Our stay at Melissa's was very much 5*. The apartment is very modern and exceptionally clean with sparkling glasses and crisp sheets on one of the most comfortable beds I've ever slept on.
The location is suburban and feels very safe and secure and it's easy to reach town and the rest of the Cape by car.
The hosts treated us like friends from the start with great tips on things to do and see. They even went as far as to take us on a full day tour of the Stellenbosch wine region in what turned out to be an exceptional day, culminating in a Braai (BBQ) at the their house.
I have stayed at many top hotels and Air BnBs and can truly rate this as one of the best. Thoroughly recommended!