We loved our stay at BiniNina. The house is very pleasant, with full privacy (many houses nearby have their swimming pools in plain sight; whereas this house's pool is hidden by trees). It is ideally located steps away from the water, and from cafes and restaurants. The host was gracious and very responsive.
The sand beaches are quite crowded at this time of year - we went to the beach either early in the morning or very late in the day. There are fewer people who swim in the rocky areas of the island - the creeks are beautiful to swim in, and we never felt crowded in the water.
We will definitely be back!