The apartment is very conveniently located--we had a great hike up Arthur's Seat one morning. It's clean and spacious in the apartment, and we felt very welcomed by the wine and shortbread waiting for us. The housekeeper was very helpful as we were arranging details before arriving. As previous reviews have noted though, the apartment does need some TLC with several of the fixtures (doorknobs, towel racks, etc.)--we read in previous comments that these issues had been addressed so we decided to keep the booking, but were a bit disappointed to find several things still needing attention.