This apartment is in a great location, on a beautiful street of typical Edinburgh houses ... and it's an easy walk into the city centre and all the shops and restaurants. It's a big apartment with three big bedrooms. It's comfortable and well equipped, and Jonathan was a great host and responded to our questions quickly. However, there is clearly a damp problem, as the flat felt cold and it smelled musty, especially in the back bedroom. We put the heating on (in August) in an attempt make it feel more cosy - this helped temporarily, but soon wore off. Jonathan was honest about the TV not working, and although he's put in an aerial to try to help, you have to stand on the window ledge with your arms in the air to get it to work. Luckily we had a laptop and an HDMI cable, so we were OK. So, overall, this is a great base for a few days in Edinburgh, and I would recommend it for location, size, comfort and responsiveness.