Paul was a wonderful host. He was very responsive to questions in advance of our stay. He met us at the apartment and provided some much-appreciated snacks, juice and milk. He took the time to show us around the apartment and direct us on how the heat, TV, etc. worked. He'd also left a binder of good local restaurants and activities that he briefly reviewed before leaving us. What a great resource that binder was! The apartment is lovely. Obviously renovated with alot of care and thought. The view out onto the Royal Mile absolutely cannot be beaten. And the location was so convenient to exploring the Castle, Holyrood House Palace, all of the closes on the Royal Mile....Just a great location. We had a fabulous time while in Edinburgh and that was due in no small part to our accommodations and host.