Pros: location - walking distance to most everything we wanted to do. Communication! Kate was very quick to reply, even when I sent a question late in the evening during our stay. The space has some charm, including a piano, and lots of light.
Cons: no hand soap (which seems like a very low bar). There WAS shampoo, but no conditioner, no body wash, no bar soap nor hand soap. Check in process involved going to another location a ~12 minute walk from the airbnb to get the keys, which was ok, but i could see it being a little hassle if you're coming from airport with luggage. Last thing I'll mention - this is up 4 flights of narrow windy stairs. Take that in mind, especially if you pack heavy.