I stayed at Gabriele’s place for a month but I wouldn’t recommend it for a long-term stay. On the positive side, the location was good as it was walking distance from many of the historical sites and right across from the Central Market. However this location is also very noisy, not just from people on the street (which could last well into midnight or longer) but the sound of trucks picking up trash and the early morning trucks delivering their goods to the market and the restaurants on the street. I’m not a light sleeper but was woken up a few times in the middle of the night. People tend to sit on the steps outside where the entrance door is and you can hear when they bang against the door. The apartment is on the top floor and the bedroom is upstairs, but still the noise travels.
Also as stated in the agreement, utilities are not included in stays of longer than 2 weeks. Personally, I like to know what I am paying up front with no surprises. Gabriele was very fair with this though and the amount I paid was within the range that he stated in my communication with him. He met me at the apartment and was easy to get a hold of in case any issues came up.
Keep in mind that being on the top floor (3rd floor to us Americans) the walk is 37 steps to get to the apartment with no elevator. Personally I didn’t mind it, as walking and climbing steps helped offset the effects of the delicious food and gelato that can be found in Florence. It’s just an FYI for those who may have difficulty with stairs. Gabriele helped me with my luggage which was nice. Also there are steps up to the bedroom.
All in all, the place is as described, the pictures are accurate, and Gabriele was a great host. There are however some things beyond his control that one needs to consider if you plan on making this your home for a couple weeks or more.