John's place is wonderful. Spacious, well-equipped, and with a lovely garden. (Knowing that it was advertised as "cozy," I thought it might be cramped. Not at all--all the rooms are good sized and comfortable for 3 people. We found the location great for walking to different parts of Edinburgh, from Old Town to the Leith Walkway, Dean Village,and the Royal Botanic Gardens. We would stay there again in a heartbeat!