We were delighted with the superb apartment, perfect and warm. It is wonderfully located to visit the entire city by foot, it's great, especially when you are there for only 3 days! The Scots are friendly and very smiling. Caroline was adorable, always listening to help us. Edinburgh will remain unforgettable in our heart for all this as well. When we return, we will resume the same apartment, for sure, thank you Caroline and Merry Christmas !