Caroline's flat was absolutely amazing. It was spacious, tidy, and so clean that it looked nearly brand new. Both bedrooms had a ton of space and comfy beds, and Caroline even left us some bottled water and Scottish shortbread in the rooms. The shower is quite a tight fit, so beware of that, but that's literally the only issue we had. Definitely not worthy of fewer than five stars! We had a wonderful time in Edinburgh and Caroline's cute & centrally located flat made it all the better.