This has definitely been one of my most positive experiences on Airbnb. Katherine is one of the best hosts you are likely to come across and both Katherine and her husband Andy were absolutely fabulous. It is a very charming house, immaculately maintained, and is an absolutely charming place to stay in. Everything was exactly as described. The only tiny tiny problem, especially if, like me, you are visiting Edinburgh for the Fringe Festival is that it is slightly away from the centre, which actually only becomes a bit of a problem when you have a late night out, as there are no convenient night buses to this neighbourhood.