Hanne is a helpful, thoughtful host and has created a great rental here. The flat is an authentic tenement space, relatively basic, but set up in a clean, comfortable way that's ideal for a base to explore Edinburgh from. What I'd award a sixth star for is that Hanne has generously equipped the flat with all the little things you need but don't want to buy on a short trip - shower gel, olive oil, coffee, tea, etc - AND it's all nice quality stuff.
The single biggest plus about this flat is its location. It's really close to the tram for centre, airport and Waverley. In the streets around (centre and Haymarket) is every kind of takeaway and restaurant you could want, but not jammed with tourists or noisy all night.
We had a great stay and this would be our go-to Edinburgh rental for any future trip.