My parents and I really enjoyed their stay at Jamie's (it was also my parents' first Airbnb experience!). Jamie's superb, he met us at the apartment after our constant communication ahead of the check-in and ensured that we were settled in proper. He provided us with tips and one thing that stands out would be the extremely detailed attention towards the necessary information we required which were nicely printed and left on the table. In addition to this, there were plenty of current brochures and listing for food, culture, etc for anyone to easily peruse.
The location is perfect for getting anywhere and it's extremely close to food, groceries and public transport. The apartment is extremely clean and perfect for the 3 of us. Having been in Edinburgh before, I would put Jamie's apartment at the top of a must-stay list.