We really enjoyed our stay in Edinburgh. The apartment is situated right in the centre of Old Town and it's an ideal base from which to explore the city. There are plenty of pubs, restaurants and shops around so it's very convenient. The apartment itself is charming, having wooden floors and big windows with views of the main pedestrian street out front and a nice city skyscape at the back where you can catch the sun set. We slept really well the 3 nights we were there and we didnt notice any disruptive noise from the street. It was very clean and well maintained.
Note that apartment is on the 5th floor arrived at by a curious winding stairs. If you have heavy suitcases you wouldnt enjoy lugging them up the steps.
Overall I found David to be very efficient, polite and responsive our to questions before and during our stay. Thanks a lot David!
At the same time, I found it to be one of the less personal experiences I've had with airbnb. I usually meet or speak with the host and maybe find personal local recommendations in the apartment and I missed that personal touch this time.
Overall I recommend the apartment as a comfortable, convenient and efficient experience for anyone visiting Edinburgh.