A beautiful location, great walks from the doorway as well as easily accessible to central Edinburgh by bus. John provided a lovely welcome pack including tea,coffee,milk, orange juice and biscuits. The apartment looked as it did in the listing and was clean and warm with adequate facilities for both cooking and relaxing. John responded quickly and efficiently when we had a problem with the key breaking in the lock. There was a little noise of footsteps from the apartment above but they didn't cause us any problems. Overall we had a lovely relaxing 3 night break.