We really enjoyed our stay in Caroline and Malcolm's apartment. It's in a lovely quiet location and is only a 10 minute (uphill) walk away from central Edinburgh and all it has to offer. There's loads to see and do, and a visit to the castle is a must. The apartment itself is clean, bright and airy, and is well equipped. If I had to make a criticism it would be about the electric shower which is a bit weak. Also, instructions on how to turn it on would've been useful as I don't have an electric shower and it took me ages to realise that you have to pull a cord by the bathroom door to get it going! Overall though, a great apartment and we would stay again.