Things we liked: the appartement feels light and spacious, there is a big mirror in the hallway, the shower is big and comfortable, beautiful doors with shutters, the bedrooms are at the back (no street noise), the area is charming, lots of practical information provided beforehand, Paolo was quick to answer any texts. There was some soap, tea and laundry detergent, and enough toilet paper.
Things that can be improved: on arrival we suggest to provide a city map and some tips or brochures.
We would have appreciated some more basics like a small amount of coffee, some olive oil, bottle of water etc. In the kitchen we missed some small sharp knives. There was no coffee machine, only the Italian one that you put on the stove.
We would advise to change the layout of the living room: there is tight space to sit at the table, whilst large space unused in couch/tv area, the beds are a bit tight for two people per bed (this was not a problem for us because we were only the two of us and we used separate bedrooms).
Some things we already communicated to Paolo (and he responded very nicely to them, I am sure the would be fixed for future tenants): a window was broken (couldn't be shut), the toilet brush was dirty, not enough discloths/kitchen towels.
The pro's definitely outweigh the cons. Overall we had a nice stay and would recommend this appartement.