We booked the apartment for four nights for the famous Hogmanay celebrations - it was our first time in Edinburgh. Before and during our stay the communication with the host was perfect, they were available at all times and responded quickly. We also enjoyed the location of the apartment and explored the city on foot. The check-in was as easy as can be. However, we believe the apartment was too expensive for what we got: spiderwebs in every room (when paying a high cleaning fee I expect there to be zero), the heating in the bedroom didn‘t work as supposed, there was no place to leave our clothes as the piece of furniture in the bedroom was filled with extra blankets and towels for a potential third guest, the mirror in the bathroom was above the toilet(?) and the mattress was very worn out. All in all, great location, great host, but a few changes would have to be made to make it the perfect apartment to stay in:)