We left after the first night and only because it was already 10pm when we arrived. Very heard to reach--total commute time from Malta airport was 5 hours. The bus in Gozo completely skipped the stop she described (we were following his route on our phone GPS), and he made a detour and didn't even know our stop. We got off at the next stop (already 9pm) and called the person taking over for Alexandra and he didn't answer. Alex finally messaged us and called a cab for us (which charged 16 euros for a five minute drive) and she mentioned she knew that the bus sometimes takes a detour, incredibly frustrating that this wasn't mentioned to us previously. We would have just taken a cab instead of bus.
Once we got to the house--we let ourselves in and had to message her to ask what room we were in, etc. The house downstairs smells terribly of cat litter, it's disgusting. It's also incredibly messy and cluttered. Bathroom is dirty, no shower curtain or door so water was all over the floor, hair in the shower, and no hand soap!! Also, not close to anything, 20-30 minute walk anywhere, esp terrible in the heat going uphill after a long day at the beach.
We left the next morning (1 night) after having paid for 4 nights and it was the best decision we made.
Based on the positive reviews of this home, we were shocked. And I think the difference is whether or not the host herself is there during your stay. Someone name Simone was taking over for her and it was horrible--when we finally met him the next morning all he said was "hi". Summary: When host is not there, it's dirty, smelly, and incredibly inconvenient location. The only pro--Alex answered our messages almost immediately.