We stayed here for a weekend and really enjoyed it. When we had issues with the heating, Rob replied really quickly and fixed it for us. We especially loved the area, there are a lot of cute cafes really close by and you can reach pretty much everything in Edinburgh on foot. We only found the front door a bit hard to open, as there's 2 keys and its not so intuitive, but we managed. And the bathroom smelled a bit musty from the drains I think, as they do in many airbnbs, but thankfully wasn't so noticeable most of the time. We'd come back :)