This can only get 5 stars from me. Stayed with my 14y.o daughter for 4 nights. The flat is sparkling clean, exactly as shown. A big room with queen bed and a private bathroom with toilet and bathtub just next to it, strictly for the guests use. Comfortable bed and enough pillows. Location is also a 5 star. I didn't want to stay in Edinburgh center. I am very ok with taking the bus and the busstop was just in front of this apartment with several bus choices and coming frequently too. A 20min bus ride to Princes Street and another bus about 35mins to The Museum area. It was too convenient as per location. Finally Josh made us very comfortable, he lives in the flat but you rarely see him. We were able to use the fridge and microwave and eat breakfast and even brought out the iron for me when I asked to use one. He took his time to tell me about the bus we needed to take. It was extremely great value for money and would definitely be returning to stay if we visit Edinburgh again.