The place was clean and reasonably close to town and Arthur's Seat (would highly recommend hiking there early in the morning). Catherine provided us with some great breakfast food and responded to all of our messages very quickly. She was nice to work with. My only gripe with the place is that the bathroom is a "wet room," so the floor gets wet after a shower, which means wet feet if someone else needs to use the restroom. I think the shower drained a little slowly as well, and it required some effort to avoid flooding it.