I really enjoyed our stay here! Visited Edinburgh for a few days during January. For a fair, concise review, a pros & cons list:
Pros:
1) Amazing view of the city.
2) Surprisingly quiet and cozy
3) Well-appointed bathroom. Great tub & shower, felt very luxurious and private
4) Great location - very easy to walk to restaurants and bars nearby
Cons:
1) Finding the place was a little tricky; they provided some decent instructions but their utility was contingent upon being at the right starting point. Took us maybe 20-30 minutes to find the staircase that leads up to the building. From there, finding it was easy.
2) The area around the Airbnb has a lot of foot traffic, so people are often poking their heads into the living room. A little annoying. Most people left by sundown though, so it wasn't so bad at night
3) The heater wasn't amazing. Took a good while to heat up the place
4) The bed wasn't very comfortable
All in all, loved our stay, would visit again!