Good Points - lovely Victorian house, spacious rooms, use of large, well-equipped kitchen, beautiful main bathrooms, secure private parking, very quiet location, convenient for buses into central Edinburgh
Less Good Points - shared bathroom (though some rooms have an en-suite shower)
Problems we encountered - we were asked to change rooms at short notice, which was extremely inconvenient as I was away overnight visiting our daughter, and my husband was involved in all-day meetings. When we returned to the new room at 10:30pm, our belongings has been transferred, but there were no towels, and we were unable to contact the host by phone, text, or email. This was not acceptable.