This was our first visit to Edinburgh and we found Roberta and John's place to be a perfect home base to explore the city. Everything that we wanted to see and do was within walking distance so our car remained parked the three days we were there. The apartment is warm, clean and comfortable which is nice to come back to in the evening after the days adventures. Communication, (handled by Hayley) was perfect. We would happily book Roberta and John's apartment again for any future visits to Edinburgh.