We were a little bit put off by the entry when we arrived, it’s was very dirty and dark and the stairs are a bit dangerous however once you arrive in the apartment it is clean, bright, and pleasant. We enjoyed our stay. The beds were a bit hard, but we managed. It was central to Haymarket train station making our arrival easy, we used Uber to make our way to most sites and it was no more than £10 each ride. The restaurant below was great for a last minute dinner without heading into the city. Overall I would return and recommend Joanna’s apartment to others visiting Edinburgh.