We had a wonderful, comfortable time at Tony's cozy place. The apartment is wonderfully located in a lively part of old town. It was spotlessly clean and stylishly appointed, with some nice local touches. I loved that the apartment was nestled in one of Edinburgh's famous closes, and opening the red-door in the stone wall added to the charm. For a North American family - this was a real novelty! My husband and I were traveling with our 5-year old daughter and the fold-out sofa bed in the living room was just perfect for her. I highly recommend Tony's apartment.