Catriona's place is so beautiful, exactly (or better) than the photographs. It had nice details all over the place, and is extremely clean.
Some of the items that were mentioned in the house manual were missing (fabric softener, coffee pods, etc) but it had just about everything you would need for a great stay.
The day of our arrival there was an issue with the cleaning person (who left the flat past 5 pm), but Catriona let us leave our bags inside the flat before the check-in time (3 pm).
I would definitely recommend Catriona's place, and I will stay there again when visiting Edinburgh.