The location is very good, and easy to get around Edinburgh. The place itself has character, and the room is stocked with an interesting selection of books. The loft is comfortable, though it is quite high. I will note that the listing indicated that there was a dryer, though that did not appear to be the case.
I was just in for a couple of nights and really only utilized the bedroom and bathroom to any extent, so I can't speak to the condition of other areas of the apartment.