I have given a good rating based on how I anticipate the apartment will be once it is complete, but we were the first guests, and therefore had a few teething issues. We unfortunately had nowhere comfortable to sit because the bright large lounge was unfinished and off limits, and we had to eat in semi darkness next to our bed. The apartment has no mobile signal for EE or 3, which won't be a problem once the wifi has been installed.
However, the decoration of the bedroom and kitchen was good, and the bed was comfortable for sleeping, and I expect the rest of the apartment will be just as smart once completed.
The nearby restaurants were very good (especially Porto & Fi), and the number 11 bus into Edinburgh centre provides a frequent service.