This place was AMAZING! The location was great. It was quite and residential but only about a 5-8 min walk to resturants and shops. As I am now in a AirBnb that is right in the middle of shops, I can tell you it's loud. I miss his apt already. Also the internet works wonderfully! I had to use it for work and it did better then most hotel wifi signels. The past reviewer must not have been able to see the prominant sign attacted to the table with the router. (It's pretty hard to miss) Also yes there are hills at this apartment; however I'm here to tell you all of Edinburgh has hills. It's an old city. They didn't grade it all to the same level like NYC; hence the charm this city still has. I highly recommend his apartment. It's warm, cozy, quiet, and has the perfect Scottish feel to it.