Can't emphasize enough what a great location Paul's apartment is. Literally in the oldest section of Edinburgh. Within easy walking distance of all the great historical landmarks. Plus a short walk to New Town and the train station ( which was helpful for our day trip to the Open Championship in St. Andrews). He provided great suggestions for dinners, etc. as well as for a local "talking" pub, i.e. no music. The snacks as well as the juice and milk were greatly appreciated upon arrival.