Don't hesitate to stay with Aurora.
Her home is lovely and spacious, with a high ceilings and perfect central location on the main road of Ortigia.
If you need to communicate with her, don't put your phone down after sending a message because her response time is almost immediate. Marisa, her colleague, was also just as quick to come and resolve any "issues" we had.
There are many beds to accommodate larger groups. We stayed for 7 days and felt very at home in her space, with a well equipped kitchen and plenty of extra pillows, blankets, and towels. And when we needed a place to store our luggage before check-in and after checkout, Aurora was kind enough to provide a solution for us that was easy and secure. The wi-fi worked well and all of the tvs are smart, though I would definitely recommend spending as much time as possible seeing beautiful Ortigia and Sicilia rather than in front of the tv. Unfortunately for us though, during our stay October 1st came and so did the rain, and Aurora's flat proved to be the cozy retreat we needed. This is definitely rare for Siracusa though, so undoubtedly you will enjoy the many balconies within the apartment, and as a tip, be sure to check out the rooftop for an incredible view of the island.