We had a fantastic stay at Andrea's villa. It's beautifully designed, very well looked after, the view is incredible and we made to feel really welcome. It's particularly good if you're after a combination of relaxing and sightseeing as there's a lot to see and do close by.
Siracusa is about 15 minutes drive and there are some good beaches close by. If you go a bit further south (35-40 minutes) there are even better beaches near Noto. We didn't have time to explore the town but look forward to when we stay again next as we will definitely be coming back. That's how good this place is!