Melody house was a perfect option - it is really large, clean, well and modern furnished, we most appreciated the large comfortable bed and a good pressure of water so we were able to take a perfect shower, and a nice kitchen. We are travelling with our son- a toddler- and the apartment felt really safe for crawling, no child hazard, so this is a bonus.
Its location is quite central, but quiet at night, with lots of small shops and supermarket in the area. The parking in the neighbourhood is free and spots are easy to be found. We had our car parked in front of the house and were able to reach all the points of interest on foot. Do not miss the nearby modern church!
Sergio and his wife and daughter were extremely friendly and helpful, gave us plenty of advise as for what to see in the city. There was little breakfast prepared in the cupboard for us, coffee and fresh water. And we loved the Sicilian almond treats :) When leaving, we were able to keep our bags indoors while we went to a morning stroll in Ortigia, which saved us some kilos of backpack weight!
All in all it was a great experience.