Drew and Tom were a delight to stay with for our first ever AirBnB experience. The place was extremely well furnished, and our room was the same. Whisky and chocolates were left every day, which was a great added touch.
The place was well located, with local shops and cafes around the corner. A fifteen to twenty minute walk got you to the Royal Mile, a little less for Princes Street the main shopping district.
The only downside was that you could feel the springs through the padding of the bed, but it was certainly not unsleepable - my boyfriend and I both slept fine. Also, the floorboards were a little squeaky so if you intend on getting in late at night keep this in mind and advise ahead of time.
Drew and Tom were both very hospitable and open for a chat, and I highly recommend staying with them.