We really enjoyed our stay. Arguably the best location on Waiheke, right on the beach. Private, great facilities (bbq, hot tub)
Areas for improvement:
1) Cleanliness. The place needs a deep clean. Appliances were dirty and random objects + a lot of dust found.
2) kitchen appliances + furniture is old, dirty and not in line with the price paid.
overall we enjoyed the stay and would consider going back if the price was more reasonable (~$650pn would be fair) and a thorough clean was done beforehand.