i was in john's apartment last easter sunday with my family. I must say that the house itself is wonderful and the rooms very large and comfortable. the location is perfect, quite near the edinburgh centre. But i agree with the guest with who we shared the house, Clementina. Although our beds and bathroom were clean, the kitchen and the living room were not. The lights of the hall and the stairs didn't work, so we couldn't see anything as we went upstairs when we went back to the house in the evening. However i have to say we enjoyed our stay there and i'm sure that everything goes better when John is there.