Keith was an excellent and very responsive host. We really like him and felt he was very focused on our comfort. He answered emails promptly and came over to the apartment quickly on the one occasion required - even though it was Xmas Eve! The apartment is very well located just off the Royal Mile. You can walk up to the castle or down to the palace in 5-10 minutes. The access through Old Tolbooth Wynd is convenient and historic/funky. The apartment is accurately described with everything you need in a kitchen or bathroom. It is warm in winter. It is relatively quiet although the ceilings and walls are a bit thin. The only minor issue is access to a supermarket on foot. There is a decent Sainsbury's over the rail line on St Andrews Square approximately 10 minutes walk. We were able to do all our xmas lunch shopping there. Overall, we Highly recommend Keith's apartment.