I stayed here for 4 days in October. The apartment is as described. The location is perfect, in Grassmarket and just a few minutes from Victoria Street and from Edinburgh Castle (2 min if one takes the outside stairs!). It is spacious, comfortable and well furnished. The bedroom is on Grassmarket, but there are double windows, so there was no noise pollution (and I stayed a saturday night). The view from the kitchen gives to the castle, it's really lovely. Very good communication with Malcolm, who was quick to answer any questions I had before my arrival.