An excellent location and a very comfortable, quiet space. The room is actually larger and nicer than it looks in the photos! John is a very friendly, helpful, and proactive host. He regularly checked in with me to make sure my stay was going well. When the central heating went out, he provided an extra portable heater. The kitchen and bathroom were both very clean. There are quite a bit of stairs to climb (no lift), which wasn't a problem for me but could be difficult for someone with mobility issues. I hope to return to Edinburgh sometime, and I will definitely consider staying with John again!