We were initially put off by the graffiti on the front door at street level and by the foul smells in the dark and dingy entry way. We also did not expect to have to climb three flights of stairs. (Later, when we arrived home in the evening, the lighting was not on in the entry way and stairs; fortunately, the sun sets late in Scotland in the summer.)

The flat is light and airy. We especially enjoyed the high ceilings and period details. The linens were fresh and clean. However, the beds and mattresses were of low quality.

There have been upgrades to the kitchen (which was well equipped) and bathroom (although the narrow passage past the shower was annoying).

The whole flat would greatly benefit from a deep cleaning. The refrigerator also needs defrosting.

There was no paper copy of instructions for using facilities in the flat, but Tim did e-mail them to us.

Even on the top floor, the street noise at the front of the flat is endless. The back of the flat is much quieter.

The neighbourhood is interesting with plenty of shops and restaurants. Leith is a short taxi or bus ride to the centre of Edinburgh.

Overall, the flat suited our needs quite well, but the experience of guests could be improved as suggested above.