We loved staying at Natalie's and wished we had planned more days there. The location is great to get to the lake and various trail heads.
As for amenities, the kitchen had everything we needed to cook our meals.
While some of the furniture may look a little dated, I can safely say the couches and beds were very comfortable. The view of the stars through the skylights at night were an added treat. The one thing to note is that because there are no curtains/blinds for the skylights, the upstairs rooms can get quite hot during the day when the sun is shining. We did not mind as it cooled down enough by bed time and we spent the daytime outside and downstairs. I would definitely recommend staying here.