The flat itself is very clean and everything worked. could do with a few more glasses! check-in was straight forward, parking a 5 minute walk away which wasn't ideal but did the job.
Host was excellent, very organized and when we did have a minor issue responded in minutes, no complaints there.
mixed feelings about the location. Its a 10 min walk to the royal mile, right next to Arthur's seat which I recommend, so great for sightseeing. But! it's also part of a block of flats that I will politely describe as 'rough'. I actually felt unsafe returning at night/ sometimes in the day, it's not really the right setting for an Airbnb.
Pricing is comparable to city centre hotels and being honest if I was booking again, based purely on the neighborhood, I would book the hotel.