Can't say enough good things about Jack's apartment.
1- Jack is a lovely host. Very responsive in pre-communications, personable when meeting us, and helpful in providing recommendations for dining and drinks in Edinburgh.
2- Location. This place couldn't be in a better position. Just 5 minutes walk from the train station, truly centrally located. The Royal Mile is out the backdoor, and Edinburgh Castle is a 5 minute walk away. We easily walked into the New Town to Stockbridge one evening.
3- The apartment itself has spectacular views and was a very comfortable size for the two of us. Nice touch with fresh fruit and croissants, and the kitchen is stocked with teas and coffee. The bathroom is fully modern, and despite the old charm of the building, there is a lift! The apartment may be cold upon arrival, but quickly warms up thank to a very powerful space heater. I'm particular about staying warm, and this apartment was absolutely fine in that regard.
Would happily stay here again and recommend Jack's apartment to friends.