The location was excellent. We were able to walk to so many restaurants, museums, etc. or take a quick, inexpensive Uber ride. The level of cleanliness and lack of amenities would make me rate it a little lower. Unfortunately there were a few negative things that were out of the host's control, but that affected our overall experience. The host was very attentive, though, when the issue came up. The building can get pretty loud, but if you're mostly out and about it won't be a huge disturbance. All in all, location was great, we loved the terrace, and the bakery downstairs has delightful treats with very nice people! I think based on really great reviews, I was expecting more, but I'm not sure what all that would be. There are other places in the area for less and if you're spending most of your time away from the place I might opt for that. It is a cute, charming spot, though and at the end of the day we definitely enjoyed ourselves because Mexico City is an amazing city, not much can bring you down!