Perfectly put together place in an ideal location. This is airbnb at its best, it feels like your impossibly cool designer friend is letting you stay at their place while they're out of town. We walked in and my wife was just wandering around taking photos and talking about how we could do similar things in rooms at home. Plus there's tons of light and windows which can be much needed in Edinburgh at times.
We had stayed closer to Princes St in New Town before staying here, and it was louder there both late at night and early in the morning, and there wasnt even good coffee nearby. This location felt like more of a real neighborhood and has lots of little cafes and sandwich shops and grocery stores, but is still just as close to all the restaurants. The botanical garden is a quick walk away as well so we ended up walking through there multiple days - incredible to have that as your neighborhood park.
This site has review inflation everywhere, so almost everything ends up almost 5 stars and its hard to tell the real gems from the perfectly acceptable and fine value places. We both agreed this was the nicest place we'd stayed out of maybe 30 places total over the years.