Pros: location is top notch. It's a busy street dotted with eateries near the Quattro Canti. Gaspare is very clear with his check in communication. When the wifi couldn't work, he answered quickly and fixed the problem. The house instructions are clear and in English, and I liked that there was a washer and a big kitchen, which unfortunately we didn't use at all (street food was too good).
Cons: The immediate area entering the building is dark and looks run down, and a homeless person with his animals is permanently parked opposite. The home in general has softer lighting. You need to be prepared: e.g. bring your own shampoos if you prefer soaps to be liquid. Toilet paper comes in one roll shared between two people for a multi day stay, and if you ask where the extras are, you will receive an oddly stern and wordy reprimand.
Note: You will be asked to sign an extra contract of some sort, which will be entirely in Italian. Hopefully they can offer an English contract for clearly non Italian guests in the future, like they managed to do with the house instructions.