We had an excellent stay at Marie's place for our two nights in Edinburgh. The apartment was clean, stylish and functional. We liked the small garden and appreciated the Netflix connection. Overall it was as advertised and then some, and reasonably-priced. Also, getting to and from the train to the airport was very straightforward from the apartment.
Our only hiccup was in finding late night attractions near the apartment. Our flight arrived late and by the time we were in the apartment the only open businesses were one bar, (very close and looked like a good spot), and a convenience store. We couldn't help but think if we were on the Royal Mile we would have had more options, but in the end we got a pizza from the store and used Marie's Netfilx connection to watch a movie and still had a good night in, and our other night there we made plans in other parts of town, (including a "Underground Vaults Walking Tour with Whisky").
We would stay in the apartment again, and would recommend it to family, friends and other Airbnb'ers. Thanks Marie!