Emma's place was very quirky and artistic. The apartment was also super quiet and the internet was fast! The space is more than big enough for at least two couples, three if you don't mind sharing a bedroom. The apartment was the top floor so it might not be suitable for people with limited mobility (this wasn't an issue for us).
Unfortunately there were a couple of things that didn't quite meet my expectations. The apartment was lovely and tidy, however, it wasn't super clean. Hopefully this would be improved for future bookings. Also, I was shocked to find that the apartment is a 30 minute walk to Princes Street and a 40 minute walk to the castle. However, on the listing it says it is a 10 minute walk. Because of this, we drove into the city centre every day which made finding a parking space upon our return more difficult (but at least we had a car so we had the option to drive). Also, I was looking forward to a cup of coffee after a long car journey but there wasn't any milk, which was disappointing.
With a few tweaks, this could be a lovely place to stay.