leith with visiting the Britannia.
For a family with 5 children the apartment was spacy enough although we had to organise ourself. As mentioned in the description of the flat, it would be more comfortable to stay here with less persons.
All in we could say that this apartment was very good for our stay in Edinburgh.