My boyfriend and I had a wonderful stay. It was much larger than expected, very comfortable. The location and view simply can't be beat! Castle and Royal Mile are literally around the corner and it's an easy walk across the bridge to the high street, etc. We experienced delays on the travel up from London and John (caretaker) was extremely accommodating. It's an older building (most are) so there were little quirks as others have mentioned with the shower and heating, but John explained these fully and they certainly did not detract from our stay. Highly recommended for your stay in Edinburgh!