Modestino's place was very clean and cute. The location is great, no more than a two minute walk to get to the famous Ponte Vecchio. The balcony view overlooks the nice city street. They also sent many recommendations and were very responsive to any concerns we had.
We did have a couple of complaints, which I hope will be different for other guests. Check-in is listed as 11am but we got a message the day before our stay saying that it would be ready at 1pm instead. We arrived at 2pm after walking in the cold rain from the train station, and found the cleaner still inside cleaning. We had to sit outside for another 40 minutes after that while he finished. We were obviously very frustrated and surprised. When we finally got inside, the heat had not been on and the windows were open, so we had to wait another 3 hours for it to warm up from 35 degrees F. Unfortunately, the washing machine had an 'out of order' sign on it as well so we were unable to wash our clothes like we had planned.