We had a really good stay in Edinburgh. The flat is stylish and comfortable. It’s very central, close to the train station and walking everywhere is really easy. The host was very helpful and easy to communicate with. Whether the flat suits you depends on whether you like to be in the midst of everything. We enjoyed sitting on the window seats, watching the world go by and listening to buskers. The downside was at night when there were a few disturbances outside (I think mostly because Scotland had just won a rugby match.) Overall the pros outweighed the cons, though.