I gave some specific feedback about cleanliness concerns on the internal survey that was emailed to me at check in.
Those things aside, I loved this place! It was cute and nicely decorated. It had every amenity that I needed for my stay, and a great location. I especially appreciated the assortment of outlet convertors after realizing that I did not bring the right kind with me. I don't think I've ever had a more responsive Airbnb host. I would happily book this place again if/when I return to Edinburgh.