Absolutely fabulous! I spent 2 nights at John and Vicky's apartment with three friends - we were over in Edinburgh to go climbing in Ratho. From the outset the Gumleys were very accommodating - setting up the sleeping arrangements to suit the group. This standard continued throughout our stay - the apartment is beautiful with all the amenities you require (and more) and is surrounded by rolling countryside. John provided all the ingredients for lovely breakfasts which were well received! The highest praise I can give is that we will definitely return - assuming we will be welcomed back!