This was an amazing spot very walkable to the castle, restaurants, pubs, and walk up to Arthur’s seat. It looks just like the pictures and I loved that a Christmas tree was put up (we visited in December). Guy was very responsive and helpful.
My only call out is because it’s center of town there can be some noise of people heading home after their night out, but that will be the case with any central location & of course if you’re one of the ones out not a problem!
Long winded - I recommend! Great stay!