3.5 stars. The good: Plenty of space, good location with restaurants and Bay within walking distance (the Irish pub was our favorite), beds were comfortable enough and linens were nice and clean. Showers had extremely strong pressure which could be good or bad, depending on preference, not adjustable though.
The not so good: WiFi was strong when it worked but I often had to reboot the modem/router to get it working again. Furniture and floors and counters were scuffed and tired but serviceable.
Usually this doesn't bother me, but the water tasted gross so we bought bottled water. When I complained, I was told it was because the city water has chlorine. It wasn't that. The tap water in all the restaurants in town tasted fine.
It was unseasonably hot while we were there. There were no fans and very poor airflow in the house so we were very hot and there were tons of flies. there are space heaters in every room, so I suppose it would be fine in cold weather.
Good value, just don't expect it to be quite as nice as it looks in the photos.