Nice smart well furnished and imaculately clean apartment in a great Location no more than 15 minutes walk to Grassmarket , The Royal mile and Edinburgh Castle. Although we didn’t meet Paul during our stay he stayed in contact and left very clear communication about checking in etc and was always on hand if we needed anything, however I have to say you probably won’t need to as everything we needed was though fully left for us. Tea and Fresh coffee and all your essentials are generously provided. Having free private Parking available was also a bonus especially so close to City centre. Really chilled out , me and my wife would definitely return and would highly Recommend a stay at Pauls place.