Davids apartment was perfect! It was in a great location just off the Grassmarket which was perfect for us, close to pubs and great restaurants. The view of the castle was a real treat! The apartment itself was clean and comfortable, very warm, the bed was lovely and the extra bits left for us by David (coffee / biscuits etc) were very much appreciated and a great touch. The guidebooks were brilliant and so helpful. The check in instructions sent by David were excellent and made arriving so easy, also he helped us with recommending where to park our car - which without him would have been challenging! I would highly recommend this as a place to stay and hope to visit again one day!