The apartment is very nice and comfortable. There were a few nice extra homely touches, such as board games which we very much enjoyed playing. The living room was slightly smaller than we expected from the pictures but very comfortable and had been tastefully decorated for Christmas. Check-in felt rather late at 3pm but went very smoothly. We didn't meet Dave, the host in person but he was very good at communication in the run-up to the stay and we met the lovely cleaner to let us in. The location is very convenient for central Edinburgh. There is only parking space for one car so our second car had to be parked in a nearby car park but that was fine and reasonably priced at £18/day.