I would strongly recommend Maria Antonietta's place - she and her husband, and the staff onsite were the perfect hosts! We had a wonderful stay and very much enjoyed the breakfasts, and the option to have wood fire pizzas and a four course meal on different nights!! I would definitely like to come back here some day. The views are exception, the house is beautiful and everyone is very friendly and helpful. The pool, which has a wonderful view of the ocean is also fabulous!
The only thing people should be aware of is, that like many places in Sicily, you cannot put toilet paper in the toilet but must use the waste paper basket. This said, there was someone who cleaned the bathrooms and emptied these for us daily so we didn't find it to be a problem.