The room was everything advertised, and after my 50+ AirBNB rentals Dave was one of the very best hosts I've ever had. He's a kind and delightful guy who'll do whatever it takes to make your rental experience up to snuff. I enjoyed getting to know him as much as I enjoyed the apartment itself.
The apartment has superb super-fast fiber-based wifi, which never had a hiccup during my week's stay. It's a quiet flat in a quiet neighborhood, perhaps a 20 minute walk from where all the action is on the Royal Mile, but it's only a few minutes to a superb pub (The Hoppy), a Sainsbury's supermarket, and a Costa Coffee spot that opens early. Plus you're 15 minutes from Plant Bae, a delightful veggie/vegan breakfast and lunch spot with great coffee. If I return to Edinburgh there's no question I'd rent from Dave again.