We mostly enjoyed our stay at Charlotte's flat in Edinburgh. Communication and response time was exceptional. Self check-in/out was a breeze with easy to understand instructions. The courtyard-facing flat allowed for a quiet stay while at the same time being on the busiest street in the city.
It is an easy walk to not only the train station but the new part of town. Restaurants and most major attractions are an easy walk from the flat.
The only two complaints I have relate to the non-smart TVs without cable service. While we weren't there to watch TV, it is nice to wind down two children after a day out and about. Having cable service or a smart TV to connect to a streaming service was standard as we traveled in the UK and Ireland.
The other item I was disappointed with was the property claiming to have a king bed. This was one of the reasons I booked the property and the bed was a queen, at best.
Know that you are staying in a historic building and be prepared for what that entails. By the last day of our visit the shower drain was nearly clogged and showers more than one minute resulted in a flood. The last night of our stay I suddenly heard water dripping in the bathroom and found water pouring from the ceiling light fixtures. The upstairs plumbing was having the same issue but on a larger scale. I don't blame the host for this but it was not ideal being unable to use the shower and clean up minor floods.