Overall, our stay in Edinburgh at this Airbnb was very solid. Great location, short walk to places to eat and explore - or, short uber to destinations in the city. The owners communicated well and we enjoyed our stay. Our only feedback is that it's an odd layout and I personally didn't enjoy the master bed - although by other reviews, some liked it. So, maybe that's preference. For the price and location and cleanliness - it's a win. We rate our stay a 4 as we reserve 5's for our best stays that truly meet all expectations based on the listing and what we experience. But, we can see why others would easily give it a 5.