Andrew is a great host and his place is so central and comfortable that you can't go wrong with this choice (and you'll be lucky to find an available booking)! He was helpful with arrival instructions, and accommodating with left luggage on the last day. The room is generous in size, the bed comfortable and everything clean and presentable. I found the shower a little lukewarm - but as he explained, it works better when the radiators are on, so if I'd showered at night when the place was toasty warm, I probably wouldn't have noticed it so much as in the wee chilly hours of the morning in mid-winter! I would definitely re-book as you can't be more in Edinburgh and part of its charm than here. :-)