I echo what everyone else has said about staying with Craig. This is a very personal experience, quite different from the places that offer self check in and you never see the host. You can have all the privacy you like, but if you want to engage with Craig and get to know him and the community, it makes the experience all the better. Craig knows a ton about the island and is a great resource for where to eat and things to do. He is often around to help if you need anything.
We loved the gorgeous view and sleeping to the sound of the waves. His homemade yogurt, fruit, and muesli made the perfect healthy breakfast, and it was lovely that the fruit cake from the trees around the house. The cabin is tiny but has all you need. If you are squeamish about bugs this probably isn’t the place for you, but they are harmless and the mosquito net will keep you from getting eaten alive while you sleep. He also provides bug repellent if you need.
Location was excellent and so many lovely wineries and restaurants to walk to. 372 and Charlie’s nearby were very tasty and convenient. We loved breakfast at Charlie’s and lunch/dinner at 372.
We did make use of the ocean kayak one morning, which was fantastic (though it is very heavy!).
If all this sounds good to you, you will love staying with Craig!