This apartment is exactly as described and so lovely. Before arriving, Duncan gave us a giant list of places to go and restaurant recommendations which was very helpful and the ones we tried were great! Duncan met us at the apartment on our arrival and showed us everything we might need to know, and Daniella had left home made shortbreads - which didn't last very long - but all added to the sense of welcome we felt staying here. The apartment was really central and easy to find for two first time visitors to Edinburgh, and was cosy and quiet in the evenings. This was my best air bnb experience so far - thank you for having us!