It's a very good place in a very good location. It's clean, and breakfast is offered, which is definitely a huge plus. The shower is great and Julian is a very attentive host. The only thing to consider is that the room is facing a street with traffic, so, if you're sensitive to noise, you may like to use earplugs to sleep (I did and it worked just fine). Other than that, I totally recommend renting this room if you're coming to Edinburgh.