Communication with Denise was excellent. Denise was kind enough to meet us at the apartment on arrival from the airport. Denise provided us with an introduction to the apartment and details of the nearby amenities which was a great help. The apartment is first class, spotlessly clean and equipped with everything guests could possibly need. The welcome pack was greatly appreciated, as was the whisky and shortbread!!! The apartment is very secure as is the private car-park which is a real bonus, given the limited paid street parking in the area. The apartment location is fabulous (very quiet), it's in the New Town, and takes around 15-20 minutes to walk to the Castle, no tourist site/attraction is too far away to visit on foot. We only used the car for trips further afield, such as St Andrews and Scone Palace. We are planning to visit Edinburgh again and will book Denise's apartment well in advance to secure our reservation. We have no hesitation in recommending Denise's apartment to any Airbnb member visiting Edinburgh. A sincere thank you Denise for a wonderful stay. Craig and Kerry (Melbourne, Australia)