We are a family of 5 and we had an amazing stay at Oscar's villa. The villa is beautiful, spacious and homely with everything we needed. We spent most of our time in the beautiful garden by the pool. The pictures don't do it justice.
Oscar's father was there for check in and helped us figure out how to use the coffee machine but otherwise there is complete privacy.
The location is really good. A few minutes walk to a lovely cove with beach and trees for the shade and another cove where you can jump from high rocks in turquoise ocean. Also a short drive to Ciutadella (a nicer town than Mahon in my humble opinion) and many beaches within in 30 min drive. I would definitely return to Menorca and Oscar's villa.