Our experience at Gherardo's was perfect from beginning to end.
We arrived a little earlier than expected for check-in, and we were happy to see that Gherardo was already waiting for us. He gave us a tour of his spotless apartment. It is just as beautiful as the photos, and it has all of the amenities you could need. He also left fruit, wine, and spaghetti for us, which was very thoughtful! The location is very close to the Duomo and a short walk to everything else we wanted to see- lots of restaurants and stores nearby, too. The neighborhood is quiet and safe.
I can't say enough about Gherardo as a host. He has been very quick to respond to any questions. He even messaged us after our first night at his apartment to make sure that everything was going okay. He called a taxi for us the morning we left and met us promptly at the time we agreed upon for check-out. He is truly a kind and courteous person!
If you are going to Florence, stay with Gherardo. You will not be sorry! We hope to come stay here again.