We overall enjoyed staying in Gary’s apartment. He is very responsive and has an easy check in policy. We were even able to leave our bags with the housekeeper when we arrived before check in time. The apartment was very spacious and accommodated four of us easily. There is a bus stop nearby that we took to Arthur’s seat and it is an easy walk to Edinburgh castle! Two of us noticed a mildew smell throughout the apartment that we think might bother someone with allergies, but to be fair, our husbands said they did not notice anything.