Sarah's dovecot is the most unique property I have ever had the pleasure of staying at. It is well-located just south of Bruntsfield where excellent shopping and restaurants abound, and is just a short bus ride from the city center. The property itself is incredibly unique and well appointed - Sarah's renovation of the 15th century dovecot was so tastefully done and so beautiful that we just wanted to stay forever. Sarah was also an absolute delight, from her introduction to walking us around her garden and making herself available, and even coming by to say goodbye; I have never had a greater host.
Only word of advice - stay longer than you initially planned for.