Gillian is a very good host, the appartment is very clean, all you need is present and the description and photo's are correct. The communication went very easily. The apt is only a 30 minutes walk from the center. We enjoyed our stay in Edinburgh very much. Beautiful were the walks up to Arthur's seat, the river Leith walk, the Botanical gardens and the Dean gardens. One remark has to be made for which only the architect was responsible : for the contstruction very light materials were used, with the consequence that you can hear the upper neighbours. But during the night is was very quiet.