My family and I had a terrific stay at Philippa's place. The location can't be beat for exploring Edinburgh, and it's super clean and well-appointed. We would definitely stay here on our next trip to Scotland. If you're traveling with kids or senior citizens, it might be important to know that you have to walk up three flights of stairs to the apartment, and it can be pretty noisy at night, since a number of pubs and cafes line the street directly below. However, that's the price you pay for being in such a fantastic location in the heart of the new town. Highly recommended!