Andy's house was wonderful- full of history and character. Location is ideal as it's central to everything. However, just to note if you have heavy luggage and you're taking an intercity bus to Dunedin, it will be better to take a taxi from the bus stop to Andy's place.
Beds were decent, it gets cold at night and there wasn't heating in the room so we requested for extra blankets.
Overall, his place is a good value for money.