With my experience from 20+ vacation rentals on 3 continents, I can assure you that this is a perfect choice for your Edinburgh visit. The location is really central but the neighborhood itself is very nice and quiet. The apartment is stylish yet functional and, most importantly, spotlessly clean with really fresh bed linens and towels. Check-in&out were very simple and the host provided all the necessary information and details. The only downside for us, who really want to cook and eat in, was that the kitchen was rather sparsely equipped (with only 4 of each type of cutlery and plates, only small pots and one small pan and nothing resembling a salad bowl, for example). But I did not reduce the rating because of this, because it probably won’t be a deal-breaker for many and could be easily mended. So, all in all, I highly recommend this place.