Good points: the location is perfect. Beds are comfortable. Very spacious and luminous. Also the attention of John.
Bad points: the stairs are extremely dirty and smelly (weed). Also the apartment wasn't better. We found a big spider in the bath, the oven was terrible and the kitchen in general wasn't very clean.
The apartment in general needs painting and remodeling.
We understand it's fringe so we say thanks to find a place in Edinburgh, and we didn't expect a beautiful apartment, seeing the pictures, but at least, a clean and nice place.