The location is excellent, you are close to a lot of sights but yet it is calm and quiet up at the apartment, probably because you are on the top floor. The Medici palace is next door, the Duomo is just around the corner as well as many other sights. Not to mention the most fabulous gelateria right across the road!
The beds were comfortable and the aircon worked well (important during a Florence heatwave!) The wifi was good enough so we managed to do a bit of work. We never cooked in the kitchen though, it was a bit basic but why would you cook when you have all these fabulous restaurants right on your doorstop. We liked the spaciousness and the decent sized bedrooms.
The balcony was a little disappointing as you can smell the cooking fan from the restaurant next door but again, not an issue as there are many lovely spots for coffee close by.
The communication with the hosts was wonderful too, very responsive and easy to reach.