If I could give it a 5 plus, I would. Rosie was so hospitable really and the flat had just about everything we could ever need to have a comfortable stay. Kitchen utensils, bathroom supplies and crockery were of great quality. She left beverages, oil, cereal, milk and even welcome cookies for us! The beds and pillows were super comfy too. Another plus point is that it was convenient, near to the town centre and within quick walking distance to amenities like tesco. It was on the first floor too so it was easy access for our creaky knees! I would love to stay there again. Thank you Rosie! You made our stay in Edinburgh that much more memorable.