We spent one week at Stuart's place and we had such a wonderful time! The apartment is clean, cozy and has everything you need, including a nice tv with Netflix and BBC iPlayer.
The bed is really comfortable and nights were quiet. We were there during winter months, so we don't know if it gets noisy in the summer. It is located a few steps from the Royal Mile, close to the Airlink 100 bus stop and New Town. You can walk everywhere from there and feel like local.
Stuart is an incredible host. He helped us with our luggage up to the fourth floor and checked in on us a few time to make sure we were doing fine. He sent us a welcome package with lots of useful info on the apartment and Edinburgh. Both check in and check out were easy and smooth.
It was our first time using Airbnb and travelling with our 9 month old baby and we only have good memories from this trip.
We highly recommend this apartment and hope to go back one day.