Had a great stay, was perfect as a base of operations - basically to get to the tour of Hobbiton.
No previous experience with AirBNB so impossible to compare, all I can offer is don't expect high end Hotel amenities but with benefit of being much quieter, this stay was all we needed & a little more.
Gayleen was very friendly & helpful - had located & put into a parcel items I had left in one of the bedside table draws for shipping to our next location (got there before we did!!).
Magee the Springer was an added bonus to the stay, particularly if you don't mind throwing a ball for her for as long as it takes.....
More than happy to recommend this stay.