We stayed 7 days at Andreas place. He is a super nice host -we didn't meet him in person, but he replied quickly and super friendly. Everything was very clean and tidy, we found what we needed and for 2 - 4 people it's the perfect size. There's a small bay with pebbles and also a sandy beach in walking distance, with a small beach bar. We strongly recommend to come by car, since restaurants, bars and Cefalú are difficult to get to by foot. Cefalú is worth a visit! Also we went to Palermo by train from Cefalù, which is a lovely train ride and super easy. The place itself is in between a holiday home area, it can get a bit busy sometimes, but we didn't mind to see and hear the neighbours though. Coming in October was a good choice, it's still very warm, also the ocean was still perfect. We had a lovely time!