Paul is a very sweet and supportive host - giving extra towels, helping out even when he wasn't there and providing useful advice for going around Edinburgh. The bedroom is very comfortable and the apartment is nicely located only 15 minutes by bus (4.5 £ for a day ticket/1.8 £ for a single journey) or a 20 minute walk (if you follow Paul's description instead of the maps!). We could also use the kitchen which was very helpful. It's got a great value for money and we would come back! :)