Booking:
Martin was very responsive and answered all of my questions in a prompt fashion. He was very accommodating and he let us drop our bags off at the apartment before our check-in time.

Location:
The apartment is in a perfect location, right off the Royal Mile, a five minute walk to the train station and just across the bridge from the new city. It's right in the middle of everything.

Bathroom:
Clean. The shower is a little weird because the shower curtain doesn't wrap around the entire tub. It's not a huge deal because you can just face a certain way to keep the water from splashing out onto the bathroom floor. Still, it was inconvenient.

Living room:
Decent size with plenty of natural sunlight. The TV is tiny, but we didn't go to Edinburgh to sit inside and watch TV!

Sofa Bed:
The sofa bed was subpar, I could definitely feel the frame through the mattress. WIth that being said, it's rare to find any decent sofa bed and I slept just fine, so maybe it's not that big of an issue.

Bed:
My parents said the bed was OK. They said the mattress wasn't very thick but they both slept fine, so maybe it didn't really bother them.

Conclusion:
The apartment is a great value and I would highly recommend it to anyone else. Our family of 2 adults and 2 grown children fit comfortably and did not feel too cramped. If you don't really mind mediocre beds/sofa beds, I wouldn't hesitate to book with Martin.