Stayed for a long weekend in January with my partner and my folks. The location is great, with lovely views of period buildings and the city towards the Firth of Forth. The place was very warm, despite it's size, and the seasonal chill. All amenities as described; the kitchen was particularly large and well equipped so that was really helpful. Sue and Grant's communication was very clear and helpful throughout the stay. The property does pick up on street noise on busy weekend evenings - this is not a complaint, however, more a note of caution to those sensitive or unused to the city at night. For us, the atmosphere of the old town more than made up for it. We ate at Mother India's Cafe (10-15 mins walk away), and Vittoria on the Bridge (5 mins) and would recommend both. There's a stop for city bus tours only 2 mins walk away which will take you to the Palace of Holyrood House in 20 mins. The Writer's Museum and Gladstone's Land are both lovely, and right on the doorstep.