My family and I loved staying at Scott's flat. It was perfectly situated for our forays to the Fringe, and to the local supermarket and restaurants. The flat was very well equipped and the beds were so comfortable.
We loved looking out from the kitchen sitting area and seeing golfers (we even tried a bit, courtesy of the clubs in the flat), families and playful dogs. Charlotte was wonderful and so accommodating, leaving a nice note for my daughter who arrived earlier than I did. She was also extremely helpful with local information (how much does a taxi cost from the airport? Which bus to take from Waverley station?). The check-in process was very smooth.
Our only regret is that we did not stay longer! We would love to come back again, to further explore Edinburgh.