Though only for one night, we very much enjoyed our stay at Phil's. It was impeccably clean, had anything we could have needed, and had sweeping views of the lake and surrounding hills and valleys.
Phil is an A+ host and made the entire process seem effortless. He's very knowledgeable about the area and had no shortage of ideas, information, and activity brochures for any itinerary. We wished we would have had more time to explore!
The only thing I would note for others is to make sure your car is in decent shape (and by this I just mean not falling apart), as the driveway is a bit rocky in parts and is somewhat windy and on a downhill (which means it's then uphill as you leave). I only mention this because we had the unfortunate situation of driving in with a small rental car that had a flat tire earlier in the day so when we arrived with a "donut" on our car, we were having to be extra cautious driving in/out. Not a big deal at all but just in case anyone might have a less reliable car on their hands (though I'm sure Phil even has automotive contacts that he could recommend - he really does have all the information you'd need! :)
Otherwise, this is a total no-brainer and I'd recommend this place to anyone visiting the area.
Thanks for everything, Phil!