David's apartment was even better than expected-- a very ideal location to see and do everything, enjoy fabulous meals, and still feel safe and private. As a host, Dave truly goes above and beyond. There were snacks and drinks waiting for us, breakfast provisions, toiletries, and a delightful goody bag of activities and treats for my 3 y/o- she was thrilled by this sweet gesture, as were we. The apartment was spotless, and had an assortment of luxuries that I would not have expected, such as games to play, books to peruse, scotch to sip, and access to the SONOS which my husband enjoyed a great deal. It was truly a great retreat away from home, and a most comfortable resting place when we were done with all our adventuring for the day. I cannot say enough good about the wonderful job Dave has done hosting his apt on Airbnb. The welcome packet is super useful, and something I wish all hosts provided. We took Dave up on some of his restaurant recommendations and were not disappointed in the least. He is wonderfully understanding, accommodating and easy to contact for questions. I recommend his apartment in Edinburgh a 1000 times over- whether traveling as a small family (as we were), or small group of friends. He truly helped us have a really great holiday in Edinburgh.