Great value for the money, with all necessary amenities and a couple nice extras. Greig was a very responsive host. He addressed a couple concerns rapidly and took the time to follow-up during our stay - very professional customer service.
For our family of 5 this was a "good" stay. No complaints from the kids on the beds, but ours could've been more comfortable. Personal preference to be sure, but as a 'middle age' couple, a pillow top and high thread-count sheets are things we always hope for and rarely expect outside of a Hilton.
Some reviewers complained of noise, we live in NYC on 8th Ave., so we found the small crowd rolling out of pub at night's end to be minor -- and for summer was expecting it to be much louder.
The view from the back of Calton Hill is most definitely special, and not done justice by photography. It adds a very welcome 'destination' vibe to the living room and kitchen. We also found it to be an easy walk from/to the train station and other local attractions.