The apartment was perfectly located for exploring Edinburgh and we thoroughly enjoyed our stay. it was very close to transportation, restaurants, shops, etc. John was very responsive and communicative and everything went smoothly. The beds were comfortable and the apartment well equipped. With six of us (my husband, me and 4 adult kids), having 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms was perfect! A few very minor things to note: it is on the second floor with no elevator. Not a problem for us (we needed the extra exercise after eating well ), but if you have physical limitations, something to take into account. Also the only coffee maker was a small french press. Would have loved a larger coffee pot. That was a minor inconvenience and didn't detract from our overall appreciation of the apartment!