After not finding anything particularly appealing (or remotely reasonable price-wise) in the "entire space" (or whatever) listings, I cautiously dipped my toe into the "private room" listings to see what I could find. I am SO glad that I did! Ariana and Luca's place was AMAZING. They run a three room B&B, where two rooms (including the room I booked) share a bathroom - right outside the door of each - closed off from any other public space. Our room was fantastic. AMAZING super firm IKEA memory foam mattress and lots of space - as if you're going to be spending your days in the room and not out exploring Venice! The bathroom was clean and large. Had an issue with running out of hot water one day, but it never happened again. Breakfast is provided each morning - assorted pastries, breads, granola, yogurt, fruit, coffee, juice, etc. Location is quite excellent, though unless you've been to Venice, plan on getting frustrated. I don't care if you think you're flipping Magellan, Venice is an epic navigational clusterf*ck. Ariana and Luca provided very comprehensive directions, which probably are the best route (approximately 10 minutes from Rialto Bridge without luggage), but there's just no good option for dragging luggage through the streets of Venice. But at least you're not dealing with cars! And definitely don't plan on arriving after dark unless you plan on setting up camp.
But the best part about Ariana and Luca's was Ariana and Luca! I didn't see Ariana too often, but we were greeted by Luca who offered up tons of recommendations and great walks through the less touristy areas. Oh, and did I mention he works at a killer little wine bar that is clearly loved by locals and easily became our favorite spot as well! This is literally THE reason why AirBnB is so great. We never would have wandered where we did or found the things we found. I tend to experience a visceral recoiling at the idea of touristy gimmicks, and it's no secret that Venice is basically considered by many to be one big floating (sinking) tourist trap. But I would go back in a heartbeat and stay at Ariana and Luca's place without even bothering to look anywhere else. Thank you so much for a wonderful Venetian experience, beyond anything we could've imagined!