If I could give this one 6 stars out of 5, I would. Best value/experience I've had yet with airbnb. Patrizia and Gianni were very communicative, and met us at the station to pick up our bags. When we got to the apartment, it was beautiful, clean, and well-stocked with breakfast food and snacks. This wasn't just leftovers from previous guests, but a thoughtful spread of new, unopened packages. We were on our honeymoon, so they had a bottle of champagne for us. Truly lovely. They were very helpful throughout our stay with good restaurant and activity tips. Overall, it felt like the room quality was that of a very fine hotel, but with a personal touch and at a fraction of the price. The location was great too, very convenient to the center as well as the cool San Niccolo section of Otrarno.
The only drawback was a bit of street noise at night (American college kids on their way home from bars, and trucks rattling over the stone street). If you're a very light sleeper it's something to consider, but it wasn't a problem for us.
Definitely recommended!