This place was quite suitable for our needs. Settignano is an adorable little town, and the bus makes it quick and convenient to get to central Florence.

It actually seemed even a bit smaller than in the photos, but it was very clean and comfortable, and certainly not incongruent with the pictures.

They had power adapters for our North American connections, which was very handy.

Also, they didn't give us a hard time for getting lost on the way there, and being late.

My only minor complaints would be:

- There was a bit of street noise, and the place is right on the street. We brought ear plugs, so it was not a big deal.
- The bed isn't uncomfortable, per se, but it wasn't great.
- The wi-fi password is extremely and annoyingly long. You only need about 12 characters for a reasonably secure password:
http://security.stackexchange.com/questions/15653/recommend-length-for-wi-fi-psk/15686#15686

I gave the place five stars, because the cons were minor, and the experience was in line with what we expected. Good value for the money.