My wife and I stayed here from Oct 16 - Oct 20 for my first and her second visit to Florence. We decided on this AirBNB because it was close to everything but without being in the extremely touristy area near the Duomo. And that was a fantastic decision. We were jet lagged and tired the first couple days and we were so thankful the apartment was so quiet. We were also thankful that the bed was super comfortable! The apartment is nice, clean, and had all the comforts of home, and the views from the lookouts were stunning, especially if you're there at sunrise and sunset: you can see some of my photos on Instagram @johnnotman.
We don't have anything negative, at all, to say about this place. If you want a quiet, safe, comfortable and well-located AirBNB in Florence, you need to consider this one. Also, I love it when hosts are responsive and have open communication, which was the icing on the cake: we had travel delays from the US and Elisabetta and Leonardo and I were in touch through each step of the way. Their communication made this feel more like a hotel than an AirBNB... maybe even better than a hotel! Anyways, stay here. You won't regret it.