Highly recommended for a wonderful stay in Edinburgh. Joanna was a marvellous host - very welcoming, quick to respond, helpful and friendly. After hearing that we were traveling with children Joanna left several toys for the kids as well as many guides of things to see and do in Edinburgh. The apartment was in the perfect location, short walk to the castle and a stones throw from Haymarket train station, close to authentic bars and several supermarkets. The apartment was very clean and as described. Would definitely return on our next visit.