We had a nice stay at Bobby's flat, but there were a few details that could have been better ironed out. Check-in went very well, and Bobby was kind enough to let us check in a few hours early. The flat itself was comfortable, though a bit dated and sparsely decorated. There were a few items for breakfast already provided, but even though there was bread there was no jam or butter to go with it. Otherwise there was milk, coffee, tea, sugar, and instant porridge which was very much appreciated. There was no hand soap in the bathroom, and the expel air didn't work. Finally, the Co2 detectors didn't seem to work, as there was no light on them, which could be a major concern if something did go wrong! In a longer term property let, this would not pass regulations.
Aside from these things, we really enjoyed the location. There are some beautiful walks along the Water of Leith and many great restaurants and pubs near by. It's also not hard to get to many of the tourist attractions by bus or walking.