Had a great stay at Federica's place and would stay here again.

Location was excellent - short walk from train station and all the main sights within walking distance. Tough to beat having Michaelangelo's David as your neighbor!

I'm sure it would depend on who else is staying in the apartment, but when we were there, only a couple other people were staying and they were quiet and we didnt see them much. We didnt have many issues, but if something came up, it is nice that the hosts live in the same building to be able to fix it.
We booked a private guided trek with Emmanuele a short distance outside the city, and that was great too - definitely recommended if you want to include some natural scenery in your trip.

Great restaurant recommendations from the hosts. Had a wonderful time and will recommend it to anyone that is ok with sharing a kitchen and common area.