Paul was a brilliant host who went out of his way to ensure a perfect stay for us. Apartment is exactly as described, with all the amenities any traveller needs, very clean & compact, with bus stops right in front for easy transportation. There is also a lovely 40-minute walk along the river into the city centre. Paul was personable and responsive to all our questions, and if we needed something, he made sure we had it. The extra touches--fridge stocked with a few basics + wine, great binder with everything we should know about the apartment and travel within Edinburgh & things to do--were wonderful. Thanks again, Paul.