We truly had a lovely time in Silvia's apartment. Ideally situated in the downtown of Firenze, we were close to a bunch of different restaurants and bars. We were warmly welcomed and enjoyed talking to the other roommates coming from different places around the world.
I am not bumping up my rating to 5 stars as we had minor issues with the shower (no hot water after 4 minutes) and the cleanliness of the place was not optimal.
Nevertheless, we still had an amazing time for our New Year and I highly suggest Silvia's place if you want to be close to the town's center