I would definitely recommend Julie's place to stay. Julie is a great host, welcoming and informative. Her apartment is beautifully appointed, well equipped, clean and comfortable. It was very easy to catch the bus into central Edinburgh (c20mins). The apartment is in a quiet residential area within easy walking distance of the Botanical Gardens and the bars and restaurants of Newhaven. Public transport is within 5 minutes of the apartment which makes it easy to get to Leith or the city. It is also a short drive to Cramond, Portabello, Queensferry and the Forth Bridges. We had a very enjoyable stay and wouldn't hesitate to stay there again. Thank you Julie.