If you're going to Edinburgh with a group then this is the place for you. I spent a week here with family members at the start of 2020 and found it a large comfortable space with great views of the city. Public transport is at the end of the street and Haymarket station is a short walk away which we used while my car was parked at the premises with the supplied permit. The host was available whenever needed but not intrusive at all, definitely a 5 star.