Livio's place offered the exact experience we were looking for. In the two nights we stayed, we went snorkling, ate pizza and a calzone from a local pizzeria, went swimming with the locals, caught sunrise on the rocks by the water (only a short walk from the airbnb), bought fruits at the market, relaxed on the hammock, and enjoyed each other's company on the balcony where there was unbroken views of the water. The place was clean and had thoughtful touches. I would definitely revisit.