Jenna's place was exactly as advertised and more. We loved all the small touches that made the place feel more comfortable including tons of natural light, bikes (with helmets) that were ready to ride, and killer views of the mountains just outside our window. On two separate occasions we were able to take the bikes for a ride on the Queenstown bike trail into and out of town, which sat just outside of our doorstep. Their home is also nicely situated in a secluded part of the neighborhood so traffic and noise is minimal.
Jenna was also very responsive to all of our questions, offered tons of suggestions on places to see and eat, and provided everything we could have wanted in terms of personal space and quiet relaxation. We would definitely love to stay here again if we can ever make it back to New Zealand.
The only very minor thing I would advise others of is that the spiral staircase to the second floor is a bit narrow if taking luggage upstairs with you. It's by no means a big problem, but can be a bit tricky if you have a larger suitcase that you don't want to bring downstairs. Outside of that small detail, we can't recommend the place enough.
As a quick fun side note, we wandered out to the bike trail at night and happened to stumble upon a wild hedgehog. Completely unrelated to their rental, but it made the experience that much cooler to be so close to NZ wildlife.