Six stars. That's a problem with the AirBnB rating system -- hosts are unhappy if you give them fewer than 5 starts for an adequate clean bed to sleep in, which doesn't leave room to differentiate the adequate from the exceptional. Charlotte's place is exceptional -- a beautiful and very comfortable flat in a New Town (in Edinburgh "New" is relative -- in this context means circa 1820) Georgian building in an excellent neighborhood with lots of great restaurants, cafes, pubs, and even a couple of markets if you want to cook in. The flat is well furnished throughout with thought and quality from furniture to furnishings. Easy walking distance to all the sights yet out of the noise and bustle. We had a great time visiting the city greatly enhanced by having a comfortable and homey place to rest after our adventures. Highest recommendation.