The Rose St Flat was perfect for the second half of my stay in Scotland. Located in New Town, this flat feels cozy and has the right about of space to relax after walking all around hilly Edinburgh. I recall mentions of a "dark and scary" stairwell but don't judge a AirBnB by the stairwell, the apartment is light and airy.
Rose Street is off a main thoroughfare and filled with pubs, shops and three city sized grocery stores close by. I stayed during the week so noise was never an issue and I couldn't bet the convenience of the location.
Rachel, the host, was out of town during my stay but was still communicative and on-top of a repair issue from a previous guest. Overall it was a great experience.