Carol's place is exactly as it's described/shown, both by the hostess and in the comments from other visitors. The place was clean and ready when we arrived. Carol's system for handling the access keys is very convenient and easy.
Yes, it's above a busy street, so one does here the late night crowd leaving the bars, but for us it was just a few people and only on a couple of nights.
For improvements: The lighting in the stairwell didn't work at night, but thankfully another tenant had their lights on which shown through the window above their door to light up the stairwell enough to make it up. Also there were times when the WIFI speed was just a crawl.
Yes, I would stay here again.