Definitely would stay here again. Place was clean and very walkable going up north to Leith, all the way down to the National Museum past the Royal mile, and even to the Royal Botanic Garden. Rental car not needed. Tons of space for the 4 of us. Heater with Nest thermostat kept everything comfortable even though it was very cold and windy outside! Loved how there are a few markets within a 5 minute walk so you don't always have to eat out. Had an issue with the smoke alarm but that wasn't anyone's fault and it was addressed as quickly as it could have been(although we lost sleep over it). Internet speed was fast enough to stream on our devices. Note there is no TV(not a bad thing if you are vacation!). Also rooms had no locks, but not needed for us. Joe was very friendly and quick to reply to questions! Note stairs up to flat are steep if you have leg issues, heavy luggage, or vertigo. Would definitely recommend!