I have to give our stay at Luca's place 3 stars out of 5.
First, the positive things.
The apartment is large and matches the pictures from the listing. The kitchen is large and it has everything that may be needed. There is no microwave so we were using the oven to heat our food.
It was easy for us to get to all the major tourist attractions by bus which we preferred because we could see around while getting there. Bus stops are a short walk away from the apartment.
Now, the negative part. Several things were out of order and the host did not want to fix them.
We were initially met by Luca's neighbour Pepe who let us in and showed us inside the place. We immediately noticed that it was very hot in the living room. This was because the main radiator valve was stuck at its highest setting (fully open) and would not shut off. Pepe told to just open a balcony door to cool it down inside if we felt like it. I later contacted our host Luca via Airbnb chat and his reply was "Hope it's not too warm for you and if you open a window should balance out". There was never an offer to fix the problem.
Another thing we noticed right away was that the shower holder was broken. Luca's response was also pretty quick - "The shower hose still works freehand and or the bath". Again, there was no intent to fix it.
A sink in the bathroom was draining very slowly. Our host responded via chat - "The water still drains it just takes a bit longer. Apologies for any inconvenience caused". Nope, not fixing it.
It all got really annoying. I suppose, I was not prepared for this kind of attitude of any Airbnb host. I was able to find a plunger in one of the closets and fixed the drain for now. Then I was able to turn the radiator valve off after turning its knob forth and back multiple times. Unfortunately, that did not last and the next morning it was back to its wide open position and it was hot in the living room.
Several light switches are broken and I also let Luca know about it. Got no response.
I also learned that the host in his review of me wrote that I "was also very handy in the apartment". Would you expect a hotel or a B&B guest to be "handy" too?
I chose to stay at Luca's place based on its 5 star rating from the previous guests. One of them wrote that some small problems had been taken care of by the host. This is the opposite of what I experienced.