We had a great time at this apartment. It was very clean and had a good set of basic cooking supplies. It was nicely located a short walk away from one of the Hop On-Hop Off tour bus stops, and a short uphill climb to Edinburgh Castle and High Street. We were able to house one child on the living room sofa and the other in the bedroom, which made for a more comfortable trip for the two of them. The only negative was needing to hike up the stairs at the end of a long day of sightseeing. (It's on the top floor and three flights up, so not suitable for someone who may have difficulty with stairs.)
Jeffrey was very communicative and the apartment was ready when we arrived so we could go straight out for sightseeing. (He was able to have it cleaned a little earlier so we could check in right after our flight arrived. Not necessary but very accommodating.) I couldn't have asked for a better host for our first Airbnb rental.