I loved my stay at Carmen's place (very well managed by Dan!). It's a warm, comfortable and well-equipped home, and the views out to the Forth are just incredible no matter the weather. Although on the edge of the city it's well served by the local buses (which can take you to two different large supermarkets in less than 10 minutes if you need supplies), and I really think that the location and high standard of the apartment more than make up for not being closer to the city centre. Very highly recommended!!