i don t think any place could have been better , for hospitality, comfort, cleanliness, location, and value. It was easy to walk to from the bus stop. It was super quiet and cozy with double windows on the street side and the back windows looking out over historic churchyard, beautiful garden and great view of calton hill. Richard provided milk, butter, eggs , bread, coffee and tea. And there was a vase of daffodils on the table between the tall windows , late afternoon sunlight - it was a perfect welcome to edinburgh.