We had a great experience in the apartment and with the owner. There are some structural inconveniences, third floor up a narrow stairwell (about 60 steps) with no elevator, keys require some jiggling, and some sporadic excessive noise from neighbors and the street below. The apartment may not be appropriate for the frail or finicky, but for the adventurous it boasts an incredible location in the heart of old Girona with a breathtaking view. The apartment is well maintained, clean, orderly and tastefully furnished, appropriate for a long stay. The owner, David, is friendly, knowledgeable, responsive, and generous with his time and energy. This is a great value compared to other rentals we have seen and we would eagerly return for another visit.