I loved my stay in Malcolm's Grassmarket flat. It was very spacious and clean. The bed was comfortable. I felt very safe in the building and quiet--no noise at all from outside. I had a beautiful view of the castle. It really was the perfect place to stay--all the local attractions were very close by and there were several pubs nearby. Malcolm is a gracious host and very helpful with the many questions I had. I would definitely recommend this flat and Malcolm. I cannot wait to return.