Everything was fine and the apartment provided all necessities for even a longer stay, especially with the fully equipped kitchen. Although, while I would still say it was a nice place, I was expecting to be a bit more 'wowed' given the AirBnB Plus status and the photos. Communication with the host was perfect via the app (fast, helpful, clear and friendly) but he must live abroad as you just collect the keys in an automated box. Very practical, true. But when we arrived the apartment was freezing cold so I can't say the welcome was great. Understandably, this is best for the environment of course but when you've been in the cold rain all day... Note as well that you are well situated for the Playhouse, Holyrood or Calton Hill. But it's quite a walk into the centre. Likely more enjoyable in the summer! Note the bathroom is TINY. Unfortunately it really wasn't comfortable (and I am a petite woman...), so something to consider as this point is what would keep us from coming back. But the open kitchen/living area is great. All in all, James did a good job with the space, but just providing my honest notes for future guests. We enjoyed the plethora of books and the comfy couch and wool throws (perfect for an afternoon nap). We found the bed and pillows comfy and slept well. The place was spotless as well. Finally, this was not a problem for us but note there is no lift/elevator if you are carrying heavy luggage.