Pros
The location is great and the views are indeed spectacular. Driving time to/from Florence is 30m during the day and a little less than 20m later in the evening, with less traffic. A great choice when planning to visit Florence, the Chianti towns or other places in Tuscany.
The owners / managers are responsive and very nice to deal with. When we had (minor) issues with furniture or access, they promptly responded and addressed the issues.
The place is very spacious and can easily accommodate 8 guests - but keep in mind that only one bedroom has a private bathroom.
Cons
The villa, furniture and appliances are dated. Workable/functional, but long due for a good refresh/replacement. Especially the kitchen. This is reflected in the price but prevents the villa from feeling like a true 5-star accommodation. We still gave it 5 stars, because 4.5 is not a possible rating and the good interaction with the owners, and the friendly price are taken into consideration here.
The villa doesn’t have a clothes dryer, requiring washed clothes to be hung to dry (indoors), which can take up to 48 hours. If we had known that, we would have packed enough clothes to avoid needing to wash them.
The pool is not warmed. So using it off-season (May / October) requires good tolerance for colder water.
Cellular reception is poor in this area, but the villa has Internet access (25 Mbits/sec).