Travelled with a friend in late July to favignana after having been in a mix of other hotels, air bnb and standard bnb accommodation. Unfortunately this was our least pleasant accommodation.
While the location was great (right across from a sandy beach), the cleanliness of this apartment was not.
On check-in (arranged with the waiters downstairs at the restaurant), we found an unflushed toilet with faeces in the bowl. On our third day we spotted a cockroach in the apartment.
This obviously left us with some concern about the overall cleanliness of the place.
A couple of other things; this is a self catering apartment yet no amenities provided to wash the dishes, so we had to buy this ourselves. There are also no housecleaning amenities so any sand or dust tracked back from the street or the beach couldn't be cleaned up.
The Wi-Fi stopped working on our second day here and this was not resolved when raised (we were informed that this was due to high internet traffic on Favignana however the issue appeared to be a security issue). The Wi-Fi did not working for the rest of the week, and the neighbors also had difficulty connecting to the Wi-Fi.
From the pictures we thought that the apartment was on the ground floor on the beach, however it was upstairs on the first floor above a resturant.
Claudio did help us book a taxi when we were leaving, and generally was good with responding quickly.