We had a great stay in Caroline's apartment in Edinburgh . The apartment was as described , clean and tidy with plenty of character and lovely and warm. Beds were very comfortable and the rooms nicely decorated with charming personal touches . Kitchen and dining was compact but well equipped for our needs with the exception of a bottle opener , had to go down to a bar to open a bottle of wine with a cork top ! Entry instructions easy to understand and position was great for sightseeing and proximity to transport and attractions. Only minus was the noise from the restaurant above us . We were not were fortunately not going to bed really early in the evening but if we had been or if we had young children with us it would have been a problem . Fortunately they stopped clambering about after 11.30 pm . All in all a great affordable place to call home for 3 nights .