Location was great, minutes walk from the city centre. Communication was clear and prompt - instructions for check-in, although a little confusing at first, were easy to follow.
Unfortunately I am a very light sleeper and on both nights of our stay, the apartment above us were walking around on incredibly squeaky floors between 1-3am. This of course is absolutely not the fault of the listing, just something to perhaps keep in mind if you struggle to get to sleep.
Only other slight downside was that milk, fruit and some other bits listed on arrival were not there - but there is a Sainsbury’s Local so close to the apartment.
Had to take the bins out on exit which was new for us with AirBnB given the cleaning fee, but it wasn’t hard to find a place to get rid of the rubbish further down the street.
Overall I would say it is a lovely place to stay in Edinburgh that was ever so slightly tainted by some things outside of the listing’s control.