I'm surprised that this place got such rave reviews. It was adequate, but not brilliant. Very dodgy wifi - something the host was aware of before we arrived, but showed no interest in fixing beyond an 'i'll reboot the router' - there are clearly on going issues with it, and guests shouldn't rely on it.
The space wasn't filthy, but it hadn't had much effort put into the cleaning. Toothpaste on bathroom sink splash-back, mould in runners of shower door, air freshener oil leached into lace curtains, pillows not fully into the pillowcases...small things, nothing you can't live with, but not what you'd expect from the reviews. Bodge job in a cupboard for sort-of kitchen-type space. No door on the bedroom, no hand towel... Hard to define, but all a bit... 'meh.' The location is great, so if you want to stay in this area, i wouldn't say nonononono, don't do it! - unless you really need wifi - but there are many better places to stay in Edinburgh for similar price. Shop around.