Great stay at this quaint house! My boyfriend and I stayed at this place for a week over New Year's and there was everything you needed! As we rented bikes from the next neighbourhood it was easy for us to get around and Mike gave us lots of tips of what to do, where to go, etc. Also his wife warmly greeted us.
If you wanna have a good time, away from the big tourist areas, then St. Paul's bay and Mark's place is definitely a good decision!