I would give this a 4.5 stars, but airbnb only allows full-star increments. Ian is a great host - helpful, communicative and the kindest I have ever met.
The house looks exactly as in the pictures and one can tell a great deal of care has been put into decorating it and everything was clean when we arrived. The kitchen appeared to be fully stocked in terms of utensils and whatever else you might need, but since we only stayed for a week, we didn't make full use of it, so I cannot comment much on that. The only minus I would note here is that we couldn't use the electric kettle, due to heavy scaling, which would have required multiple descaling procedures.
Regarding the bathroom, it could use a refurbishment, as the fittings are quite old, hence the implied drawbacks. Being a house, it can get a bit chilly in the colder months, especially not being lived in. The Nest system is set on 20 degrees for mornings and evenings, but once the heating stops at around 11pm, the temperature can become uncomfortable. Luckily, there is an automated electric blanket set under the bedsheets for the cold nights, but it is still unpleasant to wake up in a cold house. However, if you are used to colder climates, this might not be a problem for you.
The neighbourhood is very beautiful and well-connected to the city centre via the National Railway system and the buses. Note though that the trains run approximately every 30 minutes during the weekend, so it can take you a while to reach the centre. However, this wasn't really a drawback for us, since the quiet and picturesque nature of the negihbourhood offered a great respite from the busy centre.
Aside from the slight minuses that I mentioned, we had a great stay and I don't think anyone would regret booking this, all things considered.