We loved our stay at Katie's place. (Family of 5 with grown children). The space is cozy, sunny, roomy, full of historic character, and has a modern kitchen and bathrooms. There is plenty of hot water for morning showers. The 5th bed is a loft in the study, fun for some people (like my daughter), but not for everyone. Best for older children, and shorter adults. The charm of Katie's place won me over, It was a perfect place to relax between sightseeing adventures.
The location is ideal: It is on a very quiet side street in beautiful New Town. It's a 20 minute walk to downtown locations. The neighborhood has shops and cafes. There are good breakfast options nearby: two bakeries (Archipelago and Cuckoo), and a coffee house (Caffeine-our favorite). And if you check in really late, as we did, there's a nearby tapas bar serving until 1AM (El Paso).