My husband and I stayed in Kelly's cosy little flat for 3 nights and enjoyed our stay very much. Kelly has put a lot of thought and attention to detail into the flat and provides her guests with lovely touches like fresh flowers and her own guide to the city. The flat is very clean and well stocked with any basics you might need - e.g. the kitchen had a surprising amount of cooking utensils and basic ingredients, tea, etc. - there was shampoo and body wash in the bathroom, and so on. The location is excellent - it is right in the middle of Newtown. It is only a short walk to the train station, to Old Town, to Arthur's Seat, etc. so it an ideal base from which to explore the city. Because the flat is tucked away in a side street, it is very quiet. The only thing I would note is that we visited Edinburgh in early March and the heating in the flat was, in our view, not sufficient for the temperatures. Kelly was extremely quick, friendly and helpful in responding to us whenever we contacted her, but despite several attempts to change the thermostat's programming it was not possible to get the heat in the flat up any higher than 18 degrees Celsius during the day and 15 at night, which we personally found to be too cold. I would given our stay 5 stars had it not been for this one point.