Pros and cons
Pros;
good location, centrally located in Edinburgh. Can walk to shops, restaurants, theatre. There is a steep hill to climb but quiet and a nice space. Has a whirlpool bathtub.
Cons;
Mostly related to service issues. Host did not send check-in details prior to arrival. We called the host on arriving to Edinburgh. They could not find the reservation, they were not responsive to our needs, no sense of urgency to help. Had us thinking that we had arrived in Edinburgh with no place to stay. They eventually emailed check in instructions. The flat itself is cute and could have been much nicer if it was better cared for. There were 2 out of 3 lights out in the kitchen and one of 4 out in the bedroom. They did replace one light but not all.
The fold out bed was filthy and unusable. There were no linens for it. The bedroom closet was dirty, full of items and hard to fit any hanging clothes. There were enough toiletries for 1 shower. We were two people staying for 3 nights. there were no batteries in the remote.
This could be a nice place if the owners paid better attention to detail and took an interest in the guests staying there. Unfortunately, this was not our experience.