The good: airbnb was clean, had parking, good view from the balcony, had all necessary amenities (stove, fridge, laundry), was walkable to downtown although a bit far (15 minutes, steep hill on the way back).
But: it was really worn, there were gouges in the floor and wear on the surfaces from previous travelers. The kitchen layout was fairly awkward, making it hard to find dishes. The nice balcony is over the central road in and out of Queenstown. There bedroom is open to the living room so you can see outside, but even when I closed the wooden shutters there was a crack sending very bright light into my eyes while sleeping. The parking was great for the Toyota Aqua I rented, but a bigger car would have been tricky to maneuver in the very small garage.
Overall it was fine, but I was a little disappointed the whole time, especially given that I opted for a more expensive airbnb thinking it would feel luxurious.