Pros: it’s right in the heart of tourism Edinburgh, food and shopping. Cons: flat is very small, 4th floor w/o elevator, bathroom smells musty and cost is a bit high. We stayed in another flat on Airbnb in the same part of Edinburgh 2 weeks earlier that was bigger, cleaner and offered free early bag drop off for less $. These features make a big difference to travelers and are not offered (w/o a fee) on this one. But in the end, it was just a place to crash at the end of the day so 4.5 stars.