We had a wonderful time in Edinburgh at Paul's apartment. It was spacious, wonderfully equipped, and the location is perfect for visiting Edinburgh by foot. He was there to let us in, and explained everything about the flat, as well as good places for food and drink in the local area. Only slight recommendation to anyone using it would be to put smaller people on the sofa bed if there are four of you! We would definitely come back to the same place if we came again. Thanks Paul!