If you are looking for a comfortable apartment in Edinburgh within a half-hour walk to most of the sites, this is the place. The space is clean and well-stocked. The internet works well and the hot water and heating system are good. Although we didn’t meet our host, the communication was excellent, and the host provided extras that we appreciated including toiletries, plenty of towels and linens, and kitchen condiments, as well as maps and brochures. Check in was easy with the lock box. I cannot suggest any improvements.