The positives: great location, a short walk to the royal mile and many Edinburgh Fringe venues. Nice sheets and towels. View of the castle from the bedroom window
The negatives: smoke smell in bathroom. Small apartment. I didn't realize it when I booked it but the price was about 4x the usual price during the Festival. I was expecting a nicer place due to the cost. If I had paid the usual price I would have been pleased with it. The location is superb.