We had the most amazing stay at Ray’s apartment and will definitely book when we are in Edinburgh again. The apartment was spotless ( V V clean!!!), basic utensils, oil and some spices in kitchen. The living room was very cosy, had a TV and dining table. There are 2 bedrooms with clean bedsheets.There is a co op at a 4-5 minutes walk and getting into old town is fairly easy on the tram ( haymarket station is 3 minutes walk away)! Thank you Ray