I really hate writing a bad review, especially since Francesca was so friendly but I have to be honest for my fellow travelers.
I will break it down to 3 main issues I had with our stay.
1. Location: While reading the reviews and the listing itself, it said that you are 20 minutes from the center. You might be 25 min from Zone 1, however, you are actually about 35-40 minutes away from the actual center (with the Duomo).
2. The noise: Which was the worst part. The walls were paper-thin, we could hear everything. One night there was a party of some sorts and they were up for a while and then woke up early. Thankfully I had earplugs but my companion barely got any sleep.
3. The temperature: We were freezing in the apartment. We used the extra blanket provided but it still wasn't enough and we had to use our jackets to cover us during the night.
If it were just location, I wouldn't have reviewed it as negatively. However with the other issues listed it just didn't make our stay pleasant. I once again appreciated the friendliness of Francesca and that there were small breakfast goodies.