The place is clean and well-kept. Everything works in the flat. The neighborhood is quiet and safe. Arnold is great at communicating with me the entire time. If there is one major consideration I'd take into account if I'm booking his place again, it's the distance from the city center. It takes over 30 minutes to reach Edinburgh proper by bus, and about 45 minutes on to an hour on foot. If you have a car, it'll be perfect. Otherwise, be prepared to commute. This is my only quibble with the place.