We spent the last week of September at Anna&Giuseppe's place. They make you feel welcome and are discretely there to help if you need them.
The place is tiny but certainly enough for two. There is a hob inside, but no sitting facility so that you have to sit in the outside veranda to have your meals. This is like a lovely extra kitchen, with barbecue, hob a big sink, table and chairs. For us it added charm to the place and we sat there long hours just enjoying the quiet and beauty of the place. Indeed this is the ideal spot if you want quiet or if you (like myself) struggle to sleep where there is noise. There are no busy road nearby and I can't imagine the place being noisy even in high season. A gate on the walled fence lead you to the beach which is - literally - on the door step.
Bars and restaurants are at walking distance (but not on the door step) and Marsala, Selinunte, Mothia, the Egadi Islands, etc. are all reachable on a day trip.
Highly recommended. We hope to go back next year.