I primarily looked at Stephen's place as it is one of the few Airbnbs that allow pets on the island, which is a huge plus. Steve confirmed it is no problem to take our dog with us, and I think the doggo enjoyed our stay there just as much as we did. The place is much larger than expected, with a lovely comfortable living/dining area and a large yard which we would have made better use of if we hadn't been there on the one rainy week of the year. Right on the doorstep there is a magnificent viewpoint of the northern parts of Malta, and plenty of hiking spots just a short walk away to explore some wonderful caves and cliffs. The flat is in a very quiet location, right next to the Mellieha church, with lots of parking spaces around. There are some shops within walking distance including a grocer and a bakery, but many more shops, restaurants and banks can be found on the main road a quick walk away.
Stephen and his family were very helpful and accommodating, and the place was fully equipped so we didn't lack for anything. It's large and comfy, and great for families or just as a quiet couples retreat. The flat is a semi basement, but still gets plenty of light from the yard and bedroom windows. It's fully equipped in terms of cable TV, kitchen equipment, extra pillows, blankets, etc, so it felt quite like home away from home. We will definitely be returning!