We stayed in Ian's place with a family of four for four nights. Before we checked-in, our local host messaged us and we coordinated a smooth check-in. She also sent us several recommendations and arranged for a taxi to pick us up upon departure - she was fantastic!
The apartment is in a great location - 2 min from the Uffizi and around the corner from an amazing sandwich place (you can't miss it...there are tons of people eating sandwiches all around the block). The tratorria downstairs (Roberto) was also delicious.
The apartment is very spacious - we had lots of space to spread out. As others noted, it's on the 3rd floor so we definitely got a good workout.
Because the apartment is centrally located, it could get noisy at times - especially the back bedroom. I think it must overlook a bar or restaurant because we could hear people (aka drunk americans!) until early morning, as well as trash trucks, deliveries, etc. The bed in the back bedroom was also too small from my husband and I to fit, so we took turns sleeping on the couch in the front bedroom.
Overall, I think this place is a good value for the price we paid. Thank you, Ian!