Staying at Catherine's was perfect, the flat is exactly as shown in the pictures and she and her family were very friendly thorough my stay and attentive to my needs. I got to meet most of them when I fell asleep and was late for check out, sorry about that! I was their first host ever in airbnb but I'm sure they will have many more and do great with their flat over here. Excellent place and hosts, definitely recommended for a pleasant stay in Edinburgh.