Pros: This place is absolutely stunning as it looks just like it does in the photos. It is designed to perfection. Looking out of the windows to the square below was my favorite part of the trip. The square is always filled with people which was very pleasant. There are excellent restaurants and coffee shops just right below. The neighborhood is exceptional especially when trying to live like a local and get away from the touristy things. But if you do want to experience the touristy things then those are very close as everything is walkable to get to.
Cons: The place reeked of cigarette smoke just as we entered the place and stayed that way for about 3 days. It was so bad that I had trouble breathing for the rest of my trip. We had to buy several candles and air freshener sprays while leaving the windows open to get the smell out but it took a while. We messaged Giuditta the first night we were there about the situation and asked if she could do anything about it but there wasn't much she could do besides tell us to keep the windows open which we were already doing. We had high hopes for this place and would have given it a 5/5 if it weren't for this problem. It's just something we had to fix on our own and it was extremely disappointing.
If Giudatta can fix this problem of making sure the place doesn't feel like you're living in an ashtray then this place would be perfect. She seems like a good host so I'm hoping she will take care of it!