Its a gem in Edinburgh. Don't think twice, just book! Takes about 20 minutes to walk to the City centre/Edinburgh Waverley train station. The view of Arthur's seat from the living room during breakfast is amazing. And if you prefer to catch a bus to the city, the stops are just a stone's throw away fro David's place. Whole range of breakfast item on the table, coffee/tea, fruits etc. Superfast wifi. The bed,pillows - brilliant, get ready to have a good night sleep. The neighbourhood is quite but restaurants and convenient stores are within few minutes walking distance.
I could go on and on and being a veteran airbnb user since 2012, i would say, hands down, this has been one of my best stay so far. If i ever go back to Edinburgh, its where id love to stay again, and if David would be kind enough to host me for the second time!