I stayed one night at Shirley and Noels place. They were caring and put in effort to make your stay as comfortable as possible. The house is shared between Shirley, Noel and other guests. A separate bathroom (including shower) is shared between all guests. The place itself is in a convinced spot if you arrive/depart via Queenstown airport. The place is very clean and in a quiet location. Restaurants or supermarkets are in walking distance (20 min walk).
I would definitely stay there again.