Stayed at Katie's place with a few friends and it was absolutely perfect for us. The location worked out such that we were able to walk to everything we wanted to see in town, and really close to the train station, but in a quiet and beautiful neighbourhood. Beds were comfortable (everyone got a great sleep), and the kitchen and living areas were perfect for relaxing in the evening. Katie was an amazing host and was very open with communication, quick to respond, and give us very detailed directions for finding her place and for check-in. Would highly recommend, and would love to stay again if I find myself back in Edinburgh.