Staid at Lucia’s with our 1 year old and it was great. The location was perfect for us. All of Ortigia was accessible and most of the big tourist destinations in Siracusa were walkable as well (we don’t mind long walks it was all flat) . The staircase to the bedroom is an adventure with a baby in arms but the bedroom staid gloriously cool throughout the day and let us put baby down while still able to enjoy food and wine from the market next door and the views of the temple of Apollo.