We had a wonderful stay in Sally's apartment! We didn't get a chance to meet her because she was away on vacation, but she made our arrival very smooth by arranging for her friend Rhi to meet us and show us around the apartment. It was clean and cozy and the beds were extemely comfortable! The breakfast provided was also delicious!
It's a bit of a walk if you're coming from the train station but we were able to figure out the buses fairly easily and most of the main sites are within a 15-20 minute walk. Arthur's Seat is literally outaide the front door and the neighborhood is very tranquil, with many nice restaurants and pubs in the area. Would definitely recommend and would love to stay there again if I ever come back (hopefully when I come back) to Edinburgh!