This apartment is a good size and in a great location for visiting the centre of Edinburgh and all it has to offer. It was easy to find (we found the instructions very clear, so not sure why others have had trouble, although one of the restaurants named in them has changed). It also has good amenities although a bit tired in places, and could have been cleaner, which I fed back during our stay. We needed to do a good hoover before we were happy for our toddler to play and quite a few of plates and glasses needed rewashing. To her credit, Monique acknowledged my message quickly. Bedding and bathroom very clean though.
Some other basic things like no tea towels, or instructions/facility for recycling were other mild annoyances.
We stayed over new year, and due to toughened restrictions it wasn't too noisy, but I agree with other reviews that if the pubs and clubs were busy this would be a loud place to stay.
Lastly I found all the automated emails about checking in and out, asking for when we'd be arriving/leaving quite tedious, especially after we had filled out the form and the check in/out times are very clear.
It's fine, just not our best AirBnB experience.