Amy's flat was just perfect for our family's stay in Edinburgh - it was clean, bright, spacious, uncluttered, & as quiet as quiet could be (it was miraculously warm while we were staying & we had the windows open at night - not a peep from any neighborhood noises). It's also a few minutes walk from a handful of very nice places for dinner. The water was hot, the bed comfortable, the sofa bed perfectly adequate for our 7-year-old, and the kitchen had a lovely big table for enjoying a "kiddo is sleeping" glass of wine together in the evening. The location is about a 20+ minute walk to Waverly Station (mostly uphill, which you truly appreciate when you're on your way home DOWNhill after a long day out & about!). There seemed to be lots of buses in the neighborhood, but we had such great weather, we just walked everywhere. I wouldn't hesitate to stay at this location again!