Donatella's place was very charming! It was very clean and furnished very nicely. The location was absolutely perfect! You could walk to all the sites from her place. The train station was only a 15 minute walk. We found it to be spacious enough for the three of us.
Donatella recommended some wonderful restaurants. Wish we were there long enough to try all of them, but the few we did go to were awesome.
From a communication standpoint, it was perfect. Donatella got back to us right away. I would definitely rent Donatella's apartment again if I am back in Florence.