Great place. We were expecting something cozy like in most cities, especially when the place is right in Grassmarket. We were very surprised that the apartment was so big. We had plenty of room to walk in the bedroom and the living room was almost as big as our previous hotel room. All amenities were as described, we had a great time. Good communication from host, we had no problem finding her place. The only thing to keep in mind is that the apartment is about 15 min from the train station with some hills but I had no problem with my large suitcase.