We spent just over a week at Phil's place. Phil was a great host and very helpful with information verbally as well as written in the flat, which we always appreciate and wish more hosts would do. His recommendations were great and we enjoyed each one, especially the little Italian restaurant just down the street on Easter Road (Polentoni) - don't be put off by no wine or beer you can bring in your own, and they are incredibly gracious and by far the best meal we had in our 9 day visit! Also there are 2 really good wine shops right down the street as well. The flat was very clean, bed was quite comfortable, the shower was perfect, and the neighborhood quiet.
Although the flat isn't in the main hub of activities, between walking and the close proximity to bus stops we were able to get everywhere we wanted to go. Just a side note - if you are used to taking buses when you travel be aware that most of the buses in Edinburgh do not announce stops, and there is nothing visually to tell you what the upcoming stops are. We were only on one bus that actually had in bus signage. You just need to know when to get off. However, the bus drivers as well as locals are very helpful if you tell them where you want to go.
We very much enjoyed our stay and would recommend Phil's flat.