We very much enjoyed our stay in Carol's Cabin. Carol was a great host and made sure we had everything we needed including lovely breakfast supplies. The cabin itself is clean and comfortable with a nice space outside for sitting out. The only slight downside was lack of a kitchen sink. A positive plus was being visited on the verandah by Ginny the lovely dog and the occasional hen.
Papatowai is a hidden gem and well deserving of a stay of at least a few days - the two long beaches on either side of the town are world class (the sea lions must think so too) and the Lost Gypsy curio van is similarly splendid (but difficult to describe).
Recommended.