We really enjoyed our stay at the Birgu Lodge as it has so many thoughtful touches. The hot tub is an ace experience to have as it is beautiful up there.
However there were many issues that prevent me giving a top review. First and foremost, the bed is two slim single beds pushed together with a gap of a few inches between them due to thick wooden bases. This was really uncomfortable and we struggled to sleep well.
Other issues include thin walls outside a walking tour hot spot (I'm not sensitive to this, but others will be), and Ed being 30 minutes late for check in with no explanation until afterwards.
All in all, if you are looking for a cozy place in a gorgeous area with a unique experience, this is a good idea. But just prepare yourself for that bed and thin walls...