My parents had a lovely stay at Gill's place in Edinburgh. The best part was the location of the flat. It's right in the heart of Edinburgh and within walking distance of lots of restaurants, shops and bars. The flat was exactly as described, up two flights of stairs in an old historic building. There's a small bathroom and kitchen, and a separate living space. The flat was very well heated. My parents were also warmly welcomed by John at the flat after a late night flight from London. No dramas or issues at all. Great value. Would highly recommend.