A true three star review: there were a number of five star features, and a number of one star features.

Five star feature: The location is perfect. On a quiet block walking distance from all the great stuff in Roma Norte. The block itself is beautiful and absolutely safe. Metro is just a couple of blocks away.

One star feature: The apartment has a mosquito problem. For two of the four nights we really couldn't sleep at all, moving from the lofted bedroom to the futon downstairs, because a cloud of mosquitos was after us. Bummer.

Five star feature: The apartment itself is really nice, and looks just the way it does in the pictures. Lots of charm and character, and the price feels like a good value.

One star feature: When we arrived, we found that there was neither soap nor toilet paper in the apartment. The latter would have been good to have upon arrival. After which, the former would also have been good to have.

Five star feature: Rodrigo was very quick to respond to emails, and arriving and departing was a breeze (just pick up/leave the keys with the doorman, who is pretty much always there).

One star feature: Combining three things here, since other reviews mention them: there is a bit of a funky smell in the apartment, loud construction goes on nearby every weekday morning, and one of the nights there was a loud party going until 3am or so.

Five star feature: Apartment is located directly above a crazy, crazy good bakery/cafe (Panderia Rosetta). Morning coffee/pastries were a joy. A new, nice looking restaurant just opened downstairs as well...

So, all in all, a bit of a polarizing experience. The mosquitos were, unquestionably, a real drag, and I have to imagine the toiletry situation was a simple oversight. Overall I'd recommend the apartment because of the fantastic location, albeit with the caveats mentioned above.