We spent 2 nights in this lovely apartment and I highly recommend it. We’ve been traveling through the UK and have stayed in many nice Airbnbs but this was our family’s favorite. It was clean, nicely decorated, in a nice area, and had lots of space for our group of 5. The second full bathroom in particular was nice as many European places only have 1 or 1.5 even with 3 bedrooms. Having parking on site was another bonus.
The hosts were also very communicative about how to check in and were accommodating to us when we requested a change to check-in.
Another reviewer noted hostile neighbors but we didn’t encounter anyone the whole time.
Two things to note as FYIs that did not impact our enjoyment of this place. First, even with the very detailed check-in instructions, parking was a little confusing so just be prepared for that. The spot is in the back behind building 8, the only entrance to 7 is around the front. Once you find the spot though it will all make sense. The second is some reviews mentioned it being walkable to Edinburgh Castle etc. IMO it is not walkable —at least not an easy walk with kids. The hosts are accurate in the distance but I had assumed we’d be able to walk based on some reviews. We drove into town and it was quick and we had no trouble with parking. It was a walkable distance to the water (Leith I think?) though we drove there as well.