Ali's place was a phenomenal introduction to our stay in Edinburgh. It is a great location in New Town not far from all of the tourist sites. It was very spacious for two people, providing private space for each person, if that's what you are looking for. The ceilings are high, the window views are gorgeous, and the furnishings just right.
Ali is a gracious hostess. She gave us a thorough tour upon arrival and allowed us to extend our check out time.
The only thing of note for us was the temperature difference between the two bedrooms. If you prefer a cooler room, take the king bedroom.