I did not meet Keith in person, but he did communicate well by email. Check-in went smoothly (lock-box available). And, there were no issues during our visit.

The neighborhood for this rental is superb. It's centrally located in New Town, so it is extremely walkable to many cafes and shops. It's also near a large park. Despite it's central location, we found the flat to be very quiet and secure.

The flat itself is very spacious. It was very comfortable for the three of us. The flat was quite clean as well. Bring your own detergent/shampoo/bath wash, etc.