This flat is exactly as described. It was exceptionally clean and had all the amenities (except no microwave, which we really didn't need, but just an FYI). The location is perfect. It is within walking distance of all the sites in Old Town. The flat is off the main streets, so its quiet. (If you do need to get somewhere too far to walk, the taxi service in the city is wonderful.) The hosts responded quickly to all questions/requests. There were books and lists of suggested activities and restaurants. The only not perfect part of the flat was the lock box to get the keys. The hosts are aware and I'm sure they have fixed the problem. That's minor. In sum it's a perfectly located flat that is exceptionally clean with all the necessary amenities. Yes I recommend this place and would stay again if I come back to Edinburgh.