We had a wonderful time at Caledonian Quarters. The location is convenient, and pretty quiet, and the neighbors we came across were friendly. Sjoukje and her husband went out of their way to accommodate us, even when things went a bit askew on our end. They were probably the most helpful and gracious hosts we've ever had. The apartment itself is absolutely beautiful. The decor is stylish and relaxing. The bed was comfortable, as was all of the living room furniture. We would definitely stay there again if we have the opportunity for another visit to Edinburgh.