Lovely flat. James was really helpful and easy to contact and provided all the information we needed. The wine and shortbread was a nice touch. The flat was very clean, comfortable and spacious with comfortable beds. We walked to the Botanic Gardens and found various cafes within 5 minutes (Blue Bear Cafe makes a great breakfast) Buses into Edinburgh ((10 mins) were frequent and cost us £8.50 for a family of 5 for the day. Views of Carlton Hill amazing.