This property is absolutely beautiful, what a gem! We booked rather late in the day so didn't have high expectations, but instantly we could tell the apartment was so well-appointed and well-cared for. Carly has clearly thought out every detail to ensure a maximised guest experience. We were so appreciative of the little items (including beer and Tunnock Teacakes!) that had been left for us to enjoy. The amenities of the apartment are absolutely five star. The location couldn't be more perfect (5-10 minute walk to the Castle!) The value for money left me genuinely thrilled. The only issue is that the apartment is so cozy you just want to hang out there instead of going out into the city! On the second night of our stay one of the neighbours did hold a small party, but when we went out at midnight they explained that it was their birthday (understandable!) and immediately quietened down, and the whole thing had wound down by half twelve, so we didn't even consider this a blip. We will definitely be returning every time we stay in Edinburgh, and have also clued in our friends and family too. What a find!