We chose Stuarts place because of the great location, right in the heart of the Old Town. It is easy to get to there from the Waverley train station and the Airport bus.
Stuart has been really helpful with directions to his place, the check-in and with place recommendations. The place is clean and has everything you need for a few days (hair dryer, washing machine...).
We would definitely stay it Stuart's place again, if we have a chance to visit Edinburgh a second time.