This was one of the best places to live in Edinburgh. It was an amazing apartment and the best location with walking distances to all the cultural attractions, places to see and dinning places, and close to public transportation (eg Wayerly train station) and only a short walk from the airport bus stop.
One thing was that when sleeping in the livingroom, there was a lot of noise from the vibrant city, however the main the livingroom is facing the courtyard, so there the noise is not that much of a problem, so if you only sleep 2 people it is great, and if you are not sensitive to noise, then no problem. And the only other thing was some problem with the toilet, we would just have wished that we knew about the problem beforehand.
But I guess it will not be a problem for the next guests, so I can just say a cozy apartment, it felt homy, and good location.
So I and all of us would highly reccomend it!