Maggie's place is in the greatest location possible for touring Edinburgh. It is facing a court so you're in the Old city's center (Grassmarket, 10 minutes walk from the Castle) while enjoing perfect calm & quiet when in the apartment. Maggie responds super quickly and is helpful and willing to resolve issues. There were issues in fact: the sheets and towels were smelly (I wasn't sure the sheets were actually washed), the toilet's flush was problematic and then clogged completely, the wooden floors are very old, so you can hear every step in the apartment upstairs. The apartment more generally could use a thorough renovation. Overall - if you're looking for a central place and you're not very peaky about cleanliness - the place has many advantages.