I stayed here for three nights with two of my friends and we found the apartment to be the perfect home base for our weekend in Edinburgh. Above all else the place is huge, incredibly spacious and comfortable, and impeccably clean. The location is great - it's in New Town which has some of the better and more affordable restaurants and bars, but was a short walk to Old Town, so we had the best of both worlds. The host was also super helpful in providing tons of recommendations. The only con would be that it's on the third floor with no elevator (beware if you have heavy suitcases)!