The apartment was lovely and clean and the instructions on how to get in easy and clear.Didn't see Caroline but with everything so well laid out that was fine.The apartment is brilliantly located,near to the Royal Mile and the train station.It is also close to some bars and clubs and unfortunately this meant that it got quite noisy at kicking out time.We were there Tuesday to Friday so not the weekend but we were disturbed every night at least once between 1 and 3 am. It wasn't for long but if, like us you were in Edinburgh to sightsee and walk it was a bit of a pain.Completely not Carolines fault but something to note. Another niggle was the fan in the downstairs bathroom,if you are disturbed during the night and get up to use the toilet don't switch on the light as the fan goes on for about 30 minutes,absolutely necessary but somewhat annoying. Despite this we had a great stay and loved using the flat as our base.