We had a great visit in Edinburgh and Giovanna and her husband were very responsive when issues arose. The apartment was clean and the three bedrooms were large. Giovanna was especially nice about coming to set up an extra bed as we had our 2 year old with us (who we planned to have sleep in our bed). She was also wonderful when our daughter accidentally broke a wine glass! Very happy about the hosts.

The only drawbacks I think of the apartment are that it was up a few flights of stairs and the bedrooms face the street so can be a bit noisy. It didn't bother us at all - we'd stay here again very happily - but we had brought my 70 year old parents with us and they did struggle with the urban sounds.

Otherwise would stay again!