Maria communicated quickly and clearly and was gracious about our late-evening arrival. The kitchen window in the apartment does have a nice view of Arthur’s Seat over other buildings in the complex. The apartment is tastefully decorated and neat, and location is convenient to lots of shops, restaurants and sights as described. There were some listing inconsistencies: This stay offers a private bedroom only, in a rather tight, 3-bedroom, 1 bath apartment where two of the bedrooms are listed on AirBnB. I expect “private living room” (in listing) to mean a space additional to the bedroom, which we did not have. Dedicated work space- There is a small desk in the bedroom not present in the pictures, which makes the room more cramped than it appears. Garden view- I would not really say so. The 4th floor unit is within a large, multi-building complex, and though nicely landscaped, the surroundings are mostly parking lot and buildings. 1.5 baths- We did not see evidence of an extra half-bath, though perhaps that was off the tenant’s room. Two of us shared a small hall bath with another couple in the second AirBnB bedroom, and the bathroom door lock didn’t work properly making for an awkward moment or two. Lake access- having this in the listing may be a stretch; we did not see a lake close by. It was great to have access to free parking. Directions to the specific building within the complex would be helpful.