If you are looking to sample a bit of the simple life in rural tuscany, yet minutes from Florence, without a doubt select Tuscan sun Villa. The comments about the property are fair; yes, a simple Villa (very clean) and hidden a bit away but waking to birds and greeting neighbors and their cat or dog are not to be missed.
As a fellow hotel owner, I have to say that Alex goes above and beyond to solve any problems and needs. He offers extras like groceries, cooking classes, firewood, wine and lots of recommendations. Our cooking class with Cynthia was a hoot! You will have the chance to meet and live with "real" Tuscans. Great for visiting Florence (literally 5 minutes from free parking outside the city) and as a base to visit other cities, though you might just want to "stay at home in Tuscan Sun Villa".