Cataldo's apartment is in a great area! It's a bit outside of downtown so it's quiet and less expensive, but just a short bus ride or 15 minute walk. There are several bus stations just near the apartment for convenience. Cataldo was extremely helpful in making sure our check in was very easy, and the apartment is immaculately clean, and huge! It's way bigger than it looks in the pictures and has everything you need for a comfortable stay- Great TV, wifi, a full kitchen with coffee, oven, etc., blowdryer, iron, extra sheets, and anything else you can think of! I did not want to leave and definitely would stay again if I come back to Edinburgh.