Robert's place was just as described. It was extremely comfortable and his attention to detail made our stay a very enjoyable experience. The extra snacks and comforts of home were much appreciated. Robert welcomed us personally and gave us great information about the apartment and the area. The flat is in a great position with many lovely bars and restaurants nearby and an easy bus ride into the city. We had a terrific time and would love to stay at Roberts place again if we come back to Edinburgh.