The price is good BUT …
There is on-street parking (for small cars) BUT none “on-premises”
The rooms are large BUT sparsely furnished and no garden or patio
The bed is large and comfy BUT the stairs are narrow and steep
The water is hot BUT the bathroom smells of sewer gas (Carlo has been working on it)
The kitchen is functional BUT the pots are old and there isn’t a kitchen knife
The neighborhood is dodgy BUT Carlo left enough food so we didn’t have to shop
You could certainly do worse but this place doesn’t rate a 4.9 on AirBnB, maybe 4.6