We had a good holiday staying in Greg's apartment. The location was excellent, right in the middle of the town. Easy walking to the Castle, Royal Mile, the river and loads other attractions. The apartment was warm and cozy, had all the essentials for a comfortable stay. The beds were very comfy. Though it was surrounded by several pubs, it's surprisingly quiet at night. Very convenient for public transport. The only drawback we had was the noise from the flat above. For two days, we could hear thumping footsteps, moving of chairs and people talking. Luckily it was very quiet during Christmas holidays. On the whole, it was a very good, comfortable flat for a short holiday in this beautiful city.