We spent one night at Natasha's house. Even though it is not located in Otranto, it is about 10min drive away which is totally ok. The apartment is well equipped (kitchen, TV, A/C, WIFI).
The only negative point was our arrival and departure. Natasha's friend was late when we got there, even though we had made efforts to be right on time and communicated all day long about our time of arrival. And then the next day, we were basically thrown out of the house. The man parked outside around 9:50am and made us feel we had to rush to be out before 10am even though there was no reservation that day. Not a very pleasant way to end the stay.
Except for this point, I would totally recommend this house to stay in Otranto.