I had a short stay here, and I had a great experience. This was my first time using AirBnB and I am not disappointed at all. Kathy's room was in the basement, so there was privacy, and it was very cosy and clean as well; the bed was very comfortable - alas, I could not take it with me! -, and Kathy is an amazing host, and I recommend her as a host and the room for its comforts. If I am ever in Edinburgh again, I would not hesitate to stay here!