The Good. It would be difficult to beat this location! The view onto the castle is spectacular and you almost feel as if you were staying in a castle yourself. No one is joking about the climb with luggage up to the 4th floor. It helps to have able bodied teens at hand. Kitchen well appointed with dishes. VERY spacious. Easy for our family of 3 adults 4 teens to have own beds and navigate bathroom. Sitting area large and lovely for gathering.
The Bad. Furniture is very old and tired, which is partially charming - antiques! - partially not - several slats missing from daughter’s bed and mattress fell through to the floor twice, seats in dining chairs caved in, sofa cushions won’t stay in place... Internet spotty and does not reach to sitting room which is where everyone wants to hang out and search for things about Scotland. Mattresses pretty uncomfortable. Cleanliness left much to be desired - lots of dust and dirt in drawers, on shelves.
All in all - would do it again!