Fabulous from start to finish! Amazing location, walkable to all that Edinburgh has to offer, clean, warm and comfy and what a view of the castle! Communication with James was excellent, he was very accommodating and quick to respond, and all instructions were really clear. We were sad to leave and this would definitely be our first choice place to stay when we return to Edinburgh (hopefully in summer when we can enjoy the balcony with its astonishing view of the castle). Thank you James!