We stayed at The Rest in Hahei just for one night. It was a perfect location for our itinerary - walking distance to the Cathedral Cove hike (which was amazing!) and Hahei Beach for a relaxing afternoon.
The house itself has a ton of character - really cool photography and artwork hung up in the house. One thing to note is that most of the bedrooms require walking up stairs to reach - which was fine for our group but just keep in mind may be difficult if any group members have trouble with that.
We also ate pizza and drank beers at The Pour House which was recommended by Duncan and a two minute walk from the house. The food and drinks there were great, and the ambiance was very chill and relaxing! We had a lot of fun here.
Thank you Duncan and Ann for being responsive to our inquiries as well.