There was quite a delay before getting in due to an incorrect key safe code but once communications had been sorted (whats app seemed the best) with Joanna then everything was fine.
I found the apartment was a good price, quite spacious, clean, comfortable sofas and a good sized bed. It was noisy with the traffic, but this didn't bother us whilst sleeping and people should know what to expect if they read the reviews. There was great shower pressure and the water was always hot. We used the kitchen quite a lot and it had everything that we wanted.
There were a few things that combined together would appear niggly but nothing major. I passed these on to Joanna and hopefully these will be quick fixes and sorted out.
The location is excellent. Asda superstore 3 mins up the road. The bus stop was a 30 second walk from leaving the apartment block and we took the number 16 or 35 depending where we wanted to go in the city centre. We were advised to download the Lothian bus app by someone local which was really usefull.
Within a few hundred yards there are plenty of eating and drinking places. If you wanted beaches or harbours then these are close by, Portobello and New Haven. In the AirBnB web documentation there is a whole list of good places to go to for us tourists.
Overall I would say its a good apartment in a great location.