We have had 3 experiences now with airbnb and all have been remarkably good: 1) great hosts who communicate quickly and effectively 2) great hosts that ease your transition into a new city, complete with their favorite restaurants recs conveniently located nearby (We loved Hosteria and Prego, Emma!) 3) a convenient location that didn't feel touristy yet was near the tourist spots we wanted to visit (4 blocks from the Anne Frank house).
Thanks for everything, Emma!