John is a great host! He thougt about everything even about stuff we didn't. The check in was very nice and without any problems. For example could we park our car in front of his flat. He couldn't be there all the time. So he prepared little paper messages for us which were really helpful. The breakfast was good and the view at the park with Athur's Seat from the breakfast table was wonderful. The room and his home are very cosy. We had a wonderful time in Edinburgh! Thanks a lot, John!