My friend and I spent 9 days at Rosie's. She's the most gracious and welcoming host you can ever imagine! The room and the whole place is neat, the beds are super comfy and her breakfast is delicious (sorry about not getting up in time for it though)! Rosie made us feel at home the whole time and I couldn't imagine staying elsewhere when I return. Whisky and Poppy (two adorable Westies) are the cutest dogs I have ever met. I strongly recommend Rosie as a host if you're coming to Edinburgh.