My partner and I had a lovely stay here, in this enormous very central flat. The current photos don't do it justice, it's a very spacious flat. Enormous bedroom and living room. The kitchen has all amenities needed, and there is a corner shop about 30 seconds away.
The host David had some excellent local tips, even though we have been to Edinburgh many times, we discovered some real gems in the town with his advice. He was excellent at replying to messages.
Really the location is everything. It is about half way down the Royal Mile. I have never stayed so central to the city.