Ample room for our group of six — three adults, three kids (ages 13, 10, and 8). Clean and neat, though sometimes we could detect a sewage smell (understandable, perhaps, being in Old Town?).
Enough room to hang out together and comfy beds. Kitchen had basic utensils but would not be a place for a person wanting to cook regularly.
Located right next to sights for tourists but tucked into a corner that was quiet during the day. At night, especially since the weather required our opening windows, the bar crowds could be quite loud.
Kids had tough time sleeping because of the noise, but something about the accents made it more charming for me than annoying. If you have light sleepers, not the place for you.
It seems more a place to hang your hat whilst out doing other things in Edinburgh than a place to relax and vacation. Worked for us on our layover before week-long rural escape, but would not be a place I’d choose for an extended period.