I would give it 5 stars for location perhaps because we loved the neighborhood and were grateful to be away from the throngs of tourists in the historic center but for some that distance (15 minute walk) might be a negative. Piazza Tasso is a wonderful neighborhood if you are not really in town for the museums. The space was very nice and the landlords quite friendly. We did bring earplugs which might be useful if you have a light sleeper in the front bedroom. All in all we had a great 5 week stay.