I would highly recommend you staying in Favigniana with Maria Antonietta! The rooms are very beautiful and new, and they include private entrance, terrace with chairs and tables as well as little kitchen and bathroom. The hosts are really helpful. They came to pick us up from the port and they also dropped us on the day when we were leaving. It was handy as we had two suitcases with us. The host will give you some advices about the island and where to rent a bicycle or motorbike. For English speakers only - they don't speak perfect English but you can still communicate ;) Highly recommended!