We were delighted with this apartment: so close to everything, plenty of room for us, and considerately maintained. Plenty of restaurants and pubs nearby and there's a grocery store within five minutes' walk if you prefer to eat in. And though it was the middle of the Fringe festival, we had no problems with noise or traffic. We would definitely stay there again. Bonus: Eleanor (and Keith) are very lovely hosts, very patient and friendly with any questions.
Our one warning -- have directions to the apartment at your fingertips when you arrive at the airport. Our cab driver (she may have been a bit distracted) seemed to take an extraordinarily long time to find the place. It's not that hard to find at all, but she said, by way of apology for the long, long ride, that she didn't know that the street (Lady Wynd) existed.