This apartment was absolutely perfect for us! It is very clean and very comfortable, and Ellie and Scott have thought of everything, including leaving us a nice Toblerone bar (which we scarfed down happily), nice products in the bathroom, little lavender sachets, excellent cereals for breakfast, etc. They have a sense of style in everything they do, and we kept exclaiming that we would happily just move into that apartment and live there. The beds and linens are very comfortable, and the apartment is dead quiet (looking out on a pretty garden). We also felt we lucked out totally on the location. I didn't have time to do a lot of research for this last-minute impulsive trip, and I picked their place pretty much on a whim. The location couldn't be better, in a lively, pretty neighborhood that is very typical of Edinburgh's new town. It is just a few minutes' walk to the main tourist sites, but feels really like you are living the way the citizens of Edinburgh live, far from the madding and maddening tourist crowd on the royal mile. It is just a few steps away too from a nice walk along the waters of Leith. We followed Ellie and Scott's suggestions for places to eat and drink and never went wrong. If you want to try some scotch, do not miss the bar they recommend: Kay's. It's unimaginably cozy and lined with many varieties scotch, with good bartenders that will help you find your way through the thicket of choosing one to your liking. Ellie and Scott are particularly good about communicating and get back instantly with responses to any question. Check in is as easy as can be, with the key in a lock box. A really winning airbnb experience--go, you will love it.