Alice and Giorgio's place is very central. Everything within walking distance. It is clean and has a great balcony (great for summer!). Ortigia is beautiful... I would recommend staying here. It was strangely quiet at night and I slept very well.
Most impressive was the fact that I missed my flight to Ortigia and therefore missed a night at the their apartment. They gave me an extra night for free. It was very nice to have people being so nice after a long journey!!!
Thanks, Rohan