Our family-of-5 from Western Australia had a great time staying in Paul's beautiful Edinburgh apartment. The location is fantastic for all Edinburgh sightseeing and the apartment itself is huge and very tastefully decorated. Gorgeous. The beds are very comfortable and the bath & shower are the best I've experienced in any Airbnb. Fantastic! My only gripe was that we couldn't control the main heating thermostat which we did find quite frustrating at times. Though we were never cold, we would have liked to have had more control over the settings. The small laundry with great washing machine & dryer were very useful and the small electric heater was very handy for drying clothes. Being able to watch some of the Hogmanay fireworks from the front steps of the apartment was very exciting indeed! Paul's communication was also excellent. Thank you.