We had a very nice time in this lovely apartment during the Fringe festival. You can walk to the New town but we mostly took taxi's as my mom was with us. The neighborhood is historic, quiet and beautiful. There are some nice restaurants nearby and a very beautiful river walk. There is a very nice back garden but the great rainy and cold weather in Edinburgh didnt give us too many chances to enjoy it. The apartment is very tastefully decorated and comfortable. If you are into having long baths in a tub - this will be the best tub you ever see. You don't meet John but the check-in/check-out process is very easy due to the drop box up front. I definitely recommend this place if you are visiting Edinburgh.