I stayed in Judy and Mark's fabulous apartment with 7 friends for a long weekend. The apartment is really well equipped, comfortable and warm.A great location. It was an easy walk into the city and to Arthur's seat. Buses run frequently if you don't want to walk. We shopped in the co-op,below the apartment ... fantastic croissants , fresh every morning! There are 70 steps up the apartment from the front door, great exercise and lovely views on the way. Lots of places to eat nearby. Communication was great, and instructions very clear. I would certainly recommend and hope to return one day.