Paul met us at the apartment and welcomed us. In fact, he was in regular contact leading up to our arrival, so that he could be present. He patiently and graciously answered our questions and wished us the best. He was available by phone, email and text throughout our stay. The apartment is absolutely lovely and updated. The two bedrooms feel quite private because they are not next to each other and one has its own bathroom. The apartment basically splits in two, essentially turning the second bedroom and second bath into its own suite as well. The apartment is a couple blocks from Edinburgh castle, and right off the Royal Mile, outside some very cute stores. It was the perfect location for Hogmanay events - convenient to everything. The spiral stone staircase leading up to the first floor apartment is classic. The internet worked well, as did the TV and the appliances. The view from the big windows out onto the Royal Mile can entertain for hours. We just loved sitting on the couch in the living room, absorbing the history and energy. Despite being on the Royal Mile, there was no street noise in the bedrooms. There are multiple small grocery stores within walking distance (we like to dine in for breakfast).