We had a great stay at James's place. It was perfect for four of us and an easy 15 minute walk to the center of town. The keys are in a lockbox which was very convenient. The flat was clean, comfortable, and as described. The neighborhood was quaint and quiet. I was dumb and locked the door from the inside before leaving (don't do that!) and locked us out. James was responsive when I texted him. The best solution ended up being coming in through the back door. His next door neighbor let us through to the back. She was so friendly. We'd stay here again on our next trip to Edinburgh.