Paul was a fantastic host! The flat was just as described, comfortable and clean as well as decorated for Christmas which gave our holiday stay great atmosphere. He met us on arrival and gave us the tour including offering to drive us to a grocery store if need be though there is also plenty of markets within walking distance. It was an easy 20 mins walk to the city center and castle but tram and bus transportation is also very close. Paul provided us with milk, bread, butter, mince pies and a bottle of wine as well as the traditional shortbread and dram of whiskey as we were celebrating New Years! We would absolutely stay here again and would definitely recommend this flat to anyone looking to spend a few days in Edinburgh.