It's very hard to achieve perfection, but this came very close. The accommodation was exactly as described with Judy and Adrian as first class hosts.
We were able to enjoy the rural ambiance of the gardens while only a short bus ride into the city centre to enjoy Edinburgh at festival time.
An unexpected bonus was a guided tour of Adrian's racing cars and workshop, it was fascinating to spend time chatting to someone who's actually competed with some of the top drivers.
I would highly recommend the "Gate House" for a short break to a wonderful city.