Bob's place was fantastic, his daughter Jennifer took great care of us during our stay. She met with us at check-in and gave us some great suggestions for restaurants, local markets and things to do in the area. She checked in with us via e-mail every day to ensure the apartment met our needs and to see if there was anything else we needed. The location was great, the apartment was exactly what we needed for this trip. If we ever find ourselves in Edinburgh again we will definitely be staying here.