Lovely spacious bright apartment with far-reaching views. The open-plan area is a good size and pleasant to spend time in. Two good size bedrooms. It's very quiet, hardly any noise from neighbours (although if you switch off TV/music you can hear a couple of fans in kitchen/bathroom that seem to run 24 hours). Throughout everything is well-equipped with what you need. The kitchen is well-suited to home-cooking - the only limitation that the hob is very slow.
Great location for us: very quiet area, nice walks nearby but still easy to get to Leith and City Centre. The private parking is handy but beware if you aren't a confident driver as the entry is tight.
It would definitely be 5 stars except for a backlog of maintenance work that needs doing, so various little things didn't work properly. Emma said that nobody else had reported them so hopefully now she knows these will get fixed and future guests can fully enjoy this lovely place.