Our stay in Tom's place was truly amazing. We weren't able to meet Tom personally but he was always reachable whenever we needed to ask some questions. Some things that we appreciated and remembered from our stay were:
Before Check In: We were already provided detailed instructions on how to get to the place and how to check in. It was very convenient.
Place: Very stylish and homey. Everything was provided (including the bottle opener). Bathroom was large and clean. Bed was super comfortable. There's even a radio and TV.
Location: A bit far from city center as it's located in a residential area. This was great because you get to feel like you're a local in Edinburgh. If you like walking, then there's no problem. Personally, we just Uber our way around as it's cheap and convenient for us.