Jonathan responded to my last minute booking very quickly and even picked me up at the train station after my last minute booking request, which was an excellent way to be greeted. The apartment was as described in the listing, and was in an excellent location. The whole experience was comfortable and easy, and I would definitely recommend it to other travels who want to experience Edinburgh. However, Jonathan doesn't live at the apartment, but another person does live there permanently, and they didn't seem very happy about the situation.