Jennifer and Steve generously stocked the flat with more than the basic provisions. The information on local amenities was very helpful. The flat is airy, light and very clean - entirely in keeping with its description. The neighborhood is convenient - it's at the foot of Calton hill - a pleasant walk from Arthur's seat and Holyrood palace and a short bus ride from Portobello beach. It's also close to Prince's St and Waverly station. I would be happy to return.