We stayed two weeks here while visiting family.
Pros: two large bedrooms with comfy beds, third pull out bed in living room, on major bus line to Portobello or downtown area/Waverly station/castles, two blocks to supermarket, quiet building, we felt safe.
Cons: Indian cuisine restaurant below flat permeates flat with strong smells of curry/cooking oils/cooking meat odors in PM (poor ventilation in restaurant), to reach this first floor flat (not on ground floor) climb 25 stairs on narrow, winding staircase but well lighted, heating system on timer and cannot be changed, no contact person in Edinburgh if problems arise like heating regulation and CO monitor goes off, host sends utube video or doesn’t respond for a few days with difficult questions, otherwise is very quick to respond.