We stayed at Al and Cindy's place for 3 nights and we absolutely loved it. The property is located in an amazingly peaceful and quiet beachside area, just outside the town, it comes with a fantastic view of the bay. The room itself is spacious, clean and well equipped. Al and Cindy were great hosts, super friendly and had some great advice on stuff to do locally. Best of all though is the fact that you can borrow their Stand up Paddleboards and canoe, it's such a great way to explore the bay and made our stay that extra bit awesome. If you're going to the Bay of Islands we definitely recommend you stay here!