Thanks to Lorenzo's recommendation we ate dinner twice at San Giorgio e il Drago which was the best food we ate in Sicily (we stayed in Palermo, Cefalù, Randazzo, and Catania).
Marghe and Lorenzo were incredibly nice and easy to talk to (in English since we don't speak Italian). The room was charming and strangely huge. The shared bathroom was not a problem at all. The location was ideal since it was within a 10 minute walk to absolutely everything we wanted to do in Randazzo.