We were a group of 7 : 4 adults and 3 children and stayed for 3 nights in Edinburgh.
We had a fantastic experience at Paul's place. The apartment is just as it appears in the photos. It is a very tastefully decorated apartment, and with a fully equipped kitchen, with even the smallest of amenities thoughtfully provided ( eg. Dishwashing material, a number of types of coffees, air freshener in the bathrooms, a bunch of DVDs - you get the drift!). The check in and check out process was super smooth and Paul dropped by once to say hello. The apartment is also excellently located-within 10 mins walk to the start of the royal mile and also within 10 mins of 24 hr open McDonald's for the nocturnally inclined!
Overall a fantastic experience and one we would highly recommend to anyone planning a stay in Edinburgh!