While in Italy for 3 weeks, we stayed at 5 diff Airbnb's (Rome, Florence, Vernazza, Venice, and Milan). I base my reviews on Location, Cleanliness, and Roominess. Location - 5 stars-- in the heart of historic city center. Walking distance to all attractions, 5-min to train station.
Cleanliness 5 stars-- This was the cleanest place we stayed at. Everything was very up to date. Bathroom was spotless. Two air conditioners was a plus.
Roominess - 5 stars-- This was by far the most spacious place we stayed at. Nice layout.
I would highly recommend this apartment. Host was very helpful and kept in touch if we needed anything.