A delightful surprise!
If you have your own car, I would clearly recommend you to drive the 15 minutes you will need to reach Pupi’s home from the nice (but bursting) Cefalú. The house is in the middle of the woods - but closely enough (300m) to an always-open bar/restaurant/shop. A perfect combination of quietness and easy reach from Cefalú. Besides, Pupi is a great host and she will make your stay as you were in your own home.