My family and I had a nice stay in Scicli at the Pagani family's home. The home is situated up the hill so if you choose to park at Piazza Italia, you will have quite a walk up. Nevertheless, the walk is worth the lovely view you get from both balconies in the apartment.
Although our stay was overall nice, I feel I should mention that upon our arrival, the air conditioning units were not working (which was not a nice surprise). The family, and Sabina (the woman who checked us in while the family was away) were kind enough to sort this out by purchasing a portable air conditioning unit that same night. However, since they were aware about this issue a few days prior to our arrival, we would have really appreciated being notified ahead of time and given the option to modify or cancel our reservation. The portable air conditioning units made all the difference and we appreciate the trouble Sabina went through to get them up to the apartment.