A bit disappointing. On a positive note the location is great with easy access to public transport and within walking distance of Murrayfield. The flat is large and will easily accommodate 8-11 people. However, the condition and cleanliness of the flat was disappointing. The general cleanliness was poor e.g. coffee machine full of old coffee, fridge covered in dust, dishwasher full of dirty dishes, cups and dishes in cupboards were dirty and various objects (used earbuds, broken plastic, old clothes labels etc) found in drawers and floors. In addition one of the beds collapsed as there were missing or broken connectors for the bed slats and light fittings in one bathroom was loose and hanging by the wires. Arshad did offer to repair the bed but as we were only in the flat for one more night and repair would have required replacing the connectors we declined. In general Arshad's response to complaints was very disappointing with a complete rejection of any complaints despite having informed him of the coffee machine and bed during the trip and him personally seeing the dirty dishwasher on our arrival. His argument was that we should have informed him of every single issue at the time . Our view was that we weren't willing to get into a long discussion when we were only in Edinburgh for two nights with young children. Previous reviews have noted the cleanliness of the flat as a positive feature so hopefully this was an isolated issue and will be addressed in the future if Arshad is willing to accept the criticism.