Overall, as a family of five adults, we had a great experience.

The Pros:
Mehmet was very helpful and personable host.
The space was clean, breezy and filled with natural light.
Walking distance to great fun places with just the right mix of local and tourist atmospheres.
Reasonably priced for the number of beds and bedrooms it offered.

The Cons:
No air conditioning in the heat of summer. (There was an honest miscommunication from the host in that regard).
Four sets of stairs to climb without an elevator (for some of us with bad knees).
Two of the bedrooms overlooking the street were a bit noisy from the traffic below.