This place is way further from city centre than what we expected from the description.
The checkin is at another location (a lockbox would be preferable) and the time slot for checking in is tight!
Finlay just seems arrogant. His attitude makes you feel like he has much better things to do. He either responds slowly or not at all.
The apartment is kinda crummy in comparison to the pictures. Overall it just seems worn out. The fridge was dirty. There was a heatwave, while we were in Edinburgh, and the windows can't open more than 5-10 cm.
The neighbourhood is surprisingly noisy. People yelling loud profanities from their flats and loads of dogs barking.
It's close to good restaurants, main bus lines and Arthur's Seat, which is definitely worth a hike.
I would not recommend Finlay's apartment.