We did a lot of research to try and find the perfect place to stay in Ciutadella, and in terms of value for money vs what you get, nowhere else we found came close to Teofilo and Silvia's place. We were really blown away- and were extremely pleased to find that the place looked exactly like it does in the pictures. The decor inside is really beautiful- modern but homey- and the whole place feels really bright and spacious. The patio was also a really beautiful space to chill out in the evening warmth. We weren't sure what the pool was going to be like- and though it certainly is not big enough to really swim in, it was certainly clean and pleasant to be in- and it is near to other parts of the patio so you can talk to others who are not in the pool. The place was really quiet (friends of ours said their place was quite noisy) and there were some useful supermarkets nearby.
On top of all that, the extra touches were something we were not expecting- we were welcomed with a bottle of wine and found many useful things in the house- international adaptors, shower gel, snorkels etc. I found the entrance a little hard to find- so do ask the hosts if you are also having trouble, Silvia was very quick to reply to messages. Also note that you need to get taxis/bus/car into the centre (walking would take a bit too long for most people).