This was frustratingly close to being a great, great Airbnb. It's a bright and spacious home with a well equipped kitchen. The layout is super useful and the extra bed in the living room was apparently quite comfortable. The location is awesome. It's a quiet block and everything is walkable. Bars, restaurants, festival things, the old town ... All super easy to get to.
A few hassles held it back for us; the biggest problem we had was that the shutters in the bedroom are missing a panel so you can't have full privacy or keep the morning light out. We woke up to the sun which would be fine if sunrise in Edinburgh wasn't at 6am.
We found the Internet to be almost completely unusable for the duration of our visit. We were able to connect to the network, but speeds made basics like Google Maps inaccessible. We let Pam know, but never heard anything back about its status.
The handle to turn the shower on and off was also difficult to operate. My wife couldn't turn it at all and I could only do it with a towel. I was actually afraid the water would get stuck in the "on" position.
All in all, not the end of the world, but it made our stay less comfortable than it could have been. It was a shame to walk away from such a nice place with less than happy thoughts about it.