We had an amazing stay at Lisa/Sophia's-- I could not stop saying that I'd be happy to live in their apartment forever and it was certainly one of my favorite airbnb experiences. Sophia was very welcoming and helpful as a host. The place was beautiful, spotlessly clean, and very spacious. The bed is comfortable. There are 1.5 bathrooms shared between us and the other guest room.
I also really appreciated the small things that made our stay more comfortable, such as a large stock of toiletries and access to kitchen necessities.
The location is great, just a few minutes walk from Waverly, as long as you don't mind walking up a hill and a flight of stairs to get there. The location is also convenient to the old town, new town, and Calton Hill.