You will want to choose Tonio's place. It has the best location possible I think. The windows open up onto the harbor, and the sight of the harbor and the surroundings is simply a beautiful way to start one's day. Also, it is close to everything without lots of walking- Bus, fast ferry, gondola stop,e-car, and taxi all come there, and there are multiple restaurants, on the harbor, just around the corner. It's a busy place with lots of local folks to make one feel like you are really in the heart of a country. Walk up a few steps and you are in the very old original church of the Knights of Malta, or a couple of shops to pick up what you need. The place itself is good-sized, with small details handled nicely, good internet, beds, bathroom, and a kitchen that has been thoughtfully done. Tonio was an excellent host, very on top of things, and going out of his way to be hospitable and helpful. He obviously loves his country's history and made us very welcome and familiar and comfortable for our week's stay. You can't go wrong with this place, and we are so glad that out of the many choices, we chose this one. Not knowing one part of Malta from another, it was a gamble, but everything we did, we'd do again, now that we know more.