Alan is an incredible human, and his love, curiosity, and interest in travelers is clearly evident from the moment he shakes your hand in the train station -- yes, Alan picked my boyfriend and I up from said station when we arrived, and even drove us around the city and then to our rental car spot the next day -- his friendliness and generosity knows no bounds! His apartment is in a fantastic location just minutes from central Edinburgh by bus or foot, with tons of excellent eateries and shops just around the corner (which he can advise you on), and is clean, comfortable, and professional feeling (hotel-sized shampoo and conditioners await you in your private bathroom, etc) without ever feeling stuffy. The location really was ideal for me -- out of one window you have a fabulous view of Edinburgh castle from the balcony, and from the other side of the apartment you look out onto an idyllic and quiet riverside and park (with occasional heron and otter spotting!). I would definitely stay in this location again, and highly recommend it!