I took this apartment after reading all the reviews that was written on this forum. Marc is also listed as a super host in air bnb. From our stay over there for 2 nights. This is our opinion about that place.
Positives:
The place was really nice and clean. It’s easy to get around and reach the city centre. You can easily walk there from Florence train station. There are many good restaurants around.
Negatives:
Difficulty to get inside the gated community.
Long response time from the host for any queries.
We didn’t meet the host during check in and didn’t get any instructions on the amenities inside the house. We managed to figure out most of the things ourselves.
We also felt that the toiletries provided are of poor quality ( compared to the rest of the places that I stayed in Italy)