We had a great stay at Jordan's flat in Edinburgh. The reviews and the description are accurate.
Location is very central, close to great restaurants and pubs and nightlife. Also very close to events associated with the Fringe festival.
For some, it could be too close to the action, as we heard revelers in the streets until the wee hours. We closed our windows and used ear plugs to get a good night's sleep. Beds were comfortable and flat was very clean.
I feel bad for the reviewer who had to lug three large suitcases up those stairs and had two small children with her. That would be difficult. On the other hand, we are a couple in our 60s, in good health but by no means really fit, and we were fine with the challenge. Our kids who were traveling with us are both in their early 20s and had no complaints about the stairs.