Our family of four had a wonderful stay. The pool and outdoor setting is spectacular. Both the pool itself and the deck furniture are in excellent condition. It is wonderful to spend time out there at any time of day, enjoying the view of the sea and the herbal scents of the almond, apricot, and date trees, while lounging in the pool. It is a 10 minute drive down the hill to the town of Cefalu, where you can find street parking by the beach (blue zones).
The house itself is small but stylish, well-appointed, and clean. The beds are very comfortable. The kitchen has everything you need to cook. However, there was no welcome basket of foods, etc., provided at check-in. They should remove that from the advertisement.
We had one significant setback during our stay: the air conditioning stopped working. As it was July and got to be 30C degrees inside the house, we were unable to stay our last two days. When it was clear to Salvatore (who rents the house with his family) that he would not be able to quickly fix it, he refunded our last two nights. We were able to find another hotel nearby without a problem. It was disappointing to have to cut our stay short. But Salvatore handled the situation with integrity and was in close communication about it throughout. So I do not think this should stop others from staying there. If something goes wrong, you can rely on them to try to make it better, or refund the stay if they cannot.