This was our first Airbnb stay , and it was a pleasant one. I brought my wife and 2 boys (ages 6 and 4) here and we stayed for 4 nights. The flat was spotless, and was in an excellent location and was walking distance from the main attractions. It also had parking which was a big bonus for us and it added to the convenience.
The only negative was that one of the heavy wardrobe doors was not fixed properly on its hinges. We weren't made aware of this and when my excited children entered the flat, it almost fell on them. Luckily my wife stopped it. This should've been mentioned to us prior to us arriving as it was a hazard.
Overall, I would recommend this stay to family and friends and if I was to return to Edinburgh, I would book this apartment again. This apartment felt like our home for the duration of the stay.