We had a wonderful time at Randall and Amanda's place! As many of the other reviewers mentioned, we loved the freshly baked bread and eggs in the morning. It was amazing. I was a bit concerned about sharing a bathroom but honestly we didn't see the other couple at all.
Just one thing to note - this is well described above but I will reiterate that this is quite in the countryside. It's about 1 hour and 20 minutes away from Queenstown. We really liked being in the countryside though!! Very relaxing.