Overall, it was a nice, modern flat, within walking distance to the Royal Mile and Calton Hill. The manager, Gill, was very helpful in answering our questions before the trip, greeting us with flowers, a pint of milk, and advice upon our arrival. She promptly dealing with the leaky shower head in one bathroom and blocked drain in the other. Lots of convenient shelving in bedroom closets and bathrooms, but more towel bars or hooks would be helpful. Mattresses on the beds were adequate, but not great. Washer/dryer unit was an asset. While first impressions are of a clean, well-taken care of place, a little more attention to details (e.g. burnt our light bulbs) is needed. Gated, off-street parking for our rental car was a plus. The car was not needed in Edinburgh itself, but allowed us to travel to the Trossachs and Lochs.