My family and I had a wonderful three nights at Rebecca's "crib". The house is beautiful and equipped with everything you need for a great stay, including a fire for the colder mornings and super comfortable beds. The kitchen has everything you need to cook meals at home - necessary as the only restaurant was fully booked the whole time we were there.
The location is great for taking off on exploratory walks around the island, as you can drop down to either side of the island from its position on the hill. Yes it's a bit of a hike up the road, but the local taxi service is fantastic for getting your luggage up to the house and it's totally worth it for the amazing views from the top.
I can't recommend Peterson's Hill Crib enough - it will be our go-to accommodation for future visits.