I'm not sure that the star rating with pre-selected comments really does justice to this apartment. It is, as indicated, scrupulously clean, warm, tastefully furnished and handily sited for central Edinburgh. Margaret and Neil were wholly hospitable, accommodating about my check-in time, friendly, and explained how everything worked with clarity. It was the attention to detail that really impressed me however: decent croissants and orange juice available for breakfast, a quality bag of crisps too as a snack; toiletries that you might actually buy yourself; TV with radio channels (always handy if you want to chill out with BBC Radio 3). This is no place to go into Edinburgh's planning regulations and licensing intentions for Airbnb but the potential loss of family-run accommodation like this is surely a disbenefit to the city - collateral damage in an understandable effort to control the algal bloom of corporate and commercial short-term lets in Scotland's capital.