Niccolò’s spot is great for a lot of reasons but misses the bar in a couple of ways that really soured my whole opinion of the space.
Starting with the positives: it’s clean, the beds are comfortable enough, and everything is walkable. I guess most places in Florence would be “walkable,” though, so maybe that’s not a ringing endorsement.
But the negatives: the house rules are very stingy. If you want to use a second towel, it is suggested you chip in extra. If you have to supply sheets from the closet to another bed that isn’t the main double bed, it is suggested you chip in extra (I didn’t). There was no toilet paper provided for our visit, which was strange, and disappointing. Thankfully we discovered that before we needed it.
The previous reviews are speaking truth when they mention that the photos make it look bigger than it really is, but that’s pretty consistent with every listing, and it’s not so small to be limiting (we didn’t prepare any meals at home though, which may change things for you). We found the size to be adequate.
We visited in November and the whole place ran pretty cold, so just be ready for that.