5 stars! As all the other stellar reviews have noted, both Ernesto and this apartment are fantastic. Ernesto hosts better than anyone else I've encountered on Airbnb, and every little detail has been thoughtfully considered. For example, not only is the apartment exactly as described and perfectly clean, and Ernesto meets you there and is so easy to book and communicate with. But he has done the little things: a fantastic guidebook to local restaurants, bars, sights, which you can access on the website, and it is also printed out and on the desk in the apartment. (Many places I've stayed have not done this.) He has also done things that you would expect more at a hotel: towels and soaps laid out, breakfast items included, etc. So you end up with the best an apartment can offer with the best a hotel can offer. And Ernesto is like your personal concierge! Catania is fantastic too. We were only there 2 nights unfortunately, but it was great for sharing as a couple with 1 baby, as well as my mother in the 2nd bedroom. And for people with strollers, you will appreciate having no stairs to enter the apartment. Parking was easy and set up by Ernesto with a private garage nearby. We walked everywhere, the garage was just for car storage. We stayed in winter, and the apartment was nice and warm. It was also really nicely set up, more like someone's home, not a typical holiday rental. This means nice tools for cooking, nice furniture, nice furnishings. Really loved it, thank you Ernesto!