Really nice apartment in an excellent location in Edinburgh. Caroline was an excellent host, who was very responsive and helpful. We had a few minor issues. The flat could have been cleaner (e.g., lots of dust on the floor, paint cans in the wardrobe, lack of bins in the apartment). The toilet door did was broken and couldn’t be opened from the inside. We also lacked some basic amenities such as toilet roll. However, Caroline was quick to resolve this. Overall, I would recommend Caroline and her apartment. The location is excellent and the flat is very nice. However, given we paid a £40 cleaning fee, I expected the flat to be cleaned to a higher standard.