We had an excellent stay at this apartment.
First the localization: it is our third visit to Edinburgh. We had previously stayed in the Old Town. But this place is just perfect. Near everything: shops, nice restaurants, pubs. Lovely walks nearby.
Second the apartment itself; we were three couples, with our son and daughter and their partners and we had three very comfortable rooms. Also, the living room and kitchen are very nice and spacious. The apartment is very well equipped and nicely decorated.
Rob was very kind, we did not meet him, but he gave us all the assistance that we needed and he promptly responded all our questions.
In conclusion, this is an excellent choice for anybody who is looking for a charming stay at Edinburgh.