(pretend this review is 2.5 stars) I think we were the first people to stay at these cottages. That being said, I don't think anyone had checked on the cottages before we stayed there and nobody had been there in months. This feels like a classic case of "I have something to rent so I'm going to list it without doing any work". These cottages COULD be amazing, they just need some love and updating.
Pros: Walkable to a gorgeous beach, good location for a getaway but close enough to Wellsford and other things you might need, affordable, dreamy.
Cons: Needs updated. There's a great ocean breeze but no screens in the windows so you can't leave a window open or the place fills with bugs. The drive in wasn't cleared, the area around the cottages was mowed but the road in had 2 foot high shrubs growing in it. The locks are 50 year old, take skeleton keys and stick. The hand drawn map left for us was confusing. The place was very dirty when we arrived. Should include linens.