The room itself was perfectly fine, even though the bathroom was a bit smaller then I anticipated from the photos.
Also, we were unsure if the towels Fatih left were clean or not. They had some small stains on them were hanging over the bathroom door, not folded like in the photos.

Now about Fatih: He was ok with giving us directions and advice for our travel- however I must share a story from when we first arrived. We were exhausted from our trip, and took the wrong Ferry from Kadikoy to Karakoy. This Ferry dropped us of on the other side of the bridge, or about a 5 minute walk. When we got of the ferry were calling and texting Fatih, trying to find him. He did not pick up his phone at all and only answered 1 or 2 of the many texts. This is not a good feeling when you have no idea where you are with many bags. When he finally did arrive, instead of apologizing for the confusion (it was our mistake, but still- that happens) He raised his voice and showed lots of frustration and anger that we didnt follow his exact directions! I was shocked!
After that, everything went smoothly, though Fatih was never as friendly or welcoming as I hoped, or the other reviews suggested.