I stayed here for 2 months and it was great. The location was perfect for me, university, train station and city centre was all on walking distance. The view towards Arthur's seat is really nice and I often went for an evening walk. The flat itself is clean and has everything you need, including a nice big living room to rest/watch TV etc. or to do your work from home. Jonathan is a very friendly host, open for any question or suggestion that you have. Noise does pass easily through the building, and it is important to keep this in mind, especially since there is a long-term flatmate living.