Location cannot be beat, you really feel like you are in the historic centre of Edinburgh. The apartment was quite old and I do think a little bit more of a spruce up of the furniture and curtains would be excellent as it feels like the bare minimum has been done to the apartment in order to rent it out. Doors all had broken knobs and holes in them so there is really no privacy whatsoever. But the kitchen and the bathrooms have been redone and were in great condition. Plenty of hot water and the heating for the apartment was great given it's winter. Kelly was really fantastic in terms of responding in a timely manner. It's my first time using Airbnb and in general it was a good experience.