Catherine and Craig's apartment could not have been better in any way. It is very centrally situated in Edinburgh with easy access to Waverley railway station, the old and new towns and some of Edinburgh's best restaurants. Catherine and Craig were more than helpful, supplying us with extensive information about places to see and things to do on our four days in Edinburgh. They checked during our stay to see if there was anything we needed. The kitchen was well-stocked with the essentials, including drinks for which there was an honesty box for payment. We even had access to their beautiful private garden in the next street. In short, we cannot recommend this apartment highly enough. It exceeded all expectations and is certainly one of the two top AirBnBs we have stayed in around the world.