Duncan and Dee's apartment was simply amazing and absolutely as advertised. Clean, tidy and in an wonderful central location just off the Royal Mile. Their recommendations were top notch and we ate at a selection of them - not a one disappointed. Duncan greeted us at the flat as was incredibly helpful and attentive (even checking we were ok after our first night). As a first time Airbnb experience we can't fault the value, or treatment we received. Absolutely wonderful.