This place is amazing. I've been living en Edinburgh for a year and this was the first time I was coming back to the city. As you could expect, I was worried that I would feel weird being back in the city but in a different place than mine. However, Finlay's apartment is amazing and I felt at home since the first moment.
The ubication is unbeatable, right next to the Arthur's Seat, 10 minutes walk from different supermarkets (Lidl, Sainsbury's, TESCO...) and near to the city center.
The place was really really clean (I was surprised, since it's relatively common to have spiders in the UK houses, but in this case there were none of them) and the kitchen is full-equiped (it even has an oven).
Finlay was a great guy who helped us a lot. It was easy to communicate with him and he was very kind and helpful. We were going to Edinburgh with our own car and he made all the arrangements in order to let us park right in front of the apartment.
In conclusion: This place is the real deal.