We had a great stay! Here’s a quick pros/cons:
Pros: Very spacious — having three bedrooms and three beds made our stay very enjoyable. Very clean. Francesco met us during the check in and made it very easy. Plenty of bath towels. A/C was functional and kept us very comfortable. Neighborhood felt very safe and was quiet at night.
Cons: The place is located up hill (maybe an issue for some folks). The electric water heater and toaster didn’t work at the time of our stay. Walking to the historic center of Florence will take closer to 20 minutes or so.