Location, location, location. For the money this place is amazing. Now it's not luxury but it is its warm, comfortable and clean. What more do you want?
Positives:
Great kitchenette
Amazing location
Attentive host
Free Parking
Lashings of hot water and heating
Superb individual shops, restaurants and cafes on doorstep
'Boris' bikes for hire just down road
Easy walk into all Edinburgh has to offer
Rooms far bigger than shown on advert
Negatives:
It's not luxury, but functional and fun. Don't expect Egyptian thread count or Molton brown!
Bed settee in lounge is not comfy as a sofa (but this is the city - get out and explore and take a seat in bars and restaurants)
It's a soft mattress on bed (I'm used to a firm and so this is a personal negative)
WouId I return? - YES of course. The positives are huge compared to a few negative niggles of mine