This was an adequate apartment for our two day stay in Edinburgh, with some minor quibbles. It is well-located in the Haymarket neighborhood with great bars and restaurants nearby and a short walk to Old and New Town. Fiona and her team were responsive and helpful including helping with parking - normally we would never have a car in downtown Edinburgh but had to on this trip as we were making many side trips. (The JustPark app is great for this and we found parking either a 30 second or 5 minute walk from the apartment). Amenities were provided and while we didn't use the kitchen it seemed well-equipped. It is on a quiet street but close to everything.
As has become common with airbnbs these days, these are actually two buildings with multiple apartments all owned by one company. Upon check-in you are "assigned" an apartment in one of the two buildings. Ours looked like the listing so I suspect they are all similar. We asked, but never received, wifi information as it was "after hours" (weekend) and it was not posted anywhere in the apartment. There were some small inaccuracies in the listing - for example the apartment was up a flight of stairs, with additional internal stairs to the bedroom (fine for us but worth noting for guests with big bags or mobility issues). There is also a washing machine although the listing said there was not one. The apartment is definitely dated and showing signs of wear and tear (the bathroom door regularly came off the track/wouldn't close, chipped paint, cracking shelves etc) but it was a fine stay for what we needed. I can't find any faults, but do think there are nicer places available for what we paid - unfortunately we visited between the Open and Fringe festival so availability was limited.