We had a great time in Edinburgh and enjoyed our stay in Malcolm's apartment.The location is perfect and there are nice pubs, restaurants and shops within walking distance, The flat is cosy, spacious for two people and has everything you need when staying in a self catering apartment. It was clean, but did show a few signs of wear and tear. Although we knew we had to switch the hot water on in advance to have a shower, we did have difficulties getting it hot when needed. But that might have been just us :) Malcolm was very helpful and we could even arrange an early check in and late check out. He always responded very quickly and provided us with useful information for our arrival.