Pros: location, cleanliness (although cleanliness does not make up for maintenance), comfortable beds (although one of the six beds made noise every time you move).
Cons: noise (comes with location), from previous reviews I knew that the apartment condition was not the best, but it was worst than expected, part of the the ceiling in the dinning area came off due to water damage from the apartment above, the cleaning person explained that it had just happened and asked if we wanted to stay and that a discount will be provided due to the issue. We accepted to stay because we didn't want to deal with finding new accommodation during Mexico's city busiest time (dia de los muertos) and with an 86 yrs old in our group. The toilet got clogged during our stay. The host was very responsive until I asked about the reimbursement that was offered due to the condition of the apartment (it does really need maintenance). There is a hole on the floor that is covered by the carpet, and that could cause a dangerous fall.
We rented Apartment 1 and 2. The above applies for apartment 1. The only issue about apartment 2 was mosquito bites, since one of the bedrooms window is rusted and cannot be closed. With all the above said Apartment 1 has the potential to be a pleasant stay mainly for its location and proximity to public transportation and maybe perfect if you stay only 1 o 2 nights. We stayed for six nights and it was too much you start feeling frustrated for what is supposed to be your enjoyable vacation.