Doreen’s place was great! It was a little off the beaten path, and my husband and I prefer to walk, so it took us about 30 minutes to walk to the city centre every day, but the view on the walk was gorgeous! The flat was very clean! a perfect place for us to come home and relax a bit before bed, but not very big if you plan on spending a lot of time inside. She was very quick with responses and very helpful. We recommend this place to those looking to spend most of their time in Edinburgh exploring!