We spent 7 nights in Giovanni's apartment and were so pleased. There were several thoughtful touches - shampoo, slippers, towels, a bottle of wine/water and small breakfast items to really make us feel welcomed. The space is cozy and comfortable, including a fireplace.
We traveled for our honeymoon, but those with a small child could stay here easily, as a pack and play in set up in the bedroom. The bed is very comfortable, and although we did not need it during our October stay, there is an air conditioning unit -which would definitely come in handy in summertime. The shower has slightly low water pressure, but no different than what I would expect in any high up apartment, and the towel warmer more than makes up for it. There is a reliable lift to take you to the 4th floor followed by a short flight to the top. The lift is definitely nice after long days of walking and climbing stairs.
The view is beautiful - very small outdoor area with just an amazing view - we we're actually able to watch fireworks from here one evening.
This was our first (of hopefully many) trips to Florence and Giovanni was very accommodating in terms of responsiveness and making recommendations. He helped us to find some great places to eat, as well as helped us avoid falling into some common shopping tourist traps.
The location was great - perhaps a 12 or so minute walk to sites like the Duomo, very close to the river, less of a touristy feel but still easily accessible to everything, quiet at night and overall very safe feeling.
I have no hesitation in recommending a stay at Giovanni's place !