We had a really nice stay here and it’s a great apartment in an excellent part of town. Esther was very responsive and helpful- there was a bit of miscommunication, including a cleaning person coming in without warning. Giving 4 stars because it’s the first time in 30+ Airbnb stays that there was no soap, no paper towels, no salt and pepper - no anything. Just a couple rolls of toilet paper and that was it. Companies that run Airbnb homes should provide the minimum to at least feign that the accommodation is in use and not just a for-profit venture.