We loved it at Luigi’s place when we stayed for a week off season in april / early may. Outdoor dining area is wonderful! Picked lemons fresh from the tree and gazed at the smoking crater each morning.
On the downside, the shower is really small, laundry facilities VERY basic and cleaning was maybe not 5/5, though by no means terrible. Luigi’s relaxed and welcoming attitude makes up for any of these minor improvement areas, and personally, I would not hesitate to book this place again. I can definitely recommend it unless you are looking for a hotel standard accomodation.