If I could give half stars I would have gone with 4.5. The 1/2 star deduction is due to some early morning noise from the shared wall with The Pantry cafe. Great to have a cute breakfast cafe so close but 6am movement of tables & chairs likely to clean the floor before opening woke up both of us in the 2 bedrooms. Perhaps it's not an everyday occurrence but something to be aware of. Otherwise the place was really cute, larger than expected, on 2 floors which gives some privacy when sharing space, clean, great bathrooms / shower, and a beautiful green space in the back which we didn't use but appreciated the view. Walkable to everything, although in Edinburgh walking means hills. I would return but with a white noise machine next time!