We would definitely recommend Andrew’s apartment. The location is great for getting around Edinburgh conveniently and the apartment itself is nicely decorated and offers everything you’ll need. There were four of us sharing the apartment over New Year’s Eve (and a few days before) and we all had plenty of room.
The apartment is seconds from the Royal Mile and a ten minutes’ walk from the castle which we loved. Being so close to the action can obviously mean that the evenings are quite noisy - do yourselves a favour and take earplugs. It’s not that bad but with the earplugs the noise then didn’t bother us at all.
We would absolutely recommend this apartment and happily stay there again.