I would recommend Catherine's flat to anyone. It's beautiful, with lot of little personal touches everywhere, as well, of course as all the necessities. It is so quiet as it's at the end of a dead-end street, with trees (& squirrels!) both front and back. We didn't meet Catherine in person, but the lock box check in worked flawlessly, and the 2 emails I sent Catherine (one to say we'd arrived, the other to tell her what time we were leaving) received instant responses. The location is great too, with lots of shops and conveniences within easy walking distance, plus we also walked easily into the city centre. Excellent bus service into town or out to the airport. All in all, it was the perfect location for our all-too-short stay in Edinburgh.