Staying at Luigi's place was definitely a good decision, in fact it determined our entire experience in Sicily. As i am pregnant, me and my husband have decided to go for a quite location, not very touristic, not crowded but beautiful, and Tindari is indeed heaven if you are looking for these things.
We loved the place, the apartment was just like in the pictures, we had a great view over the church. The natural reservation - Lagetti di Marinello is extreamly beautiful, great beaches, crystal clear water, very few people. Luigi as a host was very open and helpful, he responded quickly to all our questions and needs.
There are a few things you should be aware of when going for such a location:
1. You need a car. There is no public transport in places like this.
2. There are not many restaurants and shops in the area, in fact you will have to go to a neighbor village to eat on a weekday.
3. As for supermarkets (available also in a neighbor village), you will have to go there in the morning as they work only till 13.00.
4. Very few people speak English here :)
5. Be careful where you park, we got ourselves a fine in our first day.
If you can get yourself together and organize these things we would definitely recommend this place!